Know Your Lore: The sorrow of Southern Barrens

Cataclysm brought with it a lot of changes -- the face of Azeroth was forever changed as the landscape altered when Deathwing burst forth onto the scene. But along with the physical changes, there were plenty of political changes as well. For the Horde, Cataclysm saw the rise of a new Warchief in Garrosh Hellscream, as Thrall took his place beside the Earthen Ring and tried to repair the tattered land. The Alliance saw the rise of the Council of Three Hammers in Ironforge, as Magni Bronzebeard's sudden demise left a hole in the heart of the Bronzebeard dwarves.
It was the shattering of the land that saw both Alliance and Horde forces immediately move to reconfigure their borders and take whatever land and resources they could possibly get. Though the war rages on, some places are no longer war-torn and filled with the sounds of combat. Instead, these once-populated areas are filled with the silence of lives lost, of the cautious footsteps of looters looking to take whatever spoils of war they can carry.
Perhaps the most saddening of these is the once-peaceful settlement of Camp Taurajo -- now a charred version of its former self, left to wither back into the harsh lands of the Southern Barrens.
The Southern Barrens presents a unique and new tactic with World of Warcraft storytelling. Two sides fight over territory, Alliance and Horde -- and the result of that fighting is a small outpost, one that wasn't doing any harm to anybody, populated by the relatively peaceful tauren, shredded to pieces. But what makes the storytelling so unique is the fact that there are two sides to it -- Horde players see one half of the events, Alliance players see the other. To that end, we'll be visiting both sides of the faction war, though today our focus is on the Horde side of the equation.

And so, shortly before the Cataclysm, plans were put in place to build a road straight across The Barrens, from Dustwallow Marsh all the way to Stonetalon Peak, connecting the two. It was understood that there would be Horde resistance, so forces were sent from Northwatch Hold to pave the way and clear out the area, including the Horde outpost of Honor's Stand. As for Camp Taurajo, though on the map it doesn't appear to be standing in the way of a road, it clearly stood in the way of progress. Orders were given by the Alliance to secure the roadways and anything that stood in the way, including Camp Taurajo.
Forces from Northwatch Hold started their march across the landscape, while forces from Theramore apparently did the same. The Northwatch forces attacked the Crossroads, holding them at bay and then, in the middle of the fighting, presented an organized march south to Honor's Stand. As for Camp Taurajo ... the tauren in the village were quickly overwhelmed and killed, the survivors barely managing to escape and fleeing north.

But The Barrens didn't just belong to the Horde -- the native quillboar of the area chose that moment to attack and captured many of the Camp Taurajo survivors. The land chose to move in their favor, and the brambles and thorny brush that the quillboar called their home rose up from the earth, quickly taking over the path between Razorfen Kraul and Razorfen Downs that led to the Great Lift in Thousand Needles. Not that any seeking refuge south had anywhere to go -- the ocean burst into the canyons of Thousand Needles and left behind a lake of water and still more lives lost.

But the Horde was strong, and the Horde would not let the Alliance pass. Though most of the survivors of Honor's Stand traveled south at the orders of Warlord Gar'dul, some insisted on staying behind and letting the Alliance know that they were encroaching on Horde lands. Embittered survivors of Taurajo holed up and created an outpost at Vendetta Point, where they continued to attack the Alliance forces that had murdered their kin -- and keep them away from the much more hospitable lands of Mulgore.
The tauren people knew that it was only a matter of time before the Alliance decided to launch an attack on Thunder Bluff. Before they could get that chance, the tauren constructed a great gate, blocking off the only entrance into Mulgore -- well, the only known entrance. High above the rest of The Barrens, paths over the mesas used for years only by tauren hunters were opened up, providing a vantage point to attack the Alliance forces below. The narrow paths were easily defended -- and the Great Gate into Mulgore remained firmly closed.

The tauren, already dealing with the suffering caused by Cairne Bloodhoof's death and the struggles to fight off the treacherous Grimtotem. The tauren, arguably the kindest race the Horde had to offer. Of all the Horde races, the tauren are the least deserving of the heartbreak they are receiving in Cataclysm -- first the loss of a Chieftain, then the inexplicable slaughter of a peaceful hunting outpost, the treachery of the Grimtotem, then the Cataclysm that saw an uprising of the quillboar which shattered the peace of Camp Narache, a flood that ruined the comforting rises of Thousand Needles.
Perhaps the most surprising note in all of this is that the attack on Camp Taurajo, on the Crossroads and on Honor's Stand was carried out by orders from Theramore. The Northwatch Patrols carry Theramore Merit Badges, clearly marking them as members of the Theramore forces. Camp Triumph, situated across from Desolation Hold, is populated with members of the Theramore army. A brief look at the new map of Dustwallow Marsh shows the beginnings of the road the Alliance wishes to construct. Which makes one wonder ... what exactly caused Theramore to order this assault? Or more correctly, Jaina Proudmoore, leader of Theramore?

