Know Your Lore: The Third War, part 2

A few months back, I started on an overview of the Third War. As you can see from reading it, the following week, I did not in fact talk about the Third War at all. If you're familiar with my Thrall piece for KYL, you understand this is something that happens to me from time to time. I fully intended to go into more details about the war, but I got sidetracked by something shiny or a colorful ball of twine or what have you.
But with Wrath of the Lich King a month from its exit from center stage, it's time to look back again at the war that made it all possible.
After the Culling of Stratholme, Arthas Menethil had taken his first steps into obsession. The Culling itself is often treated as an indefensible act that proves Arthas was already evil, but I personally see it as the first tipping point, when a young and idealistic man who wanted to do right by his people was presented with an untenable choice and let his own impulsive nature decide. Waiting outside the city for the residents to turn into undead and destroying them as they attempted to escape was, after all, neither a more merciful nor a more prudent option. In the end, Arthas made the choice he did, and in so doing alienated both Uther, his direct superior as a paladin (and one who has his father's ear, to boot) and Jaina, his on-again, off-again romance. This left him free to pursue Mal'Ganis to Northrend.
His actions would change the face of Azeroth and her nations forever.
The roof of the world
At the time, not much was known of Northrend by the peoples of the Eastern Kingdoms. There had been some expeditions sent to the forbidding roof of the world, and some small colonies had been settled in its more temperate climes, but it was for the most part a wilderness of harsh climates, hostile cultures and unknown mysteries. It was in the area known to us today as the Dragonblight that young Prince Arthas made landfall and began his preparations to find and destroy Mal'Ganis, the object of his obsession.
Amazingly, his old friend and weapons trainer Muradin Bronzebeard was also in Northrend at the time. I've often wondered how, exactly, Muradin learned of Frostmourne and began to seek it out, since the Lich King had brought the blade with him to Northrend and forced it out of his icy prison in order to use it in his elaborate plan for escape and revenge. Since we know the Lich King always intended Arthas to find the blade, did he whisper its location directly into Muradin's mind?
After helping Muradin against waves of undead that threatened his expedition, Arthas decided to seek out the runeblade the dwarf told him about in order to use its power to destroy Mal'Ganis. So devoted was he to this task that when news from his father in Lordaeron called Arthas' ships back home, he went to extreme lengths to avoid answering his father's summons. Arthas hired mercenaries to burn his own ships, then diverted his angry, homesick soldiers and their justifiable anger onto those self-same mercenaries, who were then killed.
Having successfully trapped his men, Arthas led them against the undead and, with Muradin's help, found the cavern where Frostmourne lay. Defeating an elemental revenant set to guard the blade, Muradin and Arthas read the inscription and learned of the blade's curse, but nothing was beyond Arthas at this point. What the Culling did not destroy in his once idealistic spirit, the betrayal of his own men and his mercenaries had.
So must power scar the spirit
Whomsoever takes up this blade shall wield power eternal. Just as the blade rends flesh, so must power scar the spirit.
This warning, carved beneath the runeblade, proved true. Taking the blade did indeed scar young Arthas Menethil, rendering what remained of the young, eager paladin as cold and dead as the people of Stratholme he'd tried to protect from the curse of undead by destroying them himself, as chill and foreboding as the cavern he'd found the blade in. Leaving Muradin's seemingly lifeless body where it lie (the explosion of the runeblade's icy pedestal smashing the thickheaded dwarf into an unconsciousness so profound that an uncaring Arthas took it for death), the former paladin led his remaining forces against Mal'Ganis. The dreadlord confronted Arthas, believing himself safe because (as he explained) the second Arthas took up the runeblade it had rendered him a soulless servant of the Lich King, prompting him to look within himself to see the Lich King's will.
Sure enough, Arthas was now a slave to Frostmourne and the Lich King. However, the Lich King whispered in his new tool's mind that he should indeed have his vengeance against Mal'Ganis, and the dreadlord was quickly (although as we now know, not permanently) dispatched. Some time after this, Arthas turned Frostmourne on his own men, rendering them lifeless slaves as well. Certain members of his forces like Falric and Marwynn were favored with more autonomy than the vast majority of his forces and retained personality and mind. Most did not.
