Shifting Perspectives: Why (or why not) to play a night elf druid

I owe you guys a cheat sheet for patch 4.0.3a and probably something on the recent tank cooldown announcements, but with raids still being tested on the beta, I'm afraid that Blizzard will make whatever I write obsolete within days. My informal sense of class balance as things stand now is that bears needed to be nerfed, cats might be nerfed a little bit (though perhaps not at all) and restoration is definitely going to get nerfed. I was wrong to predict that Blizzard would shy away from encounters with massive raid damage, though not as wrong as Blizzard was in reinstituting it. Rejuvenation spam, hoooooooo!
Anyway. In addition to updating our 101 and leveling guides when Cataclysm settles down, I've wanted to write a more lore-centric series on the new worgen and troll druids. While drafting those, I realized that what I really wanted to do was write a series on each druidic race now that the choice is more complicated than, "Are you playing Alliance or Horde?" While there are folks out there who can and will spend time on a character rolled purely for utility, most of us need to care about a toon in order to play it extensively. It's not really about roleplaying, it's about ... personality, for lack of a better word? As an example, I wound up deleting my first night elf because she bore a terrifying resemblance to Cher. I mean no offense to anyone who's a fan of her music, but the idea of Cher being able to Berserk is, at best, disturbing.
We'll start today with the original druids, the night elves.
The full series is available here:
- Shifting Perspectives: Why (or why not) to play a night elf druid
- Shifting Perspectives: Why (or why not) to play a tauren druid
- Shifting Perspectives: Why (or why not) to play a worgen druid
- Shifting Perspectives: Why (or why not) to play a troll druid
Two things:
- My perspective on all things Azeroth has been heavily influenced by two fan works: Blogatelle's Play Files and Travels Through Azeroth and Outland. The former is a series of roleplaying suggestions; the latter is a work of fan fiction. While I don't necessarily agree with everything said in either resource, they were both written by people who thought long and hard about what in-game quests and existing lore imply about any given character's background and psychology.
- I will probably tread on a few sacred cows in this series, and I apologize. The intent is not to bash races for their failings or to insult players for the choices they've made, but to examine druidic Warcraft cultures critically and ask why they can produce druids in the first place, why they do the things they do -- and, more uncomfortably, why they make the particular mistakes they make. Your character is not interesting because he or she has beaten the Lich King or faced a host of uglies within raids; I think WoW roleplayers are correct in their assertion that game mechanics invariably lend a touch of Mary-Sueism to the average player. Your character is interesting because he or she is the product of a culture with its own idiosyncratic view of the world.
You destroyed this forest, and for what? Arrows and weapons destined for the throat of an innocent? Shelters to whelp more of your unnatural race? You deserve the fate you gave these trees, and I intend to give it to you.
Random facts:
- Only male elves could be druids until recently; women became Sentinels or priestesses. Lorewise, this is assumed to have changed in the period between Warcraft 3 and the start of World of Warcraft.
- Female night elf druids were the race and class combination most likely to be played by an actual female player for the duration of classic WoW. There doesn't seem to be any recent data on this, so it's possible that this is no longer true. Judging from informal surveys I've seen pop up in player communities, women are most likely to play night elves, draenei and blood elves.
- Night elves are the third most popular race in the game with a 15 percent share of all characters as of patch 3.3.5 and were historically the second most popular until supplanted by blood elves.
There's an endless number of roleplaying possibilities or backstories with the night elves. You could be a 10,000-year-old druid who's spent most of his life in service to Ysera within the Emerald Dream, but you could just as easily be a young female elf completely new to the vocation. Do you resent the loss of your immortality? Did you approve of Teldrassil being grown?
Why you might not want to play one The night elves' two great failings are xenophobia and arrogance, although the latter is perhaps a misnomer. Central to their sense of identity is their recently lost immortality and how it's set them apart (and inescapably above) the mortal races of the world and their noisy, pointless little quarrels. Night elves aren't conditioned to believe that other races might have something important to say, and on the chance that, say, a human does distinguish himself, why should they care? They might not be immortal anymore, but they'll still outlive anything but a draenei by several hundred years.
So it's not particularly that the night elves are arrogant -- they're simply unable to relate. A night elf might reasonably ask of the Stormwind-Defias conflict why it's so important as long as the Westfall woodlands are being spared. The race collectively charged with the guardianship of the natural world has little apparent concern for the welfare of the sentient races within it.
Allie's take What's good about the night elves is very, very good. These guys have fought the Burning Legion for thousands of years, made the ultimate sacrifice to keep them at bay on the last go-round, and can always be counted upon to raise an army to address an existential threat. And yet ... what's bad about them is very, very bad. Whether it's Tyrande ordering the slaughter of her own Sentinels in Warcraft 3 in order to release Illidan, the Sentinels' firing on the orcs unprovoked, or the growing of Teldrassil, there's a persistent ugliness to how this race sees and relates to the world. At times, one wonders whether there are some among the night elves have confused their guardianship of nature with a sense of mastery over it.
