15 Minutes of Fame: Progressive guild thrives under uncommon leadership team

There's plenty about Wreck List of Garrosh (US-H) that's a little different from your run-of-the-mill World of Warcraft guild. The sprawling social guild doused Ragnaros just days ago with a team of core raiders rooted by several members in their 50s and 60s. In fact, the guild is run primarily by women over the age of 50 -- "at age 51, I'm the baby of the group," admits guild leader Dkosmama. With a median member age of about 40, Wreck List boasts well over 200 members, half of them women.
Even more remarkable than its unusual gender and age mix, though, are the guild's roots -- Wreck List is the unofficial guild of the popular progressive political blog Daily Kos. Not limited to members from the Daily Kos community, Wreck List is open to any player looking for a sanctuary from trade chat madness, away from "threatening racist, homophobic, and misogynist language and ideas." The group's official Declaration of Purpose clearly states that "while guild chat is mostly non-political, it is also where we express our leftist political views, which sometimes may include a sharp word or two about Republicans. Because many guild members did not come to the Wreck List through political blogs, we do not expect everyone to hold progressive views on all issues; however, we do expect that all members respect the liberal foundation of the guild."
An unusual balance for an entire guild? We thought so, too, and sat down to visit with Dkosmama about the balance of ideas and free expression that makes this whole group hang together.
Editor's note: This article focuses on this group's integration with the World of Warcraft and is not an endorsement or promotion of any particular political ideology or agenda. Please keep comments focused on the guild and its activities, rather than political ideologies.
Main character DkosmamaGuild Wreck List
Realm Garrosh (US-H)
15 Minutes of Fame: Take us on this journey, Dkosmama -- how do we get from a well-known political blog to a World of Warcraft guild? What kicked off this idea, and who stepped up to make it happen?
Dkosmama: In late March of 2009, Moodyloner posted a comment in a community diary on Daily Kos about World of Warcraft. Other players joined in, and within a day or so, they had decided to roll Horde on Garrosh and start a Daily Kos guild called Wreck List.
Moody, a fan of nontraditional online organizing, explains: "I've been in other guilds before. Good guilds. Solid raiders. Nice people. But, and this is a big but, I'd find myself watching what I talked about in guild chat. I'd soon learn that there were subjects that I could not talk about -- politics, rights, equality, feminism. Soloing was worse -- general and trade chats were infamous, and still are, for the hostility. ... And I was trying to level, and I couldn't talk to my guildies, and I couldn't talk to anyone else.
"I thought it would be something, not to have a raiding guild or a PvP guild or a leveling guild, but to have a liberal guild," [Moody continued]. "A guild united not by what people did in game, but what people were like out of it."
By all accounts, it sounds as if it's grown to become a pretty large group.
Currently we have about 825 members representing about 270 accounts. Roughly two-thirds of our members are from Daily Kos or other liberal blogs, notably Balloon Juice. The other third have come to us from the server or are people who searched for a "liberal guild," found us, read our guild's Declaration of Purpose and Principles, applied online and then switched servers to be with us.
What proportion of the players refer themselves over from the Daily Kos?
Of our Daily Kos members, some are just readers, and some are very involved with the site. Every summer, our raiding takes a bit of a hiatus as a bunch of members attend the annual Netroots Nation conference. One of our members, Suluca, is a staff writer for the front page of Daily Kos as well as a moderator for the Black Kos community.
Every Thursday, Moody posts a diary to Daily Kos about what's going in with the guild -- and every week, like clockwork, we have at least one or two new members join us from there.

Actually, we've have had some issues in the past. Because of these issues, last year I asked a group of senior members to draft a Declaration of Purpose and Principles for the guild, to be like our constitution. The committee included two lawyers, an anthropologist, and three of the founding members of guild, one of whom was an experienced raider and another who never raids, plus Moodyloner.
