Know Your Lore: The shu'halo

We talked about their origins last week (although that was primarily speculation), and we've talked about their politics and how they fit within the Horde. We've discussed Cairne and his son Baine, the great leaders of their people, and Magatha, the greatest living villain. But what of the shu'halo, the tauren people themselves? Who are they?
The tauren today are in a very unusual position. They revere the Earthmother and yet are allied to people who stripmine her very flesh to plunder her resources, chop down her forests, and poison her creatures with plague. Former nomads, harried by enemies, they now reside in their ancestral homeland due to those same alliances. The Horde gave them much and now asks for much. For the tauren, the shu'halo, the debt owed when Thrall and his people helped them reach their promised land has never faded. But who were they before it?
The ancient past
The tauren people are unlike the other races who have shared Azeroth with them. Their origins are as yet unknown. They themselves believe that they are the direct children of the Earthmother, born from her body by the shadow of her hands, and they need no other explanation. The tauren tell many myths about their history, the myths dealing with the reason the sun and moon orbit the world, the shu'halo's great prowess as hunters and how it led to the birth of Cenarius, and how the monsters known as centaurs drove them from their home. We do not and cannot know at this time how much truth there is in these myths, but they do teach us that the oral historians of the shu'halo were working to explain the world and the tauren place in it. However, one thing is certain. Unlike the trolls and the kaldorei, the tauren established no empires. They conquered no lands.
Tauren numbers have never been great. Despite their vast size, strength, and aptitude for certain kinds of magic, the tauren simply have never desired to swamp the lands under their weight. Whether or not there's any truth to the idea that the tauren helped cause the birth of Cenarius, it seems clear that the forest god did indeed know of them and teach them at some time before the coming of Malfurion (even if we distrust Xarantaur the Witness, who claims exactly this).
We know this because of the time meddler Krasus, who reached out to the tauren when he found himself completely stomping all over history. Clearly, the tauren had to exist before the War of the Ancients if only because they participated in it, even if they only did so because a dragon from the future asked them to. Huln Highmountain was the tauren representative in the War of the Ancients, and he and his people proved to be valiant warriors in that long ago conflict.
Deliberate forgetting and the rage of centaurs
However, one way or another, despite keeping to their ancient ways, keeping the elements and the Earthmother sacred, the tauren lost the druid arts. Unlike the night elves, who worshipped Elune the mother of Cenarius and who had Cenarius' student Malfurion and his allies to thank for preserving what of their society survived the sundering, the tauren retreated back to their nomadic ways.
Furthermore, as Hatred of the Centaur states, the centaur began their pogrom against the tauren after the sundering. We have no idea exactly when, but it would have had to be after Cenarius' son Zaetar sired the centaur with Princess Theradras and was slain by them in turn. The centaur exploded out of their holy site of Maraudon, the former prison of Theradras that she turned into a shrine to Zaetar, and made war on the tauren.
Why did the centaur so hate the shu'halo? Well, in part it's purely because the centaur hate everything. Remember, the first five Khans of the centaur killed their own father, a keeper of the grove and a son of a demigod, as soon as they were able. Furthermore, both the centaur and the tauren were nomadic at that time, so it's not hard to expect conflict between two such powerful races who seek a similar lifestyle, even if the centaur tend to despoil and move on while the tauren revere the land and its natural balance.
However, the Cenarius -- Zaetar -- centaur lineage helps explain not only why the centaur hate the tauren so much (since the tauren claim to have created Cenarius, they can therefore claim to have created the centaur as well) but why the tauren would come to lose the druid arts while battling the relentless, fecund and avaricious centaur. Harried from place to place by Cenarius' descendants, the arts he taught could fall out of favor due in part to necessity and also due to bias. You too might reject someone's teachings if his children were trying to kill you.
The edge of death and the new hope
The tauren spent thousands of years passing on their traditions while warring constantly with centaur tribes. Tauren warriors and hunters and their shaman leaders were wise and brave and kept the Earthmother in their hearts, but their enemies were just as fierce, could move faster than they could, and were far faster breeders, since they had no qualms about despoiling an area and moving on and thus did not try to live in balance.
