Raid Rx: How to handle button mashing syndrome

Wildstar. Firefall. Counterstrike: GO. Novus Aeterno. Those are games I either looked at or tried out at PAX Prime in Seattle a couple of weeks ago. Keep them in the back of your mind if you're looking for future games to get involved with. And now, back to some weekly healing for thought!
My friends, I have noticed a trend among newer healers. Players new to the art of healing are reporting some slight bruising or sore fingers. Now, I have a theory as to why this is happening: I call it button mashing syndrome. I was at a friend's place a while ago and watching him heal. He was really smashing the healing spells through that keyboard. But there is a fine line between mindless, panicky button smashing and tactical button mashing.
Now, if you are a member of my guild, you would immediately attest to the fact that I am a button masher. In fact, when I'm speaking over Mumble during a raid, my players like to comment that it sounds like there's a building under construction on my end due to the massive sounds of keyboard pounding going on. (I'm actually sporting a Razer Black Widow Ultimate. If you're not familiar with it, the keyboard is reminiscent of the old IBM keyboard that was really clunky but durable.)
So what's the difference?
Panic button mashing
To be fair, I witness this symptom in other games in addition to World of Warcraft. Do you remember playing Street Fighter or other fighting games when you were younger? You didn't know all the moves. You had a hard time remembering which button was high kick, low punch and block (even if the labels were right next to the arcade buttons). What you remember doing was smashing all the different arcade buttons in the futile hope that you hit some combination that resulted in using a super-special move, blowing up your opponent.
This level of panic isn't going to help, especially as a healer. If you're the person your party is counting on to sustain the raid, then you need to be the most level-headed player there. Actually, both you and the tank will need to have really cool heads. Blindly pressing your keys and fervently hoping that the group doesn't die isn't the best way to go about it at all.
Why not?
In a client/server type of setup for MMOs like WoW, the game takes the initial command that a player inputs and transmits it to the server. Any subsequent spell instructions are typically ignored or queued with a limited buffer (but it depends on the game). Sometimes, moving or sending a command to the server can instruct the server to cancel the last command that was sent, such as a stopcasting macro. In other words, you might end up casting a slow healing spell only to discover that the situation warranted a much faster spell instead. Guess what? You mashed the wrong key! Unless you can rectify it by stopping the cast and using the right spell, your healing target won't last much longer.
More experienced healers out there know that there is a right heal for every problem. The trick is determining which one, and that's going to be based off the amount of time you have, your mana, the target's health, the encounter and so forth. There are simply too many variables to take into consideration.
Disciplined button mashing
Now we're going to contrast this with disciplined button mashing. To illustrate an example, it ends up being the equivalent of my mashing one spell repeatedly. Targeting a player and then rapidly pressing my group AOE heal spell helps ensure that there is a minimal spell gap between my first and subsequent spells.
Latency (commonly known as lag) refers to the delay between your computer and the server. By repeatedly mashing one key, your computer is going to try to instruct the server to process a specific action. Depending on where you live and your connection speed, you might have noticed that when you're casting a spell, there are times when it looks like your next spell in the sequence is automatically casting, even though you didn't press anything. Maybe you decided to rest your hand for a bit and then noticed that a spell went off.
Due to the delay between your computer and the different server realms, it is highly possible that the server thinks your spell already finished casting. But your side (or the client side) is still playing catch-up because the server is sending information from it to your computer. Even though the spell's done from the server end, your computer is still finishing the cast. If you time it right, you can keep mashing the same key so that your client is continuing to transmit commands over the internet to the server so that it cuts down on the lag time and can process your healing commands faster.
If I'm tank healing, for instance, I'd keep rapidly pressing any big healing spells one after the other. I know I don't really need to. I can probably wait until there's a half-second (or less) on the cast before before attempting to cast another one. Truth be told, it may not even be necessary to do that. You could cast a healing spell and then another one when the first healing spell is less than a second from connecting with your target and still minimize any lag.
Naturally, this kind of stuff takes practice. Smashing the keyboard is a great way to release frustrations, but I wouldn't exactly recommend it as a viable healing method. Start with improving your healing decision making first. As you practice and heal more, your ability to recognize situations will get better and better. Your judgments and decision making skills will become even more sound.
Need advice on working with the healers in your guild? Raid Rx has you covered. Send your questions about raid healing to mattl@wowinsider.com. For less healer-centric raiding advice, visit Ready Check for advanced tactics and advice for the endgame raider.Filed under: Raid Rx (Raid Healing)






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
ayanamilily Sep 9th 2011 6:14PM
Castbar addons that show latency buffers help as well, especially when chaining casts so you can mash half as often ;)
Revynn Sep 9th 2011 9:00PM
The problem with relying simply on that latency indicator in your cast bar is that the buffer it's showing was calculated when you -started- the spell. On longer casts this latency can vary somewhat drastically, especially if you're playing on a server across the country. It's certainly better than trying to gains casts without the latency indicator, but button mashing is still better.
hp_hunter Sep 9th 2011 6:23PM
Interesting article Matt! I mash buttons on all my characters which are mainly DPSers (main is a hunter). Using Healbot Addon on my holy paladin made me control a bit the "angry german kid" syndrome but i still tend to spam Judgment key 2 seconds before its ready.