Either way, this is probably the most consistently misunderstood race in World of Warcraft. They are not the happy, fluffy bunny people that the average player might assume of such a nature-centered race. Nature is a gentle summer rain, but it's also avalanches, flash floods and predators making a meal out of the weakest among a herd. The night elves are fine with this dichotomy, but not everyone will be.
Racial attributes
- Elusiveness Very helpful to stealth classes, and as a druid, you are one.
- Nature Resistance Tauren also have this, and it's a pretty situational bonus. Nature damage in high-end raiding has generally been rare outside of Ahn'Qiraj at level 60, but it's more common in 5-man content.
- Quickness This is an enormous tanking and PvP bonus and will only be more valuable in Cataclysm, with lower avoidance rates across the board. Keep in mind that while it functions like additional dodge, it's not dodge; it's a flat 2-percent reduction to the odds of melee or ranged attacks hitting you. As such, it doesn't proc the warrior ability Overpower, and you've still got the bonus even if you're stunned or incapacitated (which otherwise leaves your avoidance at a flat zero for the duration of the effect).
- Shadowmeld This is basically an amalgam of Feign Death and Vanish, and it's been used by disgruntled tanks everywhere to remove themselves from combat without warning if a group isn't behaving itself. On a less sadistic note, it also allows druids to escape from unwanted world PvP by Shadowmelding, switching to flight form and getting the hell out of Dodge. Most importantly, it's an unmatchable bonus if you plan on doing arena, because Shadowmeld allows you to escape combat in order to drink.
- Wisp Spirit Developers joked at BlizzCon 2008 that the priest talent Spirit of Redemption was essentially "Improved Death," and Wisp Spirit is an ability along those lines. However, with graveyards being more liberally scattered across the landscape (and closer to dungeons) in Cataclysm, it won't be quite as useful as it's been in the past.
Every week, Shifting Perspectives treks across Azeroth in pursuit of druidic truth, beauty and insight. Whether you're a bear, cat, moonkin, tree or stuck in caster form, we've got the skinny, from a look at the disappearance of the bear tank to thoughts on why you should be playing the class (or why not).Filed under: Druid, (Druid) Shifting Perspectives






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 6)
Randy Nov 2nd 2010 5:05PM
"We'll start today with the original druids, the night elves"
Hey Allison, you see all those pissed off Tauren stampeding your way? Thats because those lore loving hordies have some serious issues with the above statement and have some serious disputations with this statement.
jealouspirate Nov 2nd 2010 5:14PM
I can't seem to find it right now, but I remember reading a blue post that basically stated "while the Tauren believe they were the first Druids, they're wrong. The Night Elves were first".
Maybe someone else can post it if they know where it is?
jealouspirate Nov 2nd 2010 5:17PM
Aha! Found it! Posted by Nethaera
"Yes, Malfurion as the first druid is in fact possible and true.
Keep in mind that like all history, it tends to be from the perspective of the writer. As far as the Tauren are concerned they were the first taught by Cenarius. This is a 'truth' they hold dear to them and is taught to the members of their society as evidenced by their scrolls.
The actuality is that they were not the first to be taught the druidic arts, but it was in fact the Night Elves.
The Tauren believe they were first. The Night Elves were the first. "
http://forums.worldofwarcraft.com/thread.html?topicId=43884861&pageNo=4&sid=1#62
Allison Robert Nov 2nd 2010 5:37PM
Jealouspirate looked up the quote so I didn't have to! Yes, it's been officially confirmed by Nethaera that night elves were the first druids, so that's the line I'm sticking to here.
Then again, I've always wondered exactly how anyone could ever know this, because the origins of both night elves and tauren are not among the best-documented events in the game world. The tauren pictographic histories also make a number of oblique references to Old Gods and, IIRC, possibly even the qiraji, so I always wondered exactly when they appeared relative to the night elves. As far as I know, no one's ever confirmed how old each Azerothian race is ... and, of course, the standard lore was kind of blown to hell by recent novels anyway.
Wally Nov 2nd 2010 5:41PM
the operative word here is 'Taught' the night elves were the first to be instructed by Cenarious followed by Hamuul Runetotem. We Shu'halo have been honoring Mu'sha since before the trolls first pitched the tents of their beach party on the shores of the Well of Eternity. Well the night elves may be the first Cenarion Druids, we have been following the path since the dawn of time. Ish'ne'aloh Por'ah brothers!
Wally Nov 2nd 2010 5:47PM
regarding the age of the races, i believe the generally accepted conclusion amongst the lore buff community is that the trolls and tauren are the oldest of playable races, followed by the night elves, while concurrently the dwarves, humans, and gnomes were degenerating from titanic constructs in their various installations. Whether or not the trolls and tauren predate the arrival of the titans i don't think anyone really knows at this point.
Armill3 Nov 2nd 2010 5:59PM
Were the Night Elves Trolls first, though, and were they druidic then? Or were the Trolls Night Elves before undergoing a "Broken"-style de-evolution?
The one thing I want to know: How on Azeroth will the Night Elves of Moonglade tolerate the presence of Trolls? I know it isn't quite the same as High Elves v. Trolls, but there's a lot of animosity there.
