All the World's a Stage: Roleplaying Q&A

Since Cataclysm's launch, we've covered a lot of information for new and beginning roleplayers and addressed issues that affect everyone who roleplays, from rank amateurs to experienced roleplayers who've been doing this for years. Today we're going to take a break from the tutorials and instead take a look at some of the questions you guys have been asking in the comments section and hopefully give a few answers that will help. So let's get to it, shall we?
Rhogan asks, in regards to What does your character know?:
What about if your character has actually lived through many of the events -- say, TBC/Wrath/part of Cata? My draenei was once a paladin and is now a Lore Keeper, in terms of RP roles. He actually studied all the Azerothian history he possibly could during his time "leveling up" in Azeroth.
Does that mean he has that knowledge at hand? Or does it means he knows a lot, but there still has to be things he can't possibly know? I don't know, it confuses me.
That's a good question! Draenei are a tricky race, because their interactions with Azeroth are fairly limited -- they only became aware of Azeroth's existence some time after the Second War, when the Alliance forces came through the Dark Portal. Even then, they didn't really interact with the natives of Azeroth in any great detail until the launch of The Burning Crusade, so knowledge of Azeroth would be relatively small.
Keep in mind that your character's knowledge is limited to what he's experienced. If he's played through events in The Burning Crusade, he'd know about what occurred during that time period -- but only in regards to what he had personal experience with.
What I like to do is pick and choose the quests, zones, and events that would have had a major impact on my character. Anything that directly affected my character's frame of mind, anything that caused her to think differently, anything that made for a major "a-ha!" moment was integrated into my character's memories, because it had that direct effect. In real life, we don't remember every moment of every day, but when something happens that is a major, eye-opening moment or something that challenges our way of thinking, we tend to remember it vividly.

With Warcraft, the sum of all lore and history in Azeroth makes up that giant puzzle. It would be incredibly unrealistic for a character to know the entire puzzle, even if the player knows how it all locks together. The draenei are going into the Alliance knowing absolutely none of that puzzle at all -- so it'd be a little far-fetched for a draenei to pick up all of Azeroth's history in the few short years that he or she's been on Azeroth. So pick and choose pieces of that puzzle, find the elements of history that fascinate your character, and focus on those.

Windhorn asks, in regards to Sealed with a KISS:
Blood elves, much like draenei, are a little tricky. With draenei, we're dealing with an alien race that had no real knowledge of Azeroth until they went through the Dark Portal at the end of the Second War and tried to fix the orc problem on Draenor. With the blood elves, it's a matter of playing a race that once allied with one side of the equation and now allies with the other side.1. Is it unlikely that your blood elf would like to be in the Horde?
2. Would a blood elf magister be able to be in the Horde army?
3. Is it frowned upon if you live somewhere else than Quel'Thalas?
4. How would a blood elf ambassador feel about the other races? Would he have enough experiences to have a positive view about the other races of the Horde?
As far as blood elves and the Horde go, the blood elves joined the Horde because they were at the end of their rope. Their race had been largely decimated when Arthas plowed through Quel'Thalas and destroyed the Sunwell; their leader had left for another world in order to find a solution to their problems. Blood elves, formerly high elves, are generally regarded as a reclusive race -- they don't really enjoy allying with anyone. In history, the high elves originally allied with the humans back during the Troll Wars because the trolls were a major threat to both high elf and human civilization, and the high elves couldn't handle the trolls on their own.

When Arthas paved the Dead Scar through Quel'Thalas to reach the Sunwell, it took the high elves completely by surprise. The humans of Lordaeron did nothing to help, largely because they were embroiled in their own conflicts at the time. After the destruction of the Sunwell, the high elves (now blood elves) were basically a shattered civilization. They tried to help out the humans, and the humans weren't exactly polite in return -- so the blood elves once again withdrew. They joined with the Horde because joining with the Alliance was no longer an option.
Would your blood elf like to be in the Horde? That depends on his or her political view. If he's anxious to rebuild and survive, he's probably thankful for all the help the blood elves can get. If he's a typical blood elf, he'd rather be left alone -- but in light of the sheer devastation that the blood elf race suffered, he's probably aware that there's no other option. The blood elves didn't join with the Horde out of any great wish to do so; they did it because they needed help, and the Horde was the faction willing to lend a hand.