As they worked on the initial draft, I asked other senior guild members to be quest givers for a series of quests that would introduce the newer members to our history and guiding principles. By doing the quests, members would unlock a forum on our guild website where they could read and help edit the draft declaration. The whole process took about three weeks, and most people had a blast!
Today, we require anyone who wishes to join the guild to read the Guild Declaration first and then fill out an application.
For the majority of people who join, being a member of the Wreck List is a dream come true -- a dream of civility, cooperation and compassion -- but we aren't for everyone. We expect all members to respect the political foundations of the guild. Additionally, we also are not a hardcore raiding guild, although we do have two excellent raiding teams. So we've had a few Daily Kos people join who were looking for the discipline and competitiveness of a high-end raiding guild and decided that we weren't the right guild for them, either.
So your guild culture is appreciably different, then, than that of most other guilds?
I think we are very different. For example, I read about issues of fighting in raids, loot ninjas, factions, and general guild drama. We don't have any of that. The one issue that does come up occasionally [is when] a conservative or hardcore raider joins the guild because of a friend or family member and then realizes that he or she is in the wrong place.
Other differences include that the guild pays for every member's repairs, whether for raiding or just leveling. We work hard to make sure that we can help new members get equipped, and if someone needs a stack of gems to level JC or an epic crafted piece, members help with that, too.
But I think the main thing that sets our guild apart is our demographics. We have members from elementary school up to retirement age, with a median age of about 40. We have a number of university professors, as well as attorneys, political activists, military personnel, scientists, teachers, writers, and students, which means that the topics that come up in guild chat are fairly diverse.
And for anyone who thinks that raiding is something that only young people can do well, I'd like to introduce them to a few of college professors I know.

Right now on our forums, there is a thread discussing capital punishment and Troy Davis, another debunking the recent GOP attacks on Social Security, and third on racism in the trade channel and how to get Blizzard to address it. If you're in the game and there is important breaking news, someone will always let the guild know.
There are discussions all the time about politics and current events, but also about history, science, and literature. And we even talk about the game, too. What we aren't doing is arguing about politics, so much as sharing various progressive takes on issues of the day.
Do you have any rules of engagement as far as political debate goes?
In general, all guild chat is rated PG, and personal attacks or statements that are meant to cause offense or drama are not permitted. In the opening of our Guild Declaration, it is quite clear that we are not a debating society. Because we share similar values, we can have spirited discussions about policy specifics while all agreeing on the core issues. While some members may disagree with President Obama's handling of certain things, no one in the guild doubts the fact that he was born in America.
In the past, some conservatives who were in the guild because of friends challenged us, saying while we claim to be tolerant toward diversity, we weren't tolerant of different political views - just like GOP members of Congress today demand that the Democrats be bipartisan while refusing to compromise on anything.
It's not about tolerance. We absolutely do not allow any comments in guild chat or Vent that are racist, sexist, or homophobic. And we also do not allow right-wing talking points. In other words, having women, gays, members of ethnic/racial minorities, or senior citizens in the guild is not a sign of "tolerance" -- it's who we are!
You certainly do have a demographic that's definitely different from the norm.
About half the guild is women, including officers. There are a lot of families that play together here, too - spouses, parents and their kids, and so on. We work hard to keep this a safe, comfortable and family friendly place to play.

We try to do it all, except for serious roleplaying. We have two progression raid teams, some very dedicated PVPers, and lots of leveling, as well as the occasional special guild event, heritage raids, guild achievement chasing, and so on.
Actually, during our guild quest event last year, many people really got into roleplaying, too. There's a funny story about that. One guy had joined as a friend of a friend just before the event started. Everyone was sent off to find the first quest giver. The first quest involved collecting 10 Small Barnacled Clams and turning them in order to get the next quest. Pretty easy standard WoW quest, right? We've all done hundreds of these. Well this guy went off the deep end: "You want me to collect clams and then turn them in just so I can get another quest? You people are crazy!" And then he rage-quit -- or as we like to call it, clam-quit.
