What I hope is answered in Ask Creative Development round II

My hopes are high for this next round of questions, as Cataclysm introduced countless new lore figures, quests, and story deviations into the already enormous world. I've come up with a list of four points of lore that I would like the creative development team to address, to shed some light on these very prominent figures.
Sylvanas
Every time lore question and answers come up, everyone throws their hands in the air at the same moment and screams, "What about Sylvanas?!" Well, I am no different. Sylvanas is a compelling character to both sides of the Warcraft equation. For the Alliance, she represents everything as evil as the Lich King with the added bonus that her people/minions are the literal remains of the fallen kingdom of Lordaeron. She represents to many the greatest evil on Azeroth next to Deathwing, and the continuation of her story gives the Alliance more and more reason to hate the Horde she associates with.
For the Horde, the continuation of Sylvanas' story is vital to the strength of the Horde in the Eastern Kingdoms as well as the understanding of where she stands. Admittedly, Sylvanas' methods throughout the expansion have seemed very peculiar, even for her. The inclusion of the Val'kyr, former servants of the Lich King, into her armies perplexes many on the Horde side of things, including Warchief Garrosh Hellscream. To be honest, I've been told by Blizzard for six years of World of Warcraft that the Horde is not an evil faction, but that we all live in various shades of gray, and that it's all relative. Blizzard even went so far as to craft entire zones around the premise of us all existing within many shades of gray.
So my question about Sylvanas is: What are her motivations? Will we find out what is truly haunting Sylvanas? If she is so evil, then have we, as a faction, stepped out of the gray area and Blizzard is asking us to defend her actions? Or, as I suspect, is Sylvanas suffering from some outside force that is doing to her what was done to many before her -- clouding her mind to what is really at stake and pulling her into her own form of madness? At what point will all of Sylvanas' oddness be clarified?

Thrall and The Earthen Ring have become major players in Cataclysm, with the fighting in Vashj'ir and the plight of the World Pillar in Deepholm. These great shaman have taken it upon themselves to fix the elemental wrongs of Azeroth and beyond, and so far, they have been very successful in doing so. While Thrall maintains the Maelstrom rift, keeping it just enough open and just enough closed to stop the planet from tearing itself apart, the other shaman of the Earthen Ring fight Deathwing's elemental servants all over Azeroth.
The issue comes from the fact that one of the Earthen Ring's biggest challenges, fixing the World Pillar in Deepholm, has come to pass. The success in Deepholm leaves many Earthen Ring with a mission already accomplished; they can now turn their attentions to more pressing matters outside of the plane of earth.
So my question about the Earthen Ring is: What is next for the Earthen Ring? Will we see the effects of the success in Deepholm in the next tier of content? Will the Earthen Ring be instrumental in the fight against Ragnaros, or will they be relegated to the fight in Vashj'ir and the new, unannounced creature that lurks in the waters coming in the next patch? And what of Thrall? Will he be relieved of his Maelstrom guarding duties at some point during Cataclysm, at least until his new book comes out?
Rustberg Village and Tol Barad Peninsula
Something strange is going on with Tol Barad Peninsula -- like, really strange. I have praised the Tol Barad design before, giving it style points for creating such a wonderfully tense atmosphere and perfect ominous mood. Rustberg Village is a common destination for many daily quest seekers who brave Tol Barad Peninsula for some sweet Tol Barad commendations. You've all probably met the suspicious residents of this haunting fishing village.
The villagers of Rustberg are suspicious. It says so in their name. The problem is that we don't know what they are suspicious of. Or is the suspicious moniker one of characterization? Is the villager himself a suspicious person, or is the villager himself suspicious of something?
So my question about Tol Barad Peninsula is: Who are the villagers of Rustberg Village? What are they suspicious of, or why are they suspicious? Why are they both Horde and Alliance races, working together, on this remote island that only recently became bathed in conflict? Who are these people, what are they doing there, where did they come from, and why do I kill 14 of them on occasion?

