Know Your Lore: The mysterious connection between spirit healers and the Val'kyr

They are about the only thing you're happy to see when you're dead. Beings of ghostly blue, these winged saviors of Azeroth's adventuring masses have been there since the very beginning of WoW, and are the closest thing Azeroth has to angels. They possess the power to bring the dead back to life, when said adventuring masses have had their adventuring cut abruptly short by accidentally pulling one or two more murlocs than they could handle. Gracious and kind, it seems that these beings only exist to help Azeroth's lost find their way back to the world of the living.
You only see the true scope of their power when you're dead, and it's safe to say if you're coherent at the time, you're probably not prepared or happy for what comes next. From quietly resting beneath the earth to a shambling mass of undead material, these ghostly creatures exist to pull the dead back to life -- at a cost. Where once was a whole and complete adventurer, now there is only forsaken; a living corpse with free will, although it's questionable as to how much of that will is actually free.
One brings players back to life; the other curses them with a life of undeath. Is there a connection between the benevolent spirit healers of Azeroth, and their dark doppelgangers, the Val'kyr? It's a question that's been posed to me on more than one occasion, and since we've slogged our way through the order of the Warcraft cosmos, it's one we can take a look at now.

Spirit Healers
The spirit healers of Azeroth aren't technically angels, although they certainly look like they could be. But there have been references to angels scattered here and there throughout Warcraft's history, from the manual of Warcraft: Orcs and Humans which mentions "archangels," all the way through Warcraft III where paladins resurrecting allies appeared to summon a ghostly, winged being of light. In addition, there are depictions of angels here and there within World of Warcraft -- the ceilings of the opera house in Karazhan depict "baby angels", and the ceilings at the bottom of Wyrmrest Temple feature winged women that also look like slightly more human versions of the spirit healers we see when we're dead.
Generally speaking however, Warcraft has been very careful with any religious references, keeping them to a bare minimum. The spirit healers of Azeroth may appear to be angels, but typically, angels in religious history don't resurrect they dead, they are what the dead become when they have lived a "holy" life. In Azeroth, the spirits of the dead remain as spirits, or move on to parts unknown.
In relation to the Warcraft cosmos, spirit healers exist on the spirit plane. This plane overlaps Azeroth, but lies separate from the mortal world. Speculation suggests that the spirit world and the Twisting Nether are one and the same, but since the spirit healers of Azeroth have remained unharmed by any agents of the Burning Legion, and the Legion makes their home in the Twisting Nether, we can safely assume it's not.

In Azshara, the blue dragon Azuregos has mysteriously gone missing. Over the course of an incredibly entertaining quest line, players finally manage to track him down. Azuregos hasn't just disappeared -- he's hiding in the spirit plane.
Although it's a cheeky sort of side quest, Anara does indeed seem to care for the blue dragon -- implying that the angelic residents of the spirit plane do actually feel, have lives, and do things when there aren't dead players around waiting to be revived. However, spirit healers are apparently unable to leave the spirit plane, so whatever these exploits may be, they remain unobserved.Azuregos: I've met someone.
Met someone? I didn't know there were any other dragons out here.
Azuregos: A dragon? Hah! Don't be ridiculous. You know, you're awfully rude. She's standing right here!
...the spirit healer?
Azuregos: She has a name, you know. Anara. You'd do well to treat her with the respect she deserves. How many times have she and her sisters brought you back from the grip of death itself? You're just all kinds of inconsiderate, aren't you?
I'm sorry, I didn't mean to be rude, I just...
Azuregos: I know. I KNOW. We could never be, right? Dragon and Spirit Healer... two different worlds! Not to mention the physiological problems. But you're wrong. We have a deeper connection than that. Anara and I, we're involved.

Val'kyr
On the other side of the equation, we have the val'kyr. Originally servants of the Lich King, these dark, winged beings also possessed the power to bring life back to the dead -- but at a cost. Those returned to life were no longer really "alive"; they were undead servants of the Lich King's army. The val'kyr watched over these servants -- death knights -- and if they fell in battle, the val'kyr would return them to their unlife.
The val'kyr are a creation of the Lich King. They were created from the female vrykul of Valkyrion, who fought and trained to receive the Lich King's unusual "gift." Those that were deemed worthy underwent the transformation from simple vrykul to val'kyr. But it's the purpose of the val'kyr that is a little muddled. It is said that the val'kyr serve to judge the fate of vrykul combatants, transforming the favored contestants to ymirjar, and the failed contestants to the ranks of the undead vargul.
