Know Your Lore: Jaina Proudmoore, page 2

It was there in the mountain that she met Warchief Thrall, leader of the supposed "new" Horde. And it was also there that the prophet appeared and asked the two forces to work together. It was also there that Jaina discovered that her instincts from so many years ago weren't wrong, after all -- the leader of the orcs was an honorable and respectful creature. After the human and orc forces encountered the mysterious night elves, the prophet finally revealed himself as Medivh -- son of the woman that Jaina had idolized since she was a young girl. When Medivh implored the night elves, humans and orcs to stand side by side against the Burning Legion, how could she refuse? Doing so would be in direct opposition of everything Jaina stood for.
Perhaps the trip to Kalimdor signaled the beginning of Jaina's freedom; while she was free to study magic in Dalaran, she was still constricted by the formalities of her station and surrounded by people who seemed more inclined to follow popular opinion than make decisions of their own. In Kalimdor it was all up to her, and she blossomed under the harsh conditions of war with the Burning Legion. It was not enough that the strange alliance defeated the Burning Legion; she wanted more than that for her people and more than that for the world she lived in.

Unfortunately, before Jaina could go about saving the world, she had problems from her past to deal with first. The tenuous peace pact she had with the orcs of Durotar threatened to crumble when the orcs suddenly came under attack by human forces. As tensions mounted, Jaina finally realized to her horror where the humans came from.
Daddy was paying her a visit. And he wasn't particularly happy with where his little girl had chosen to stay or her choice in companions. When he finally arrived in Theramore, it was to find Jaina accompanied by Rexxar the half-orc, Rokhan the troll, and a pandaren named Chen Stormsnout. He demanded that they be arrested, but Jaina tried to persuade him otherwise.
Much as with Arthas's mind years before, Jaina soon discovered that words were not enough to change her father's mind either, and she was left with a terrible decision to make: allow her father to continue killing her allies, or allow her allies to take care of her father. One choice would save her father but lead to years of bloody, brutal war; the other would lead to the loss of her father, but years of tentative peace and understanding. One way was good for her people; the other way was good for her.

The next few years were spent trying to keep the shaky peace between human and orc alive, though most of the time, it appeared that only Jaina and Thrall were interested in keeping peace alive. These tensions between the orcs and humans turned out to be the machinations of a demon that had rekindled the Burning Blade clan -- and in the midst of the conflict, Jaina discovered a very familiar woman in a small, unpopulated area on the far side of Mulgore.
It seemed that Magna Aegwynn -- Jaina's idol for all of her younger years -- was not dead as presumed. In fact, she was very much alive and not at all like the books that young Proudmoore had read as a little girl. Aegwynn was doing nothing more than wallowing in her solitude, bitter and angry at herself for every mistake she'd made over the eight centuries she'd been alive. Aegwynn was quick to fill Jaina in on her life's story -- how she had been so stubborn, so self-absorbed that she'd bore the son that brought the orcs to Azeroth simply to spite the Council of Tirisfal.
Duty first. Grief second. Self-pity? Never. Not for Jaina Proudmoore -- never for Jaina Proudmoore."What do you know of responsibility?" Aegwynn cried. "For eight-"
"Yes, I know what you did, Magna, you've told me quite a bit about your failures, your deceits, your lies, your arrogance -- but what you've also reminded me of is that you never once shirked your responsibility as Guardian. Everything you did -- from facing Zmodlor to defying the council to siring Medivh -- was done because you believed in what you did. Regardless of your mistakes, of your defeats, you never once shirked that responsibility. Until now." Proudmoore shook her head. "You asked me what I know of responsibility, and right now I'd say more than you, because you never had to be responsible to anyone save yourself. I have led people into battle, and I have ruled them when the battle was over -- and right now, the people who have trusted me need me, and it may well be because of a demon you were supposed to have killed. I will not see everything we have built here be brought down by your self-pity, Magna."

Perhaps that is Jaina's greatest failing -- open-minded to a fault, she expects the rest of the world to see things her way and assumes that her way is the right way. Despite years of ignoring other's preconceived opinions of the world and forming her own opinions about things, she continually touts her own beliefs as "the right way." And who's to say a world of peace would actually work, in the long run?
But in Wrath of the Lich King, Jaina was suddenly confronted with the specter of her other greatest failing -- Arthas. What Arthas represents is the future Jaina could have had: security, a marriage, a kingdom, the conventional lifestyle of nobility that she had turned away from in favor of studies and adventures. She loved Arthas with all her heart, but in the end, her love wasn't enough. She wasn't good enough for that future: a happily ever after, the sort of happily ever after than any ordinary little girl would die for -- and despite her best efforts to cover it up, despite her bravado and her concern for the welfare of her people, there was a small, selfish corner of Jaina that wished she could have had that future.

