Review of Wolfheart, by Richard A. Knaak

That pretty much ends with Wolfheart, the newest Warcraft novel by Richard A. Knaak. For those who were tired of hearing of Thrall's exploits or the exploits of the Horde in general, Wolfheart is very much the book for you. Though we haven't witnessed any particularly huge conflicts with the Alliance in game -- instead being treated to the somewhat chilly reception of Garrosh Hellscream and his plans for the Horde -- it doesn't mean that there hasn't been any to speak of. In fact, there's far more going on behind the scenes with the Alliance than anyone could have guessed.

It works, as far as the novels go. With The Shattering, we saw far more Horde progression than we did Alliance -- although Magni's death and the standoff in Ironforge were both interesting, there still didn't seem to be quite as much emphasis on Alliance events. Thrall: Twilight of the Aspects took place well after Cataclysm's launch and firmly involved Thrall, the Aspects, and little else. Wolfheart is nestled between, a look at the struggles of the Alliance as it attempts to band together just after the cataclysm itself.
While Twilight of the Aspects was a story of conflict in terms of Thrall's self-conflict and the conflict of the dragon Aspects, Wolfheart takes on a very different series of conflicts. There's the conflict between the Dwarf clans of Ironforge, which is briefly addressed. But there's also the conflict between the Night Elves and the Highborne of Eldre'Thalas, who seek to be once again accepted into Night Elf society. Then there is the conflict playing out in Ashenvale, where the Horde loom as a threat so large that the Night Elves cannot hope to stand against them alone.
And on top of this, there are the Worgen of Gilneas. Having fled from Gilneas, the Worgen seek to be accepted into the Alliance. Malfurion is all for this, as he is still feeling incredibly guilty about the existence of the Worgen curse in the first place and blames himself for it. But there's one individual who stands firmly in the way of that acceptance -- King Varian Wrynn. And he also represents one of the larger conflicts in the book.

Varian Wrynn doesn't want the Worgen included in the Alliance, and given Gilneas' history with the former Alliance of Lordaeron, it's understandable. After all, King Greymane pulled all support just after the Second War and spent the Third War locked behind the Greymane Wall as the Scourge ravaged the rest of Lordaeron. Gilneas did nothing to stop the Forsaken takeover of the former kingdom of Lordaeron, and after the events of the Battle for the Undercity, it's obvious how passionate Varian feels about that. So it's really no wonder that Varian stands opposed.
As for the Highborne, Mordent Evenshade makes a reappearance along with the rest of the erstwhile Shen'dralar, seeking acceptance within Night Elf society. Unfortunately, society doesn't seem to be as accepting, as the Highborne swiftly find themselves the targets of a series of murders. Brought in to investigate is none other than Maiev Shadowsong, making her first appearance since Illidan's defeat in The Burning Crusade. No longer in Outland, Maiev is just as obsessive about her tasks and the hunt for the killer as she was about the hunt for Illidan.
But above and beyond all the conflict, Wolfheart is at its heart about acceptance -- the acceptance of the Worgen into the Alliance, the acceptance of the Highborne into Night Elf society, even a young man's acceptance of whatever role the Light happens to have in store for him. The acceptance of mortality, the acceptance of guilt for the years spent in slumber, however vital those years might have been. And the acceptance of a man literally torn in two and put back together again -- both of the Gilnean people and of the rage within his heart.

What impressed me the most was the one thing that I felt lacking from Knaak's previous works: dialogue. Knaak has always been impressive with descriptive phrases and making readers feel like they were at the heart of a battle, but his dialogue sometimes lacked the genuine feel that Christie Golden seems to lend to her characters with ease. However, Wolfheart was full of snappy dialogue that had me wincing in some places, particularly in discussions between Varian and Anduin -- not wincing in a bad way, but wincing in an "Oooh, I cannot believe he just said that" way.
Wolfheart was full of these kinds of scenes -- those awkward confrontations that you know are just going to be terrible to have but are delightful to read as an outside observer. Dialogue didn't really feel forced, everyone had a natural flow to speaking, and other than a few moments when I felt characterization was a little off, I was delighted. Knaak is as knowledgeable about Night Elves as he has always been, but his version of Varian Wrynn is spot-on and was sheer joy to read.
For Alliance fans who are looking for a shot of good old-fashioned Alliance lore in the wake of Cataclysm, and for Horde fans who want to read more about the Alliance side of the Cataclysm struggle, Wolfheart is an excellent read. The events in this book hint and foreshadow things still to come in Cataclysm and beyond. Plus, we finally get to see the continuation of that ominous clash in the Ulduar trailer -- and let's face it, who hasn't been waiting to see that?
World of Warcraft: Cataclysm has destroyed Azeroth as we know it; nothing is the same! In WoW Insider's Guide to Cataclysm, you can find out everything you need to know about WoW's third expansion, from leveling up a new goblin or worgen to breaking news and strategies on endgame play.