Beyond this, the val'kyr also watched the fates of the training death knights of Acherus, making sure the newly born warriors didn't fall in battle before their time. In fact, these val'kyr were acting much like spirit healers -- the spirit healers of the undead. Which leads us to an interesting quest, and an interesting question. Alliance players first traveling to Howling Fjord find an Alliance encampment under attack by vrykul, and a draenei shaman named Thoralius the Wise, who sends Alliance players off to discover a secret -- a secret held within the spirit plane.
The spirit world has fallen under the sway of the Lich King. Fearsome creatures made of pure nightmare now stand watch over the realm of the elements. I sense that these val'kyr are guarding a terrible secret. I am too old and weak to survive another journey. You must go in my place. Take this incense burner to Wyrmskull Village and use it to enter the spirit world. Find the large dwelling in the northeast! Avoid the val'kyr at all costs lest they make you a permanent fixture in their world.
The Lich King turns to face you.Now here's the question in all of this: Players that complete the quest and avoid getting too close to the Lich King uncover the first signs of the true origins of human evolution on Azeroth. ...Why is the Lich King hiding this? Why are the val'kyr so concentrated in that particular corner of the spirit world, and why is the Lich King sitting there waiting for you? What's so important about this particular piece of information that the Lich King would want to guard it and keep people from finding it out?
The Lich King grins.
The Lich King says: Shamanism has brought you here... Its scent permeates the air. I was once a shaman.
Val'kyr Soulclaimer says: Shall we prepare it for you, my lord?
The Lich King says: No, minion. This one is not ready.
The Lich King says: Do you feel it, mortal? Death seeps through me, enveloping all that I touch. With just a snap of my finger your soul will languish in damnation for all eternity.
The Lich King says: But... It is not yet your time to serve the Lich King. Yes, a greater destiny awaits you. Power... You must become more powerful before you are to serve me.
The Lich King says: Now watch, val'kyr. Observe as I apply pressure. Can you see that it is not yet ripe? Watch as it pops and falls lifeless to the floor.
With the death of the Lich King in Wrath, it is doubtful we will ever see an answer to that question. With the Lich King's death, the val'kyr had no one to rule over them, to tell them what to do. They had nobody to serve. And so, the val'kyr turned to the one person who would have a use for their unique talents -- Sylvanas Windrunner, Banshee Queen of the Forsaken.
Sylvanas was left in a dilemma after the death of the Lich King as well -- her unlife devoted to seeking out vengeance against the being that had created her. Once that vengeance was complete, Sylvanas was left with the unsettling decision of what to do next -- both for herself, and for her people. The forsaken had one major flaw working against them; they could not reproduce. The Lich King was the one who created the Scourge, and now that the Lich King was gone, there were no Scourge left to turn to forsaken.
Somewhere in all of this, Sylvanas encountered the val'kyr, her salvation and solution to her dilemma. Since the val'kyr could raise the undead, they were essentially the key to keeping the forsaken "alive" as a viable race. With the val'kyr, new forsaken could continue to be created. With the val'kyr, the forsaken would continue to thrive. And so Sylvanas made a pact with the val'kyr of Northrend, promising them something in return for what they did for her -- continue to populate her motley race of living dead.
The terms and agreements of that pact are an unknown at this point, but we do know this: as a result of the pact, the val'kyr will gladly give their lives to keep Sylvanas alive -- well, as alive as a walking corpse can be considered. This implies that the val'kyr were promised something important; it would have to be important in order to warrant that kind of sacrifice. Whether or not we'll see more of this peculiar pact and the val'kyr of the forsaken in Cataclysm is unclear at this point.

The connection
So let's look at the similarities between these two races and see what kind of conclusions we can draw, shall we?
- Both val'kyr and spirit healers possess the ability to ressurect the dead. In the case of spirit healers, the dead are returned to life, in the case of the val'kyr, those raised are undead.
- Both val'kyr and spirit healers exist on the spirit plane, this much was shown in Wrymskull Village. In fact, Thoralius points out that "the spirit world has fallen under the sway of the Lich King", implying the val'kyr presence there is some sort of attack on that plane of existence.
- Both val'kyr and spirit healers possess wings and an ethereal glow, reminiscent of angels referenced in real life religion. While spirit healers seem to remain stationary for the most part, the val'kyr are free to move around at will.
The only tenuous connection that could be argued is that the val'kyr appear to be acting as spirit healers for the Lich King. The Lich King and those that follow him are not, apparently, the sort of creatures spirit healers care to deal with on a regular basis. So if there's any tie between the two, it's simply that -- the two creatures share the same task, but for different purposes. The val'kyr worked for the Lich King, and now they work for Sylvanas -- the spirit healers don't appear to be working "for" anyone at all.
