Know Your Lore: Jaina Proudmoore, page 2

It was there in the mountain that she met Warchief Thrall, leader of the supposed "new" Horde. And it was also there that the prophet appeared and asked the two forces to work together. It was also there that Jaina discovered that her instincts from so many years ago weren't wrong, after all -- the leader of the orcs was an honorable and respectful creature. After the human and orc forces encountered the mysterious night elves, the prophet finally revealed himself as Medivh -- son of the woman that Jaina had idolized since she was a young girl. When Medivh implored the night elves, humans and orcs to stand side by side against the Burning Legion, how could she refuse? Doing so would be in direct opposition of everything Jaina stood for.
Perhaps the trip to Kalimdor signaled the beginning of Jaina's freedom; while she was free to study magic in Dalaran, she was still constricted by the formalities of her station and surrounded by people who seemed more inclined to follow popular opinion than make decisions of their own. In Kalimdor it was all up to her, and she blossomed under the harsh conditions of war with the Burning Legion. It was not enough that the strange alliance defeated the Burning Legion; she wanted more than that for her people and more than that for the world she lived in.

Unfortunately, before Jaina could go about saving the world, she had problems from her past to deal with first. The tenuous peace pact she had with the orcs of Durotar threatened to crumble when the orcs suddenly came under attack by human forces. As tensions mounted, Jaina finally realized to her horror where the humans came from.
Daddy was paying her a visit. And he wasn't particularly happy with where his little girl had chosen to stay or her choice in companions. When he finally arrived in Theramore, it was to find Jaina accompanied by Rexxar the half-orc, Rokhan the troll, and a pandaren named Chen Stormsnout. He demanded that they be arrested, but Jaina tried to persuade him otherwise.
Much as with Arthas's mind years before, Jaina soon discovered that words were not enough to change her father's mind either, and she was left with a terrible decision to make: allow her father to continue killing her allies, or allow her allies to take care of her father. One choice would save her father but lead to years of bloody, brutal war; the other would lead to the loss of her father, but years of tentative peace and understanding. One way was good for her people; the other way was good for her.

The next few years were spent trying to keep the shaky peace between human and orc alive, though most of the time, it appeared that only Jaina and Thrall were interested in keeping peace alive. These tensions between the orcs and humans turned out to be the machinations of a demon that had rekindled the Burning Blade clan -- and in the midst of the conflict, Jaina discovered a very familiar woman in a small, unpopulated area on the far side of Mulgore.
It seemed that Magna Aegwynn -- Jaina's idol for all of her younger years -- was not dead as presumed. In fact, she was very much alive and not at all like the books that young Proudmoore had read as a little girl. Aegwynn was doing nothing more than wallowing in her solitude, bitter and angry at herself for every mistake she'd made over the eight centuries she'd been alive. Aegwynn was quick to fill Jaina in on her life's story -- how she had been so stubborn, so self-absorbed that she'd bore the son that brought the orcs to Azeroth simply to spite the Council of Tirisfal.
Duty first. Grief second. Self-pity? Never. Not for Jaina Proudmoore -- never for Jaina Proudmoore."What do you know of responsibility?" Aegwynn cried. "For eight-"
"Yes, I know what you did, Magna, you've told me quite a bit about your failures, your deceits, your lies, your arrogance -- but what you've also reminded me of is that you never once shirked your responsibility as Guardian. Everything you did -- from facing Zmodlor to defying the council to siring Medivh -- was done because you believed in what you did. Regardless of your mistakes, of your defeats, you never once shirked that responsibility. Until now." Proudmoore shook her head. "You asked me what I know of responsibility, and right now I'd say more than you, because you never had to be responsible to anyone save yourself. I have led people into battle, and I have ruled them when the battle was over -- and right now, the people who have trusted me need me, and it may well be because of a demon you were supposed to have killed. I will not see everything we have built here be brought down by your self-pity, Magna."

Perhaps that is Jaina's greatest failing -- open-minded to a fault, she expects the rest of the world to see things her way and assumes that her way is the right way. Despite years of ignoring other's preconceived opinions of the world and forming her own opinions about things, she continually touts her own beliefs as "the right way." And who's to say a world of peace would actually work, in the long run?
But in Wrath of the Lich King, Jaina was suddenly confronted with the specter of her other greatest failing -- Arthas. What Arthas represents is the future Jaina could have had: security, a marriage, a kingdom, the conventional lifestyle of nobility that she had turned away from in favor of studies and adventures. She loved Arthas with all her heart, but in the end, her love wasn't enough. She wasn't good enough for that future: a happily ever after, the sort of happily ever after than any ordinary little girl would die for -- and despite her best efforts to cover it up, despite her bravado and her concern for the welfare of her people, there was a small, selfish corner of Jaina that wished she could have had that future.

