Know Your Lore: The Third War, part 2

A few months back, I started on an overview of the Third War. As you can see from reading it, the following week, I did not in fact talk about the Third War at all. If you're familiar with my Thrall piece for KYL, you understand this is something that happens to me from time to time. I fully intended to go into more details about the war, but I got sidetracked by something shiny or a colorful ball of twine or what have you.
But with Wrath of the Lich King a month from its exit from center stage, it's time to look back again at the war that made it all possible.
After the Culling of Stratholme, Arthas Menethil had taken his first steps into obsession. The Culling itself is often treated as an indefensible act that proves Arthas was already evil, but I personally see it as the first tipping point, when a young and idealistic man who wanted to do right by his people was presented with an untenable choice and let his own impulsive nature decide. Waiting outside the city for the residents to turn into undead and destroying them as they attempted to escape was, after all, neither a more merciful nor a more prudent option. In the end, Arthas made the choice he did, and in so doing alienated both Uther, his direct superior as a paladin (and one who has his father's ear, to boot) and Jaina, his on-again, off-again romance. This left him free to pursue Mal'Ganis to Northrend.
His actions would change the face of Azeroth and her nations forever.
The roof of the world
At the time, not much was known of Northrend by the peoples of the Eastern Kingdoms. There had been some expeditions sent to the forbidding roof of the world, and some small colonies had been settled in its more temperate climes, but it was for the most part a wilderness of harsh climates, hostile cultures and unknown mysteries. It was in the area known to us today as the Dragonblight that young Prince Arthas made landfall and began his preparations to find and destroy Mal'Ganis, the object of his obsession.
Amazingly, his old friend and weapons trainer Muradin Bronzebeard was also in Northrend at the time. I've often wondered how, exactly, Muradin learned of Frostmourne and began to seek it out, since the Lich King had brought the blade with him to Northrend and forced it out of his icy prison in order to use it in his elaborate plan for escape and revenge. Since we know the Lich King always intended Arthas to find the blade, did he whisper its location directly into Muradin's mind?
After helping Muradin against waves of undead that threatened his expedition, Arthas decided to seek out the runeblade the dwarf told him about in order to use its power to destroy Mal'Ganis. So devoted was he to this task that when news from his father in Lordaeron called Arthas' ships back home, he went to extreme lengths to avoid answering his father's summons. Arthas hired mercenaries to burn his own ships, then diverted his angry, homesick soldiers and their justifiable anger onto those self-same mercenaries, who were then killed.
Having successfully trapped his men, Arthas led them against the undead and, with Muradin's help, found the cavern where Frostmourne lay. Defeating an elemental revenant set to guard the blade, Muradin and Arthas read the inscription and learned of the blade's curse, but nothing was beyond Arthas at this point. What the Culling did not destroy in his once idealistic spirit, the betrayal of his own men and his mercenaries had.
So must power scar the spirit
Whomsoever takes up this blade shall wield power eternal. Just as the blade rends flesh, so must power scar the spirit.
This warning, carved beneath the runeblade, proved true. Taking the blade did indeed scar young Arthas Menethil, rendering what remained of the young, eager paladin as cold and dead as the people of Stratholme he'd tried to protect from the curse of undead by destroying them himself, as chill and foreboding as the cavern he'd found the blade in. Leaving Muradin's seemingly lifeless body where it lie (the explosion of the runeblade's icy pedestal smashing the thickheaded dwarf into an unconsciousness so profound that an uncaring Arthas took it for death), the former paladin led his remaining forces against Mal'Ganis. The dreadlord confronted Arthas, believing himself safe because (as he explained) the second Arthas took up the runeblade it had rendered him a soulless servant of the Lich King, prompting him to look within himself to see the Lich King's will.
Sure enough, Arthas was now a slave to Frostmourne and the Lich King. However, the Lich King whispered in his new tool's mind that he should indeed have his vengeance against Mal'Ganis, and the dreadlord was quickly (although as we now know, not permanently) dispatched. Some time after this, Arthas turned Frostmourne on his own men, rendering them lifeless slaves as well. Certain members of his forces like Falric and Marwynn were favored with more autonomy than the vast majority of his forces and retained personality and mind. Most did not.
Arthas then returned to Lordaeron, months after he had left it as a driven, obsessed but still fundamentally noble person who wanted the best for his land and people. Slaughtering his aged father, King Terenas Menethil, with Frostmourne, he assumed the throne of a nation soon to cease its existence.
Under its new king, Lordaeron became a nation of corpses and victims, and although many did flee to safety in the south, those who did not escape the regions today known as Tirisfal Glades and the Plaguelands were either slain and converted or trapped in enclaves like Tyr's Hand. Madness, walking in the form of Arthas, had claimed the land and dredged its gaping graves for undead fodder.