Tell us about your own involvement at the Daily Kos, Dkosmama.
I started posting at Daily Kos back in early 2003. That was in the early days of political blogs. I found the site through my online involvement with the Howard Dean campaign and became a regular reader and sometime contributor.
Daily Kos has evolved from a simple political blog to a massive online community where anyone who joins can post a diary or blog as well as join in discussions by posting comments. I post there a couple times a year, although I comment regularly and read it almost daily.
And how did you become guild mama of the WoW guild?I became guild leader sort of by accident, but after two years, it seems people like the way I do things. Early on, we had several of members who had their accounts hacked. At the time, I was the only one with an authenticator, so the then-guild-leader put me in charge. We had some rocky times with drama and personality conflicts -- basically, growing pains. And there were times when my husband questioned the amount of time and emotional energy the guild required. That was my prime motivation for creating our guild Declaration of Purpose and Principle.
Since then, so many members have offered to take on various aspect of guild management -- everything from keeping the guild vault organized, to moderating our guild forums, to running our Facebook page, to coordinating raids -- that there's not a whole lot for me to do these days. I only step in when there is an issue that requires the guild leader to take action. For major decisions, I always talk to the senior guild members, the Guild Elders, and we work together to arrive at a consensus.
I've never felt that this was "my guild." Rather, is it an organization I am honored to be part of and especially honored to lead. This guild is a fabulous and supportive place to hang out with people who share similar values and really care about each other and the rest of the world.
Editor's note: This article focuses on this group's integration with the World of Warcraft and is not an endorsement or promotion of any particular political ideology or agenda. Please keep comments focused on the guild and its activities, rather than political ideologies.
Learn more about the guild at the Wreck List website or read more about the group's World of Warcraft involvement at the Daily Kos.
Filed under: Guilds, Interviews, 15 Minutes of Fame
Patch 5.3 interview with Ghostcrawler
Mystery of the Unborn Val'kyr
The latest patch 5.3 news
All of the latest Mists of Pandaria news





Reader Comments (Page 3 of 7)
Tom Sep 30th 2011 12:48AM
I meant "you" in the general case. :D
Tom Sep 30th 2011 12:58AM
Also, you presume too much, I think.
"I've merely said political views do not belong in WoW Insider."
You think this is political -at all- and thus shouldn't be here, and I think that a dislike of the subject matter isn't a basis for judging the quality of the article.
Amaxe Sep 30th 2011 1:36AM
It certainly is political when one starts using terms like "right wing."
It demonstrates a hostility towards a conservative position, much as "left wing" shows hostility towards a liberal position. Once the interviewee starts in with anti-Republican rhetoric, it is clear the article has gone from "this is what we believe" to bashing, just as a hypothetical tea party guild would be bashing if they started using similar rhetoric towards Democrats.
But I'm done with this article and don't see the point of continuing this as you seem to be determined to pin a position to me which I do not hold (I loathe both political parties and believe they both miss the point).
Tom Sep 30th 2011 1:44AM
I truly don't know what position you think I'm trying to pin on you.
I haven't said anything regarding your political leanings; there's nothing to suggest one way or the other, and your political leanings are irrelevant to the point.
To be clear, do you think this is inflammatory and inappropriate? I thought that's what you've been saying, and that's what I've been refuting. Left or right doesn't play into it at all.
KillerKarl Sep 29th 2011 9:01PM
I love the Daily Kos. I consider it to be one of the funniest sights on the internet.
ELDRITCH_HORROR Sep 29th 2011 9:11PM
Wait... What?
The entire definition of this guild is, "a liberal guild." That is what it's founded on, that is what it thrives on.
If we are to discuss this guild, we need to discuss it's political heart.
Anyways, this guild seems to be really lame. I mean, roleplaying is a fantastic idea, but the idea of acting out quests and quest giving, just to collect several mundane objects is... Rather hilarious.