It was a slow, lingering death against an unworthy adversary, a twisted mockery of a being the tauren knew as the Forestlord, monsters that mocked everything the shu'halo believed in. It was the death of their way of life, their beliefs, and their people. And the Horde under Thrall stopped it.
Cairne and Thrall became allies and friends -- so close that Cairne even led the shu'halo into battle alongside the orcs, led them to Stonetalon to help Thrall save Grom Hellscream. After the Blood Curse was lifted, the shu'halo stood alongside the orcs, the night elves (once again allied to battle the Burning Legion), and the strange pink people from across the sea named humans. Thrall and his Horde helped Cairne free his people from the long, slow death at the hooves and spears of the centaur. In so doing, they earned the shu'halo's respect and cemented their willingness to be part of Thrall's Horde. In time, Thrall and Cairne became as brothers, and the tauren stood beside the Horde when more of the pink people from across the sea attempted to take Durotar from the orcs and trolls.
To endure the future
The death of Cairne, the betrayal of Magatha and the Grimtotem, and the coming of Baine to leadership of the shu'halo has not changed the essential fact that the tauren were likely going to die without the Horde. Thrall's leaving the Horde to become the World Shaman is not a decision shu'halo would question. If the elements call him, how can he not answer? It is a decision that tauren can understand.
Likewise, while Garrosh Hellscream is young and headstrong, he is also a strong warrior who won the mak'gora (the treachery that slew Cairne was not Hellscream's doing, as galling as it was), and so the shu'halo have no reason to break the ties of friendship with their green brothers and sisters. The tauren do not forget a debt, and the Horde saved them from their great enemies and helped them start fresh in Mulgore.
In many ways, the shu'halo have become the heart of the modern Horde. Furthermore, the shu'halo's desire to balance out the aggression and (to their eyes) bad choices of their Horde allies has led them to seek balance within themselves as well. While they have reclaimed the druid arts they lost (thanks to the friendship between Hamuul Runetotem and Malfurion Stormrage), that wasn't enough for them. They have also sought out the magic of the sun, An'she, and have created new paths for their people using that light. Tauren are nothing if not obedient to the Earthmother and willing to seek balance in her name.
Next week, we continue our look at the shu'halo by looking at the tauren who walked up to Malfurion himself and asked to be taught. Today, with Cairne dead, Hamuul Runetotem is the eldest of all tauren elders. He has seen his people transform from nomads to settlement in Thunder Bluff; he has helped fight the Burning Legion and the fury of the elementals on the slopes of Mount Hyjal itself. He has much to teach us.
While you don't need to have played the previous Warcraft games to enjoy World of Warcraft, a little history goes a long way toward making the game a lot more fun. Dig into even more of the lore and history behind the World of Warcraft in WoW Insider's Guide to Warcraft Lore.
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Lore, Know your Lore
Patch 5.4 patch notes
Virtual Realms feature revealed
The Proving Grounds are coming
The latest patch 5.4 news





Reader Comments (Page 3 of 3)
Artificial Jul 6th 2011 6:17PM
Presumably Tyrande, Malfurion, and crew have better things to do than stand around all day answering trivia questions.
Also, this should *add* to the confusion, not clear it up. If you don't believe me, ask a few different people at an accident scene what happened. Ask a few hundred people who lived through historical events what *really* happened.
Presumably powerful shamans capable of seeing what happened many thousands of years ago generally have better things to do, too. As well as people who can see the future. You mention such arcane rituals exist, and indeed they do, but we know they're not commonplace or there would be no such thing as a surprise attack in WoW. There would be no point in using stealth if everyone had true-sight. Etc. There are all kinds of magic that negate some of the ways things are hidden, whether by time, stealth, or magic, but they can't be universal without destroying the setting.
It would also contradict the lore, since it's established lore that stealth exists, despite the fact that magic exists to counter it, surprise attacks exist, despite the fact that magic exists to see the future, and questions about the past exist, despite the fact that magic exists to see the past. We know these things exist, but we also know they are *not* commonplace or easy.