So where exactly did Jaina go from sympathetic and compassionate leader, to someone who orders her armies to build a road across The Barrens and attack Horde outposts? Where did peace-loving Jaina, gentle friend of Thrall, retreat to? It's unlikely any of this was done under her nose, not with the extent of the assault. Was she influenced by Varian Wrynn and forced to side with her faction over her wish for peace? Was she so infuriated by Garrosh's rise to Warchief? Or has she simply been removed from the picture?

From the Horde perspective, the Southern Barrens is a tale of tragedy, vengeance, destruction, and a definitive look at the power of Garrosh's Horde. It's a story that raises more questions than it answers -- and though the person "responsible" for the massacre at Camp Taurajo is brought to justice swiftly and with no mercy, there is no satisfaction, no redemption with his demise. All that remains is yet another empty-eyed corpse, left to hang in the harsh landscape and rot in the unforgiving sun.
Come back next week when we take a look at the other half of the story -- the Alliance side.
For more information on related subjects, please look at these other Know Your Lore entries:
- Baine, son of Cairne, chief of the Bloodhoof tauren
- Go'el, son of Durotan
- Jaina Proudmoore
- Cairne Bloodhoof
While you don't need to have played the previous Warcraft games to enjoy World of Warcraft, a little history goes a long way toward making the game a lot more fun. Dig into even more of the lore and history behind the World of Warcraft in WoW Insider's Guide to Warcraft Lore.
Filed under: Lore, Know your Lore