I mean, whenever I see a guild that has, "an open guild bank," "free repairs," "members that support each other," I know that guild will have problems. There is a reason why other guilds don't do this. It's so open to abuse.
Anyways... For a guild that prides itself on being tolerant, they are incredibly discriminatory to anyone who does not have left-wing view points. I mean, as this article describes, anyone who does not conform to this viewpoint is expected not to respond or participate in many of the guild chat's discussions. That's what I call, "a hostile social environment."
What I find quite... Disturbing is the emphasis this guild places on both, "all ages," and, "liberal discussion." I mean, I really don't believe that children or those of a young age should be heavily exposed to politics. If one surrounds one's self with those of identical viewpoints... It simply encourages an atmosphere where one cannot understand different viewpoints.
Argh.
This guild seems to be jam-packed full of bad ideas and terrible behavior. That's my opinion on it, and what I have to say.
TwoHallo Sep 29th 2011 9:49PM
LOL You know why there isn't abuse? Cause we actually care about the guild. I've been part of the guild for um.. what.. a year? give or take.. Seen some Drama (though I don't pay attention to it much) but I've never seen any real issues with our polices. I think the few times anyone has "abused" the resources.. they were talked to first.. I don't remember it ever happening more than once. We even have folks who volunteer to go out and gather mats and whatnot when we are low on things... and they actually do it. So really.. it works, assuming your adults, not greedy, and care about folks and not generally be a ^%^&%$T(#$%.
Jyotai Sep 30th 2011 1:59AM
It is not tolerance to tolerate bigotry and hatred.
Saying that it is intolerant for not tolerating bigots is an oxymoron that is very popular among hate groups to try and make themselves sound legitimate.
Tolerance is an antonym of bigotry.
As for exposing kids to politics - people do that everyday. Heck, the Tea Party is even running 'Youth Camps' (but talking about that would bring us into a Godwin moment...)
Do you feel the left should not be able to teach real nurturing family values in the place of the right's concept of power-based family values? That only one side gets to consider its values 'family oriented?'
That's a clever attempt to shut up opposition.
Carune Sep 29th 2011 9:28PM
Here is a pretty good description of the guild by a guildie.
"this guild is amazing, was thinking about it this morning. Get together a group of people bound together by common political and social beliefs, one of the largest guilds on the server, raids, social atmosphere, no pressure, and still competitive without a lot of infighting"
This was said the night that the first guild on the server got level 25. Which we didn't get and we ended up getting third place. Oh well.
taylormattd Sep 30th 2011 1:17AM
Omg Invi: "Blizzard would have to bail out their guild bank"
LOL!
mamasama Sep 29th 2011 10:01PM
I was BLOWN AWAY by this article. And not in a good way. I pride myself on being especially tolerant and open to all viewpoints, whether I agree with them or not. And to read THIS as quoted from the article, REALLY rubbed me the wrong way:
In the past, some conservatives who were in the guild because of friends challenged us, saying while we claim to be tolerant toward diversity, we weren't tolerant of different political views - just like GOP members of Congress today demand that the Democrats be bipartisan while refusing to compromise on anything.
It's not about tolerance. We absolutely do not allow any comments in guild chat or Vent that are racist, sexist, or homophobic. And we also do not allow right-wing talking points. In other words, having women, gays, members of ethnic/racial minorities, or senior citizens in the guild is not a sign of "tolerance" -- it's who we are!"
This person perfectly exemplifies the type of closed minded, ignorant and hypocritical thinking that is so rampant in our society today. To suggest that anyone leaning to the RIGHT of their views would by default NOT be accepting of all of those groups (gays, women, etc) is a notion I PERSONALLY find OFFENSIVE.
These people make me sad for humanity. Whatever happened to giving people who don't embrace your political views the benefit of the doubt? Who knows, you might learn something....oh wait. These type of harpies already have all the answers.
Disgusting.