Nowadays I'm trying to level a rogue which became a great way for myself to learn some self-control since that limited energy makes u choose more carefully what to use it for.
To help queueing/cancelling spells it might be a good idea to use the Addon Quartz - it has a "latency bar" which helps u react according to your lag (which is around 150-200ms where I live at).
hp_hunter Sep 9th 2011 6:27PM
Also I don't think you need to go that far to find reasons we button mash - Most of us have DPSers alts/mains in which a second not using skills is a lot of DPS lost... Resulting in a lot of keyboard facerolling except when soloing.
Snuzzle Sep 10th 2011 5:22AM
The problem with that is a lot of classes have very specific rotations or priority systems to maximise DPS. I used to play with a guy who mained an ele shaman, and ele shaman had a fairly easy rotation. He also decided to level a kitty alt, and kitties have a strict priority. His kitty DPS was always poor and we couldn't figure out why (my main at the time was a cat/bear druid). He knew what to do and he seemed to be hitting the right buttons from his recount. I remember visiting him (unrelatedly) and watching him play his cat, once, and the problem was immdately apparent. He had his fingers on his number keys and was drumming them, one after another, rapidly in sequence. I cringed and never brought up his DPS again.
blazenor Sep 9th 2011 6:45PM
I've never mashed buttons as a healer before, this is new to me. I heal sometimes to get away from the fast pace of DPS.
lividmonkey Sep 9th 2011 6:56PM
I'm primarily a healer and I'm not in that button-mashing group. However, I do zone out and focus intently during raids and 5-mans. I realized recently that I get into the rhythm of the cool downs and my button pressing is actually quite rhythmic. I find that I button-mash when I'm warrior DPS'ing, though.
Monion Sep 9th 2011 7:16PM
I find I do the single-button mash all the time on my Enhancement Shaman (since they're, y'know, a little crazy on the rotation). On my Holy Paladin it depends on how GCD locked I am. If it's a farm fight and I'm in control, I usually let myself have those leisurely half seconds. If things are rapidly going south or it's a fight which I'm unfamiliar with, being able to sneak in a GCD every 3 or 4 because I'm pre-casting by single-button mashing the crap out of whatever spell I know I want to cast next (Divine Light and Holy Radiance say hi!).
Revynn Sep 9th 2011 9:03PM
The Street Fighter style of button mashing is exactly why I'm terrible at PvP (and fighting games).
mdspurrier Sep 10th 2011 1:04PM
I'm in the same boat.
chris crouse Sep 9th 2011 11:07PM
I hope you didn't pay for that black widow :p
Wist Sep 10th 2011 12:34AM
There was no block button in Street Fighter. You pushed back (away from your enemy) on the D-pad. :)
dk Sep 10th 2011 2:32AM
This ... is the best article I've seen your write. Thank you.
Fawxie Sep 10th 2011 5:53AM
You don't know button mashing unless you've played a pre-cataclysm DPS warrior.
Heroic-Strike induced Carpal Tunnel syndrome anyone?
Puntable Sep 10th 2011 9:31AM
No mention of the spell queueing that was added in patch 4.0? You don't need to mash buttons anymore. You really don't even need Quartz anymore, unless your latency is really high.
Minos Sep 10th 2011 3:33PM
"Clunky but durable"? No kidding. You could beat a man to death with a Model M.
Grendalsh Sep 10th 2011 6:31PM
I simply do not understand the concept of mashing a button repeatedly as a NORMAL playstyle. If I'm stunned/silenced/etc. and need to get a cast off AS SOON as I'm back, then I'll spam that key so it goes off as soon as I'm able to cast it.. But the rest of the time, there's no point. Either the ability is instant, in which case move on to the next ability, or the GCD is up before the cast is done. In the latter case, the new keypress queuing system in WoW will take the next keypress and 'queue' it for when the current spell is done casting. So as soon as the GCD is up, I press the next ability I want, and it starts/triggers as soon as it can, whether that's on my side or the server.
End result.. all mashing buttons does is damage your keyboard and make you look like a spazz. Control your playstyle, don't let it control you.
roald.nieuw Sep 11th 2011 8:38AM
I've always been a button masher, mostly due to raiding with high latency (luckily IceHUD's casting bar works so nicely for me while healing), so it's nothing new. It wasn't excessive either. That is, until I started my Frost DW DK alt. That's button mashing heaven, with procs flying around and your uptime being 99% of the encounter. The button mashing is probably why I don't do as much DPS as other people in my current gear (370 iLevel), since I never manage my ruins or RP at all...MASH DEM BUTTONS!!!
Healing while button mashing doesn't exactly do it for me nowadays, since the situation can transpire at a moment's notice. You need to be able to react fast, and cast the right heal for the moment, instead of just GH or Penance/Bubble spams.