Know Your Lore: War of the Ancients, part 3 -- The one betrayed

Before we even get started with this weeks KYL, let's take a look at parts 1 and 2 of our War of the Ancients roundups. Now that we've done that, we'll open up this post with an attempt at a succinct overview of the war and the difficulties inherent to discussing it.
Queen Azshara and her Highborne (quel'dorei) became arrogant and obsessed with the magical power of the Well of Eternity, a font of magical power the size of a massive lake that dominated the ancient single continent of Kalimdor. The wall was the source of all magical power the kaldorei (night elves) used in their world spanning civilization and far, far more as well. Created by the Titans, the Well's incalculable power was so vast that it called across the vast distances of the Great Dark Beyond to the fallen Titan Sargeras, who sought to use the Well's power to instantly enter Azeroth bodily and commence the annihilation of all the Titan's work in creating it. Azshara, whether through domination by or love for Sargeras, sought to aid him, even though it would destroy her own people. The native forces of Azeroth, the Dragonflights and nigh-immortal Ancients, rose to prevent the Burning Legion's destruction, but due to the treachery of the earth aspect Neltharion, they ultimately failed.
With the Ancients forced into desperate holding battles or even slain in their bodily incarnations and the dragons scattered by the rise of Deathwing, in the end, only the Kaldorei remained to fight the Burning Legion's demons and their own deranged and vainglorious Queen. But one night elf began to grow afraid of just what a victory would cost, and more specifically, what a victory would cost him. Having fought the demons alongside his brother Malfurion and their oldest friend Tyrande, Illidan Stormrage had been forced to watch the woman he loved grow ever closer to his twin brother and not himself. Now, having taken Tyrande away, Malfurion proposed an even greater theft. Malfurion would take magic itself away from Illidan as well.
It was not to be borne, and so Illidan took action.
Born to master nature
Ironically, as we mentioned last week, it was Illidan and not Malfurion who bore the golden eyes that signified inherent druidic potential. We often hear that the sorcery of the Highborne called to Illidan in a way the druid arts did not, but one has to wonder if Illidan simply didn't wish to compete with his twin yet again, as they had been rivals over Tyrande for years. Even worse for Illidan, it was a one-sided rivalry that Malfurion never seemed to feel or acknowledge even as he was winning it.
Whatever his reasons, Illidan chose to master arcane magic instead of nature, despite his inherent gifts. It's interesting to imagine what a druid Illidan, with greater inherent gifts than Malfurion, would have been like. How would history have been changed if Illidan had embraced his gift and transcended even the great Malfurion in druidic arts? Would Archdruid Illidan have been the one to decide what would be done with the Well of Eternity, and since he was more comfortable with the arcane, would he have made the choice Malfurion did? Perhaps some day the Infinite Dragonflight will try and bring this about.
Instead, despite a lack of Highborne training or a role within its social order, Illidan soon became one of the strongest mages in existence with more innate power than any of their greatest. As the resistance to the Legion began and those Highborne unaware of Azshara's actions lost their connection to the Well (and thus their power), it was Illidan who showed them how to use the ambient magical energies that fed into the Well itself to draw upon and who therefore gave the night elves a fighting chance against the demons. While Ancients and dragons alike fell by the wayside, Illidan took to hunting the demons and eventually even managed to defeat a powerful demon named Azzinoth in combat, ripping the demon's weapons from its corpse and using them himself. These weapons were long, curved double blades of a style similar to those already in use by night elves, weapons called glaives, which helped him perfect their use in his own style.
I choose magic over all
Illidan came to believe that the only possible victory for the night elves in the War came from overcoming Azshara's Highborne and their control of the Well of Eternity. With complete access to the Well, it would be simplicity itself to overthrow the demons and banish even Sargeras from Kalimdor. Therefore, when Malfurion proposed his plan to Tyrande, Maiev, and the remaining Ancients to destroy the Well entirely, Illidan was sickened and horrified. Not only did he believe the Well was their salvation, not their destruction, but he alone of those involved in first hearing the plan knew the cost to those accustomed to the Well's energies. Destroying the Well would plunge all of the Highborne (the majority of them actually fighting on the side of Azeroth and not for Azshara at this point) and Illidan himself into agonies as they attempted to cope with the sudden loss of the magics that sustained and energized them. Worse, it might well kill them and even vastly shorten the lifespan of all night elves, who were themselves born out of the Well's energies.
