Know Your Lore: The Shattering, part 3

Garrosh Hellscream is probably one of the most contentious additions to the Cataclysm expansion. Oh sure, he existed all the way back in The Burning Crusade, but he wasn't Warchief at that point in time. Nobody thought for a moment that the depressed Orc in Garadar would one day be leading their characters into battle against the Lich King. And nobody dreamed that Garrosh would one day be sitting on the Horde's throne.
It wasn't so much the surprise of the situation that people took issue with, however. Instead, it had much to do with Garrosh's attitude throughout Wrath of the Lich King. Headstrong, ruthless and downright bloodthirsty, Garrosh's decisions in Wrath didn't ring right or true with the playerbase. Even more jostling to players was the notion that despite the player dislike of the character, the NPCs of the world loved the guy. It may very well be the first time that a large chunk of a faction's players have blatantly disagreed with a fictional NPC faction -- and the NPC faction won out.
The Shattering makes it clear that Garrosh's position is only temporary, but in Cataclysm, he's certainly attacking the job with gusto.
Today's Know Your Lore contains pretty much every possible spoiler that exists for the novel The Shattering by Christie Golden. If you're avoiding spoilers, run away! Run away!

Thrall arrived at Nagrand, happy about his return and looking forward to seeing his grandmother again. Aggra intercepted his approach, not bothering to introduce herself and instead getting off to an excellent start with the Warchief by insulting his choice in using the name Thrall and generally being rude. After informing him that Aggra would be teaching him, she finally clued him in to the fact that she was Aggra. Thrall wasn't exactly pleased about this development.
Nor was he pleased as Aggra continued to be blunt and curt to the point of rudeness to Geyah. When Aggra left to go get some water for the Greatmother, Thrall asked her about her student and why Geyah put up with her terrible attitude. Geyah replied that Aggra was curt, yes, rude, possibly, but it was because she spoke what she felt in all things. Sometimes she was right, sometimes she was wrong, but she always spoke what she felt was the truth -- and thus, Geyah appreciated her opinion and would never seek to silence her.
Thrall thought back to his conversation with Cairne and how he had dismissed Cairne's observations about Garrosh. Cairne was simply speaking what he felt was true. The Warchief resolved to apologize to Cairne once he'd returned to Orgrimmar, ashamed of his actions.
Upon Aggra's return, Geyah filled Thrall in on what was to come. While Geyah would train him as much as she could, she was old and not able to travel. Aggra would take him where he needed to go and teach him along the way in the event that he needed to leave Nagrand for a lesson.
Thrall and Aggra began their journey, and Aggra continued to insult Thrall at any given opportunity. When Thrall finally got frustrated enough to call her out on her behavior, bluntly informing her that he was not the idiot she seemed to believe he was, her attitude changed for a moment, but only a moment. The two continued onward to distant parts of the world, so that Thrall could speak to the corrupt and twisted elementals of Nagrand and see if their behavior could somehow help him discern the behavior of the upset elementals of Azeroth.

Anduin Wrynn stayed in Ironforge at his father's request -- Varian thought that the Dwarves needed their support now more than ever, and as the prince had made several connections with the Dwarves, he was the ideal choice to stay behind as representative. King Varian admitted it wasn't a pleasant situation to handle but that as future king, Anduin would one day have to deal with unpleasant situations such as this one. At the very least, Anduin should remain until a new heir had been found.
Anduin didn't have to wait very long. While speaking with High Priest Rohan, the two were interrupted by a royal guard in a state of panic, who told them they were both needed at the High Seat at once. Puzzled, they made their way to the High Seat and were absolutely shocked at what they saw. For there, sitting on Magni's throne, was none other than his estranged daughter Moira Bronzebeard -- or rather, Queen Moira Bronzebeard, as she called herself. Moira returned to Ironforge with her infant son, the son of a Dark Iron.
Moira sweetly requested that she and Anduin have a nice, long chat. Anduin tried to get out of the situation by mentioning that his father wanted him to return to Stormwind as soon as an heir was found. Moira vetoed the option. Every word from her mouth was sweetness and light, and Anduin felt a sinking sensation as he left the throne room. His gut feeling was that he had just walked in on a coup, despite the fact that Moira was indeed the rightful heir.
That feeling was confirmed when he discovered that Moira had proclaimed all gryphons terribly sick and in need of quarantine, allowing no visitors presently in the Dwarven capital to fly out. And it was doubly confirmed when he discovered that the Deeprun Tram had been mysteriously damaged and was out of service -- and that Moira was having all mages arrested for suspicious behavior, to prevent them from creating portals out of the city. Anduin was, in a word, stuck.

