The Light and How to Swing It: Customizing your retribution paladin

This edition of The Light and How to Swing It, where we'll discuss gemming, enchanting and reforging your retribution paladin, was in the works a few weeks ago, but I made the decision to hold off on it for awhile because we weren't entirely sure when patch 4.0.6 would launch at the time. Patch 4.0.6 flipped paladin stat priorities upside down. Haste, which was our favorite stat ever, is no longer so important to us. Mastery, which was some sort of bad joke previously, is now the best secondary stat for us.
It didn't make a lot of sense to release a guide to customizing your paladin's stats when all of it was going to change within days. Now that patch 4.0.6 is here, we don't need to worry about that any more.
Stat weights
Knowing the stat hierarchy is the core to getting the best out of your class. Once you know which stats are best for you, your gear choices will become second nature.
The current stat priority seems pretty solid post-patch 4.0.6, but I'll include my usual warning about these numbers: Theorycrafting is an ongoing process, and we're only in the first tier of Cataclysm raiding. The stat landscape could change drastically as soon as someone comes along and brings a new angle to the table. However, you can't live in fear of potentials, so currently, you want your stats in this order:
- strength
- hit until capped (8% for raids)
- expertise until capped (26 for raids)
- mastery
- critical strike
- haste
Mastery is supreme as our secondary stat, due to the mastery changes in patch 4.0.6. Mastery now adds holy damage to Templar's Verdict, Crusader Strike, and Divine Storm and that holy damage scales with Inquisition. A hefty chunk of mastery will do more for your DPS than any other stat, including the cooldown reduction on CS from haste.
Gems
Gemming as a retribution paladin could not be easier. Strength is so far superior to every other stat available that there are very few situations in which you do not want to gem strength. Your meta gem should be a Reverberating Shadowspirit Diamond, and you should have a Bold Inferno Ruby in every other gem slot unless the piece of gear has two gem slots with a +20 strength socket bonus, or three gem slots with a +30 strength socket bonus. In that case, you want to strength hybrid gems, such as a Skillful Ember Topaz or an Inscribed Ember Topaz. In the current tier of content, you'll be gemming pure strength in the vast majority of situations.
Reforging
Just like gemming, reforging your retribution paladin is extremely easy. The first question you should ask yourself is "Do I have enough hit and expertise?" If the answer to either of those questions is no, start reforging your worst stat (according to the stat weights above) into either hit or expertise, whichever you need. If you are both hit and expertise capped, reforge the stat at the bottom of the stat weight totem pole into one closer to the top. Does an item have mastery and haste on it as its secondary stats? Turn half of the haste into crit.
Do note that once you're over the hit and expertise caps, those stats drop to the bottom of the stat hierarchy. They have a clear point of no longer supplying any mentionable benefit. If you end up with extra hit and you have an item with hit and haste on it, you would want to reforge the hit into something else, not the haste.
Enchants
Enchantments are a bit more involved than either gems in that you can't simply say "strength or bust." Not every slot has an available strength option, or it would be the winner by a very significant margin. Let's break it down.
- Head Arcanum of the Dragonmaw / Arcanum of the Wildhammer
- Shoulder Greater Inscription of Jagged Stone
- Chest Enchant Chest - Peerless Stats or Enchant Chest - Mighty Stats. Peerless Stats is clearly the superior or the two, but Maelstrom Crystals are extremely expensive in the current tier of content. Unless you're in the most hardcore of hardcore raids, your raid leader isn't going to give you grief for the 5 stat loss. In future raid tiers, Maelstrom Crystals are likely to be more plentiful as an entire tier of epics becomes outdated. When that time comes, Peerless Stats will always be the way to go
- Cloak Enchant Cloak - Greater Critical Strike or Enchant Cloak - Critical Strike as a non-Maelstrom Crystal alternative
- Bracers Enchant Bracer - Major Strength or Enchant Bracer - Critical Strike as a non-Maelstrom Crystal alternative
- Gloves Enchant Gloves - Mighty Strength or Enchant Gloves - Exceptional Strength as a non-Maelstrom Crystal alternative
- Belt Ebonsteel Belt Buckle with a Bold Inferno Ruby socketed
- Legs Dragonscale Leg Armor
- Feet Enchant Boots - Mastery or Enchant Boots - Precision. This is one of the only situations where you would try to pick up hit rating from sources other than base gear or reforging. Both enchants are +50 to their respective stat, so their equivalency is the same as if you were reforging.