Enraged by what seemed to him a betrayal not only of himself by his own brother but of his entire people's future, Illidan formed a desperate plan. He needed sufficient power to defeat the Burning Legion before his brother could destroy the Well, and the only source of such power on Azeroth was the very Dragon Soul that had nearly done so before Neltharion had become Deathwing. In order to obtain the Dragon Soul, Illidan actually embarked upon the most perilous gambit of his life: He sought to deceive Sargeras himself.
Illidan engaged with Lord Xavius,Azshara's chief among the Highborne, and while Xavius was sure Illidan was manipulated by him into jealously over Tyrande, Illidan believed he successfully fooled the father of all satyrs and presented himself to Azshara and Mannoroth as a new convert to their cause. In time, Illidan even found himself before Sargeras himself, who believed Illidan's plan to retrieve the Dragon Soul (now called the Demon Soul) had merit. Unfortunately for Illidan, Sargeras was so impressed with him that he made a few improvements to the kaldorei sorcerer and demon slayer.
Blessed by Sargeras
It's known that Sargeras carved out Illidan's eyes and replaced them with burning orbs that could see all magic, and his famous magical tattoos were also a gift from the fallen Titan. It's unclear how much of Illidan's original purpose was left to him after Sargeras' ministrations, but it is known that alongside Azshara's thrall, Captain Varo'then, he hunted after Deathwing's hiding place and was there when his brother managed to gain access to the Demon Soul. Delivering the device into Varo'then's hands, it seems that Illidan was at least partially under Sargeras' thumb.
Yet it is telling that Illidan took no part in the epic battle that followed as Malfurion's allied forces and Azshara's met in battle. While Malfurion and Tyrande fought to prevent the coming of Sargeras and to destroy the well, and Azshara met them in full force, Illidan took action, his true plan manifest. He no longer cared which side won, so long as the Well endured.
Seven vials of the seething waters of the font of all Azeroth's natural magic did Illidan take, and so, when Malfurion ultimately succeeded in his mad ambition and destroyed the Well, shattering Sargeras' portal and preventing the Legion's invasion force from succeeding, Illidan was prepared. It was Illidan who found the small lake atop Mount Hyjal and poured three vials of the Well's waters into it, kindling the creation of a new Well to serve as a font of magic for the new world that came into existence following the first Well's destruction.
Although found and chastised by Malfurion for this, it's clear that without Illidan, the original plan of the Titans (creators of the Well, remember) would have been utterly beyond salvaging. For his choices and actions, for having dared to disagree with his brother as to the importance of arcane magic, Illidan was imprisoned for 10,000 years beneath Mount Hyjal. (If you've quested there and gone into the den containing Fandral, you've been to the place Illidan spent 10,000 years.) Yet it is impossible to argue that without Illidan, there would be no Nordrassil, no sacred mountain, no druidic order as it currently exists, and no arcane magic on Azeroth.
So Illidan Stormrage became the architect of the modern world of Azeroth. Slayer of demons, preserver of the arcane, he could have been the greatest druid ever to exist. His brother took the love of his life from him, threatened to take the only consolation he ever found, and then took his very freedom for the crime of defiance. It would come to cost them both very, very dearly.
Next week, time wizards change everything.
While you don't need to have played the previous Warcraft games to enjoy World of Warcraft, a little history goes a long way toward making the game a lot more fun. Dig into even more of the lore and history behind the World of Warcraft in WoW Insider's Guide to Warcraft Lore.Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Lore, Know your Lore
Patch 5.4 patch notes
Virtual Realms feature revealed
The Proving Grounds are coming
The latest patch 5.4 news





Reader Comments (Page 2 of 3)
Zenith Feb 24th 2011 4:56AM
Just a note that originally it was just one weapon - the warglaive of azzinoth that was a huge ninja star type weapon(same as the glaives thrown by night elf glaive throwers) that illidan split up into two:
X -original warglaive
/ and \ new split-up glaives
I think wowhead had the split up/combine warglaive as a developer weapon at some point, but not sure if it is there any more (if you look for it prepare to be disappointed at the look/size of the combined version)
smdrpepper Feb 23rd 2011 5:16PM
Interesting. So in the long run Illidan Stormrage ends up being right and not quite the villain.
Now I kind of feel bad killing him at the Black Temple.
Logan Feb 23rd 2011 5:29PM
or did you?