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 4)
Matticus Sep 14th 2011 1:07PM
Got this on my kindle. Totally second Anne's recommendation. Good read. Wrynn kicks a lot of ass in this book.
Donhorn Sep 14th 2011 6:33PM
And I got it on my phone's Nook app, haven't had the chance to fully dive into it, but I'm glad to hear that this is much better than his previous works. Can't wait to get reading it now!
Olania Sep 14th 2011 1:11PM
OK, I'll say it...
KNAAAAAAAAAACCCCKKKKKKKK!!!!
There, it's done. Let's move on.
Vector Sep 14th 2011 1:34PM
Knaak is a great writer, but sometimes he just kills me with the way he builds the plots. He is always ducking back and forth drastically between different sets of characters and sometimes even different times it would seem. Sometimes it takes me a page or two to catch back up to where those characters were and I feel like I need to go back and re-read them to fully get what he's saying.
Perhaps my reading level isn't where it should be at my mid-thirties, but I find that I get more pleasure from Golden. But I'll give this one another shot. Maybe if it's highly focused on just the Alliance side the point-of-view swaps won't be so distracting.
Olania Sep 14th 2011 1:57PM
Oh I don't have a problem with Knaack per say, but I just know that the sheer mention of his name tends to cause much anger and gnashing of teeth among the fanboys. So I figured it'd be faster to get the inevitable hate out of the way so we can move along and actually discuss the book.
Double posted. Fail on my part. >.>
The Giant Sep 14th 2011 3:44PM
I read the title of the article, and my first thought was "When did Knaack start writing for WoW Insider?"
VSUReaper Sep 14th 2011 5:04PM
I really disliked Knaaks previous works due to the whole "time-traveling Mage that can cast spells when NO ONE ELSE CAN", but I have started reading some of his oldest works and have been really impressed.
I hope that this is just as good!
Hurbster Sep 14th 2011 1:13PM
It's about damn time the Alliance got some love. Cata was depressing in too many places for my liking.
Fathertouk Sep 14th 2011 1:19PM
Honestly a little surprised to see such a glowing review, considering some of the flaws in his past works. I'm really excited to give this a read now!
Vinyl Sep 14th 2011 1:27PM
Jeez, this is making me miss Alliance like you wouldn't believe. Totally picking up the audiobook, thanks Anne :)
dannyflorida Sep 14th 2011 9:20PM
For the first time, I'm LISTENING to a Warcraft novel. I've read all the novels, so I thought I'd try the audio book version of "Wolfheart." I'm so glad I did. It's wonderful!
Tip:
I got my audio book via Audible.com, and I got it FREE. You can get a free book, too, when you sign up for a free 30-day trial. You can even cancel the trial before it ends, never be charged for membership, and still keep the book. (I promise I don't work for Audible or receive any consideration. I just thought others, who may be cash-strapped like me, would like to know about how to get the book free.)
Vinyl Sep 14th 2011 9:44PM
Wow, protip! Thanks man :D
Reklisc Sep 14th 2011 11:52PM
Any chance someone could tell us the name of the audio narrator? I'm gonna get this audio version definitely (free is free, after all), but still curious.
eirinefrostblade Sep 15th 2011 3:21AM
It was mis-posted on audible's website as being Knaak, but the audio credits a Scott Brack (Brick? not completely clear). At any rate, he's got a better voice than the last one, even if he still mispronounces "Tyrande."
roguers Sep 14th 2011 1:30PM
anyone got a good place to start with the lore literature out there?
sauron_1969 Sep 14th 2011 2:10PM
I would suggest the link called "WoW Insider's Guide to the Chronological order of WoW's novels & comics" that is conveniently located on the right side of this web page.
SaintStryfe Sep 14th 2011 6:25PM
The only truly required stop off in Warcraft novels is Christie Golden's "Rise of the Horde" - it's the single best Warcraft novel and stands on its own as a fantasy novel proper. It's not Shakespare but it's perfectly readable.
At all costs avoid Knaak's dragon books - the War of the Ancients, the Night of the Dragon - they're completely terrible. Golden's other books - Arthas and Thrall - are quite readable but not needed to enjoy the story.
Sunstreaker84 Sep 14th 2011 1:30PM
Hey...hey Varian...those are...umm...those are some *large* shoulderpads you got there.
No, no! Don't get up! Just settle back down in your throne so that you can brood at me from their depths.
Blayze Sep 14th 2011 1:45PM
He's probably not capable of standing.
Siaperas Sep 14th 2011 1:30PM
This may be an unpopular belief, but my opinion is that Varian could take down Garrosh in a fight any day of the week.