When Horde and Alliance collided during the Battle for the Undercity, Jaina went so far as to teleport the Alliance forces out when it became clear that Varian Wrynn was far too angry to do anything but murder Thrall and the remainder of the Horde forces. She could have let the conflict play out, but she didn't, instead choosing to separate the forces for what she deemed in her mind to be "the greater good."
Was she correct to do this? Who knows? The point isn't that she made the choice; the point is that when she made that choice, she was convinced that it was the best for everyone around her.
That's why Varian and Jaina clash so badly -- she's driven by common sense and the need to be right, and he's driven by raw emotion, anger, and the pain of years upon years of grief that began the moment his father was murdered by Garona. In a strange way, though, the two are suited for each other; her sensibility and stubbornness has been shown to curb his temper. And if there's one thing Jaina needs, it's a man who can bring back the side of her that she shoved away when Arthas left her -- the mischievous, fun loving woman who isn't afraid to let her emotions get the better of her every now and again.

For more information on related subjects, please look at these other Know Your Lore entries:
- King Varian Wrynn
- The Council of Tirisfal and the last Guardian
- The Second War
- Current Alliance Politics: The humans
- The Alliance
While you don't need to have played the previous Warcraft games to enjoy World of Warcraft, a little history goes a long way toward making the game a lot more fun. Dig into even more of the lore and history behind the World of Warcraft in WoW Insider's Guide to Warcraft Lore.
Patch 5.3 interview with Ghostcrawler
Mystery of the Unborn Val'kyr
The latest patch 5.3 news
All of the latest Mists of Pandaria news