But murdering his father and his nation was only the beginning. In order to carry out his master's plans, Arthas would have to claim the urn containing his father's ashes, and to do that, he would have to murder Uther the Lightbringer himself. He did both. He then marched his horrific armies north through the Eversong Woods, through the ancient elfgates defending the city of Quel'Thalas and right to the Sunwell itself, despite the heroic resistance of high elven heroes like Sylvanas Windrunner, the Ranger General of SIlvermoon. Sylvanas herself, for her efforts, was taken captive by the death knight fratricide, who tortured her for daring to stand against him and ripped her spirit from her body to linger in undeath as a banshee.
Arthas struck down Anasterian Sunstrider, the King of Quel'thalas, and brought the remains of the fallen necromancer Kel'Thuzad to the Sunwell itself. He hurled them into the font of magic for the high elves, utterly befouling and destroying it in the process of raiding the necromancer as a lich. In so doing, Arthas had by this point destroyed two of the most ancient nations in the Eastern Kingdoms -- but all of this was merely a warm-up. The true danger was yet to come, as the purpose of the raising of the Scourge and the creation of the Lich King was at hand.
The death knight and lich led their undead forces to Dalaran, the magical city of the Kirin Tor. Despite the best efforts of the most powerful mages the continent had to offer, they seized the Book of Medivh and used its magical secrets to tear open a portal potent enough for Archimonde the Defiler to step bodily onto Azeroth again -- the first time the Legion was able to enter the world in force in over 10,000 years.
The Defiler returns
Archimonde - The Destruction of DalaranLet this scar signify the first blow against the mortal world
From this seal shall arise the doom of men, who, in their arrogance, sought to wield our fire as their own.
Blindly they build their kingdoms upon stolen knowledge and conceit.
Now they shall be consumed by the very flame they sought to control.
Let the echoes of doom resound across this wretched world, that all who live may hear them and despair.
From this seal shall arise the doom of men, who, in their arrogance, sought to wield our fire as their own.
Blindly they build their kingdoms upon stolen knowledge and conceit.
Now they shall be consumed by the very flame they sought to control.
Let the echoes of doom resound across this wretched world, that all who live may hear them and despair.
Archimonde's arrival left the Scourge in somewhat of a position of playing second fiddle. The Defiler quickly moved to appoint trusted Legion dreadlord Tichondrius to oversee their corpse army and declared no further need for the Lich King, even as Kel'Thuzad warned Arthas not to trust them. The Lich King had seen it coming; his death and rebirth at the hands of Kil'jaeden had removed any blinders the former shaman Ner'zhul had about the Legion and their habitual betrayals. Indeed, the perfidy of the Legion was exactly what the Lich King had hoped for, as it rendered Kel'Thuzad and Arthas free agents, no longer part of the general Scourge forces under the demons' control.
Knowing of the existence of Kalimdor and the ultimate plan of the Defiler to destroy the night elves who had balked the first demonic invasion of the world of Azeroth 10 millennia before, the Lich King sent Arthas to find and push over the one domino that would lead to the Legion's defeat.
Next time in Know Your Lore: the clash of orc and night elf, the command of the prophet, the ascent up the slopes of Mount Hyjal of armies of the Legion, and the Defiler's ultimate fate. I'm busily taking all the exciting shiny things out of my workspace even now to prepare.
While you don't need to have played the previous Warcraft games to enjoy World of Warcraft, a little history goes a long way toward making the game a lot more fun. Dig into even more of the lore and history behind the World of Warcraft in WoW Insider's Guide to Warcraft Lore.Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Lore, Know your Lore
Patch 5.3 interview with Ghostcrawler
Mystery of the Unborn Val'kyr
The latest patch 5.3 news
All of the latest Mists of Pandaria news





Reader Comments (Page 2 of 5)
Angrycelt Nov 3rd 2010 7:34PM
I still find it interesting, considering the treatment Sylvanas received from Arthypants, that she'd take such a similar path in Cata.
Need more troops? Kill the living, raise 'em as your own. Forsaken players can argue about "free will" all they want, but my guess is they're not exactly taking just volunteers in that war against Gilneas, and I'm sure they're asking, right before they kill them, "Hey, you wanna come back as one of us? By the way, don't ask me how I'm talking, seeing as I don't have a jaw, and my tongue's just hanging straight out of my neck".
Blayze Nov 3rd 2010 7:45PM
Now I'm imagining the dead signing consent forms--or rather, banshees possessing corpses to make them sign consent forms.