Arthas then returned to Lordaeron, months after he had left it as a driven, obsessed but still fundamentally noble person who wanted the best for his land and people. Slaughtering his aged father, King Terenas Menethil, with Frostmourne, he assumed the throne of a nation soon to cease its existence.
Under its new king, Lordaeron became a nation of corpses and victims, and although many did flee to safety in the south, those who did not escape the regions today known as Tirisfal Glades and the Plaguelands were either slain and converted or trapped in enclaves like Tyr's Hand. Madness, walking in the form of Arthas, had claimed the land and dredged its gaping graves for undead fodder.
But murdering his father and his nation was only the beginning. In order to carry out his master's plans, Arthas would have to claim the urn containing his father's ashes, and to do that, he would have to murder Uther the Lightbringer himself. He did both. He then marched his horrific armies north through the Eversong Woods, through the ancient elfgates defending the city of Quel'Thalas and right to the Sunwell itself, despite the heroic resistance of high elven heroes like Sylvanas Windrunner, the Ranger General of SIlvermoon. Sylvanas herself, for her efforts, was taken captive by the death knight fratricide, who tortured her for daring to stand against him and ripped her spirit from her body to linger in undeath as a banshee.
Arthas struck down Anasterian Sunstrider, the King of Quel'thalas, and brought the remains of the fallen necromancer Kel'Thuzad to the Sunwell itself. He hurled them into the font of magic for the high elves, utterly befouling and destroying it in the process of raiding the necromancer as a lich. In so doing, Arthas had by this point destroyed two of the most ancient nations in the Eastern Kingdoms -- but all of this was merely a warm-up. The true danger was yet to come, as the purpose of the raising of the Scourge and the creation of the Lich King was at hand.
The death knight and lich led their undead forces to Dalaran, the magical city of the Kirin Tor. Despite the best efforts of the most powerful mages the continent had to offer, they seized the Book of Medivh and used its magical secrets to tear open a portal potent enough for Archimonde the Defiler to step bodily onto Azeroth again -- the first time the Legion was able to enter the world in force in over 10,000 years.
The Defiler returns
Archimonde - The Destruction of DalaranLet this scar signify the first blow against the mortal world
From this seal shall arise the doom of men, who, in their arrogance, sought to wield our fire as their own.
Blindly they build their kingdoms upon stolen knowledge and conceit.
Now they shall be consumed by the very flame they sought to control.
Let the echoes of doom resound across this wretched world, that all who live may hear them and despair.
From this seal shall arise the doom of men, who, in their arrogance, sought to wield our fire as their own.
Blindly they build their kingdoms upon stolen knowledge and conceit.
Now they shall be consumed by the very flame they sought to control.
Let the echoes of doom resound across this wretched world, that all who live may hear them and despair.
Archimonde's arrival left the Scourge in somewhat of a position of playing second fiddle. The Defiler quickly moved to appoint trusted Legion dreadlord Tichondrius to oversee their corpse army and declared no further need for the Lich King, even as Kel'Thuzad warned Arthas not to trust them. The Lich King had seen it coming; his death and rebirth at the hands of Kil'jaeden had removed any blinders the former shaman Ner'zhul had about the Legion and their habitual betrayals. Indeed, the perfidy of the Legion was exactly what the Lich King had hoped for, as it rendered Kel'Thuzad and Arthas free agents, no longer part of the general Scourge forces under the demons' control.
Knowing of the existence of Kalimdor and the ultimate plan of the Defiler to destroy the night elves who had balked the first demonic invasion of the world of Azeroth 10 millennia before, the Lich King sent Arthas to find and push over the one domino that would lead to the Legion's defeat.
Next time in Know Your Lore: the clash of orc and night elf, the command of the prophet, the ascent up the slopes of Mount Hyjal of armies of the Legion, and the Defiler's ultimate fate. I'm busily taking all the exciting shiny things out of my workspace even now to prepare.
