Know Your Lore: The curse of the worgen and the Scythe of Elune, part two

Last week we uncovered the true origins of the worgen, and of the Scythe of Elune. Far from the mysterious object it appeared to be throughout vanilla World of Warcraft, the Scythe was actually constructed for a specific purpose, though the results of its construction were a horrifying disaster. The Scythe of Elune would not be seen again in anyone's hands for thousands of years, presumably stowed away somewhere for safekeeping.
As for the worgen, they continued their existence in the Emerald Dream to which they were banished. But this was not the end of the worgen; though they dreamed the dream of the wild, they always sought a way to escape. The exile of the Dream, a paradise to most druids, was a torture beyond comprehension to the followers of Goldrinn. Malfurion had done what he thought best for all considered -- the tree Daral'nir would supposedly keep the worgen at rest. Yet how, exactly, did Malfurion know of the tree's existence?
Please note: Today's Know Your Lore contains spoilers for the five-issue miniseries Curse of the Worgen -- an excellent series that I cannot recommend enough -- go pick it up if you haven't! If you do not wish to be spoiled, now would be a very good time to turn back.

It didn't work. The worgen were just as vicious as ever, perhaps more so given their imprisonment. And thousands of years later, a magician of Dalaran named Ur began researching the worgen, though he could not comprehend what they actually were.
The worgen's home is a dark place, a place of nightmare. If that world fosters locations safe from the cursed Worgen, then my research has revealed no such bastions. And if one considers the ferocity and wickedness of the Worgen, it is likely that no such bastions exist. It is surmised that the Worgen are content to remain on their world, for although some Worgen possess powerful magic, they have made no attempts to reach Azeroth of their own accord. And for this, we are fortunate.
It is my hope that no Dalaran wizard seeks out the Worgen, even if done in light conscience. For no pact may be struck, no secrets may be learned, no good can come from these beasts. They are best left to their world. For if found in ours and not destroyed, our peril will be dire... -- The Book of Ur

Ur was hesitant about experimenting with the worgen -- but Arugal was not. Under Greymane's orders and using Ur's research, Arugal summoned the worgen from whatever strange world they originated in. To a human, the Emerald Dream was an utter mystery, and viewing it would indeed be like viewing an entirely different dimension or world. Fortunately for Arugal, the summoning worked as intended. Unfortunately for Arugal, Ralaar -- now Alpha Prime -- and the rest of the worgen weren't really the allies they'd hoped for.
Alpha Prime and the worgen took care of the Scourge as instructed, and then promptly turned on Arugal and the rest of the wizards and armies of Gilneas that they were supposedly fighting beside. Though originally the bite of the worgen was an immediate catalyst for the transformation into worgen, thousands of years in the Emerald Dream had dulled the effects. Soldiers that were taken back into Gilneas to recuperate and recover eventually turned into worgen themselves, and began attacking their fellow Gilneans.

Halford was "gifted" with the worgen curse by Alpha Prime, and as he progressed from man to worgen, discovered the story of the worgen -- their origins and how they came to be. Alpha Prime's actions did not go unnoticed by the night elves, however. Belysra, still alive after thousands of years, traveled to Gilneas presumably upon hearing of the rampaging worgen in the area. But in order to defeat Alpha Prime, Belysra would need the object that Alpha Prime was desperately searching for, the object that imprisoned him so long ago, and could very well do so again -- the Scythe of Elune.
The Scythe had been absent from history for thousands of years -- presumably locked away by Malfurion and the Cenarion Circle so that its powers could not be used to release the worgen from their imprisonment. But the powers of the Scythe would be unleashed again, this time by a night elf named Velinde Starsong -- an elf of no particularly high rank or note. Velinde was charged with clearing the forests of Felwood of the demons that plagued it -- demonic agents of the Burning Legion and satyr alike, presumably left over from the Third War.

