BlizzCon 2010: WoW Insider interviews author Richard A. Knaak

WoW Insider: Richard, thank you for joining us, it's great to meet you! Obviously you did Stormrage earlier this year -- how closely did you work with Blizzard on the book?
Richard A. Knaak: Everything was back and forth with them. I've been very fortunate from the beginning to work with a group of really fantastic people and I've been able to immerse myself in the game. Mick Neilson, who's the publishing lead right now and Evelyn the lore mistress, between those two especially every one of my questions would be answered quickly and efficiently, with a lot of graphics in case there was something that wasn't visible for me to see on the game.
They sent you screenshots?
I get lots of screenshots -- I see lots of things you won't be able to see for awhile! There's other people like James who works with Mick, he's one of the top publishing people too. And of course Chris [Metzen] has been there from the beginning -- he basically grew up reading my Dragonlance work, that's fantastic to me. Everyone's been great at Blizzard.
The book Stormrage covers a lot of material originally introduced in World of Warcraft. Did you play through the game?
I had been through elements of it, but there were so many things they kept coming to me with that were new. I've been well immersed in it. And god, the graphics get better and better all the time. It's been really fun. And I do as they ask of me for the storylines. So if something disgruntles someone about how the outcome of the story is, you can know that this was discussed thoroughly with myself and the people at Blizzard. They felt that these were the directions to go with things. I know that people would have liked to see more of the Emerald Dream in the game -- I myself was begging for it! They were very happy with how the novel turned out and how it explained quite a bit of what they wanted to do, which I'm very grateful for. They asked me to bring certain characters into the situation that I had not considered they would want to be using, but once they asked about them I said "Okay, that makes perfect sense." They wanted people to recognize a lot of what was going on.
Stormrage overall has been one of the most in-depth experiences yet. Although that will obviously change as time goes on, because every time the new stuff comes out -- I mean Cataclysm, let's face it, everything you knew is no longer what you knew – so there's going to be quite a bit of fun going back to places that are not quite the same anymore.
So far your focus has mostly been on Alliance -- you've had Broxigar, you've had Thura and of course all the tauren druids. Would you like to write more from the Horde perspective?
Oh I enjoy both sides -- if you've noticed the manga series, I have Trag, the first tauren deathknight as he turned out to be. I was very happy to see him in game -- I love Rhonin and Vereesa and all those characters but I've always had this thing for minotaurs. And when I came up with Trag for the second volume of the Sunwell Trilogy, I couldn't let go of him!

That's the thing -- I told them I needed to do another story and I told them what I wanted to do and they were fascinated by that. Tauren alone is a reason for me to do horde. I play a tauren, they're my favorites. I do like a lot of the more traditional aspects of the orcs. Broxigar was a terrific character for me, he was my creation and he just took on a life of his own. He had that essence about him, I was surprised at how much I got out of him. And when it came for him to do what he had to do at the end of War of the Ancients, it just made perfect sense that he be doing it.
Speaking of Thura -- she's Broxigar's niece. Who's her father?
That's something that we haven't fully -- we can't answer that right now. That was decided.
Was that deliberately omitted?
That was deliberately omitted, yes. But that doesn't mean you'll see something about it -- I think it was more omitted because we may decide to do something or we may not decide to do something. Unfortunately we have to leave a lot of things open, we can't put anything in stone. Unless it's a statue of Broxigar!
We heard that in Cataclysm there's going to be a Caverns of Time: War of the Ancients instance. How do you feel about that -- are they going to bring in characters from your books?
I would certainly enjoy anything that reflects back on the storyline that I did. So if anybody shows up, be it Malfurion or Tyrande or characters like Shandris or Jarod Shadowsong, if any of them would show up in there, I'd be very happy about that.
The War of the Ancients trilogy was a huge undertaking that covered a major war in Warcraft history. Would you like to cover the original War of the Shifting Sands with Fandral and his son?
There is nothing that I have on hand in that direction, but yeah, the Shifting Sands was always a really fun time. Blizzard is usually the one who comes and says we've got an idea that we'd like to propose to you, we'd like you to write about this. Sometimes I'll suggest things to them, and we'll go back and forth on it. It's really a two way process that works very well -- and let's face it, most everything they suggest is something that's certainly going to be of interest to most people.