Moanique Sep 29th 2011 10:18PM
I guess I have to ask you and others in the thread that have commented in such a negative way that if a similar guild were put together from say, Redstate, would it be more or less tolerant of dissenting views in its guild chat?
No matter what you think of this guild personally, it's a fair question if you simply are criticizing because of the politics involved.
Anyone that reads both sites as I do, can come to their own conclusions about that.
As to the article itself, there's nothing wrong with people of like interests grouping together to be social and enjoy their favorite game. The guild itself sounds like a nice place to be if your views are consonant with the guild's specifically-stated leanings and if politics is an interest. It's not like it's a secret or anything.
Tom Sep 29th 2011 11:13PM
"To suggest that anyone leaning to the RIGHT of their views would by default NOT be accepting of all of those groups (gays, women, etc) is a notion I PERSONALLY find OFFENSIVE."
... but they didn't, at least that's not how I read it.
"Whatever happened to giving people who don't embrace your political views the benefit of the doubt?"
Yeah, whatever happened to giving people the benefit of the doubt?
Amaxe Sep 30th 2011 12:02AM
@Moanique
The problem is WoW Insider chose to allow a guild to air its political views. Personally I don't give a damn if the guild was from the Daily Kos or from the Tea Party. Such an interview could have been done without such partisan grandstanding as was done when it described the relationship in the guild. Let's try it:
"The guild members are expected to avoid voicing certain opinions which go against the political values of the guild. If they don't like our values, they can go to another guild."
See how much less partisan that is?
Xenikos Sep 30th 2011 10:13AM
Conservatives are not necessarily sexist, racist, homophobic, or bigoted.
But they *do* support candidates who on the whole push policies that make it more difficult to strive for equality. Even if that is not the rationale behind their support, they still help foster bigotry and inequality because of the policies their candidates push.
On a slightly related note, it is absolutely hilarious how the party that represents the interests of big corporations suddenly adopts a victim complex the instant anything even remotely related to politics appears that they don't agree with 100%. The clear intent of the article was to showcase a unique kind of guild: one formed around a political background, with older leaders. And conservatives are reacting as if Wowinsider's entire staff went out and urinated on Ronald Reagan's grave.
Hal Sep 29th 2011 10:41PM
Am I the only person who goes to Azeroth to get away from the real world? I just can't understand the appeal here.
Finnioch Sep 29th 2011 11:12PM
No one said anything about individuals being gkicked.
And as far as "when a purported conservative is being criticized for expressing racist, homophobic, or sexist view"...
Did you know that Tea Party members are called racist because they don't like the Presidents policies? Did you know that they are also called racist because Herman Cain won a straw poll for the Republican nomination in Florida this week, because according to the liberal sage Janeane Garafalo conservatives only voted for him to hide their racism?
No matter what conservatives do, someone, somewhere, is going to call them a racist for it. It is a no-win situation.
But I digress.
My complaint was that the GM seems to see any political view, other than her own, as an intolerant one. While that is fine and dandy for her and the running of her guild, more power to them, it boggles my mind why WoWInsider decided to spotlight such an powderkeg of topic without offering any semblance of balance. Instead, the columnist sits on the sidelines and acts as a stenographer.
Tom Sep 29th 2011 11:16PM
"Instead, the columnist sits on the sidelines and acts as a stenographer."
... which is precisely what she should be doing.
If someone wants to see a conservative counterpart profiled, then it's up to them to suggest it to Lisa.
Darasen Sep 29th 2011 11:13PM
The Huffington influence rears it's ugly head on Wowinsider. Surprised? Not me.
Just remember Daily Kos is the place where people regularly make comments that Republicans need to die and Christians are worse than islamic terrorist. But, they are all so tolerant. BS.
Senotonom205 Sep 30th 2011 11:02AM
I would like you to show me one example of a post or diary that does either one of the things you just accused. As someone who just posted nonsense on this blog, you cannot possibly blame the site for anonymous commenters.