Velinde didn't, couldn't know what the true power of the Scythe actually was. She also had no knowledge of the true identity of the Lords of Emerald Flame -- the satyr that battled the night elves thousands of years before, during the War of the Satyr -- the same war that sparked the creation of the worgen. But something gave her the Scythe of Elune and urged her to open the portal between Azeroth and the Emerald Dream, to release the worgen as a weapon against the demons she'd been sent to conquer.Elune has granted my wishes. The lives of my fallen comrades will not be in vain, and I shall avenge their deaths using the Scythe of Elune. It is an ancient thing, a branch, twisted and gnarled of wood that could be older than even the Kaldorei.
For many hours I examined the tool that the goddess granted to me. It is no ordinary weapon, that is for certain, nor is it a simple magical implement. With it... it is as though the barriers of time and space are weakened. Holding the Scythe in my hands, I received a vision of chaos. Wolf-men... the worgen... battled an incredible enemy. The worgen fought savagely, as fit their primitive race, but their enemy was unflinching: the Lords of the Emerald Flame.
And that was when I realized the true power of the Scythe. By focusing on it, I became able to communicate with the worgen. It was not speech I used to contact them, however. It was something different... I could not describe it.

Goldrinn died during the War of the Ancients, but even in death the Ancients are quite possibly powerful enough to continue to affect the real world. Given Goldrinn's nature and his eternal conflict with Elune, he may have found a way to get the Scythe to Velinde in order to release his "children" of sorts -- but again, this is just speculation. Regardless, the events afterward were typical for the worgen we now have the origin story for; they fought the demons of Felwood, and gradually grew more and more powerful, their numbers increasing despite the fact that Velinde halted summoning the creatures. They grew more feral and more dangerous, and Velinde decided to seek advice from a man reported to have summoned the worgen without the help of the Scythe -- Archmage Arugal.
Velinde's journey took her from the forests of Kalimdor to Booty Bay, and then north to Duskwood. And then, inexplicably, Velinde Starsong vanished from the face of Azeroth, never to be seen again. The Scythe was found in a mine, unearthed by a miner named Jitters who unwittingly released a score of worgen in Duskwood. He managed to flee, but dropped the Scythe on the way. But what of Velinde? What happened to her, where did she disappear?

But perhaps Velinde met a slightly different fate. After all, the Scythe that she thought was opening a portal to another dimension she'd never seen before was in actuality opening a portal to the Emerald Dream. Perhaps Velinde -- who was not a druid of any kind -- simply had no idea what the Emerald Dream looked like. And in the depths of Duskwood, nestled in the very center of the forests lies one of four portals that lead directly into the Emerald Dream. ...Is it possible that Velinde discovered the portal, and simply stepped through, intent on seeing what the home of the worgen was really like? If so, she could simply be lost somewhere in the Dream -- possibly a victim of the Emerald Nightmare.
More concerning however are the tales of the Dark Riders of Duskwind Pass, a mysterious group of dark figures in search of the Scythe, though their reasons are unknown.
Are the Dark Riders actually part of Alpha Prime's worgen forces, attempting to retrieve the artifact for their leader? Or do they work for some other entity we have yet to discover? It's never really clarified. What we do know is that the Scythe was found in Duskwood and taken to Gilneas at some point just after Cataclysm, and Alpha Prime and his worgen followers were dispatched and taken care of."The Scythe of Elune." one of the Riders shrieked in a voice both harsh and shrill, like the grinding of an axe on stone. And the last word - Elune - it croaked, as if choking on the sound. Dread gripped me when I heard that voice, both from the horrid sound of it, and because...I knew the Scythe of which the Rider spoke. It must be the same cursed thing I drew from the rocks of Roland's Doom days before. It was what the Black Riders sought! -- Jitters' Journal