So far, the story of the Explorer's League in WoW has been a fascinating one. Brann Bronzebeard has been an instrumental figure in many locales all over Azeroth, especially if the Titans are involved. Recently, Blizzard added some much-needed depth to the blood elves by giving them an interesting role to play within the Horde -- a contingent of blood elves known as The Reliquary are the Horde's answer to the Explorer's League. Instead of having pure motives of finding and unlocking the hidden treasures of history, these elves are hinted to be looking for ancient powers and the means to use them. While not power-hungry and addicted as they once were, these blood elves take their arrogance and apply it to archaeology.
So far, we have witnessed some awesome back and forth by these two factions. As the Explorer's League strives to uncover the tales of history, the Reliquary is right there to throw them off the trail and find answers first. We watch them tussle in the Badlands and duke it out in Tanaris, and we see some major players in Uldum. Sadly, this great conflict is not played out as well as I would have hoped in Uldum, but the main characters do make appearances.
So my question about the Reliquary and the Explorer's League is: Will we be seeing more of this awesome new addition to the blood elves, and will their story, along with the Explorer's League, play into the further exploits of this expansion? The theme this go-around has been steadily more and more about uncovering the darker sides of our selves and our factions, from the Dark Irons moving back in to take their place in the dwarven halls, to the worgen unleashing their inhumanities to beat back the Forsaken. From the orcs accepting back the greatest dragon hunters to ever live, the Dragonmaw, into the fold, to Sylvanas diving deeper into her own little madness, we are watching as each faction finds out a little bit more about itself and its ruthless tendencies. This seems absolutely ripe for conflict, ancient evils, and powers beyond our wildest dreams. Having the Explorer's League and The Reliquary, especially with some Belloc versus Brann/Harrison Jones action, would be pretty spectacular.
World of Warcraft: Cataclysm has destroyed Azeroth as we know it; nothing is the same! In WoW Insider's Guide to Cataclysm, you can find out everything you need to know about WoW's third expansion, from leveling up a new goblin or worgen to breaking news and strategies on endgame play.Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Lore
Patch 5.3 interview with Ghostcrawler
Mystery of the Unborn Val'kyr
The latest patch 5.3 news
All of the latest Mists of Pandaria news





Reader Comments (Page 4 of 5)
JonasB Jan 27th 2011 8:49PM
I'm interested in development of the draenei and worgen. The draenei because their race shows a lot of potential but essentially no growth, and the worgen because, for a race with such an active stake and drive they don't get much attention. I think part of this is because of the Gilneas battleground, and I guess my main concern is that the Gilneas BG will prevent any development of the Gilnean storyline.
Xerron Jan 27th 2011 9:02PM
isn't there a vision about the people at the maelstrom dying ?
What of that ?
Is it really gonna happen =O ?
Eli Jan 28th 2011 8:51AM
That was just a nightmare in a quest chain. You're taken there to make your character lose hope to such a huge extent (seeing deathwing kill the earthen ring shaman one by one, and thrall telling you that you're a useless [class]) that you kill yourself or you go insane, and since your character is actually a hero according to the NPCs, it would be a huge loss.
VioletArrows Jan 27th 2011 9:34PM
That was just the Maw of Madness creature (can't remember its name) at Twilight Highlands planting bad thoughts in players' heads, same as that quest you do in Vashj'ir by putting a Merciless One on your head. It's not a vision or portent of things to come, just Old Gods and their cute little pranks.
Jinx Jan 28th 2011 12:01AM
It wasn't a vision of the future, it was a madness induced nightmare. It was only to freak out the PC (into thinking you failed to kill Deathwing and that it's your fault everyone died) and it did its job quite well :D
The old god's name was Iso'rath.
The Dark Wayne [Planeteer: Power of the Batusi] Jan 27th 2011 9:38PM
Damn it, I can't believe I missed this. Me and my guildmate have been conspiring to email Chris Metzen our probably a little excessively detailed theories and questions, dang. Now how will we ever find out if our theories about Vrykul creation are true?