Artificial Jul 6th 2011 6:31PM
It also should be noted that the people in question aren't omniscient, no matter how old they are. Suppose you ask Malfurion, "Who was the first druid?" and he answers. Let's further assume he's not lying. What does this prove? It proves nothing more than that Malfurion is unaware of any druids prior to whoever he names in his answer. Alas, it doesn't tell you who the first druid actually was, it just tells you the oldest one Malfurion knows about. This may be quite interesting, but it proves nothing. His answer may or may not reflect the reality of who the first druid actually was.
History is never easy. Having people you can ask helps, unless you take their answers too seriously, in which case it actually hurts.
Omacron Jul 6th 2011 7:05PM
You don't use simply one source when asking people about history. You interview malfurion, but you also interview Zaetar and if you can, you interview Cenarius. Plus, Tyrande, Malfurion and the like were not the only people around during the WotA. In fact, it's more likely that noncombatants survived into the modern age, too. It's less hazardous to your health to be a gardener or an auctioneer than it is to be a glaive-slinging huntress.
Plus, let's look at the societies most likely to put together history textbooks: Dalaran, Quel'thalas, Stormwind, maybe even Undermine. All of these have powerful mages and a few even have powerful shaman. It's not at all unlikely to believe a publisher could get a few of these guys together and gain a consensus on history by getting a bunch to scry for them.
chrissaunders Jul 6th 2011 4:27PM
Garrosh? Young?
He's older than Thrall...isn't he in his 30s or 40s?
Yrmes Jul 6th 2011 5:08PM
Yeah, but Mag'har have longer lives than Orcs, I'd always imagined. By that standard Garrosh is still a young man, Granted, he's probably the equivalent of a 30 something man leading a small construction workforce (in behavior and attitude) but Thrall's life is much more stressful as are most Azeroth Orcs. By that standard Thrall is much more mature and wizened, leading to the idea that Garrosh is a pup.
Ilmyrn Jul 6th 2011 5:36PM
That's actually something I wish Blizzard would have played up through Wrath. Garrosh acts like a brash young guy and Thrall treats (or used to) him like one so much that I and, I assume, most other players assumed he WAS younger than Thrall.
Imagine then, how much more it had to gall Garrosh to not only have this green orc raised by humans telling him what to do, but for this upstart to be significantly YOUNGER than him to boot!
cyanea85 Jul 6th 2011 4:55PM
Tauren are, without a doubt, my favorite species in the game.
I still am uncomfortable looking at my Draenei Shammy when I faction changed her along with the rest of my guild. I miss the deepthroated, three-pack a day laugh she used to do.
Matthew Jul 6th 2011 5:48PM
At least you're a female dranei shaman. The males are just too weird.
hillbillyrod Jul 6th 2011 5:12PM
Where this tauren loremaster is concerned, the shu'halo; has been payed back a thousand fold. We need to eradicate the very disease of the horde from the earth. LK was breaking the back of us taurens being horde, cata broke and smashed the back. There is no concieveable reason why we are still allied with the orcs, and especially goblin, undead and b.elf. They all destroy, not just some but alot.
I can see where bliz was going with tauren. But the story going along and the changes, do not match the tauren from 5 or 10 years ago. We are the same people the horde is not the same. No tauren would sit back in the homeland and allow every land around the world to be destroyed.
Tauren should either leave and become neutral, or become alliance. Atleast the alliance isn't strip mining/clear cutting/mutation experienmentation every land there presence is. Maybe it's time we joined the Guardians. Atleast we wouldn't be raping the land. Tauren lore now is laughable, and that's sad because we had the best around up to LK.
Murdertime Jul 6th 2011 7:35PM
You mean the Tauren should leave the people with the exact same culture and outlook, from the shamanic belief system to the fairly martial outlook, as them, who've finally let them thrive once and who even Garrosh treats with the utmost respect and join the Alliance who...er...um...
...
I mean, I'm sure there's something the Tauren have in common with the Alliance races?
I mean, there's the Nelfs who ignored them and left them to be wiped out despite gladly accepting military aid in the past? The Dwarves who are digging up Tauren land? The humans who burnt down their settlements, are currently bombarding them with giant spears and who they're locked in a brutal guriella war against in the Barrens? The Gnomes who are gnomes?
vocenoctum Jul 6th 2011 7:57PM
It's an odd thought that occured to me during this article, I guess. I can see the duality of orcs, part nutjob warriors, part shamanic nomads...