Though we now know the true origin of the worgen, and how the humans of Gilneas came to be affected with the worgen curse, the ultimate fate of the Scythe of Elune is still up in the air. Was it returned to Kalimdor, now safe in the hands of the kaldorei? Was it taken to Hyjal, where the resurrected Ancient Goldrinn now roams whole once more? And what of the Dark Riders of Deadwind Pass -- where do they fit into the story, and will we ever hear of them again?
While the origins of the Scythe and its ultimate purpose have been revealed, there is much to the mysterious artifact left to be discovered. Even though the playable worgen of Warcraft are humans that have the curse under control, there are still worgen out there in the forests of Duskwood that have no master and no control. It seems as though the Scythe, despite the clarification in its origin, still has elements left that should be explained. Perhaps one day we'll get that clarification -- but for now, we at least have a solid idea of the Scythe's roots and the worgen's origins, something that has been haunting players since vanilla WoW.
For more information on related subjects, please look at these other Know Your Lore entries:
- The War of the Ancients
- The Eternals Part 1: The Ancients
- Current Alliance politics -- the night elves
- King Genn Greymane of Gilneas
- A history of Gilneas
While you don't need to have played the previous Warcraft games to enjoy World of Warcraft, a little history goes a long way toward making the game a lot more fun. Dig into even more of the lore and history behind the World of Warcraft in WoW Insider's Guide to Warcraft Lore.
Filed under: Lore, Know your Lore