While you don't need to have played the previous Warcraft games to enjoy World of Warcraft, a little history goes a long way toward making the game a lot more fun. Dig into even more of the lore and history behind the World of Warcraft in WoW Insider's Guide to Warcraft Lore.Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Lore, Know your Lore
Patch 5.4 patch notes
Virtual Realms feature revealed
The Proving Grounds are coming
The latest patch 5.4 news





Reader Comments (Page 4 of 5)
chris crouse Nov 3rd 2010 9:24PM
Rossi, this is pretty clunky. Many of the sentences should be broken up and separated by individual ideas. It's fine for spoken conversation, but too many of the sentences have too many side points that are extremely distracting.
jarrett miller Nov 3rd 2010 10:37PM
If I was in Arthas's place I would have purged the city.
arcaneterror Nov 3rd 2010 10:47PM
By the way, Rossi, the language is Eredun, not Eredar. Just a little nitpicky detail but I love the draenei/eredar lore, so I caught that one.
Sl0th Nov 4th 2010 1:09AM
One thing occurred to me as I read this.
Who exactly wrote the inscription Muradin read before Arthas took up Frostmourne? I don't think the Lich King would have hurled out some kind of warning plaque along with the sword (Granted, the warning didn't do much to stop Arthas, but still...) I don't think the the Dreadlords would have written it either, given they wanted Arthas as an agent of the Scourge to help bring down Lorderon from the inside and further set the stage for the Legion's re-entry into Azeroth. It seems like the most likely author would be the revenant who guarded the blade. But then, why would they do so and at who's behest? In fact, why were they there to begin with?
The best answer I've come up with is that Yogg-Sarron - given that the Old Gods still appear to have some sway over elementals - may have sent them in order to curtail the Lich King and Legion's move to take the world it and its breathern have long been trying to claim as their own. But I have nothing to back up that bit of tinfoil hat wearing aside from there being very few beings outside the Scourge and Legion who could have known of the Lich King's existence at that point and who would have had cause and/or the means to slow the Legion-led Scourge's advance. Also, elemental revenants would not likely have succumb to wanting to wield Frostmourne themselves and probably couldn't be otherwise brought under the control of the Lich King, so they'd make excellent guards for a relic like Frostmourne.
Daedalus Nov 4th 2010 8:53AM
Actually, I don't think it's too far out there to think that the Lich King might have had the inscription put there.
Without the inscription, Arthas (and everyone else) could believe that he was tricked, duped into becoming a tool; that might have given him some scrap of humanity to hold on to; a way to believe that there might be some hope for him, if he broke free of the spell he was placed under.
However, by putting the inscription there, taking the sword became a willing act of self-damnation. Arthas knowingly gave up his soul; he walked into it with both eyes open.
By making it a concientous choice, the Lich King took away any chance for Arthas to regret, and try to change his mind; this was his own doing, and he'd have to live (sort of) with the consequences.
$am Nov 4th 2010 2:39AM
You forgot a very important note imo, when Arthas took the sword himself, Arthas clearly said : "I'll gladly bare any curse to save my homelands" and "I'll give anything and pay any price only if it helps saving my people"
These lines show that Arthas (also he went to evil) clearly was thinking he is doing the right thing.
In Arthas: Rise of the Lich King (which was very good book) it is clear that Arthas even after becoming a Death Knight still thinks he is acting the right thing, by raising his own horse : invincible
I know this article is not about Arthas, its about the 3rd war, but still you made Arthas (who is one of pure evil characters) seems to acting evil for just being evil, like old gods or burning legion, Arthas is evil but he believes deep down he is doing the right thing
Elazul Yagami Nov 4th 2010 3:23AM
Not true in the slightest.
http://www.wowwiki.com/Arcane
Quote:
"Arcane magic is the gift of titans to the world, a gift that comes with the highest price. Thousands of years ago, the titans placed the Well of Eternity in the center of Kalimdor to serve as a source of restoring, life-giving energy. They intended that the Well's energies would empower life of all forms to emerge on Kalimdor — plants, animals, monsters, races."