I believe she read my book and the people at Blizzard helped her with it. She's so busy with things and I'm so busy with stuff -- if there's any questions she would have, I'd be happy to answer them and vice versa, but with people like Evelyn and the other people at Blizzard that know the background better than anybody, I think she's in safe hands. I'm sure they send her any relevant material or the book if she needed it. I get material all the time from them.
Fan reaction to you is notoriously polarized.
I've noticed that!
What do you say to that? What do you think about that?
First of all, A.) you're not going to please everybody. B.) I've had to do some things that they haven't necessarily liked, even if it wasn't necessarily my decision on that. C.) I seem to be enjoyed by the majority of the fans. I'm sorry that some people don't like what I do -- I know some people don't like what Christie or Aaron Rosenberg or others have done. I'm doing what Blizzard asked me to do and I'm trying to do it the best I can, for the most part I think I've done well with it. Some people make judgments based on things that are totally irrelevant to the book. And there's people who seem to think I've never played the game, which I did. I just tell them "When you're writing the books, you have to write the books!" So you can't go in the game as often as they do.
When you're writing about the game, you step away from playing it.
You have to! I'm a freelancer, we aren't paid to do this 24 hours a day unfortunately. Although I'd love to!
Thank you for your time Richard!
BlizzCon 2010 is upon us! WoW Insider has all the latest news and information. We're bringing you liveblogging of the WoW panels, interviews with WoW celebrities and attendees and of course, lots of pictures of people in costumes. It's all here at WoW Insider!Filed under: Interviews, BlizzCon






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 4)
Felix_rew Oct 23rd 2010 7:03PM
Must...resist...raging..
Kolyarut Oct 23rd 2010 7:10PM
Rage away to your hearts content!
Just try and make it about something he said in the interview that annoyed you - we've all heard enough "KNAAAAK" comments by now, right?
I still haven't read the guy's non-manga books yet, but I find his response to "do you play the game" interesting when contrasted and compared to Christie Golden's answer to the same question (hers being "yes, lots", essentially, compared to Knaak's "no, not really". I think the answer he's supplied there is a little bit iffy - yes, he has to work for a living, but so do the rest of us, and we manage to find time to play somewhere - I know if my job was writing about the game I'd make the effort to learn as much about it as I could...
niko Oct 23rd 2010 7:17PM
I dunno, I still quite enjoy a good KNAAAAAAAK post.
there's got to be some absolution therapy we're doing by seeing/posting this stuff.
oh, and this post is getting an /obligatory
KNAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAK
Chronos88 Oct 23rd 2010 7:44PM
Just be happy he didn't say "leviathan" throughout the entire interview. I'm very proud of him and I shall give him a cookie as a reward.
kabshiel Oct 23rd 2010 7:51PM
I like how his response to anything that people don't like about his books seems to be "Don't blame me, it's Blizzard's fault!"
brian Oct 23rd 2010 8:02PM
The thing is Knaak did some very good work fleshing out dragons and creating the Dragon Aspects. The reason they have an Accord and are more than creeps are because of him.
The thing is, when he strays from existing characters and starts forcing his own, there starts being a little too much "Writer on Board" and "Author Avatar"- pardon my tropes.
Shadda Oct 24th 2010 3:04AM
At the risk of being thumbed-down infinitely, I'd like to go on record saying I absolutely loved Stormrage.
/ducks in cover
Why? Lines like "I don't want your damned candle!" :D I loved the little details. As an alchemist, the creative use of Dreamless Sleep Potions made me laugh. Likewise, the description of hearthstones as a rare artefact seemed to be a joke shared with the reader. There was a lot of acknowledgement of the players within the novel (the group of adventurers who free Naralex from the Wailing Caverns, for example) and many of the most powerful heroes were written among the first to fall prey to the Emerald Dream, but perhaps people were miffed about their personal favourites missing out on the action?
