WoW Insider reviews The Shattering: Prelude to Cataclysm by Christie Golden

The Warcraft universe has incredibly rich lore supporting it, and it's natural that, like many IPs, it would expand outside of the game world. Warcraft novels have historically been hit or miss, largely due to the strengths and weaknesses of the various commissioned authors who write them. Some novels feature out-of-place characters invented by the author specifically for those particular stories; some struggle with the characterization of beloved characters. But there have been some bright spots: Rise of the Horde was a fantastic look into the birth of the Horde on Draenor, and Arthas: Rise of the Lich King provided insight into the man who would become the Lich King.
These books have something in common besides their IP: Christie Golden wrote them. In Arthas, she gave Blizzard its first The New York Times-bestselling novel. Now, her latest offering is the Warcraft universe's newest novel, a tie-in to the upcoming Cataclysm expansion. We present to you our review of The Shattering: Prelude to Cataclysm.
These books have something in common besides their IP: Christie Golden wrote them. In Arthas, she gave Blizzard its first The New York Times-bestselling novel. Now, her latest offering is the Warcraft universe's newest novel, a tie-in to the upcoming Cataclysm expansion. We present to you our review of The Shattering: Prelude to Cataclysm.
The war in Northrend has taken its toll on both the Horde and the Alliance. Both sides lost tens of thousands of soldiers and citizens in the year-long battle against the Scourge and the Lich King, but some losses cut deeper than others. Anduin Wrynn lost a father figure in Highlord Bolvar Fordragon, and the Horde lost one of its finest up-and-coming heroes, Saurfang the Younger. And it's not just people who were lost -- the war was costly in terms of money and supplies, leaving Stormwind and Orgrimmar in dire financial straits. Orgrimmar has also suffered unnatural droughts, causing Durotar's already slim resources to dry up.
Things are so bad in, fact, that the Alliance and Horde have actually agreed to a truce, ending all hostilities on all three continents. Not everyone is happy about it, including the Horde's favored son, the Hero of Northrend, Garrosh Hellscream.
What drives The Shattering are politics and personal relationships between Alliance and Horde, teacher and student, tauren and orc, father and son, even Azeroth and Draenor. Golden wisely spares us the introduction of super-powered characters we've never met before, instead relying on strong characterization of lore figures we've grown to know and love over the game's six years.
Garrosh Hellscream, who's been the subject of much vitriol from some Horde players (and Alliance players alike), is given a fair shake in this novel, which finally sheds light on events that have been rumored for some time to occur pre-Cataclysm. But beyond that, we also learn what drives Garrosh, sometimes from inside his own head. He's presented as an individual, not a caricature; he's fiercely loyal to the Horde and an excellent warrior, even if his decisions aren't the correct ones 100 percent of the time. He really does want what's best for the Horde -- the issue being that perhaps his Horde isn't today's Horde, but the juggernaut his father could have built were he alive today and Warchief.
It's that dream and that attitude that worries tauren chieftain Cairne Bloodhoof, who is constantly at odds with the young orc. Cairne is given extended screen time in The Shattering, showing us what we've always known about him -- that he's an honorable, wise and old-fashioned old bull. It's because of these qualities that he can speak his mind to Thrall, who is faced with some very tough decisions after a fire rages through Orgrimmar.
Thrall is given his own story, mostly separate from the intertwined events that take place throughout the novel. He's depicted as world-weary; he realizes that many of his decisions in running the Horde may not have been the right ones, and Eitrigg notes that Thrall has done little for himself since becoming Warchief. He has no mate, no child, no one to take his place should he "return to the ancestors." The mag'har of Draenor end up providing him with more than just knowledge of the elements, and Thrall emerges from the book as a much stronger and fleshed-out character than he has been previously.
Dealing with sabotage from within and without, and losing their venerable Warchief even temporarily, causes ripples throughout the Horde that turn into tidal waves, sometimes literally, while the shadow of the Cataclysm looms overhead.
But the Alliance also gets plenty of time in The Shattering. The Alliance storyline almost exclusively follows Anduin Wrynn, crown prince of Stormwind, as he interacts with notable leaders on both sides of the world (and of the Horde-Alliance conflict). His father, Varian, has been struggling with his dual nature, the result of the ritual that originally fused his warlike and kingly sides back together following his run-in with Onyxia. He lashes out at those around him, from Anduin to Jaina Proudmoore, and wisely suggests that Anduin spend some time outside of Stormwind Keep.
It's through this suggestion that Anduin gets to know "Aunt" Jaina and "Uncle" Magni Bronzebeard better, spending time both in Theramore and Ironforge. Jaina serves an important role in the novel as Anduin's surrogate mother; Anduin is an uncommonly well-behaved and mature kid, but he's still a kid with no mother and only half a father. Through tutelage from both, he discovers a side of himself that he always knew existed, far removed from the warrior his father wished he would become. And it may be that side of him that keeps his father from making a huge mistake.
The theme of father and child is present in another part of the Alliance story focusing on Magni Bronzebeard as he desperately tries to determine what's causing the elemental upheaval that threatens his people. Throughout this process, we learn the nature of his relationship with his estranged daughter Moira, and some shocking events, both elemental and political, occur that threaten to destabilize one of the oldest pillars of the Alliance.