ItarI Nov 4th 2010 3:38AM
The right thing to do at Startholme would have been to try to find a cure, failing which they were to kill the undead, not the people. Quarantine was the thing to do, not mass slaughter. Arthas always drowned his pain in impulsive action. He went into Stratholme using the impending situation as an excuse. His first impulse was to do the harsh thing because, according to him, that is always the right thing: Making the hard choices that others can't. This is the heart of his darkness
Pyromelter Nov 4th 2010 12:55PM
I'm fairly certain that 10 years after the events of warcraft 3, there still is no cure. And the plague was fast acting. No, the townspeople were doomed, and also remember, Arthas wasn't just cleansing the town, he was also trying to find and stop the powerful demon that was leading the biological warfare attack on Lordaeron.
Krem Nov 4th 2010 4:46AM
"utterly befouling and destroying it in the process of raiding the necromancer as a lich."
..I think you mean 'raising'. :)
Blayze Nov 4th 2010 8:30AM
What annoys me the most isn't their actions, it's that they've never been called on it--like Tyrande slaughtering Illidan's jailors and freeing the Betrayer himself.
Just one reason why I stand up for Staghelm.
Daedalus Nov 4th 2010 8:45AM
Dalaran is principally a city of Mages, but delving too deeply into the Arcane opens the door to other things. Use of the Arcane attracts the attention of demons because the demons know that access to that kind of power corrupts; some will want even greater power, and will deal with the demons to get it. That’s where warlocks come in. Warlocks weren’t outlawed in Dalaran, they were just frowned on. (They may have been technically illegal; the lore’s a bit fuzzy on that. However, Kel’Thuzad was a member of Dalaran’s ruling council, and openly studied “the forbidden arts,” including necromancy.)
So, Archimonde wasn’t necessarily talking about the mages; just those mages who, like Kel’Thuzad, sacrificed goodness and decency in the pursuit of greater and greater power. In essence, it’s all warlock’s fault.
Daidalus of Gnomeregan
Warlock
P.S.: Anyone know how I go about creating a phylactery?
Pyromelter Nov 4th 2010 12:51PM
"P.S.: Anyone know how I go about creating a phylactery?"
I'm not sure if it's described in wow, but I imagine it would be similar to how Voldemort creates Horcruxes in Harry Potter.
Drahliana Nov 4th 2010 1:27PM
Actually he was talking about the mages. Because deep down Fel and Arcane are brothers of the same flesh... partaking of the same source of power as the demons themselves... the Twisting Nether. It's also why it's no surprise that a City of Mages birthed so many Warlocks and Necromancers, they're both outgrowths of the Arcane.
Archimonde was speaking of the entire city.... not just Warlocks. And he was right.
Lorne Nov 6th 2010 7:44AM
Also, IIRC, a Phylactery typically contains some of a mages blood, and are typically a relatively simple container itself, usually an enchanted phial to contain it and keep it from rotting.
Daedalus Nov 4th 2010 8:54AM
Bah; damnable comment system.
This was supposed to be a reply the earlier thread about Uther and Jaina. Please vote down.
Siaperas Nov 4th 2010 11:46AM
What struck me about Warcraft 3, was the war didn't seem start until almost halfway through the game. The game starts with Thrall leaving to Kalimdor at the behest of a powerful profit, who turns out to be Medivh. That same profit urges Terenas, Antonidas, then Arthas to do the same, but Terenas and Antonidas thinks he's just a lune, and Arthas is too busy chasing zombies to care. Jaina heeds the call and bails right after Stratholme. The human campaign is really one man and his forces trying to fight the undead. The story continues with the Scourge, and that's more of a slaughter than a war as Arthas steamrolls everything in his path. I suppose you could argue that it starts when the Scourge march on Quel'danas. They did leave a rather large impression (Dead Scar) on the land, and ended up almost completely erradicating the elves just to raise Kel'thuzad as a Lich. I would again say it's more genocide than war.