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 6)
Tidelord Apr 24th 2011 6:13PM
*inb4 accusations and factional arguments start spreading like wildfire*
Kyrt Apr 24th 2011 7:36PM
Its difficult to see how things pan out.
Tuarajo was razed because it was identified as a post where the Horde trained warriors, hunters, etc. That assessemnt is probably correct and givent he state of war at the time, it does seem a legitimate target. Nor was the Alliance entirely out for slaughter....the General in charge deliberately left the civilians a way out; those who remained and fought were armed combatants.
More problematic is the timing. On one hand we have a Tauren who states the battles took place before the Cataclysm. On the other, we have information that the road was needed to reinforce Stonetalon...a battle that didn't start until Garrosh decided to claim all of Kalimdor and it resources for the Horde after he became warchief. The Shattering complicates matters as it seems to show that the events of the cataclysm occurred mere days after Thrall stepped down, days after Baine bid Jaina and Anduin farewall and yet no conflict is seen in the Barrens.
Synchronizor Apr 24th 2011 7:56PM
Yes, I'm not going to be surprised if this treatment of the story leads to a lot of flaming.
This is a fair, accurate description of the Horde side and perspective to the story in the Southern Barrens. However, the two-week format really can't help but come across as biased against the Alliance. The Alliance side of the events are a strong counterbalance to the Horde perspective, but I think this issue, which is quite touchy for a lot of people, will suffer from being split up.
It would have been far more constructive, in my opinion, to offer both sides of the conflict in a longer, single article; even if it took longer to write and pushed the release back a week.
In any case, I urge everyone here to hold off on condemning the Alliance for their actions until both sides of the story have been explored.
vocenoctum Apr 24th 2011 9:23PM
I think the problem is twofold really;
1) we don't know what really happened, neither of the questlines (horde or alliance) is really facts.
2) Perception is very biased in this matter. "The Tauren are peaceful!" so, wait, the grimtotems didn't attack Dustwallow for years? "They don't count!" and there are no tauren's fighting for the horde? Was this peaceful little camp growing daisies, or were bands of hunters staged from there? Did they produce weapons of war, or did the blacksmith only make special shoes so the peaceniks couldn't Warstomp anymore?
I'm not saying the alliance is right, but they are fighting a war of skirmishes. This is not a military town, but the people there DO fight for the horde.
(Otoh, the tauren are probably the only horde race that actually HAS a claim to the lands they use. People gloss over the horde's attack on the ancestral lands of the night elves as the night elves fault too, so I guess we can gloss over the humans armies rolling tanks into the Taurens lands...)
Wulfkin Apr 24th 2011 10:45PM
Quite frankly I find all this talk of training up hunters and 'legitimate targets' appalling. Yes you can go on a long rant about what the Horde have done, and how in all kinds of ways the the Alliance could be justified in this that and the other, but none of it matters.
The simple fact is this: You don't murder children.
The burning of Taurajo was a horrific, immoral act, made all the worse by the fact that it was entirely unnecessary as even a military move. Wars can be fought without destroying civilian targets.
Don't look at the act in the larger sphere. Neither the Horde or the Alliance are ever going to come off as the 'good guys' if you do that anyway. It's all personal bias. But look at the act itself and it is clearly completely unjustifiable.
zweitblom Apr 25th 2011 12:26AM
"It would have been far more constructive, in my opinion, to offer both sides of the conflict in a longer, single article; even if it took longer to write and pushed the release back a week."
And yet that is *exactly* how Blizzard chose to tell this story. I for one salute the author to reimagine that kind of inciteful storytelling by splitting up the article about it as well. There is no *one* Azeroth anymore - not only the land has been sundered, people(s) have been as well.
Vaeku Apr 25th 2011 4:24AM
"The simple fact is this: You don't murder children."
Tell that to that general in Stonetalon. Yes, Garrosh killed him, but the fact that it happened in the first place says a lot about the "absolute control" a Warchief has over his forces.
Not to mention that the Alliance didn't kill any children at Camp Taurajo. The general in charge deliberately left a path open for the civilians to leave, even when some of the people under him didn't share his feelings.
Wulfkin Apr 25th 2011 8:49AM
@Vaeku: The ghosts of those murdered at Taurajo seem to tell a different story.
But on Stonetalon, yes absolutely. That's why I'm saying neither side can take any kind of moral high ground, we've both committed atrocities and gone too far. That's why these whole 'we were justified because of x' arguments are so foolish.
Noyou Apr 25th 2011 9:28AM
Having done the quests on alliance side it still doesn't sit well with me. I do love the Tauren as a race of honorable and mainly peaceful people. There was time allowed as you learn, for any non combatants to escape. So my interpretation is that no women and children who weren't taking up arms were not killed. Since there were other factors in play (Deathwing, Quillboars and corrupted wildlife) if you stumble onto the scene after the fact and see the bodies of innocents on the ground naturally you are going to assume it was the alliance who did it.
Throm Apr 24th 2011 6:15PM
People always focus on how terrible, how horrible Taurajo is. Why does nobody speak of the firebombing of Astrannar? Oh wait, that's right. Only the Horde suffer from anything anymore. The Alliance are always the evil aggressors, always to blame.
pakkman781 Apr 24th 2011 6:21PM
Don't forget Southshore.
Revnah Apr 24th 2011 6:26PM
Two wrongs don't make a right. I was appalled when I (with my horde characters) discovered what the horde had done in Ashenvale. Disgusted, actually. And when I log on my Ally characters (which doesn't happen a lot these days) I am ashamed for the reckless and unprovoked attack on the Tauren - and that wasn't just Camp Taurajo, as the article pointed out.
I guess the Tauren get a lot of attention because, again as the article highlighted, they have had so much heartache and loss at once. And also because they are probably the most peaceful, non-aggressive of all races in Azeroth.
Darky Apr 24th 2011 6:29PM
Because the main faction Taurens have never done anything to anyone, ever. They are the most peace loving race in the game (excluding the grimtotems and the various outlaw Tauren). You cant say that about any of the other races.
Micheal Apr 24th 2011 6:34PM
because tauren are awesome, cute and fluffy. that's why.
Scunosi Apr 24th 2011 6:36PM
Well at least in Taurajo's part it was pretty much unprovoked-this was a peaceful Tauren settlement deep in established Horde land. Ashenvale has always been contested between the Night Elves and Orcs, so that's more of just an escalation in the conflict.
Southshore too though I think was fairly unprovoked, at least for the level and brutality it ended up facing. Players may have warred there for years but I'm having trouble remembering any outright fighting between the Humans and Forsaken, it was mostly subversive tactics.
Mejari Apr 24th 2011 6:38PM
"You cant say that about any of the other races"
Gnomes, Night elves, Draenei and Dwarves say hi. For all the crap humans get, the Alliance is filled with, for the vast majority, very peaceful races.
Bagelator Apr 24th 2011 6:45PM
What about the gnomes? And the draenei? I wouldn't call a tauren more peace loving than a gnome
Sayis Apr 24th 2011 6:47PM
This article is focused on how terrible Taurajo was because it's about the Southern Barrens, written from the Horde's perspective. I'm sure next week's article will offer a good counterbalance since we get a view from the Alliance-side. It's not trying to say one side's right or wrong, it's just saying what happened.
lancrkllr Apr 24th 2011 7:10PM
Trying to stay out of the factional argument, but here's my take on it:
Ashenvale has always been about the intrusion of the horde into the ancestral lands of the night elves. Since Durotar is devoid of all resources, and northern barrens isn't much better, Ashenvale becomes the best possible target once the repairs of Orgrimmar begin.
Camp Taurajo was probably supposed to be a "drive em back into Mulgore so we can claim Barrens" action by the Theramore military. The razing of the village was intentional, the number of casualties on the Tauren side was probably not.
The Forsaken are pretty much running things their way right now. Sylvanas has pretty much told Garrosh that she's not listening. The blight bombs were never supposed to be used again following the events of Wraithgate.
*HOWEVER*
Considering that the Forsaken are currently in combat with the Worgen, and neither side really has any form of readily available reinforcements (for the forsaken, the closest allies are the bloodelves up north, and pretty much all of the alliance are south of them) the destruction of South Shore can be seen as a defensive move. By eliminating a port in which alliance troops can be moved into hillsbrad, the Forsaken can move most of their forces to engage the worgen.
Chokaa Apr 24th 2011 7:20PM
@mejari
Night elves?? Peaceful? Really? When first encountering another race (this is in wc3, btw) the first thing they did was attack. There was no diplomacy or peace involved at all.
Not to mention goig firther back with how NE's treated illidan and then firther back how Azshara acted. And she was worshipped by her people!
I will agree on draenai and Gnomes, though.