Léona Feb 23rd 2011 5:45PM
Sure, he meant well 10,000 years ago, but when we killed him in the temple, he had gone sufficently mad enough for anyone not to feel bad about it. ^_^
Go VH! Feb 23rd 2011 6:37PM
Word. The more I learned about WoW lore as I got into the game, the more upset I became as to how Illidan was handled in the MMO (versus the Warcraft I-III, and such). He goes from a fascinating character with all kinds of interesting motivations to, "what's Illidan up to in Outland? I dunno, just being sort of evil," in Burning Crusade. Seriously, what else was he doing besides bolstering forces against a potential attack? He's one of the greatest mages ever with access to several vials from the original Well of Eternity in a land gushing with nether energy, and they turn him into Skeletor. =P
SaintStryfe Feb 23rd 2011 7:34PM
Illy D has the sin of pride and the sin of jealousy. he couldn't handle that the love of his life just didn't love him. And thus he gave into that hatred. Don't think he's a tragic Jedi, he's Sith, all the way.
Dankie Feb 23rd 2011 9:12PM
That may be true factually, but after you read the Knaak 'war of the ancients' trilogy you may feel less sympathetic as he's a bit of a brat (understatement) and whiny >.> After reading the books, I want to go back to BT and kill him repeatedly just because of his characterization in those novels.
KNAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAK! /Kaaaaaaahn!refrence
magicjamie Feb 23rd 2011 5:16PM
i literally lmaoed
Ganatola Feb 23rd 2011 5:33PM
Ah, Illidan. The most evil good guy in the history of Azeroth. Or is he the the most "good" bad guy in the history of Azeroth? Or maybe he's the most misunderstood loser in the history of Azeroth...
Actually he's none of the above.
Despite the fact that Illidan did somewhat shape the face of Azeroth for future generations, I still don't see him as a good or even misunderstood person. I see him as a very, very solid bad guy.
LIST!
Reason #1: He did, in fact, ally with the most evil power in the universe, the Burning Legion. He did this SO THAT - wait for it - he could betray them for his own gains.
Reason #2: He abandoned his people during their greatest hour during the final battle, spending his time executing his own plans.
Reason #3: He betrayed his own brother. Sure Malfurion stole Illidan's crush, but Life certainly is not fair. Get used to it, punk (Illidan).
Reason #4: After he was released during the Third War, he executed Reasons 1-3 AGAIN. The EXACT same things. He abandoned the night elves AGAIN to chase after the Skull of Guldan. He betrayed his brother AGAIN by succumbing to the lure of demonic power. He allied again with Kil'jaeden and the demons AGAIN. Guess what - he betrayed the Burning Legion by running away to Outland.
His name is Illidan "The Betrayer" for a reason, people. You don't get that nickname by being a good person.
I've heard people complain before about why we killed Illidan. They say he was just misunderstood. Hear this, though. A person today that uses people like stepping stones and throws them away for his or her own High and Mighty goals isn't misunderstood - he or she is a BAD person.
Illidan did just this, but on a global scale.
Just because Illidan was out in Outland, minding his own business, doesn't mean we weren't justified in killing him. Sometimes vermin just need to be exterminated.
/rantover
Also,
"Perhaps some day the Infinite Dragonflight will try and bring this about."
I see what you did there...
Reordan Feb 23rd 2011 6:17PM
Actually, as I recall it, he didn't "abandon" the Night Elves during the Third War, he practically ensured their victory by consuming the Skull and killing Tichondrius. When he then returned to Malfurion and Tyrande, they banished him. Illidan is only "The Betrayer" in the eyes of Malfurion. You can watch the cinematic here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gv4KIRafuvI&feature=related
In case people can't be bothered, I'll transcribe it below:
Malfurion: Foul demon! What have you done with my brother?
Illidan: It is I, Furion. This is what I've become.
Tyrande: No! Illidan, how could you?
Illidan: The leader of the Undead has been destroyed, and the forests will heal in time.
Malfurion: At the cost of your soul? You are no brother of mine! Begone from this place, and never set foot in our lands again!
Illidan: So be it... brother.
Ganatola Feb 23rd 2011 6:49PM
Good call, my friend, but I have a hole to poke in your argument. Illidan did not win the War for the night elves, but rather an important battle. Malfurion actually won the Third War by releasing the wisps upon Archimonde. Malfurion, the elf you just said Illidan betrayed. Meanwhile, where was Illidan at this time? Banished and without the chance to fight for his people. He abandoned his people through his actions that led up to his banishment. Was being a powerful sorcerer not enough? Nay, he hungered for more power.
Let's put it this way. In Illidan's fight for power, he became what he and his people were fighting against. Demonic power. Pure evil in their eyes. And in the eyes of most of the living population.
It is mentioned in the article, the reason that Illidan hunted for more power. All he wanted to do was be better than his brother so that he could have Tyrande, and he sold his soul, as you just mentioned, in his attempt for this.
Dravie Feb 23rd 2011 7:10PM
@Ganatola
Thats what we call a "Demon Hunter" man.