- Weapon Enchant Weapon - Landslide or Enchant Weapon - Avalanche. Landslide is far superior to any other weapon enchant for retribution paladins, but it's another case of Maelstrom Crystal madness. A strong epic weapon is worth spending the money to enchant with Landslide, but until you get your hands on one, settle for Avalanche. Nobody will fault you.
Profession bonuses
In addition to the customization that everybody can do to get the most out of their paladin, many trade skills have some sort of customization they can do as well. We won't worry about the baseline bonuses that gatherers acquire, only what crafters can add to their gear to improve upon it.
- Blacksmithing Socket Bracers and Socket Gloves with Bold Inferno Rubies in each
- Enchanting Enchant Ring - Strength
- Engineering Tazik Shocker or Synapse Springs. Some engineers aren't fond of the Synapse Springs because it locks out your on-use trinkets for 15 seconds, but I personally prefer them over the Tazik Shocker quite a bit.
- Inscription Lionsmane Inscription beats out any other available shoulder enchant.
- Jewelcrafting You are allowed to socket up to three Chimera's Eye gems. You want three Bold Chimera's Eyes socketed at all times.
- Leatherworking Draconic Embossment will overwrite other bracer enchants, but it is better than any other available option.
- Tailoring Swordguard Embroidery will overwrite other cloak enchants, but it is better than any other available option.
World of Warcraft: Cataclysm has destroyed Azeroth as we know it; nothing is the same! In WoW Insider's Guide to Cataclysm, you can find out everything you need to know about WoW's third expansion, from leveling up a new goblin or worgen to breaking news and strategies on endgame play.Filed under: Paladin, (Paladin) The Light and How to Swing It
Patch 5.3 interview with Ghostcrawler
Mystery of the Unborn Val'kyr
The latest patch 5.3 news
All of the latest Mists of Pandaria news





Reader Comments (Page 2 of 3)
Hal Feb 16th 2011 5:43PM
I've gotta say, the patch changes really were for the best (at least so far). The constant monitoring of procs got a little easier, and I don't find fights where I'm struggling just to hit everything while it's still available.
That said, I think we're still a bit too reliant on procs. I've gone entire dungeon boss fights without getting a single proc, and others where I've gotten them as fast as I can press the buttons for four or five seconds. It's better, but still results in massive swings in our DPS (or at least mine).
jonas Feb 16th 2011 6:09PM
4.0.6 definitely feels a little calmer to me too. It's terrible - I've always been very dismissive of "rotation helper" addons, claiming that you should know your spec well enough to play without one. However, a month or so ago I gave up and started using clcret - and wow, what a difference it made. Now, I'm starting to get the hang of things again, and getting the finger reflexes and muscle memory where it needs to be, and I'm trying to wean myself away from it again; but for anyone having ret rotational issues, give it a try.
Ignatius Feb 16th 2011 6:59PM
Honestly, there is no reason not to use CLCRet or any other rotational aid. It keeps your focus on the encounter, allowing you to provide certain utility where needed or move. There are times when HoF/HoSac/HoSalv and even HoP are of great use, one of your cooldowns can save the entire raid, so get your focus out of your bars and get it onto the encounter.
I'd be incredibly surprised if any of the top 200 rets on World of Logs don't use CLCRet/CLCInfo or some form of those.
(cutaia) Feb 16th 2011 5:58PM
I'll just remind people about Ask Mr. Robot in case people missed this the other week: http://wow.joystiq.com/2011/02/09/ask-mr-robot-what-gear-should-you-get/
Ever since I checked it out, I feel much more confident in my choices in gemming and reforging.
revulva Feb 17th 2011 11:11AM
Thanks for mentioning it!