What's interesting about this book is its focus. As stated previously, Golden deals almost exclusively with existing lore characters, which is a wonderful departure from books like Stormrage and the War of the Ancients trilogy. But for a book that acts as a prequel to Cataclysm, there's little (if any) discussion of Deathwing or of the goblins and worgen. Even races like the blood elves, Forsaken and draenei have little to no face time with readers. The book deals mainly with orcs, tauren, humans and dwarves. Those who were expecting some exposition regarding other races might walk away disappointed, but not for lack of information on the aforementioned races.
The Shattering thrives in much the same way Rise of the Horde did -- on its characters, not its plot. That's not to say that the plot isn't well-crafted or interesting, but the nature of the novel as necessary, not ancillary, material to fill in gaps between Wrath and Cataclysm means that it follows a particular structure. Despite that, or possibly because of it, the book moves very quickly, making it an incredibly brisk read. There are plenty of action sequences amidst the dialogue and intrigue, so those who, like Garrosh, would rather bust heads than drink tea and chat will appreciate the book too.
Avid players will appreciate appearances by minor NPCs they've met in the game, and small details in descriptions of action, environments and spells will keep sticklers happy as well. You're right, Anduin, that is what dropping a totem sounds like.
My only real complaint with The Shattering, and it's a very minor one, has to do with the dialogue. Understand: I don't mean that the dialogue is bad in anyway. Characters are treated with all due reverence, and the dialogue is rarely cheesy or ham-fisted and never out of character, as it could be in previous novels. In fact, the dialogue tends to do a great job bringing out sides of characters we haven't seen before -- Cairne's angry side, for example.
Rather, it's small things that caught my eye; for example, characters' full names (and titles) are repeated a lot in speech, and I'm unsure if this is to make sure that readers new to Warcraft lore will be able to follow the multitude of characters or whether this is actually how people address each other on Azeroth. I'm willing to give Golden the benefit of the doubt on this one.
All told, The Shattering is one of the finest, if not the finest, Warcraft novel to date. Those hoping to bridge the gap between Wrath and Cataclysm will need it, and those stinging from the poorly-received Stormrage will appreciate the heart and soul that Golden, a WoW player herself, has given their favorite heroes and antagonists.
Verdict: Any Warcraft fan would be remiss not to read this book, both for its respectful treatment of the Warcraft universe and for its wealth of lore information.
World of Warcraft: Cataclysm will destroy Azeroth as we know it; nothing will be the same! In WoW Insider's Guide to Cataclysm, you can find out everything you need to know about WoW's third expansion (available Dec. 7, 2010), from brand new races to revamped quests and zones. Visit our Cataclysm news category for the most recent posts having to do with the Cataclysm expansion.





Reader Comments (Page 1 of 6)
Belfonisis Oct 18th 2010 7:09PM
Yay! Mine arrived from Amazon today. ;)
adrys Oct 18th 2010 8:33PM
I just got mine today too, I'm about 40 pages in and I'm really enjoying it. I wanna read this article here but I'm afraid it will spoil the story haha.
Elmouth Oct 18th 2010 9:22PM
Definitly getting one of these, I do appreciate Golden's more mature style.
Knaak is fine, but it feels like he's focusing on a younger audience, which is also fine really since WoW is for kids anyway.
Siorra Oct 18th 2010 7:11PM
The Knaak reference there is unmissable.
North Oct 18th 2010 7:17PM
You could sense the struggle in Sacco's writing in trying to clearly say how bad a writer Knaak was without explicitly saying "Knaak was a bad writer"
martamius Oct 18th 2010 7:29PM
I am really surprised at this. I didn't think Golden's "Arthas" was written that well at all. I am enjoying Knaak's books a lot more. When I saw Golden's name on this one I just went "Ehhh".
Michael Sacco Oct 18th 2010 7:29PM
Martamius, what's it like living on Bizarro World?
SaintStryfe Oct 18th 2010 7:43PM
Fine, I'll say it: Knaak is a terrible, awful no good author who ruins anything he touches.
Was that over the top?
Revrant Oct 18th 2010 7:44PM
Are cookies cakes and cakes ice cream there?
Oh! I want to go!
David Oct 18th 2010 7:50PM
Knaak is not that bad of a writer, but he just goes far off point in his books, Stormrage was ok, and WotA trilogy was also good, but the ones with Khadgar in them are not that good, I guess because he lets Khadger one shot Deathwing. NOT OK. Christie on the other hand is amazing, love how she depicts Thrall, and Arthas as a kid!
Maymer Oct 18th 2010 8:03PM
Though I don't agree with martamius in the least bit, I do actually find it interesting that someone enjoys Knaack's writing style. It's not necessarily a bad thing, but I always felt like the characters in his books were nothing more than a piece of cardboard with maybe a beard taped on to represent a male, or a great pair of epic chest pieces...IF you know what a mean...to represent a female.