Its a specific class that hunts demons, using their own power against them.
Illidan was the first, but there are others.
In all warcraft lore illidan is usually doing something by the sides cos others didnt agree with him, but looking at the bigger picture he is aways right.
lets use as exemple:
what was he doing when he was in northrend?
trying to kill the Lich king.
For the burning legion of course, but becouse Maiev and Malfurion stoped him, a lot of people died in Wrath of the lich king exp.
The metods he aways used, were exatly like his class is described, using demonic energies to do good.
Darky Feb 23rd 2011 7:34PM
So what everyone is trying to get across is that hes basically your average warlock hero (pc)?
Valekai Feb 23rd 2011 11:18PM
Maiev and Malfurion didn't stop him, Arthas handed him his ass lol
Reordan Feb 24th 2011 3:15AM
@Ganatola: Yes, Malfurion's trap was what defeated Archimonde, and ultimately sealed the war effort in favor of the "Alliance". However, if Tichondrius hadn't been removed, and he had been able to use the Skull at will, that trap might not have worked, as the defenses around Mount Hyjal could potentially have been swamped much sooner.
Yes, Illidan has always had a hunger for power, noone can deny that. However, practically everything he has done also had a more benevolent side to it. As was illustrated in the above article, he didn't want to lose the power of the Well of Eternity, but in saving it he potentially saved much more than his own power. Consuming the Skull of Gul'dan and slaying Tichondrius also boosted his own power, but also contributed to the defeat of the Scourge at Hyjal. Obtaining the Eye of Sargeras also increased his power, but he intended to use it to destroy the Lich King. Even after being imprisoned by Malfurion, then banished, and finally sentenced to death, he still helped his brother, the brother who had won the affection of the only woman Illidan had ever loved, in rescuing that very same woman.
@Valekai: Malfurion and Maiev stopped him in Dalaran, which bought the Lich King enough time to call Arthas to Icecrown.
Pryn Feb 24th 2011 4:47AM
@Reordan
http://www.wowhead.com/quest=28257
Have you done this ingame yet? Its so facinating to aid in the fight and then watch that scene and exact dialogue in the first person.
Bodrake Feb 23rd 2011 7:12PM
Hmmmm...
At the last BlizzCon, Chris Metzen stated that he would love to find a way to redeem Illidan and return him from the dead. So, how about the following:
1) in Patch 4.x we will have the Caverns of Time raid on the War of the Ancients. This gives us a chance to go back and save Illidan. We players show up, save Malfurion from some demons, convince him that Illidan is making a mistake, and then fight through demons and evil Highborne to finally face Illidan and knock him out, thus rescuing him. Maybe the Infinite Dragonflight were behind the Broxigar/Rhonin/Krasus time travel and we get to smack that red-headed mage around too. :D
2) This could feed into the next expansion, allowing Blizz to effectively ret-con the Black Temple as part of the overhaul of Outlands (which, BTW, I think they should do as part of the effort to send us to other planets - Xoroth and Argus, maybe). Maybe they could put Azshara into the Black Temple in place of Illidan (we saved Illidan, so Sargeras transformed Azshara into a demon instead).
Dravie Feb 23rd 2011 7:18PM
3º option:
We go caverns of time, save illidan from the players that killed him, he stays in reclusion to heal injuries or something like that for a good a mount of time and then he comes back in cata to help us take Deathwing as his personal mount.
End of cata and Bring the new exp!!!!
=P
Maymer Feb 23rd 2011 9:27PM
Option #4:
Illidian was never killed at all! Instead, due to his hilarious and wacky adventures with his pals in Outland, Kil'jaeden put all of them on Double Secret Probation!
Because of this, we the players must follow ol' Illie around whilst redeeming the name of Black Temple House in time for the big Outland Parade, where tracks of "Louie Louie" and "Shout" continue to play in the background.....wait a minute.....
Go VH! Feb 23rd 2011 8:49PM
I hate retcons 90% of the time, but I'm not entirely against one to bring back Illidan. I'd hate that a retcon would be NECESSARY to do something new with his character, but seeing a second go at him after his rather boring presentation in BC would outweigh that for me. I think if Blizz does a time alteration angle, though, it might be wise to retcon LOTS of stuff; the ripple effect, and such. That way the Illidan change doesn't stick out quite so much.
In any event, I kinda doubt that Blizz will actually bring Illidan back. I think the most we'll see are lore references, like the quest chain in Felwood. I do hope something regarding the Caverns of Time results in a change at some point, though. Seems silly to have the adventurers always succeed.