As far as living in places other than Quel'Thalas, I doubt it would be frowned upon. Since The Burning Crusade, the blood elves have been trying to establish their own place in the world. Not all blood elves believe that locking themselves away from the world is a preferable option; not all blood elves are self-absorbed. In fact, the blood elves would probably like to know more about the people they've chosen to ally with, purely for their own interests -- obviously, they didn't know much about the human race, and look what that led them to. So no, I don't think it'd be frowned upon for your blood elf to take up another place of residence -- just keep in mind that all blood elves originally came from Quel'Thalas. Any resettlement would have happened after The Burning Crusade, when the blood elves began to reach out from their seclusion.
That leads into your last question regarding ambassadors. By default, an ambassador is a representative of his respective race, and he is seeking to strengthen alliances, not weaken them. An ambassador is generally the best representative of his race, and as a result, someone who automatically doesn't trust or otherwise like the other races in the Horde wouldn't be chosen for that position.

Ambassadors aren't just representing their respective races; they're also seeking to understand their allies, so there has to be a degree of trust present there. How an ambassador feels about a particular race is up to individual interpretation; whatever experiences your ambassador has would color his impressions of the races.
For more information about blood elf history, you make want to check out the Blood Elf Politics article from Know Your Lore.

This is a tricky topic. Public areas are just that: public -- so you can't really dictate what goes on in that area, nor can you dictate what kind of RP happens in that area. It all comes down to being considerate to your fellow roleplayers. If you want to RP in a public area, by all means you are free to do so. If someone comes up and starts to godmode or otherwise interfere with your RP, you can address them via whisper and politely ask them to leave. The key here is "polite"; you don't want to lash out at fellow roleplayers in a way that could escalate the situation. If they insist on continuing to godmode, again inform them -- politely, of course -- that they are interfering with your RP, and you would prefer it if they'd leave. If they continue, you can viably report them for harassment.This article touches on an issue on my own server of late, where guilds that would be involved in public service sort of RP (where they are approachable for a particular type of RP, and mostly styled on lore based organizations) have been broadcasting "rules" and trying to impose them on other RPers in the area regardless of if the other RPers are engaging with their guild or not.
What do you do when a guild known for providing RP to the community takes it upon itself to dictate to the community in a way that imposes both on other RPers and on the lore and mechanics of an area in game?
Public RP guilds are generally trying to foster RP, and nine times out of 10, they don't mean to be offensive, and they don't want to infringe upon the roleplay of others. However, overzealous guilds sometimes get out of hand. Keep in mind whether you are interacting with a public roleplay guild or you are a member of one of these guilds, being polite and considerate to those around you is a must in a social activity like RP. Not everyone's roleplaying styles are going to mesh, and not everyone is going to get along. Simply interact with those you wish to play with, and don't try to enforce rules on those you don't.
If you have any questions regarding roleplay, please feel free to leave them in the comments. I may do more of these Q&A posts in the future if I get a good response. Happy roleplaying!
Filed under: All the World's a Stage (Roleplaying)