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
vocenoctum May 15th 2011 3:41PM
We can assume the scythe was in duskwood until Jitters found it. Thus releasing worgen into Duskwood. Then it made it's way northward to be there for the quest to recover it, but the time frame there is easily possible.
Then we have to assume the Scythe was taken from the worgen of Grizzly Hills again at some point, we can assume after we gacked Arugal again as part of the quests to do so.
We also know there are druids there that might have recognized it in enough time to shuffle it off back to be used during the Gilnean troubles which occured roughly around the time of the cataclysm.
Timing wise its fine I think, though it does seem a little "busy".
The Dark Riders could be anyone, since afaik there's nothing saying they actually GOT the Scythe. I doubt they're worgen, but easily fit in the with the Scourge. If Arthas had riders get the Scythe to further his plans with Arugal that seems to fit fine.
As for who gave the Scythe to Velinde, it's entirely possible that Elune did it, perhaps out of some regret for what she had caused. Perhaps she knew they were needed.
loop_not_defined May 15th 2011 5:31PM
For a long time the Dark Riders were assumed to be a part of the Burning Legion, what with Karazhan and Attumen nearby.
If the Worgen were warring with the Satyr within the Emerald Dream, and the Satyr were still at least somewhat connected with the Burning Legion, then coming to the conclusion that the Dark Riders = Attumen and the Burning Legion doesn't seem like quite a stretch. Having the Scythe of Elune could certainly benefit them.
Anne Stickney May 15th 2011 5:51PM
Well here's the issue I have with the timeline:
1. Arugal summoned the worgen to defend the Gilneas Wall from the Scourge. The Scourge didn't even exist in the game lore until year 21-22 in the timeline, during WC3: The Frozen Throne.
2. Velinde got the Scythe at some point after that, presumably either during the early days or just before the launch of World of Warcraft - year 24-25 or so, somewhere in there. It would have had to have been at least a couple years after the events in Gilneas, because there had to have been time for #1 - Arugal to summon the worgen in Felwood, and more importantly #2 - Time for word to get all the way from the remote areas of Pyrewood Village in the Eastern Kingdoms to the outskirts of Kalimdor. The night elves didn't even really join the Alliance until about year 23-24 or so, so...yeah. Velinde had the Scythe in Felwood, then left for Booty Bay and Duskwood, then vanished, and the worgen appeared in Duskwood.
3. The worgen of Duskwood were there the day vanilla launched, making that year 24-25 in the timeline -- that's when Jitters found the Scythe and released the worgen.
4. At some point the Scythe found its way to Arugal, presumably after he died, because after his resurrection he was taken to Grizzly Hills, and that's where the Scythe ended up. That was just prior to Wrath's launch, so year 26-27 in the timeline -- while The Burning Crusade expansion was going on.
5. Year 27 was Wrath of the Lich King, players found the Scythe and it was taken back to Duskwood for...some obscure reason that hasn't been defined.
6. It wasn't in Duskwood for more than maybe a month or two before it was 'found' and taken to Gilneas just as the Cataclysm happened.
What confuses me is how the Scythe went from Duskwood to wherever Arugal happened to be to Grizzly Hills then back to Duskwood again. Why would Arugal try to find the Scythe? How would Arugal have known of the Scythe's existence? Or if it wasn't Arugal that tried to find it -- how the heck did the San'layn that resurrected Arugal figure out what the Scythe was, what it was for, and where to fetch the thing? More importantly, how long exactly was it from the moment the worgen were summoned by Arugal, to the day that the Gilneas was overrun with worgen trying to take over?
vocenoctum May 15th 2011 6:40PM
1&2 I'll grant is a little odd, though I think Velinde may have had the Scythe for a while, so her and Arugal could overlap in their timelines a little.
For 4, I don't know that Arugal ever laid hands on it. It was certainly there...
For 5&6, did it return to Duskwood though? I didn't recall it in my travels through post-cata Duskwood.
Shanic May 15th 2011 7:42PM
An easier explanation for the problem is that the Scythe in Northrend was...
*Romulan* ...A FAKE!
So it never left Duskwood where it was recovered and ended up in the hands of the Worgen of Gilneas, presumably it's ultimate fate as that is the last anyone has heard of it. Nothing in Northrend indicates its the real Scythe of Elune, so it could be all we handed over to the Worgen of Northrend was just a plain old standard scythe, which they believed to be the real deal.
That's my interpretation anyway.
Anne Stickney May 15th 2011 9:10PM
It did return to Duskwood, or it stayed there perhaps -- in the Curse of the Worgen series, it's mentioned specifically that the night elves found the Scythe there and brought it to Gilneas.
icepyro May 15th 2011 9:36PM
Uh, the human campaign in Reign of Chaos is called the Scourge or Lordaeron. The undead campaign involved the Scourge razing Dalaran. Considering the undead campaign in TFT is basically the rise of the Forsaken, I would assume Gilnaeas was attacked before the Night Elves became involved? Am I mistaken? There were plenty of loose Scourge about Lordaeron during TFT, but I thought the wall was built by then?
I thought Jitters had already found the Scythe and lost it again before vanilla launched. I mean there was that journal, but I hadn't really quested in Duskwood to know if the Worgen were still getting reinforcements or if they were simply there already and attacking, possibly spreading the curse to account for the appearance of reinforcements?
I also don't recall it going back to Duskwood after Grizzly Hills.
So by my reckoning:
Arugal had it during the third war.
Then who knows how Velinde got it, but she was on her way to visit and learn more when Duskwood happened.
My guess would be that Arugal wanted it back (or one of his "sons" did) and sent for it. It could even be that Velinde was met in Duskwood and the resulting battle over the Scythe led to her disappearance. Either way, it got back to Pyrewood after we adventurers ended Arugal.