Just so folks know, we are currently using the stat weights that are calculated in Redcape's spreadsheet for our default gearing suggestions. They follow the advice that Alex suggests in this article as well. Redscape posted the weights here:
http://elitistjerks.com/f76/t110342-retribution_concordance_-_4_0_6_compliant/p24/#post1859320
The spreadsheet can be found here:
http://elitistjerks.com/f76/t109229-redcapes_ret_dps_spreadsheet_5_14_-_4_06_ready_updated_02_03_a/
Telwar Feb 16th 2011 5:58PM
Just out of curiosity, why Avalanche over Hurricane?
(cutaia) Feb 16th 2011 6:06PM
I do think Hurricane was the best non-Maelstrom weapon enchant until patch 4.0.6 hit. But now that haste isn't so tasty for us, there's no desire for a haste weapon enchant. The nature damage is pure DPS increase, so it's the best way to go now.
jfofla Feb 16th 2011 6:03PM
I am Holy Main Spec, but I pretend to be Ret for questing and dailies.
I have the Meta you mentioned, but before the Patch it required more Blue Gems than Red.
So my current Gemming looks like it was done by an idiot.
jonas Feb 16th 2011 6:06PM
It's worth picking red gems up to replace your blue (and purple) gems. If you're only questing/dailying with your ret spec, might as well just get the green quality ones though!
Moridin Feb 16th 2011 7:43PM
Sanctity of battle will ALWAYS be worth speccing into. Don't under estimate how beneficial judgement of the just and windfury haste can be for you still. Then lust with zeal makes your rotation pretty cut and dry for maximum uptime on zeal. Combined with a golemblood pot and goak if its up, look forward to RIDICULOUS amounts of lust dps.
StClair Feb 16th 2011 8:02PM
Taking a break from the game at the moment (until all of this settles down a bit, for one thing) and I'm just wondering what set the pally in the picture is wearing.
dj.clayden Feb 16th 2011 9:12PM
As far as I'm aware, that horrific shade of blue can be attributed to our T11 Normal (ilvl 359) set.
Rimshot Feb 16th 2011 9:20PM
That would be the paladin Tier 11 Gear, sir.
(aka the gearset currently available through valor points.)
Pyromelter Feb 17th 2011 2:21AM
The heroic t11 definitely looks a helluva lot better, but I never though the normal t11 paladin gear looked that bad. Reminds me if a brighter blue colored version of the death knight middle tier 10, which I liked. T11 death knight gear is also blue, and looks pretty cool too... actually seems like a lot of the normal t11 for all classes is blue, then it becomes red (or red-ish) when you get heroic t11.
Maybe it's just that the color blue is very un-paladin like, I'd admit that. There are some sets that are definitely better (mage, warlock, shaman), but there are some that are really much worse (rogue, hunter).
StClair Feb 17th 2011 12:08PM
"Not paladin-like"? Maybe not to a blood elf or a dwarf, but mine's a human, and (Stormwind) blue is her favorite color. I'll be looking forward to getting this set for her.
Pally sets are hit-and-miss. I loved the white, blue and gold of T9; T10, not so much. And some of the earlier sets are just awful IMO.
Frogmaster Feb 18th 2011 10:39PM
whats the opinion on hurricane? i didnt think it wouldnt be on the list of enchants
Ocyriss Feb 17th 2011 12:24AM
Great read. One question though, why is it that the most popular class in the game, http://www.warcraftrealms.com/census.php the least covered?
Pyromelter Feb 17th 2011 2:28AM
Been asked and explained about a hundred times that the regular prot/ret paladin writer had some real life thing come up and couldn't continue writing the column. And you're really going to bang on wow insider for being slack on the "most popular class"?
This is going to get me downvoted, but I don't give a crap. Paladins really do cry and complain (aka qq) the most. Yeesh. They missed about a month of prot/ret when greg reece stopped contributing, and it's like we need to get out the binkies for everyone complaining about it.
Maybe the warlocks who got used to not having a columnist for months at a time can drink on the tears of all this qq in payment for not having a steady columnist for so long.
Ilmyrn Feb 17th 2011 9:51AM
To be fair Pyromelter, Improved QQ is listed as a spec bonus for both Ret and Prot when you choose to spec them.
Hairfish Feb 17th 2011 5:01AM
Customization: I don't think it means what you think it means.