Mrs. Golden's writing however felt more fresh and full, giving new life into characters once thought complete. A great example is the ever popular Culling of Stratholme moment. For all that is holy, if I have to see that seen ONE MORE TIME, I will flip! Yet, when Golden wrote it, a whole new light was added. Arthas was angry, yes, but he was shocked and felt stung when Uther thought he was being sarcastic and bitter to him.
Knaack...on the other hand....well, I can only imagine THIS scene playing out.
Arthas: Glad you could make it, UTHER...
Uther: Watch your tone with me boy, I'm still your superior as an officer!
Arthas: As I could forget-
*Massive Explosion, followed as a DeLorean stops in front of them. Out pops Rhonin*
Arthas: RHONIN! What happened? I thought you went into the next expansion!
Rhonin: I did Arty! But something is horribly wrong!
Arthas: What? What happened?
Rhonin: It's your kids Arty! Quick, into the DeLorean!
*Arthas and Jaina jump into the DeLorean*
Arthas: Hey, Rhon, are we going to have enough flight skill for this?
Rhonin: Where we're going, we don't NEED any 310% flight speed....
*Book ends with all three of them flying off into the distance, leaving both Uther and Mal'Ganis with green eyes of envy at the leetness*
THAT is how he would have written it, I suppose.
Pwnzoar Oct 18th 2010 8:07PM
Hooray, I'm outnumbered in liking Knaack's books.
BallsMcGee Oct 18th 2010 8:24PM
I will probably be down-ranked for this but I think I can share my opinion.
I find Knaak better that Golden. I just feel that her works are to much on the point. She does not really expand on anything or offer any possibilities. She just writes what Blizz wants people to see. Whereas Knaak put's new things into his books. Allows for new plots and characters to help expand and develop the Warcraft Universe.
Just my 2 cents.
Maymer Oct 18th 2010 8:34PM
@ all those you enjoy Knaack and were open about there opinions
FOR SHAME! Having a different opinion than all of us, and more importantly, me! I SHALL DOWNVOTE YOU FOR BEING ORIGINAL AND OPINIONATED!!
Joseph Smith Oct 18th 2010 8:55PM
I don't mind Knaack. And despite 'popular opinion' I can't be the only one. His stuff obviously sells, and obviously people at Blizzard like his writing too, or they wouldn't keep giving him work. Anyone who doesn't like him has an easy way to let Blizzard know that: Vote with your wallet and don't buy anything with his name on it. Trust me, if it doesn't make money, Blizzard will stop.
As for Arthas, I have to agree, I really like Golden's writing, and have since she was doing Star Trek novels, but i don't feel that Rise of the Lich King was up to her normal standards. To me it really seemed like just a recitation of what we already knew from in games, with very little character building. Especially as Arthas was growing up, it really seemed set to just speed towards the story for WC3. We get flashes of him being young and him meeting/observing some famous lore characters from past games, but no real depth to it.
That's not to say that others can't feel differently. That's the great thing about being individuals, we can all have our own tastes and feelings.
snowleopard233 Oct 18th 2010 9:10PM
I've only read two Warcraft Books so far; Stormrage and Arthas. I didn't really like either. Arthas felt like a bunch of deleted scenes put into a book rather than a full-fledged novel and Stormrage was agonizingly slow to get started and had some seriously boring characters.
However, out of the two I'd have to say I liked Stormrage the better. Why? Well, it wasn't a good book but it was at least exciting. It started out mind numbingly slow but by the last third I generally found myself interested in the characters' survival and how they were going to "save the world" as corny as it may sound. Arthas felt like someone else was playing Warcraft III for me, except poorly and without any of the suspense. Stormrage felt like I was watching some cheesey Saturday morning cartoon; stupid, yes, but entertaining in a "oooh look there's really big dragons and explosive magic" kind of way.
There's a side to Warcraft that is about drama and characters but there's also a goofy, colorful angle of "hey, I just want to watch that guy make that tree explode and hear elves talk about nonsense". It's not something I would write, but I can see how someone like Knaak would arrive there and why there are WoW fans out there who enjoy reading it.
I'm definitely checking out this latest book though. As long as it feels more like a concise narrative than a collection of lore pieces.
Joerendous Oct 18th 2010 10:57PM
@ maymer
Holy crap man, I damned near soiled myself. LOL we need a /1. Local post at least for this week.
Amaxe Oct 19th 2010 12:29AM
Thus far the worst WoW writer I have come across is DiCandido. Cycle of Hatred was not only a bad WoW book, but a bad book in any standard.
Nathanyel Oct 19th 2010 5:10AM
Sadly still haven't read WotA fully yet, but I recently read Night of the Dragon and am currently reading Stormrage, just at the part where Thura's purpose was revealed, and well, especially that confirms what I always heard about Knaak, cheesy dialogue, and characters that appear to be omni-potent, until the story specifications given by Blizzard require them to make a mistake, so that they don't just rofl-stomp every powerful evil guy.
Autoslizer Oct 19th 2010 9:09AM
@David
Actually it wasn't Knaak who wrote the book where Khadgar "oneshotted" Deathwing. Golden did. Together with Rosenberg I believe it was.