While we are in Outland, Arthas attacks and realizing what an awesome weapon that is, gets Arugal, then the Scythe, to Grizzly Hills.
I always thought it was about this time, left unchecked in the absence of the Scythe (or their master), that the Worgen invaded Gilnaeas and begins the starting area.
Now either the real scythe never made it to Grizzly Hills, or after we stop Arugal again one of the trappers decides to play with it where they knew Arugal learned and returned with it. Chances are that either way, he didn't live long, and the continued assault on Gilnaeas resulted in the Scythe migrating south with it.
Al May 16th 2011 2:05AM
I'm starting to think it's not so much a scythe as it is a boomerang. It got thrown from Duskwood to Gilneas, Gilneas to Grizzly Hills, back to Duskwood and then to Gilneas again.
Since both would be a glorified stick, no wonder the dog-men chase it around.
(I'm going with 'Velinde got lost in the Dream' as well. Going to Booty Bay via Ratchet to get to Silverpine? A non-directionally challenged person would have taken the Auberdine-Menethil boat.)
Al May 15th 2011 4:03PM
We've got a six retcon pile-up on the Lore Highway!
With the 'summoning Worgen back from the Dream' part, doesn't going to the Emerald Dream require sleeping? Wouldn't they have returned to some barrow in Kalimdor?
My head's starting to hurt, so I should probably just go with it.
MusedMoose May 15th 2011 4:14PM
I'm not sure. I know that you can have your physical body in Azeroth while your mind is in the Emerald Dream, but I also know it's possible to go physically into the Emerald Dream, no sleep necessary. As PCs, we do that in two quests I can think of, probably more. So if the worgen were physically put into the Dream, then it'd be possible to get them out the same way.
squig_masta May 15th 2011 4:59PM
I think there are multiple ways of entering the dream. After all if you could only enter it by meditative sleeping, what's the point of the four portals at all? Also, in that quest in Hyjal where we move Staghelm 'through the dream' we enter it in the deepest part of a burrow and emerge from it on the outside. Malfurion probably made sure they were banished into the dream body and soul so that it'd be less likely they'd just naturally find a way back.
Eridian May 15th 2011 4:06PM
Is there any part of the Velinde quest still in game, or has it been binned...?
Anathemys May 15th 2011 6:48PM
I believe it got scrapped, but don't quote me on that. I kinda skipped over that entire area...
snarkygoldfish May 16th 2011 6:16PM
Quest has been binned, but Velinde's ghost is still there if you head into the worgen-infested cave in Duskwood and click on the dirt mound.
rizz May 15th 2011 4:30PM
The Darkriders may be tied to the Burning Legion by sorts, they could be remnants of first generation death knights created by Gul'dan, who later after the fall of the Old horde join the burning legion( The old horde was created by the legion after all and the Darkriders came from Medivh's Karazhan castle, who by being posses by Sargeras was tied with the legion as well.) To how the Burning Legion may know of the Scythe, it maybe do to the remnants of the lords of the emerald flame who fought against the Worgen and later regrouped with the demons during the third war. If i were the legion, i would try to retrieve something as powerful as the Scythe of Elune to use against the mortals who defeated me.
aerrae May 15th 2011 11:57PM
Each time I hear "Dark Rider" I think of the new DK quest where you get your mount. The seem to match the description, and in this case here, they are under the control of the LK, and it might even help explain the way it was moved to Northrend.
Also, someone above mentioned someone brings it back, Sasha or whatever her name is in Grizzly Hills is there when you kill Arugal. Maybe she takes it and as a human member of the Alliance gets it back to someone, who then tries to take it back to Gilnaeas and its there in time for the wargen starting quests. (going through duskwood)
I really like the articales lately, but I would like to see a TFH soon. Those are the ones i like best.
Biggles May 15th 2011 4:30PM
Who says the scythe is a requirement?
Goldrinn's physical form was killed in the Battle of the Ancients - but we know from Cataclysm quests that his spirit (and those of many of the other ancients) lived on in the Emerald Dream - slowly growing powerful again, powerful enough that you help them return in Cataclysm. He's been out for, what, a couple of thousand years - and is due to emerge (at the time of the most recent events) in the next few years? His spirit is presumably more than powerful enough to influence the waking world.
So who is to say that some of the events compressed into those three years were not the result of the Scythe itself, but rather of Goldrinn's increasing influence in the waking world. Even if the Scythe was required, Goldrinn may be the reason it could disappear and re-appear in different places in such a short period of time. His tooth is part of the Scythe, it is literally *part of him* - in the lore, it's not unreasonable to suggest that he could have effects on it from the Dream.
Blagaah May 16th 2011 5:36PM
Dude, Elune thought the worgen we bad mojo. Why would she help free them?
KLRMNKY May 15th 2011 6:08PM
The problem with the Scythe is that even if evil forces get their hands on it, it's really more of a threat to them than to their enemies.
Sylvanas wanted it to spread the "curse" to humanity according to the starter zone, I figure up until she found out that the worgen were immune to being Forsaken, and then control those worgen to fight for her and the Horde. But as we have seen, the worgen have a mind of their own and will stab in the back everytime.
And honestly, it's only a "curse" until the night elves cure it. The it becomes a blessing. Superpowers, heightened senses, immune to being risen as Forsaken?
Also of note, despite Alpha Prime having such a huge impact on Gilneas, he is never mentioned in-game. They previously had a journal in Beta that explained a lot, but it was taken out.
There are just so many loose ends, dropped plots, that Blizz really needs to go back and figure it out when it comes to the Worgen. Just keeps getting messier and messier.
thebitterfig May 15th 2011 7:07PM
Because it has to be linked into any Worgen-lore discussion: Kelly's WoW, Eh? summary.
http://woweh.com/?p=536