People argue that Knaak's characterization is weak. While it's true that he focuses on the hero in action as opposed to the hero in everyday life (like Golden) I don't know that characterization is so much weak as contrary to the reader's preference. I've heard numerous female readers complain about how Tyrande is portrayed, ironically because she's not powerful enough. (How dare she learn from Azshara's pride? Where's the self-assured leader from Warcraft III who thoughtlessly slaughters Maiev's Wardens to free Illidan, then gets herself captured by Illidan, overwhelmed by the Scourge, and then saved by Illidan in The Frozen Throne?)
As for the characters being too powerful, many of the heroes of Azeroth fall prey to the Emerald Nightmare before the novel even begins. Ultimately the heroes triumph, but then we knew they would, didn't we? The game must go on...
arawn.chernobog Oct 23rd 2010 7:08PM
Knaak...
You...
GAH!
/storms_out_of_the_room_mumbling_profanities
lexxroth Oct 23rd 2010 9:12PM
Wow the nerve, to think Knaak deserves an interview...
Lol, honestly though, idk why so many people hate his books... I've only read 2 of them, but they weren't too bad. Maybe I'm missing something.
Juanin Oct 23rd 2010 7:06PM
Every time I read Knaak, my minds generates a "KNAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAK!" yell.
Dunno why.
Magma Oct 23rd 2010 7:10PM
Because it's similar to "KHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAN"?
Kolyarut Oct 23rd 2010 7:11PM
Because any time any article that mentions anything written by Knaak is posted 50% of the comments are this?
ioncat Oct 23rd 2010 7:13PM
Very good interview. I think Knaak pretty much proved the points I was making about his books a week ago.
Haters will be haters, unfortunately.
Zanathos Oct 23rd 2010 11:44PM
It's just inter-cool to hate him at this point, these things just snowball after a certain point.
Al Oct 24th 2010 2:51AM
How did that "prove" anything?
Draol Oct 23rd 2010 7:13PM
I've never quite understood why people hate Knaak so damn much. I never see it explained, mostly I just get to read the raging of "KNAAAAK!". I've read his books and I really don't see that much of a problem with them.
*shrug* Maybe I'm just weird.
roseclown Oct 23rd 2010 7:25PM
My issue mostly comes from being a snob when it comes to writing and plot elements.
You really don't want to hear my rant about the majority of Young Adult Fiction.... Seriously. Among my friends, I am notorious for my rants. Once one lasted an entire hour and thirty minutes. A rage fueled lecture.
The Pirate Oct 23rd 2010 7:32PM
He tends to butcher the REAL lore and his books are very....amateurish? I dunno i just think Christie Golden is my fave WoW Writer. Golden is like a 3 course meal at the Savoy. Knakk is like a cheap, greasy burger from Mc Ds
Sayomara Oct 23rd 2010 7:33PM
I honestly think its that fine line between fanfaction and published author. A fanfiction tends to be about someone personal characters put into a universe where they are more important than existing characters and the Existing characters spend all there time talk up those characters created by the Author. The Relationship between Rhonin and Illidan in the War of the Ancients trilogy might be seen an example of this.
However I would suggest that unlike fanfiction where characters are one dimensional conduit of awesome that sunder the world. Knaaks characters are for the most part well round if ungodly powerful.
My main issue is tends to use the same ideas to often through the course of a book. Foxbloods telporting in 'Stormrage' Sky chases in Demon Soul to name a few.
All that said his books are quick reads filled with action and while might hurt your mind the more you think about them they do tend to be enjoyable from a pulp fiction level. And to read the Interview it seems it trying to find that find line between good drama and fulling the story needs of blizzard. Sometimes it works some times it doesn't
Just my two copper
Tribunal Oct 23rd 2010 8:03PM
I -don't- hate anything, and I certainly don't hate him.
I just dislike his writing, and it's unfortunate that he was the one chosen to write a subject that I might otherwise enjoy. That's really all it's about.
But I dislike the writing of plenty of authors, including many who are popular or well liked.
Heck, I dislike the writing of some authors I enjoy... take for example Janet Evanovich. My mom -loves- her and convinced me to read one of her books. She has a keen eye for humor (she really can write some comedy) and a pretty good one for characters, but the rest of it is too formulaic and rote for my taste.
I -can- read her books just fine (and have since), but I tend to enjoy only pieces of them, vs. the whole book when the author's style doesn't irk me.