When Horde and Alliance collided during the Battle for the Undercity, Jaina went so far as to teleport the Alliance forces out when it became clear that Varian Wrynn was far too angry to do anything but murder Thrall and the remainder of the Horde forces. She could have let the conflict play out, but she didn't, instead choosing to separate the forces for what she deemed in her mind to be "the greater good."
Was she correct to do this? Who knows? The point isn't that she made the choice; the point is that when she made that choice, she was convinced that it was the best for everyone around her.
That's why Varian and Jaina clash so badly -- she's driven by common sense and the need to be right, and he's driven by raw emotion, anger, and the pain of years upon years of grief that began the moment his father was murdered by Garona. In a strange way, though, the two are suited for each other; her sensibility and stubbornness has been shown to curb his temper. And if there's one thing Jaina needs, it's a man who can bring back the side of her that she shoved away when Arthas left her -- the mischievous, fun loving woman who isn't afraid to let her emotions get the better of her every now and again.

For more information on related subjects, please look at these other Know Your Lore entries:
- King Varian Wrynn
- The Council of Tirisfal and the last Guardian
- The Second War
- Current Alliance Politics: The humans
- The Alliance
While you don't need to have played the previous Warcraft games to enjoy World of Warcraft, a little history goes a long way toward making the game a lot more fun. Dig into even more of the lore and history behind the World of Warcraft in WoW Insider's Guide to Warcraft Lore.