Reader Comments (Page 5 of 10)
Tael Nov 23rd 2010 5:33AM
Your concern's touching... but if Blizzard had any concern about the message they're sending to the little girls (or the grown women) who play their game, we wouldn't NEED to have these sorts of discussions because they'd already be making sure there were many more awesome women in Azeroth.
Saying we can't lose Jaina because it'd leave Sylvanas as the only interesting woman is... well, sadly you're right, and that shows just how poor the representation is.
Oteo Nov 21st 2010 9:06PM
@Anne
The phrasing is better, although "If there's anything Jaina needs, it's a pitcher of margaritas" would also work.
As for the rest of your post, I think it just goes to show that video game production is still very much a boys' club.
Oteo Nov 21st 2010 9:06PM
%&(@ this comment system, putting this in the right place... So, you know, I can flood my inbox some more.
NielsdeJONG Nov 22nd 2010 2:03AM
Why shouldn't she get married? Heck, a lot of male characters get married as well :) You wouldn't want the women and men to be treated unequal right? :P
Also what is wrong with her getting married? It doesn't change anything :) In fact, she only gets more power because Varian let Tiffin have as much influence as he had in the past :)
Being strong and freespirited, doesn't mean that you can't get married and/or have children :)
Oteo Nov 22nd 2010 2:21AM
To answer your comment posted on either thread, the part of the article I disagree with is that she *needs* a man. It could very well be that Jaina decides that after all the crap she's dealt with when it comes to men, she doesn't want anything to do with them (romantically) anymore.
No one has suggested (well, at least not myself) that having a romantic relationship means she's weak. Rather, we disagree with Anne's writing that "If there's one thing Jaina needs, it's a man" (to paraphrase). As I've stated elsewhere in another orphaned comment, I have a boyfriend. I have a boyfriend because I *want* him in my life--at no point have I ever *needed* him in my life.
Anne suggested that Jaina *needs* a man in order to bring out some of her repressed qualities, when she doesn't necessarily need a man at all. It could be a woman, it could be a friend (why does it need to be romantic?), it could be herself, and yes, it could be a man, but for someone to suggest that her wounds are something that only a relationship with a man could heal should make any feminist's heart rankle.
Keep in mind, of course, that historically men have been prescribed as the cure to a woman's ills (think "She's too adventurous, but she just needs a man" or anything in that vein), so "needs a man" was a particularly poor choice of phrase to use, even if in all other respects Anne is a feminist (believes strongly in the equality of the sexes). And even though I'm a science major who normally wouldn't touch the humanities with a 10-foot pole, even I tend to wonder if letting the phrase "needs a man" slip is a remnant of cultural conditioning. I guess I should have added a caveat that I'm at a liberal arts college...
perderedeus Nov 21st 2010 9:08PM
I don't think she "needs a man." I especially don't think she needs Varian. I think she could have her dalliances - she's earned at least one by now - but settling down? She is perhaps the only strong, well-known, leading female character in the game right now... having her play wife to any man would really detract from her appeal.
NielsdeJONG Nov 22nd 2010 2:06AM
Why would that distract from her appeal? :)
Being a wife doesn't mean that she has to sit at home all the time nitting.
Heck, Tiffin had at least as much influence as Varian, because he let her have that :)
If anything, she would become only more powerfull, and for all we know she would be the one wearing the pants in their relationship ;)
Boobah Nov 22nd 2010 12:23PM
"Why would that distract from her appeal? :)
Heck, Tiffin had at least as much influence as Varian, because he LET her have that :)" (emphasis mine)
Well, that's a start.
Oteo Nov 21st 2010 9:09PM
BTW for amusing couplings I would go for "Baine/Jaina" ... for the lulz.
Kylenne Nov 21st 2010 9:51PM
...that might be my new crack ship, after reading the Shattering.
(After Baine/Anduin that is.)
Oteo Nov 21st 2010 9:57PM
Not normally into shipping or any sort of fanfic but I would be inclined to agree with you on Baine/Anduin.
shadcroly Nov 22nd 2010 12:24AM
As awesome as Baine/Anduin sounds, I ship Anduin/Me'dan. Oh yes...
Nubia Nov 21st 2010 9:09PM
I love Jaina's Story.
And it is not so much that she needs a man she just wanted to have love.
Which is not a crime:)
Thank you for this!:D
RetPallyJil Nov 21st 2010 9:23PM
I find her admirable in theory and annoying in reality. It is not, however, her fault: Not enough women work for Blizz to counteract their innate fanboyness. Poor kid deserves better.
But she really SHOULD have backed Arthas up at Stratholme.
Dreyja Nov 21st 2010 9:39PM
I can't disagree more on that last point but I know a lot of people feel that way. :)
razion Nov 21st 2010 9:45PM
I pity the Azeroth that has to deal with a Lich Queen--I'll keep my less-dangerous Lich King who has no Paladin powers against against a Lich Queen backed with insurmountable magical might, thank you.
Dreyja Nov 21st 2010 9:38PM
Bravo Anne! This is the Know Your Lore I've been waiting for.
Honestly, I'm tired of people making fun of the fact that she cried in ICC. COME ON, this isn't just her facing a lost future, she's facing the man she loved who has turned into a complete monster. Her genuine spirit still held some small hope that the person she loved was in there some where.
She was very human and, I would argue, VERY STRONG in those moments. Yes, shedding tears is not a sign of weakness. Frankly, if she'd not cried she would have come across as about as warm as Sylvanas did in that same situation.
I may disagree with people that her vision isn't the right one for Azeroth but I think most people have to have at least a little bit respect for her even-handed idealism. I'm not of the mindset that idealism is necessarily a bad thing. It is an idealism grounded in a lot of practicality and hard work.
I love her as a character and she is my greatest hero in the game. Hands down. ;)
Now - if blizz hooks her up with VARIAN I am going to freak out five ways from Friday! ;-p (**INSERT Lil' X-T Freakout here: No, no, NO, NOOOOOO!*)
I'm a little worried about what is in the works for her in Cata. I'm trying to understand why her troops are some of the most active and in the most controversial areas. She's been quiet in the game but The Shattering was full of Jaina awesomeness! :D
Kylenne Nov 21st 2010 10:03PM
I don't think anyone reasonable is suggesting that Jaina shouldn't have cried in ICC. The problem is not that she cried and showed very human emotion, the problem is that this was an incredibly important, dynamic woman who basically sat in a swamp doing nothing for all of vanilla and BC, and when she finally gets to come back into the spotlight a little in WotLK, all we see her doing is playing Supernanny for Varian. And crying.
This, despite a tremendous number of things she could have done in this expansion. Malygos declares war on mortal magic users, and Jaina, who studied under the late leader of the Kirin Tor himself and is one of the most powerful magi in Azeroth, was nowhere to be found? And that's just the first thing I can think of off the top of my head. So yeah, the crying thing in the context of all that was irritating. Jaina's not a weepy waif, by any means, but that's all we ever get to see her do anymore, and it's a crying shame (no pun intended) considering the amazing things she's accomplished in the past.
Dreyja Nov 21st 2010 10:27PM
@ Kylenne - I agree on most of those points. The fact is that the Metzen and Co. don't love Jaina as a character like they do the likes of Thrall. There is so much more she could be doing, absolutely. I've only ever seen Golden write Jaina well. I wish she had some input into the game.
That's why the "green fever," and "look what happens to the men she dates," comments bugged me so much at blizzcon (as has been stated, yes, they were joking but still...). They aren't seeing her as an equal to any of those characters and it bugs the heck out of me.
The lack of good writing for her aside, I still found the crying more powerful than pouty. :)
NielsdeJONG Nov 22nd 2010 2:13AM
What is wrong with her hooking up with Varian? :)
Being married wouldn't change that much, after all it's just some note on a paper, and they could still do the things they would normally do, there is no need for her to sit at home and knit sweaters.
Heck, if anything, Varian let Tiffin get at least as much influence as he did, because he wanted it that way :)
There is nothing wrong with getting married, and it's simply ridiculous to suggest that being married makes one less of a strong person. Heck, my aunt was a feminist in the 70's, and people told her not to have kids and a husband because it would keep her down. Now she is old and resentfull, and she absolutely hates all the feminists because she feels that they lied to her. We often visit her from time to time though, but overall she says that she has never felt weaker.
Being in a relationship is meant to strengthen both of them, not the way around. And as far as we know, Jaina may well be the one wearing the pants in their relationship! ;)