If we wanted to step out on a very, very thin limb and go back to the tinfoil hat theory that the Lich King is a walking plane of existence, we could make the case that as a walking plane of existence, the Lich King required spirit healers to ressurect the denizens of its realm. Thus, the val'kyr -- created specifically to fulfill that purpose for the Lich King's plane. Except for the fact that the val'kyr don't really seem to exist in the spirit realm all that often, choosing instead to carry out their duties in the Material plane.
Unfortunately, for those intrepid tin foil hat wearing lore enthusiasts out there searching for a missing link between the val'kyr and the spirit healers, there isn't really a logical leap to make. The brief, somewhat tongue-in-cheek reference to a spirit healer's capacity for love doesn't really reveal much about the elusive spirit healers of Azeroth. As for the val'kyr and their ultimate purpose behind teaming up with the forsaken ... well, we'll just have to wait and see.
For more information on related subjects, please look at these other Know Your Lore entries:
- The Warcraft cosmos part one: The Material Plane
- The Warcraft cosmos part two: Multi-dimensionality
- The Warcraft cosmos: Tinfoil Hat edition
- Sylvanas Windrunner, part one and part two
- The Lich King
While you don't need to have played the previous Warcraft games to enjoy World of Warcraft, a little history goes a long way toward making the game a lot more fun. Dig into even more of the lore and history behind the World of Warcraft in WoW Insider's Guide to Warcraft Lore.
Filed under: Lore, Know your Lore
Patch 5.3 interview with Ghostcrawler
Mystery of the Unborn Val'kyr
The latest patch 5.3 news
All of the latest Mists of Pandaria news





Reader Comments (Page 4 of 5)
Nyarlahothep Jun 19th 2011 8:57PM
I think it's pretty clear that the omission of diefic origination implies the lack of gods as we normally think of them. The closest we get are entities like Elune, who while called a "goddess" is more likely just a powerful and benevolent creature (like a naaru). While it is likely that spirit healers are just trappings for a gameplay mechanic, it's fun to think of them otherwise. Besides, any unanswered question is potentially new lore in waiting. I prefer to think that blizzard makes these gameplay choices thoughtfully, or at least build on pleasant accidents.
Mal Jun 19th 2011 9:08PM
WTB vrykul as playable race to give them a excuse to solve this.
Jennifer Jun 19th 2011 11:11PM
There is one very large difference between Spirit Healers and Val'kyr, and it's stated right in the story: Spirit Healers resurrect on the spirit plane, Val'kyr resurrect on the Material plane.
This leads one to wonder if a Spirit Healer resurrecting on the Material plane would resurrect an undead, instead of a living person. Perhaps that's the major difference - Val'kyr are willing (or able) to travel to the Material Plane, thus creating undead out of dead people. Spirit Healers remain on the spirit plane - perhaps because, from there they can resurrect dead into living.
More of a philosophical difference - there is nothing to show Spirit Healers cannot travel to the material plane - perhaps they simply choose not to. Kind of like how everyone CAN be evil, but only some choose to.
Salubrious Jun 20th 2011 12:34AM
Maybe I'm alone on this, but I thought that when the Lich King invaded the spirit world, it was so that he could corrupt the spirit healers by fusing them with the female vrykul, thus creating the val'kyr, creatures that exist on both the spiritual and material planes. Of course, this is just my tin-foil hat idea, but it makes sense to me.
Tropxe Jun 20th 2011 2:29AM
@Ronin: "Sorry, but your pet theories don't carry the force of fact. "
I can't believe you actually said that while trying to defend a religion.
Zetsubou Jun 20th 2011 3:13AM
what about that spirit healer that was (before cataclysm at least. idk if shes gone.) visible in the material plane in the barrens? was there ever any explanation for her?
ot: if the lich king did warp something to create valkyr, it would probably have to be the spirit healers, though they don't seem to be targeted or anything in northrend. as far as valkyr revival causing undeath, that's a shaky arguement, at least gameplay-wise. dks aren't considered "undead", everyone including forsaken and dks are revived by spirit healers to a "living" state, and even dks undead powers now cause "living" resurrection. lore-wise there is probably more restrictions, but eh, its a hassle to stick to that ingame.
Balgus Jun 20th 2011 5:02AM
Haven't read the comments so I don't know if anyone has mentioned this, but Val'kyr HAVE brought people to life without them being forsaken. Just look at the DK starting area. I suggest that they have the ability to bring people back just like the spirit healers, but do not on Sylvanas's orders.
Bulbasaur Jun 20th 2011 6:21AM
People brought back from valkyrs powers are brought back as undead, being forsaken or deathknights or scourge, all of 3 are undead.