Darky Nov 3rd 2010 8:27PM
Its rather hard to keep empathy of the living when they've sworn you as their eternal enemies; with good reason of course. The reason the forsaken hate everything is that everything hates them, you would have to be lying to say otherwise. It is clearly shown throughout all of wow and warcraft 3 how hated the undead in general are. Hate is incredibly infectious, every piece of hate you inflict it tends to tripple the inflicted's hate onto you. An example of this would be bullies in real life, in school you rarely see a bully well and truly hate their victims, they pick someone weak and vent their anger; the hate that they feel is nothing compared to how much the nerd/geek's rage against the bully.
Of course there are always grey zones but in games and literature like this they tend to ignore things like that.
Getting back to the point, the entire world showed nothing but fierce hatred to anything undead, and the fact anyone who was once undead used to hate the undead as well, all of that hate against themselves and from everyone else turns the majority of them into supervillan archetypes. Sylvannas is the leader of the forsaken and she is probably the least hated member of the forsaken but she is still utterly hated by entire civilisations, she may as well be hitler even if she did nothing but pick flowers and attempt to cure herself. To sylvannas such a thing would be admitting she deserved to be hated, admitting she may as well go and kill herself, but as we can see from her live self she is a survivor and most of all she hates defeat.
The saying in for a penny out for a pound lies heavily around the forsakens lore. Yes there is no real evidence of Sylvannas thinking well everyone/thing thinks we are nothing but despicable beings that are capable of unthinkable actions, so we may as well do such things and make it worthwhile. But I believe this is how the actions themselves came to place. If she was in the same position but everyone (including the alliance) saw them as respectable allies/enemies such as the Tauren then it would be unlikely she would've gone down such a dark path.
All in all she is still on her way to being a raid boss because of her actions in both pre and post cataclysm. But it is not one of those unexplainable events, going through a process that turned you into one of the most hated beings in existence is not going to end well; especially if they can be in a situation to put everyone else in that same miserable position.
TL;DR Her position is completely explainable, how would you feel and act if you were turned into a being that is universally hated (even by yourself)?
(sorry if this is a little all over the place, I have a tendency of doing such things in first drafts but I don't truly have the energy to spend hours getting it just right; I don't get pay per post :P)
Darky Nov 3rd 2010 8:30PM
* hates the bully.
Angus Nov 3rd 2010 8:52PM
Oh please, it isn't like the Forsaken have any shortage of "volunteers" thanks to Arthas in Northrend, the Argent Tourney's many "losers," and Deathwing's little project.
At this point in time the Forsaken has a bunch of suitable candidates for recruitment. They don't need to kill anyone to get bodies.
Darky Nov 3rd 2010 9:03PM
I said understandable not excusable, she does it to be malicious.
A_V Nov 3rd 2010 11:44PM
Sylvanas isn't killing innocents to raise as more undead, she's simply raising those very many already dead after the Wrath-era wars.
Fletcher Nov 3rd 2010 11:59PM
A very good summation of Sylvanas' psychology, Darky; thank you. Anyone who's seen me post around here before probably knows my opinion on Sylvanas and the Forsaken (in summation: Death to the Dead! And Death to SYLVANAS!), but that doesn't preclude an understanding of where they're coming from. I do think that under Sylvanas they can't be anything more than Scourge 2.0 ... which makes it all the more interesting to see where this is going. With Sylvanas heading towards bosshood and epic purples pinata, one has to wonder what the Forsaken will do with their unlives once they're out from under the thumb of the Banshee Queen.
busuan Nov 4th 2010 12:57AM
Sylvanas and her Forsakens are in a dire position. Their purpose, to revenge their undeath against Arthas is now finished. Unlike all other races, they don't have a life to go back to live! The only people (strange word) similar to them are Darion's death knights. But he was foretold by his father that one day he would wield the Ashbringer. The death kights could be waiting for their next calling -- they still have a purpose of existence although they knew they "didn't belong to this world."
Yet, for Sylvanas' free-willed undead, there is nothing left, no future, only a past 'normal' that they could never get back to. As their leader, it's up to her to install such a purpose. Probably if her undead are fighting a war as an army, the "control" is maintained. She knew or not isn't important.
What's worse for them is, they can't even become dead to free up their souls or spirits bounded by their rotting flesh! As Sylvanas recently found out, there was "only darkness in front of her". Sounds familiar? The world of Azeroth simply does not care if an undead is innocent or not, righteous or not. Undeath is a mistake. Undeath does not fit in the ways favored by the Titans. Sylvanas saw that when her soul was fading away; the Forsaken's fate was defined at the birth of Azeroth: oblivion. Sylvanas might have also seen some clue in her Val'kyrs. We'll have to how it plays out.
pandaba Nov 4th 2010 7:06AM
Those that were once oppressed or abused will often use the same sort of abuse on others once they are in a place of power to do so.
