I do think the loot rules and the inability of the leader to directly kick is a bit upsetting. Unless they change the loot system so you can only roll on items that are beneficial for the spec you que as, I think this could lead to a large amount of ninjas. As for the leader being unable to kick, what if you are just filling the last 5 slots of a raid group and you want everyone to be in ventrilo or mumble. If anyone who ques doesn't want to get in you have to waste precious vote kicks on them and there is no guarantee you will ever get someone who will. Just one example but the leader not being able to kick puts me off a little. I would have liked for it to be slightly closer to the current raid finder in the fact that you can send descriptions to raid leaders of what you can do so that the raid leaders have a bit of choice. That could cause elitism but I think it would be better than getting someone who believes 10k dps is acceptable for current content. Despite these flaws I am really looking forward to this system. Hurray for casual pugging on alts! This is a gift from heaven to us time constrained players.