Safe Passage: There and back again

One year later, and I'm back where I started. To this day, I still can't believe that after my flagship comic, Byron, the Tauren Rogue, I was given the green light for another comic series. Safe Passage was actually one of the two ideas that I originally approached WoW Insider for, but I settled on Byron for my own reasons.
Byron was immensely helpful in more ways than one. If you remember my postmortem from last time, it was essentially my training wheels, a way for me to get a feel for the processes, along with my own strengths (and weaknesses) in comic creation. The first and most important thing I had to do was to get a writer. My guild leader once again agreed to help me flesh out the story from the beginning, so I hope the story was more consistent this time around.
Safe Passage began when I first heard of the post-Cataclysm Camp Taurajo quest lines. I actually hadn't done the quests when I wrote this; I hadn't gotten into the beta, so I went purely on research. If you know of my other work, then you know I have a soft spot for our large, bovine friends, and I thought that the Taurajo situation in Cataclysm was the perfect level of ambiguity to make an interesting story.
Enarrai was another of Ktok's brilliant ideas. The original synopsis for Safe Passage was:
Two Horde soldiers (preferably not Tauren) find two Alliance children in The Barrens and try to escort them back home. The situation at Camp Taurajo has ignited hostilities for both factions, but caring for these two innocent girls will provide grounds for negotiation.
Or something like that.
Developing characters
Early in the story, Ktok suggested we put a mature face on the side of the Alliance, and Enarrai was born. Instead of this dark, mature story being told by two young children, the Alliance now had a smart, sharp and tenacious night elf hunter who would lend her own adult perspective. Personally, I think she was a great addition to the story, although I wish I could have used her owl a bit more ...
Ash'gor and Mig'ai were quite challenging. I don't think Mig got as much screen time as I would've liked, and I felt that Ash got a bit, well, neutered, ability-wise. He's obviously no High Overlord Saurfang, but if his apathy was due to either protecting the girls or he just didn't care anymore, then I didn't convey that well enough.
I won't lie when I say that I took great delight in portraying the girls, Lisaara and Brynne. The children were actually the first characters to be designed, Brynne especially. I wanted a blond human girl who idolized her father. She wears oversized work boots and is constantly a mess, all because she enjoyed adventuring much more than being a boring lady. Lisaara was also designed to be a quite, timid shaman from the very beginning, although I think her shyness severely inhibited her growth in the story. Brynne is so powerful that she practically speaks for the both of them, and I wish I had balanced it out a little more.
Art-wise, I'm quite pleased with this series. I was worried that my "shojou flower shop" (as one commenter called it) would put a lot of people off, but I was pleasantly surprised when people responded well to it. This is the first comic where I used screen tones, so I still have a very long way to go. While Safe Passage is a human interest story about war, death, loss, and prejudice, I felt that showing the softer side of the two Horde members was very important. I probably did go a little overboard on some of those flower scenes, though.
The view from both sides
The most important thing I wanted to talk about was the Horde versus Alliance in this story. As a storyteller, I tried my best to see this from both sides. Yes, I play Horde exclusively, but that doesn't mean I hate the Alliance. I did a ton of research into General Hawthorne and what he had to go through to execute the attack. In a character-driven game like World of Warcraft, it's nearly impossible to label any large faction as the good guys or the bad guys, because there are plenty on both sides. At the end of the day, the Horde and the Alliance are at war. Things like old hostilities, language barriers, misinformation and rumors would add to the flames of anger. A single, relatively unimportant Horde solider would have heard the (exaggerated) rumors and maybe only seen the charred ruins being sifted through by human looters. Alliance soldiers may have heard that Hawthorne was a great man, but another jealous lieutenant may have said otherwise.
I realize that the characters may have had skewed opinions, but only because they themselves only know so much. I don't write and draw stories like this for my own biases and opinions but to tell a story, regardless of how uncomfortable it makes people. Ash and Mig were one side, and Enarrai, Brynne and Lisaara were the other. Having them come together for a common goal, while not much, is a simple gesture of peace, and in the tumultuous months after the cataclysm, I think a few would welcome the reprieve.
Next week will mark a short prologue story with the mysterious (and now late) adoptive father of the two young girls. After that, well ... I won't spoil the surprise.
Thank you finally to everyone who read, commented, criticized, loved, and hated this story. I read each and every comment, and appreciate every one. See you all next week!
Filed under: WoW Insider's Weekly Comic






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Darky Aug 16th 2011 4:29PM
You're one of my favourite web comic writers and I'm looking forward to your next instalment on WoWinsider :D.
Neirin Aug 16th 2011 4:31PM
Of all the characters you make, do you have a favorite? I'm torn between Brynne, Byron, and Cadistra.