In Thunder Bluff, Hamuul Runetotem and Cairne Bloodhoof discussed the changes that Garrosh had made. While the new Warchief insisted upon rebuilding Orgrimmar as quickly as possible, a decision that Cairne agreed with, the new Warchief was still blatantly unwilling to listen to any advice offered. Cairne decided it was best for him to return to Thunder Bluff, as it was obvious his advice was not wanted.
But Garrosh's response surprised Cairne. Instead of being relieved or completely indifferent to Cairne's departure, Garrosh told Cairne that he had no wish to offend the old bull, but he needed to make his own decisions, the decisions that he thought would be best for the Horde, whether Cairne agreed with them or not. And Cairne was perfectly fine with that -- if Garrosh truly meant those words. But he had a sneaking suspicion that Garrosh did not.
Hamuul had good news for Cairne, however. Despite the atrocities committed against the Night Elves, the druids of the Cenarion Circle were still willing to meet with Hamuul and discuss the strange behavior of the elements and the unusual weather that had been popping up all over Azeroth. The meeting was scheduled to take place at a secret glade in Ashenvale, and Hamuul was getting ready to leave. Cairne wished him luck with the peace talks and sent him on his way.
The meeting started off tense, the Night Elves wary of the Tauren despite their common ground in the Cenarion Circle. But Hamuul gently reinforced that he had no wish for violence of any kind. Though the Night Elves were dismayed to hear that Thrall had not only gone to Nagrand but left Garrosh in his place, Hamuul reassured them that Garrosh's place was temporary and that Thrall would return as soon as he had figured out what was disturbing Azeroth. The peace talks continued, and the Night Elves began to relax, as well as the Tauren.

And before Hamuul could think, Gorkrak and his companions turned on the remaining Tauren and slaughtered them as well. Once dead, they piled the bodies in a mass grave and buried them, but not too well. The grave was meant to be discovered in due time. After all, both Horde and Alliance were beginning to pin the blame on Garrosh Hellscream for the prior attack. The Twilight's Hammer was delighted to let the blame continue to be assigned to him.
Hours later, Hamuul Runetotem awoke in the middle of the mass grave, confused and disoriented, and clawed his way to the surface as the memory of the event came back to him -- he'd been shot in the back by fellow members of the Horde. To his dismay and sorrow, none of the others had survived. He was the only one left alive in the pile of bodies, both Tauren and Night Elf. Struggling to heal himself, Hamuul called an owl to carry a message to Cairne Runetotem, a message written in his own blood.
Suddenly, there was far more to worry about than just the troubled elements of the world.
For more information on related subjects, please look at these other Know Your Lore entries:
- Garrosh Hellscream, part 1 and part 2
- Arch Druid Hamuul Runetotem
- Current Alliance Politics: the Night Elves, part 1 and part 2
- The Twilight's Hammer
- Cairne Bloodhoof
While you don't need to have played the previous Warcraft games to enjoy World of Warcraft, a little history goes a long way toward making the game a lot more fun. Dig into even more of the lore and history behind the World of Warcraft in WoW Insider's Guide to Warcraft Lore.
Filed under: Lore, Know your Lore