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
Raginghobo Feb 13th 2011 8:24PM
I really enjoy the last picture. It just seems to flow so well from a description you would expect to see in a romantic novel too "I like big Butts and I can not lie!"
Fjaweru Feb 14th 2011 10:45AM
Indeed. The name Becky just makes so much more sense there. At first I was all "Hey, that's my name!"...then I read the text and wondered about the connection between Beckys and being bootylicious.
(My friends determined that "Baby Got Back" was my theme song.)
ninjivitis Feb 13th 2011 8:38PM
"They tried to help out the humans, and the humans weren't exactly polite in return"
Wow, understatement of the century. It's strange that people either forget or gloss over the fact that the Alliance set them up to be slaughtered and then were going to execute them all for treason when Kael accepted Vashj's help.
Slater Feb 13th 2011 9:57PM
It's also pretty important to note that the High Elves barely lifted a finger to help out the Alliance during the second war, despite their oath to always come to the aid of Arathi when they were in trouble. They only helped (briefly) after Quel'thalas came under direct attack.
Nagaina Feb 13th 2011 8:43PM
"Would your blood elf like to be in the Horde? That depends on his or her political view. If he's anxious to rebuild and survive, he's probably thankful for all the help the blood elves can get. If he's a typical blood elf, he'd rather be left alone -- but in light of the sheer devastation that the blood elf race suffered, he's probably aware that there's no other option. The blood elves didn't join with the Horde out of any great wish to do so; they did it because they needed help, and the Horde was the faction willing to lend a hand."
This is a substantially debatable point, and a matter of fairly significant individual preference. The decision that Quel'Thalas would withdraw from the Alliance and into seclusion was a political one made my the King and the Convocation of Silvermoon: even the crown prince, Kael'thas, was not fully on board with it, as he was a ranking member of the Kirin Tor, and the fact that considerable populations of high elves in both Azeroth and Lordaeron very simply refused to comply with the directive to return home suggests that the "typical blood elf is reclusive" line is, at best, a conjecture with little fact to support it. Also: not all blood elves originally came from Quel'Thalas. There were quel'dorei communities in both Stormwind and Lordaeron outside the borders of the kingdom of Quel'Thalas. Just as some dissident high elf communities chose exile from Quel'Thalas after the Scourge assault and the changes it wrought on their society, so some high elf communities returned to their ancestral homeland after that assault to help it rebuild.
"To that end, all blood elves that are useful would definitely be used to bolster the Horde's forces. However, given Garrosh's current point of view of blood elves, it's unlikely that a blood elf could join the Horde army proper, simply because they're small, relatively fragile, and thus not much use in combat situations. Think about it -- if you had your choice between a bodybuilder or a man built like a 13-year-old boy, which would you rather shove out there to fight hand to hand with the enemy?"
This is simply disingenuous. Blood elves are not built like children -- they're built like human-sized adults with the appropriate musculature. They *look* small because the other Horde races are *larger* in frame and build. Just because Garrosh Hellscream is a moron who holds everything not Orcish about the Horde in physically palpable contempt, that does not mean his officers would not know the value of proven warriors, and that is what the Horde needs in its armies.
Anne Stickney Feb 13th 2011 8:59PM
Not really. When Kael'thas went to Outland, he took the strongest of the survivors of the Scourge attack with him. What was left behind were the weaker civilians who weren't really strong enough for Kael'thas' army. Now it's been several years since that point, and yes, we have blood elf warriors now -- but originally there was nothing to suggest the blood elves were as strong as the rest of the Horde, comparatively speaking.
Plus Garrosh is kind of a punk.
Noyou Feb 13th 2011 9:43PM
@Nagaina
She was making a point. The horde are actually much much bigger than bodybuilders and the blood elves may be as big as humans but the humans are small in comparison to Draenei and night elves. So relatively speaking the analogy was fairly accurate.
Oteo Feb 13th 2011 9:44PM
Plus, although blood elves may not be built like a 13 year old boy, they're probably built like a 13 year old orc...
Nagaina Feb 13th 2011 9:49PM
I am aware that she's making a point.
The point is a *bad* one that perpetuates divisive stereotypes and is, at best, middling useful as roleplaying advice. Correct me if I'm wrong, but that *is* the purpose of this column, is it not? My point is this: blood elves, as members of the Horde, as just as likely as any other race to find themselves members of the Horde's regular military -- there is no legitimate cultural or social barrier preventing it supported by the game's Lore.
Sintraedrien Feb 14th 2011 12:03AM
Just a point - would the blood elves really discriminate between the various types of trolls? And would they forget that it was the orcs who forced them to involve themselves with the Alliance in the first place?
I have to say at least /some/ of the survivors would want neither the Alliance, /nor/ the Horde.
At least, thats how I roll.
Sintra E'Drien of the Ebon Blade, né Sindorei (I'm tired of fighting, I'm going to pick flowers)
Anne Stickney Feb 14th 2011 3:07AM
Also: All blood elves came from Quel'Thalas. Any high elves that made settlements outside of Quel'Thalas prior to the Scourge invasion remained high elves after the Sunwell was destroyed. Only the elves within close proximity to Quel'Thalas and the Sunwell were dubbed "blood elves," for the blood of their fallen comrades. They are also the only ones that show the green-eyed fel taint from Kael'thas' attempted "cure."
Blood elves, formerly high elves, *are* reclusive by nature. Those that chose to stay behind, those that chose to join the Kirin Tor were far fewer in number than those that simply went home. The high elves were quite content to stay behind the gates and barriers surrounding Quel'Thalas for almost seven thousand years, with one brief and notable contact with the humans and dwarves during the Troll Wars. After the wars, some stayed behind -- the rest went right back to Quel'Thalas.