Cadychan Aug 16th 2011 4:34PM
Oh wow....I really liked Brynne. She was just too much fun. I liked drawing Lisaara though, because draenei are just so -neat- looking!
kodakmsr99 Aug 16th 2011 7:03PM
mmhmm cmon Kelly....admit the truth....It's all about the hooves isn't it? =P
Great comic though. I seriously think companies are crazy for not having hired you by now!
Levielle Aug 16th 2011 4:41PM
I can't wait! I look forward to your comic every week and now have something else to look forward to.
I fully enjoyed the characters and art. So thank you for that.
I was interested in this Dwarf father and hope that the girls make another appearance as well. Are you planning on doing a following comic to this one?
shadcroly Aug 16th 2011 4:48PM
What are the chances we'll ever see Safe Passage and Byron, the Tauren Rogue hosted on WowEh?
Even if they were developed for WoWInsider, and there's nothing wrong with that, the two stories were made by you, so you should be able to host them on your site, right? (Plus, it'd be really nice having them all in one convenient location, since WoWInsider's search function kinda sucks.)
Kunikenwad! Aug 16th 2011 4:49PM
I personally loved Mig, but then again I raid on two shaman and have 4 more in various stages of leveling. So I like shaman. Disproportionately.
Jenjabenja Aug 16th 2011 5:04PM
Looking forward to more great work. I hope we get to see how the 'family' came together. I have been wondering, though, with all the wonky life-spans and growth rates, would cute little Lisaara be quite a bit older than her sister? Thanks again for the comic(s).
Ilmyrn Aug 16th 2011 5:18PM
Not necessarily. There's no real reason to think that an immortal or extremely long-lived species would have an exceptionally long childhood (and quite a few reasons to think they wouldn't). Granted, there are only a few known species in reality that are effectively immortal, but they don't, so far as I know, display a longer span of time before reaching maturity than non-immortal species.
Blank Aug 16th 2011 6:42PM
Yeah, I'm probably just over-thinking things (again), but the issue was touched upon (very) briefly in Rise of The Horde, by Christie Golden, during Durotan and Doomhammer's visit to the draenei city.
fudge Aug 16th 2011 5:08PM
I think your comic needs more Paladins in it. Preferably a human Paladin. Someone like Uther the Lightbringer.
I'd like that.
Ilmyrn Aug 16th 2011 5:20PM
Amen.
Paladin, HOOOOOOOO!
Chetti Aug 16th 2011 5:16PM
Loved this series, can't wait to see whats next. :)
Tirrimas Aug 16th 2011 5:19PM
I loved this series, and eagerly look forward to more. :)
I just did the Horde side of Southern Barrens on my warrior this week, and I must say, I didn't much enjoy it. I was angry when I was sent to assassinate General Hawthorne, and even more angry when the follow up (not for me, thankfully) was to string his corpse up in the tree by the road. While I understood and participated in the necessary evils of the battle to keep the Alliance out of Mulgore, I felt that was a bit much.
Anyway. Not all Hordies are angry battle-driven monsters.
Terrë Aug 16th 2011 6:33PM
I really enjoy your comics and I think that the problems you admitted you had with writing are much improved. I was very fond of your (quite amusing in a dark and cannabalistic way) minor Forsaken character in the Byron series, and would love to see you do something with a Forsaken character a little more in the spotlight in the future.
I don't know if you've played the new Forsaken starting zone, but the black humour behind the quests and comments had me almost crying with laughter, and I think you could do something fantastic, especially with your lovely range of facial expressions and the little touches that I love spotting in the background.
Dreyja Aug 16th 2011 6:53PM
I am going to echo all the Kudos and add that I really appreciate the care you put into trying to tell this story with characters from two sides of a conflict. You are right, no matter my reasons for playing Alliance exclusively in the game, the characters that are submerged in the world would have limited information and a support system that clearly perpetuates the conflict.
That is a sad reality and one that frankly, makes me crazy in the game due to my own un-abashed idealism, but I think you handled it very well. :) I hope that the next will have some Alliance characters we can enjoy as well. However, if it doesn't, I'm still sure I'll enjoy the ride.
Dude Aug 16th 2011 7:01PM
I thought a young Draenei was interesting, after all Imagine if a Orc or Troll warlock had found her instead of the two Horde that did... may have had a new Eredar on our hands rather than an eventual Darnassian-raised shammy.
Fletcher Aug 16th 2011 7:15PM
I'm interested to see what you'll come up with next! And yes, chalk me down for "More Alliance please"!
Prelimar Aug 16th 2011 8:26PM
"...more alliance MAGES" .... please. : )
Amaxe Aug 16th 2011 8:11PM
I think overall the series was well done. I'd like to see whatever is done next.