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
kingoomieiii Oct 23rd 2011 4:59PM
"Hamuul called an owl to carry a message to Cairne Runetotem,"
Bloodhoof?
furrama Oct 23rd 2011 5:02PM
He was loosing a lot of blood, you can't blame him for mixing up names!
:D
furrama Oct 24th 2011 12:48AM
Losing. My goodness I wish I had read that better, now I look unintelligent.
Sorry for my bad grammar guys.
furrama Oct 23rd 2011 5:01PM
Hamuul is like the Kenny of Azeroth. Or a midboss anyway.
And I can't help but feel that Anduin is going to die this next expansion. He's such a good, perfect, well liked character, so innocent... I just think he's probably going to be killed off to further the Horde/Alliance feud. If I was in charge of the story, that's what I'd do.
RetPallyJil Oct 23rd 2011 5:18PM
It's Blizzard. He'll turn evil and be a raid boss.
Average Joe Oct 23rd 2011 5:22PM
I don't think they'll kill him off, but they'll definitely do something to make him snap... the death of his father would be a good place to start.
Revnah Oct 23rd 2011 5:35PM
Or, he could take the place that Thrall used to have - that of a faction leader who sees reason and would love to have peace between the Horde and the Alliance.
Al Oct 24th 2011 1:39AM
Hopefully he goes further than Thrall and actually works towards peace. Thrall's cool and all, but I got the feeling he was barely paying attention most of the time.
"Should I do something about those Cultists in the basement, besides throwing Level 15s at them? Why do those Night Elves hate us so much? I wonder.. where do we get all this surplus timber we don't use? And did that Cockroach just /Facepalm at me, like those last two answers should be obvious?"
Sarog Oct 23rd 2011 5:58PM
I really wish they'd write Anduin with a bit more grit. I've tried to like the kid, I really have... but damn me if he isn't the blandest, most naive character I've ever met. His "I think love outlasts everything" attitude just makes me feel like I'm five years old again, coming home from school at 12:30 to watch cartoons that teach me about sharing and being polite. I really hope that he grows up and gets his illusions shattered and becomes a proper, believable royal.
LynMars Oct 23rd 2011 7:27PM
According to the Lore panel, they had NOTHING written for him until Golden wrote this book and pulled him into the storyline. So there really is a lot of room for him to grow up.
Don't mistake idealism for naivete though. This is a kid brought up in a world of politics and court intrigue, with Onyxia on one side for a good chunk of time. He figured out something was wrong with Prestor and "Varian" before many others did. He's watched his father struggle with his split personality--and is really set up opposite of it so far, a very different person from his warrior father.
Anduin's young enough to believe in a better world and hope, all optimistic and idealistic. It does need tempered with experience and practicality, but I don't think as much naivete as some think. I for one hope he doesn't turn as growly and hateful as his father can be.
Dreyja Oct 24th 2011 12:11AM
I Fear I disagree on this one:
Really, do we want to dis-regard Anduin just because he's a Teen that is smart and sensitive? REALLY?
I work with youth (teenagers) on a regular basis and... O.M.G. Many of them do not fit the shallow stereo-type of teens!!
There are kids that are Wise Beyond Their Age. Get over it! Anduin is NOT a total mutant!
Negatron Oct 23rd 2011 7:20PM
Anduin will most likely become a powerful Priest when he comes of age. He's endured much, Golden clearly indicated that in her writing through his actions.
Hih Oct 23rd 2011 7:34PM
So.. this "temporary" position of Garrosh's is sure starting to feel... less than temporary. There's no way Blizzard can have "war between Alliance and Horde" be one of the major themes of MoP if Thrall is back as Warchief, not unless the Alliance did something stupid like kidnap his grandma and hold her hostage.
I keep hoping Thrall will take back his position, but it looks like we've got awhile to wait.
Hih Oct 23rd 2011 7:35PM
oops, reply fail. That was meant to stand alone not be in reply to someone else's comment. Wtb edit/delete button, PST!
na.alnaji Oct 24th 2011 3:21PM
I still don't want Anduin to be a priest. He's a Wrynn. He will be the strongest ruler in the Alliance someday and command its armies. He should at least be a paladin.
No, I'm not a paladin or a warrior.
Dreyja Oct 24th 2011 12:03AM
I can not to seem to give Garrosh the chance that a lot of people are willing to hive him. The Dude has shown ZERO openness to change or otherness, AT ALL. If he changes, that will be awesome. We've seen no hint of it in the lore so far.
Dreyja Oct 24th 2011 12:09AM
erg... Drey should be in bed. Ignore pls. /facepalm SELF
sheela_2 Oct 24th 2011 3:55AM
I don't think Garrosh's position as Warchief is going to be as temporary as Blizzard appeared to imply (at least from an anti-Garrosh standpoint). I mean, Thrall is probably going to take a long vacation after all that he's done for Azeroth and may desire to start a family while he can. Then we have the main plot of MoP being Horde vs. Alliance; that couldn't realistically happen without Garrosh being Warchief.
Tael Oct 24th 2011 6:20AM
The problem most players have isn't with the fact that the NPCs like Garrosh, it's with the fact we're not shown WHY. It just doesn't make sense to me that the orcs would go "sure Thrall is the first of the new shamans, he's Doomhammer's chosen heir, he helped free us from the internment camps, he brought us to a new homeland, he found us new allies in the trolls and tauren, he led us in victorious battle against the Burning Legion... but Garrosh is still cooler, 'cause HE hates the Alliance!" And as for the other races, why would they EVER side with someone who shows them nothing but contempt? Never mind that his supposed "glorious victories" in Northrend are very much an informed attribute, because all we ever see him do there is be stupidly belligerent and get Saurfang to clean up his messes.
Nagaina Oct 24th 2011 8:16AM
People complain about Thrall being Chris Metzen's Mary Sue self-insert but I'll tell you this right now: somebody on the writing staff over there has a serious hard-on for Garrosh Hellscream being the Bestest Thing EVER. The pre-Cataclysm quest-text had Thrall being treated with respect and the deference due his office as Warchief -- the post-Cataclysm quest-text has multiple NPCs outright fanboying/girling Gary H as though he's the greatest thing since goblin lube.
Unfortunately, this bleeds over into the tie-in fic, where we're supposed to buy -- appropos of the plot saying so -- that Garrosh Hellscream is massively popular with the younger members of the Horde, despite the fact that he holds everything non-orcish about that organization in blatantly obvious contempt. Further, we're supposed to believe that the younger members of the three races he explicitly regards as weak and unworthy -- the trolls, the blood elves, and the Forsaken -- almost universally support his leadership...because they're "young and hungry" and also apparently enjoy being kicked in the teeth and getting up to say, "Please, sir, may I have some more?" That was pretty much where my suspension of disbelief started cracking with "The Shattering." Garrosh's ridiculously swift rise from manky emoteen to universally admired war-hero badass leader of the Horde makes his popularity feel, and read, and play, very much like an Informed Attribute.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/InformedAttribute