SliceMessiah Nov 2nd 2010 6:01PM
Actually the key phrasing here is "The Tauren believe they were the first. The Night Elves were the first." Y'all need to get over this "Tauren were the frist Druids" thing. They weren't. End of story. Move the hell on. You don't have to go home, but you can't stay here.
By the way, this comes from someone who LOVES the Tauren (PS OMG I can't wait for my Tauren Pally!). It doesn't matter so much who was first. The Tauren have been who they are longer than pretty much anything else in Azeroth. Just because they weren't shapeshifting and Moonfiring before Night Elves doesn't make them crappy knock offs. Besides, they improved on the model. Who's a better tank, a bear with feathers, or a bear with some badass horns?
Socialcockroach Nov 2nd 2010 6:04PM
Well, when taken in context from warcraft 3, when druids were first introduced to Azerothian lore, Night Elves WERE the original druids.
As for WoW lore, the referances to the Shu'Halo as the first druids is rather vague. If we assume the ancient tauren mythos is correct, then Cenarius did teach them druidic arts to the tauren first. The only real problem with this is that blizzard has directly stated that Night Elves were first, and that the tauren myths, while a 'truth' in the eyes of a tauren, are just myths.
Socialcockroach Nov 2nd 2010 6:06PM
Bah, when I started my response, his was the only comment shown. Should have refreshed the page before re-hashing what every one has said already. :(
Lemons Nov 2nd 2010 6:13PM
Well that's one battle the Alliance won...lets check the total shall we?
Alliance: 6
Horde: 4,597
We're making a comeback! *weak-hearted cheers*
Kilaybay Nov 2nd 2010 6:43PM
See, that's all well and good about what Nethaera said back in 2006, but then Blizzard went and added in http://www.wowhead.com/npc=30381#comments (Xarantaur, the witness), who says "I was one of the first tauren druids, of the last generation taught by Shan'do Cenarius, before the legion, before the sundering, when the world was still young. Before everything changed."
Which implies that there were Tauren druids before him, and well before the Sundering, while Malfurion only began to learn Druidism a few weeks before the Sundering. He goes on to say that Cenarius left the Tauren and they began to forget Druidism, which may lead to the discrepancy between who learned it first.
Blizzard's rewritten lore before. Not saying this definitely means Tauren were the first, but it makes a good argument.
Oteo Nov 2nd 2010 8:40PM
First, schmirst. I'm not as concerned with who were the FIRST druids as I am with who are the *best* druids. (hint: moo!) }:0] tauren pride
Jorges Nov 2nd 2010 9:09PM
@Wally: Isn't Mu'Sha how Taurens call Elune? I don't know how that is related with Taurens following the druidic path or not.
I think you're confused with Paladins and "The Light".
lilywillylover Nov 2nd 2010 10:37PM
Actually, I think Blizzard changed their mind about the Night Elves being the first Druidic race.
Because of...
http://www.wowpedia.org/Xarantaur
And in War of the Ancients novel by Knaak. He mentioned that Malfurion is the first mortal Druids while the Druids before have since turned into eternals and other such creatures.
Dizzle Nov 3rd 2010 6:22PM
Mu'sha is one of the earthmothers eyes, while there compelling evidence to suggest it(as KYL has mentioned) Mu'sha ! elune,
that being said, no, E'lune ! Naaru
Also, An'she ! holy light.
there all mythological perspectives that were tailored to the respective races, and while it could be true they are one in the same no where is that specifically stated.
jealouspirate Nov 2nd 2010 5:11PM
Great article!
"You destroyed this forest, and for what? Arrows and weapons destined for the throat of an innocent? Shelters to whelp more of your unnatural race? You deserve the fate you gave these trees, and I intend to give it to you."
Where is that from? Because it's f***ing badass. Sorry if I missed the source!
Overall, I really like the Night Elves... but ugh, their models in-game. Not a fan. Really, I think Blizzard did the Night Elves a disservice in WoW, both in terms of models and their
"feel". WoW portrays them as docile 'tree-huggers', but I remember playing WC3 and they were savage, badass, and merciless warriors. They did NOT bounce their breasts at every opportunity, and they weren't all soft-spoken niceties.
Basically, I want Night Elves to get their edge back.
Noah Nov 2nd 2010 5:36PM
I don't know where its from. Probably Warcraft 3.
But judging from my knowledge of lore, that was said by Tyrande Whisperwind when she met the orcs cutting down Ashenvale's trees for the first time. Grom Hellscream was leader of that expedition.
Lemons Nov 2nd 2010 6:06PM
I don't think being soft-spoken precludes being a fierce warrior. It's not like they're at war with the people they're talking to. I enjoy the nelfs current voices and I'd be quite put-off if they started talking all military-like all the time.
Allison Robert Nov 2nd 2010 6:38PM
Actually, it doesn't come from anywhere -- I just made it up as an appropriate-sounding night elf "soundbite." That said, it's something that would have been said by a night elf to the orcs when the war over the Ashenvale forest (i.e. Warsong Gulch) began, and that's what I had in mind.