Reader Comments (Page 1 of 10)
Drakkenfyre Nov 21st 2010 8:15PM
I still don't like the new face compared to her old face.
The armor upgrade was great, higher resolution, but the face update sucked. It makes her look like a chubby-faced hooker. It sucks they did that to her.
The complexion is changed too much, and the face it a little too wide, that is what makes it seem that way. But at least it's not the face used in the Ulduar trailer, holy shit that was terrible.
Rob Nov 21st 2010 11:24PM
Laugh, and her boobs. Its like someone stuck catalopes down her shirt. Breasts are usually not completely circular. Oh well. Great article.
Izaach Nov 22nd 2010 2:16AM
Agree. She looks like a stuck-up bitch.
Sarabande Nov 22nd 2010 8:10AM
Her face has become rather unpleasant . . . though I explain to people it's due to the stresses of dealing with Arthas as the Lich King . . . maybe she's been drinking or something (and I don't mean mana drinks either). I've heard a few people say she looks like she's on drugs. Could be using too much magic does something weird to your face. Or could be there is plastic surgery in Azeroth. Perhaps one of those messy gnome inventions "facial reconstruction engine" or something.
While they could have aged her a little bit (she looked very young before) I think they went too far. She doesn't look serious - she looks snooty and messed up.
I wish they could have pretty much kept her old face and just tweaked it enough so the resolution is better, so she looks a few years older and a bit more serious, but not like a completely different person.
Sam Nov 22nd 2010 8:59AM
Actually, I liked the model they used in the Ulduar trailer, it was pretty and it gave Jaina a more mature air
Scooter Nov 22nd 2010 11:09AM
I'm sorry people but just what the hell is wrong with Jaina needing a member of the opposite sex in her life? This isn't a freaking measure of her value of an individual and darn-it I'm tired of every freaking feminist out their thinking it is! Jaina is a human being not Wonder Woman. She has a personality. She has flaws. Just because Jaina is among the highest caliber of spell casters it doesn't mean she has everything figured out! Some people need a companion to help give them perspective or to balance something in their life. There are countless reasons for countless situations for countless people to surround themselves with different relationships. Could she get by without one? Sure! Does that mean she is going to live her ideal life? Who knows? I'd rather sit back and enjoy the story than use it as a narcissistic extension of how i think everyone else should be!
There is nothing wrong with having needs.
Scooter Nov 22nd 2010 11:16AM
Oh good lord. Posted rant in wrong spot. Sry people
Schadenfreude Nov 22nd 2010 11:23AM
@Scooter:
You have to understand how loaded the sentence "[She] needs a man" is. Humans need other humans, yes, no one here is disagreeing-- but the assertion that Jaina "needs a man" is tied up with all kinds of notions about women not being independent, not having power, not being able to make their own decisions, and having their fates bound up intimately with a man's, and ultimately being subordinate or secondary to that man's needs/wants/desires/anything. So while Jaina deserves to have love and companionship, she also deserves to have her own story and her own destiny that is not dependent or subordinate to some man, which is unfortunately what is happening in canon. (i.e. Jaina only exists to cry over Arthas)
Grovinofdarkhour Nov 22nd 2010 11:25AM
Well, in Blizzard's defense, the playmate-on-Xanax look is really in this year.
Oteo Nov 21st 2010 8:17PM
...
Why does she need a man at all?
Kylenne Nov 21st 2010 8:21PM
No kidding. God forbid a woman work through things or discover things about herself on her own.
Anne Stickney Nov 21st 2010 8:31PM
Unfortunately, common convention in Azeroth seems to be of the opinion that women of any kind of noble birth are pretty much there to get married and have kids. You know, continue the family line and all that.
Jaina's spent all of her life bucking the trend -- which is perfectly fine! -- but there's a part of her that still wants that conventional life, despite the other, much larger part of her that knows that would be idiocy on her part.
RiderGeshtar Nov 21st 2010 8:40PM
This.
Jaina does not "need a man". No woman honestly, seriously "needs a man" 'kay thanks bye. (It goes the other way, too, but man-needs-woman has less unfortunate implcations of doom.) I thought that line of thought went out with terrifying and flammable polyester pants and the goldenrod-coloured appliance set. Apparently it has experienced a resurgence, much like said appliance sets and pants. Sigh.
Jaina needs a vacation, yes. Jaina needs a break, so she can relax and be happy again (because while I dig Varian as a character, wrangling him has GOT to wear on the nerve endings something fierce). Jaina does not necessarily need a man to accompany her on this vacation.
Jaina was a brave, independent and whup-ass character until...I don't know, until WoW's writers apparently got into Richard Knaak's terrifying and unholy stash of NOOOO and decided his way of writing women made sense..? I wish I knew, I really did. Blizzard, where went her spine? Why in the name of Kil'jaeden's fiery bojangles did you give her a spine-ectomy!? This angers me. The record for writing the franchise's whup-assed women is not good at this point (what the crap is this terribly-written thing with Sylvanas and WHERE IS TYRANDE, YOU FOOLS), and I am not an optimistic sort with regard to this.
Honestly, I'd like to NOT see Jaina reduced to just the girlfriend. I'd like to see her having a life of her own again, and whipping ass and taking names in her usual elegant way. That said, I don't want to see her pointlessly paired off with Varian Wrynn. Let's face it, that'd be a detriment to both their characters, and...this is Varian, COME ON! He's NOT emotionally ready for it by any means.
Believe me, leaping into a relationship facefirst when one is grieving is the worst way to start said relationship.
Eli Nov 21st 2010 8:39PM
Not trying to be misogynistic here, but don't women need men as much as men need woman for companionship?
Oteo Nov 21st 2010 8:44PM
I think it was this particular line, "And if there's one thing Jaina needs, it's a man who can bring back the side of her that she shoved away when Arthas left her," that irked me. It's either from your perspective, in which case I disagree with the sentiment (that's if there's one thing she needs, it's a man) or you're writing if from Jaina's perspective, which I haven't seen and wouldn't agree with that interpretation of her thoughts--but then again, I've only read one of the books and none of the comics.
Terrant Nov 21st 2010 8:45PM
@Eli: But does JAINA need companionship? And if so, would it be the "one thing" she needs, as the article puts it?
Kylenne Nov 21st 2010 8:45PM
@Anne: I can't speak for Oteo, but that sure as hell wasn't what I was talking about, at all. I was talking about the nonsensical notion that in order for Jaina to get back in touch with that mischievous, fun-loving side of her personality again, she "needs" a man. With all due respect, that's bullshit, and it's sexist as all get out.
That line infuriated me because it basically sums up everything wrong with how female characters have been written in this 'verse post-WC3. We need far less of that nonsense in this game, not more of it. At any rate, I doubt anyone's going to be discovering any mischievous, fun-loving sides to their personalities with full scale war going on. Which is what Jaina needs to be focusing on.
razion Nov 21st 2010 8:59PM
I don't believe "need" should be taken too literally in that context... ;
Anne Stickney Nov 21st 2010 9:00PM
@Oteo Perhaps I should have phrased it as "If Jaina needs a man, this is the kind of man she needs?"
Regardless, Warcraft lore is full of women who have been nothing but prodigal babycannons since the story started. Fun stories, sure - but women in Warcraft have -never- been portrayed as being strong and self-reliant, when push comes to shove. The main exceptions are Aegwynn, who used a man to further her own self-interests, and Jaina, who is trying very hard to pave the way for other women, but also dealing with this feeling of misplaced ineptitude because she couldn't 'fix' the man she loved.
...pretty screwed up, huh?
Angus Nov 21st 2010 9:04PM
Contrary to what some folks will have you believe, the 70 yr old woman that has had a very interesting life but is still single is not cool. She's lonely and sad. And often has a lot of cats.
A being that lives only for their job ends up alone, bitter and depressed. Look at Aegwynn. She never had a love life, she had duty. How did she turn out?
A great life requires some balance, some love that is returned and someone that is there with you through those battles that are hard.
She may not "need a man" but she NEEDS a partner. We all do.