Bulbasaur Jun 20th 2011 6:22AM
Question: Sylvannas use valkyrs to create new undead people without any sort of mental control, so she is creating forsaken people. Right. But right now, who is creating new death knights? They were created by the Lich King itself, with now Lich King around doing undead things, that means there are not any new dk?
Nagaina Jun 20th 2011 10:19AM
I believe the Lore generally assumes that all extant death knights were "made" before the destruction of the Lich King (which is to say, Arthas). Bolvar hasn't made any -- and probably doesn't have any interest in making any, given that he's dedicated to *containing* rather than expanding the Scourge/undead menace.
Which is not to say that Sylvanas wouldn't be *extremely interested* in making her own death knights -- or subverting those that already exist, see: Deathweaver, Koltira, why it sucks to be him. See also: inevitable conflict between the Ebon Blade and the Forsaken war machine.
Koleckai Jun 20th 2011 7:33AM
Is this a tinfoil hat addition? Blizzard has stated in the past that Spirit Healers are a game mechanic with no lore basis.
REDMJOEL Jun 20th 2011 2:34PM
That may have been true previously; however, by including them in a quest (see Ashenvale) they have been inserted into the lore.
Koleckai Jun 20th 2011 2:36PM
Not really. One quest doesn't make Lore. There is a quest in Shattrath which is simply a memorial to an individual. It doesn't add that person the Lore of Azeroth. Lore is a much broader thing that should stand up to history. I do realize that Blizzard has made several retconns but including basic game mechanics in Lore isn't really one of them. I'll just have to agree to disagree with this one.
furry Jun 20th 2011 8:14AM
Do Spirit Healers have any part in the process of when a priest or a paladin (or maybe even druids and shaman) resurrect their allies? What about for the Mass Resurrection process?
mrespman Jun 20th 2011 8:26AM
What about the Holy priest talent that transforms them into a spirit healer skinned mob? Perhaps the current spirit healers are just people that have come before and are trying to atone for something. They failed in their quest and were made into the spirit healers, and perhaps they are stuck until they feel they've atoned?
Chad Jun 20th 2011 9:09AM
Anne or Matt, PLEASE create a RACIAL ORIGINATION FLOWCHART for the warcraft universe and who created/changed them. This is a fairly large undertaking given the number of races. It would be a good reference for SOOO much of the discussion that goes on and given the number of races, probably fairly changing as new information came out.
Also, who created the Draenei? They were happy on their own planet, but I don't remember anything about where they came from. Are they original, like the Trolls and Tauren? Again, Draenei lore is scant.
Nardash Jun 20th 2011 10:55AM
Maybe the Vrykul are the Lich Kings way to gain power in the spirit world. They might be there to displace the spirit healers, but perform their task in a corrupted way.
Owlbear Jun 20th 2011 12:09PM
Sorry if this has mentioned before, but I couldn't be bothered reading all the comments, downvote if it's been said before.
I think the biggest difference between the spirit healers and the Val'Kyr is that you, as a hero destined to combat the dangers that threathen Azeroth have to actually go to a spirit healer if you wish to continue doing so whereas Val'Kyr are able to forcibly (and this is just speculation) pull your soul from the spirit realm and bind it to your body, using it as some sort of seal to the material world, thus the soul is imprisoned rather than just resurected, enabling the lich king to force his will over it and corrupting it's material form in the process.
I also think this can explain the difficulty of ressurection lore wise, if the body is destroyed too much the soul has nothing to return to. Undead however are forced regardless of their own will and thus the state of the body (skeletons, regular undead and abominations for example) doesn't matter and is animated by the soul of that person through unnatural means, be it arcane or something else.
I also hope to hear from the Lich King again one way or another in the future, seeing how he isn't dead.
nlamio7 Jun 21st 2011 3:30PM
About the hearing from Lich King again, didn't Arthas have the Lich King "in" him for a while before It took over the entity making them One?
Yes Arthas did do some nasty things which may have hastened the change in progress, but what says that Bolvar can keep his sanity against the whispers of LK/Ner'zhul, if Ner is to wake up again and seek for revenge agaist everyone who killed him again.. for the x'th time.
Imo there hasn't been a real closure to the whole LK case, but the new Death itself risen from another plane sort of made us forget the whole Frozen Throne, for now. Inside it is already melting, with Ner'zhuls hatred and Bolvars body wrapped together with draconic fire..
josh Jun 20th 2011 12:53PM
a few things...
not all spirit healers are like the ones you described. taunka spirit healers don't have wings. they're just taunka who are spirit healers. you didn't include those guys.
can dead val'kyr be resurrected by alive val'kyr? if yes, then their "sacrifice" to keep sylvanas alive is meaningless.
and since lich king was also a shaman by way of ner'zul, why didn't the earthen ring try and take him out too?