This is true on both an individual level and on a tribal / national level. Abused children will often grow up to become abusers themselves. An oppressed population may revolt against their leaders, but the new revolutionary government will then often prove to be as oppressive, or more so, as their predecessors. In a way, the abused and oppressed learn what works at the hand of the one who enslaves them.
MikeLive Nov 3rd 2010 7:46PM
I have a Know Your Lore question.
Why is Thrall green? By all accounts I can tell, he should be brown. While Durotan and the Frostwolves crossed over to Azeroth with the rest of the Horde, they were exiled, settling in Alterac Mountains. They were exiled because they refused to drink to Blood of Mannoroth, and Thrall was born untainted. And yet, green.
Alchemistmerlin Nov 3rd 2010 8:07PM
In "Rise of the Horde" they lolore it by saying that, while the Frostwolf clan did not drink demon blood, they did spend a lot of time very close to fel energy while in Hellfire Citadel, causing them to turn green. After that, it was simply genetics?
MikeLive Nov 3rd 2010 8:08PM
Ahh, that makes... some sense. Though doesn't explain why other Orcs in Hellfire (coughGarroshcough) remained brown. Guess they just wanted the leader of the greenskins to be green?
Bouncing Gnome Nov 3rd 2010 8:23PM
Tainted Orcs are Red (like the ones in Hellfire). The Brown Orcs of Outland turned red when they drank the blood and became enraged/addicted. When the taint and rage left them they mellowed to green. I don't know why.
In direct answer to your question, Thrall was born untainted, but of tainted parents.
ducss750 Nov 3rd 2010 9:12PM
Off-topic
(I keep hearing Soft Cell's "Tainted Love" when I read these comments about Thrall)
Al Nov 4th 2010 12:40AM
Because Thrall has to be perfect, they ret-conned his tribe into being innocent. This required them not drinking the blood and not killing anyone. They forgot to explain away how they got so far north, but the Fel energies in Helfire turned them green. This required the Mag'har to have been handily quarantined, but they somehow can scout around Helfire without turning green as well.
Cambro Nov 4th 2010 1:30AM
My best understanding, from reading "Rise of the Horde", is that all the Horde were brown originally. When the shaman started learning the fel magicks taught to them by Gul'dan and became warlocks, just being in proximity to the fel magicks started turning all the Orcs' skin green. There is a point in the book where Durotan and his mate notice each other's brown skin gradually becoming brittle and flaky, and on scratching, uncovering green layers of skin underneath.
So as to why Thrall is green-skinned, I don't think this has ever been answered or really addressed, but I interpret as a genetic trait that was passed on from his parents, whose skin had turned green several years before he was born. If you also notice child Orcs running around Shattrath's Lower City, they are also green.
What _I_ do not understand is the whole thing about the Mag'har remaining oncorrupted, unless they all belonged to a clan of Orcs that had nothing to do with basically any of the other Orcs. "Rise of the Horde" emphasizes that Ner'zhul/Gul'dan united (all) the Orcish clans for the first time ever, using Archimonde's lie that the Draenei were going to exterminate them. There is no mention in the book of a clan saying "screw you guys, we're going off on our own" and in fact Durotan is under a state of constant threat to go along with the rest of his clans, for fear that the Frostwolf clan would be killed for noncompliance.
I think the whole Mag'har/red tainted Orc thing was retconned in for the purposes of the Burning Crusade expansion.
Another question I personally have: Greatmother Geyah tells Thrall that his real name is Go'el, but I don't remember her telling him what his name means, or who gave him the name. In "Lord of the Clans", Durotan and Draka take their infant son (as yet unnamed until the next lunar cycle or something) to visit Orgrim in secret and are assassinated just after leaving his camp. Did I miss something somewhere? And if his parents had already picked out his name, they were in Azeroth while Geyah was in Outland, so how would she even know his name if his existence and even the fate of Durotan and Draka were unknown until he showed up as a teenager on the Frostwolves' doorstep in the Alterac mountains?
Someone hand me my red shirt...
Astalnar Nov 4th 2010 3:12AM
@ Cambro
To your question about Thrall's real name. Just start telling yourself that spirits told her.
relmatos Nov 4th 2010 6:37AM
Thrall was green back in warcraft 3.
It really wouldnt look good if they just changed his skin color for WoW.
Sometimes lore will flicker because of past games. That's why we have to turn a blind eye to some inconsistencies.
Fraeda Nov 4th 2010 8:46AM
"A wizard did it."