The "war" really picks up when Archimonde is successfully summoned. Then all hell breaks lose. Demons and undead finish slaughtering everything around them then head to Kalimdor. I'll leave those specifics to Rossi, to but it's in Kalimdor that the night elves, humans, and orcs martial their great strengths to combat the Legion and the Scourge with the fate of the world in the balance. That's when it stops being a just hero on a quest or simple genocide (there's still some of that going on) and becomes more of a war with whole races invested in the outcome and pulling all the stops to win.
Pyromelter Nov 4th 2010 1:00PM
Wars don't start when all hell breaks loose. Often times, there are precursors or small incidents. We think of the big wars, like WW1 and WW2, and maybe the civil war, as these huge battles all over the place, which they were. But look at something like Vietnam and Korea, which were much more complicated, starting with minor skirmishes and a lot of political hand-wringing.
Siaperas Nov 4th 2010 3:20PM
But even then, there's still a difference between a war and skirmish. In my opinion, it's in the deployment of a major military force to rise in conflict against another military force in an effort to achieve a goal; a fight on a very large scale. Even in your cases, with Vietnam and Korea, there was a concentrated effort to go to war. The political sides involved were invested, and dedicated a major military deployment.
However, as you said, war is technically much more complicated than just that. War as the United States views is, is technically a political declaration. The US doesn't go to "war" unless it is first passed by congress then signed by the president. The last time the United States was officially at "war" was in World War 2. The President can declare and dedicate military force for "peace keeping" missions, however, which is how we politically view everything from Korean onward.
The point is that I agree that war is more complicated than just all hell breaking lose. However, in my opinion, when a military force engages fully, it's war. That's why I say you could argue the Scourge invasion of Quel'thalas as war. Arthas' hunting down Kel'thuzad then later Mal'ganis didn't reflect the actions of the whole of Lordaeron. He was taking his own soldiers into battle like a rogue outfit. The Scourge invasion of Quel'thalas is much like the German invasion of Poland. It's technically war, but really Quel'thalas was hit so hard and fast that it didn't even know what hit it until after it was done, which is why I say it was closer to a slaughter than war.
When the Legion invades Kalimdor, the Alliance that forms there wars against it; they put up a fight, and the factions involved are completely vested. It's not just a misled vendetta, it's not genocide, it's a fight on a very large scale. That's why, in my opinion, the Third War really didn't start until Kalimdor in the Warcraft 3 story.
Zetsubou Nov 4th 2010 5:26PM
this subject has been tough. im under the impression that most people feel it was a bad event.
looked at in defense, id say it was the best that arthas could have done with the options they had.
killing the citizens of stratholme as they become undead to limit the spread of plague and the increase of scourge pressence is sound. waiting till they turn is not so nice, but better than killing the unturned (even tho im not sure if they waited for the turn for all or not) the bronzeflight say as much, it was necessary.
what could be objected to is the reason for this. arthas was consumed with hunting the undead and mal'ganis. he wanted only to wipe the scourge from the earth, slowly losing his rational thought for people or strategy. i think the worst thing he did was leave lordaeron to fight in northrend and not return when commanded. by then he was not concerned about the undead that could/would regroup to attack lordaeron.
i cannot fault jaina and uther for leaving, because even if you take away the arguements of military process, their relationships with arthas, and his army, he must have been a difficult combatant. in the game he was stronger as a paladin, and got weaker as he became more deathknighty. if he was able to slay uther as a deathknight then uther, an aging paladin and jaina, a young mage would not have had a great time against a young strong pally on a crusade.
leaving to find a cure was better for them morally than aiding arthas, and not as difficult as fighting him.
yes they chose the easy path, but is that bad? is it the wrong path because it was easier? would stopping arthas and leaving the scourge to frolic have changed arthas' mind? i think they could have stopped all this by traveling to kalimdor like medivh fortold, but it was the majority of humanites' choice to stay and face what came.