The *only* reason Anasterian Sunstrider joined with the Alliance of the seven kingdoms was because he was honor-bound to do so, as he was asked by the last remaining descendant of Arathi. If that hadn't been the case, the high elves wouldn't have bothered. The forces the high elves sent to help the Alliance were minimal to the point of laughable.
During the war however, the orcs managed to get far enough north to burn the borders of Quel'Thalas. Anasterian blamed the Alliance for it, and that is why he withdrew. Again, those that remained behind and stayed with the Alliance (Like Vereesa and Alleria Windrunner) remained high elves after the Scourge attack -- they were never blood elves.
Marcosius Feb 14th 2011 12:24PM
And you completely forgot to note in your post that Blood Elves are something that Horde is in short supply of - accomplished, veteran magic users. Mages especially, but warlocks (blood mages in case of the Sin'dorei), priests as well, not to mention the only experienced paladins of the Horde (Tauren took up Sunwalking just mere year or two ago, also how paladin-like their abilities truly are is debatable), and for a non-playable class, there are spell-breakers. These are troops Horde would be foolish to ignore. Of course, Garrosh isn't known for his high intelligence. *cough*
I mean, just because your average Horde soldier is twelve feet tall and built like a brick outhouse, doesn't really matter when that "13 year old boy" can call down a flamestrike or an infernal, among other things.
KT Feb 14th 2011 5:37PM
Although they may not be as ridiculously buff as, say, male orcs or male draenei, take a look at the musculature on the male blood elf model. Under those robes, their biceps are about as big as their heads. Not exactly the body of most 13-year-old boys! -- or most adult men, for that matter. ;)
shadowsabre Feb 13th 2011 9:02PM
I have a question. On my server, there's a guy who's RPing a noble and has claimed large parts of two zones that are good RP spots as his personal land, granted to him by Wrynn. This is... sort of questionable, but not terrible; on some levels it's not unlike saying you live in the house by the pumpkin patch in Stormwind. The problem is, according to what I've been hearing, he's having his guild ICly drive off any other group that they find RPing on 'his' land, using sheer force of numbers and borderline godmoding to disrupt their rp and force them to leave 'his' property, even if he and his guild has no intent to RP in that particular spot at that time. His people claim it's not harassment because it's all IC; I think that's BS and they should be /ignored and reported. The problem is, I've not personally had a run-in with them; the guild I know that has had many issues with him (due to wanting to base themselves in one of 'his' zones) wants to solve it IC, which I do not see working....
At what point does this cross the line from mere rudeness into reportable behavior? I know I'll see this firsthand one of these days, and when that day comes I WILL be reporting him and his cronies....
Noyou Feb 13th 2011 9:37PM
Sounds like his "little man syndrome" leaked into his RP which makes him a bad RPer and an even worse person? I'd say get a group of people together for a picnic or something like that and push the envelope. you will have several witnesses to what happens. make sure to document the exact server times it goes down if there is any griefing. :)
Amaxe Feb 13th 2011 11:20PM
If he's trying to force others off "his land," he's basically being a jerk and a godmodder. it isn't his property that he can prevent other rp guilds from using.
If it was directed against me, I'd report him and his guild for harassment.
Vani Feb 14th 2011 7:46AM
Worst comes to worst, you could always "hire" some horde mercinaries who assault his land and take it, with the assault ending in the king taking back the land because the noble failed to protect it. Though that might be too close to godmoding.
Gozzix Goldgear Feb 13th 2011 9:12PM
I have a question as well: I have recently rolled a new character who is a guard, trying to uphold the law, dish out justice or broken noses to criminals (He's an orc). What would be acceptable things to do as a guard without invading other roleplayer's privacy or getting too close to godmodding?
Raginghobo Feb 13th 2011 9:47PM
Guards are there to defend things, Did you roll him on a rp-pvp server? I think that would greatly help his story. You could guard against cut-throat griefers in lowbie zones or offer you services to others in your faction.
Boozard Feb 13th 2011 9:43PM
i don't have a belf and i only played wc2. so if you asked me a few months ago, i would have told you that belfs were an abberation to the lore of warcraft and i would have wanted them deported back to the alliance. but then, a friend of mine explained that the reason the belfs joined the horde was because of sylvanas, a former high elf hero. suddenly, belfs made more sense and i have somewhat recanted the whole "belfs go back" thing. i mean if your chips are really down and you meet an old close friend who says he's willing to help despite somewhat obvious and sinister changes, you'd probably go along for the ride though perhaps cautiously. makes more sense now to me anyway. i think you maybe underplaying sylvanas' role in the whole belf in horde affair.
that said, i'm imagining some interesting possibilities should blizz ever want to make earth shattering changes in the future. given that the belfs are probably closer to the forsaken than the other horde races, the forsaken somewhat in the doghouse due to garrosh's disagreements with sylvannas and the replacement of arthas with a somewhat more benevolent Lich King in Bolvar, is it possible a third faction may arise comprised of the blood elves, forsaken and two other factions from the alliance (i vote worgen and human due to the fact that forsaken and worgens are former humans anyway) to form the darker new alliance perhaps? that would make horde orc, troll, goblin, tauren for horde... and dwarves, draenei, nightelves, gnomes the uhh... the other group.
ok. sorry for the wall of text. that's just me having too much time on my hands.