Jinx Jan 28th 2011 12:02AM
You didn't miss anything, it hasn't happened yet :P
Pat Jan 27th 2011 10:02PM
Maybe Sylvanas is the Harry Potter of WoW..
When the LK changed her or whatever a small piece of himself remained, hahaha! Seriously though.. I would not be suprised.
Didn't Sargeras hide out in Aegwynns body and then when she fel pregnant Sargeras posessed her son Medivh or whatever.. I guess anything is possible.
Jinx Jan 28th 2011 12:04AM
Are you saying Sylvanas is going to start making Lich babies? :O
Lathr Jan 27th 2011 11:16PM
I just wanna know what the Ebon Blade is up to these days. I haven't seen a one of them in the old world doing...well...anything.
Given that the Death Knights can be viewed as pragmatic, it seems odd to me that they're not actively up to something in this new world. Did they all just retreat into Acherus to bide their time or something...?
I sure hope it doesn't end up as "Their task is done so now they go into remission" or some crap like that. That'd be a huge letdown from my favorite faction.
Mac Jan 28th 2011 4:24PM
It's been made clear that the Forsaken are capable of being Good, it's just extra hard. Sylvanas was driven by revenge for so long that it was all she knew, so when she finally got it, she needed a new reason for existing - which is now the continued existence of the Forsaken. She'll do what she has to, which isn't always what she *should* do.
And let's not forget that there have been hints of an Old God's presence in Tirisfal, so I'd say it's VERY likely Sylvanas has been corrupted.
Maccabeus Jan 28th 2011 12:11AM
I wanna know why Shaman, who, to my knowledge, have never complained about their spell graphics being green, getting a change to their spell graphics (blue), whereas Warlocks, who have been asking for green fire for freaking ever, STILL DON'T HAVE GREEN FEL FIRE!!!!11!11!eleven!1raaaaaaaage.
/end rant.
Kurash Jan 28th 2011 2:34AM
Both Fel Flame and Chaos Bolt are green. Also, Shadowflame is purple.
My main is a warlock, and that's enough of a fiery rainbow for me. We have green fire. I'd prefer to keep it as it is, personally.
Maccabeus Jan 28th 2011 12:12AM
Also, when will the construction of New Orgrimmar be complete?
MW Jan 28th 2011 7:41AM
It took 6 years to rebuild a bridge in Redridge. To rebuild a city, I'm thinking about 2 expansions.
Duodave Jan 28th 2011 1:54AM
From what I have seen of the Sylvanas plotline, I believe she is not insane. I believe she is obsessed with maintaining peace for the Horde, with the belief that if she must sacrifice her own sanity or soul for that cause, it is a small price to pay. She is overly dedicated to self sacrifice, perhaps to atone for what she believes to be her fault - her actions while under the Lich King's control.
In this light, she could be compared to various leaders of society in our world who felt the need to make sacrifices to lead their people and make difficult decisions or take responsibility for things that were at the least, questionable.
Sylvanas' shouts of "Death to the Living" is nothing more than a battle cry against the alliance. She doesn't mean all living. After all, how many of the Forsaken are Taurens, Orcs or Trolls? I don't remember seeing any. They all seem to be humans, maybe some elves.
Prime Jan 28th 2011 2:30AM
Where is it announced that there is an unannounced creature in the water that the earthen ring might fight?
Sorcha Jan 28th 2011 5:12AM
I feel like people who are so convinced Sylvanas is pure evil just haven't ever done Ghostlands. She's the same woman who sings the Lament of the Highborne. If that's not enough an indication of her motivation I don't know what is.
Rajinnu Jan 28th 2011 6:43AM
/agree
Josh Jan 28th 2011 10:17AM
The Lament of the Highborne is several years old. We haven't seen that aspect of her personality before or since.
Yes, it's a cool moment - but one isolated, aytpical BC-era quest doesn't outweigh her actions and the way she's been portrayed in Cataclysm and Wrath.
Of course, consistent characterization isn't Blizzard's strongpoint.