So, we have shamanic orcs, idealized by thrall, with trolls and tauren.
Then we have warrior orcs, idealized by garrosh, with forsaken and goblins, mercenary, plundering...
(Okay, blood elves I can't say, they don't have a "place" after BC...)
But the "two hordes" don't really fit each other, only the orcs unify them, and I wonder if the orcs are unified themselves.
Murdertime Jul 6th 2011 8:33PM
Keep in mind the Tauren aren't exactly gentle and cuddly. They're big into the Hunter Culture Blood And Honor thing as well, ala Garrosh.
In fact, given his upbringing, Garrosh, being a Mag'har probably has more culturally in common with the Tauren than Thrall does.
hillbillyrod Jul 6th 2011 9:52PM
If the horde and Garrosh treats us the utmost respect, they wouldn't be trashing everything. Outside of Mulgore, it a mess. How can we stand by when they are cutting down the forest of felwood, when we have been purifying it. Azshara, Ashenvale, same thing. Other than a small spot of Desolace, everything the horde touches is destroyed. And I'm not even going to talk about the undead. They should be destroyed, and undercity buried after being burned, blowed up, and defecated on. If the playing tauren in the game were Grimtotem tribe, then I could let it slide. There are a quest where they ally with alliance. They are more the battle harden tauren that should be the horde.
I've finished the new content in the zones on my tauren and it's as a tauren sick. No way would there be any tauren that would do some of the quests for the undead, and b.elf. Orc quests mostly are more of a honor aspect. And tauren just reinforces the old style of life. And I'm almost finished with the alliance side, and there are a less tauren/destroy the earth quests now. And there are more taurens giving quests than n.elfs in the horde quests.
I agree there are a section of orcs that go well with taurens. But that is a very small group. Taurens are a race that give when they take. There is a balance. And the only reason the rest of the orcs associate with us is that we have honor. Love of battle only when honor is present. There isn't a bloodlust without honor.
I know we stay horde because of balance in the game. But LK and especially Cata has blurred that line so much, the line is almost gone. And from what I have done in fireland. It's almost nonexistent. Lore is lacking now, and it's sad. Because our lore was the best in the game.
Thomas Higgins Jul 7th 2011 1:31AM
I have no doubt at all that at some future date in the game the Horde are going to lose two races.
First, the Forsaken, as their Bitch Queen will piss off Garrosh Hellscream (ow, first time I used his real name in ages, feels dirty) so much that even that dense, blind, stupid idiot masquerading as the Warchief of a faction I once loved, will end up declaring war on them.
Second, the Tauren. The Goblins, being Goblins, will drive them to the point of open warfare with the result that Garrosh will end up kicking them out as well.
But, hey, you are going to get the Ogres and Ethereals as replacements, so what are you complaining about, 8-)
Ouroboros Jul 6th 2011 6:37PM
Hasn't it been allready settled that: the tauren believe they were the first druids, but the night elves were actually first? by a blue post some time ago? If yes...then, all fun speculation aside, why is this still a point of contention it this lore article? If the point is; that Blizzard have a less than rigorous approach to lore...then so what? Their word is law, and even if it doesn't make sense or can be argued against, don't we have to take it as law?
Mahram Jul 6th 2011 8:10PM
@Ilmyrn: Grain of salt? You mean to tell me that some enterprising mage wouldn't offer teleportation services to anyone willing to pay? I find it hard to believe there wouldn't be at least a few. And any news or mail/deliver service would be completely moronic not to employ said teleportation service not to be at the forefront of breaking news / quick delivery. I don't think it's very far fetched at all. As to types of information - sure, not everything is shared, but there is gossip, there is rumor, there are blabbermouths, etc.
Blayze Jul 6th 2011 8:19PM
I always wondered if part of the reason the centaur have been hounding the tauren is because the tauren may have ties to Terramok we don't know of yet--and the Tinfoil Hat theory that they're former guardians of Azeroth just like the humans got me thinking about the subject a bit more.
adam Jul 6th 2011 9:09PM
another wonderful KYL cant wait til the next installment