Last night, with a druid tank, I put MD on the fuzzy butt, waited for 10 seconds, shot one Multi-shot and then started in on the tanks focus with explosive shot followed by black arrow, and one steady shot. There were a couple auto shots in there as well. The mob peeled off the tank like he had skunk breath.

Sorry, not my fault. If the tank can't generate enough threat under that circumstance (his fault or the game mechanics fault) then something is wrong and it ain't because I'm playing it wrong. We were both lvl 85 and outfitted with quest blues and greens. According to the armory, my average iLvl is 322 equipped and his was about the same.

I spent the rest of the run at half-speed and was still getting warnings from Omen. The tank was decent in that he did all the right things at the right time but I wasn't the only one having to back off. The mage and Spriest were having a tough time as well.

Suffice to say that currently, you can't just say "BAD DPS IS BAD" and call it a day. There are other issues at play here and you discredit yourself by ignoring that fact.