The Queue: PVP, player models, and applying to WoW Insider

Man, I haven't written in a Queue (or its predecessor, Ask a Beta Tester) in a long time. It looks like my last one was in December 2009. Well, let's see if I can avoid the temptation toward extreme talkativeness here.
Nah. I like talking.
Most of the comment thread on yesterday's Queue was concerned with discussion on Mists of Pandaria or suggestions for what to name the eventual monk column, but I picked three questions past the cut to answer.
Stella asks:
A lot of people are saying that Mists of Pandaria doesn't have a story, a main enemy, or a Big Bad. I suddenly realized that we, that is the Horde and the Alliance, and our conflict is the real Big Bad of MoP ... I also gather from some of Metzen's comments that something big is coming after MoP. Something that we'll never be able to handle if we're focused on fighting each other. Am I seeing things here?
Probably not.
There's a rumor running around that Kat Hunter accidentally broke the upcoming Warcraft 4 during the BlizzCon 2011 DirecTV livestream. While I think the sound bite in question has a pretty good chance of just being a joke, the prospect of another Warcraft game does raise an interesting question about Blizzard's plans for the franchise. If the developers are planning a Warcraft 4, that story line might very well piggyback off the increased Alliance/Horde antagonism in Mists of Pandaria and then proceed to set up the next World of Warcraft expansion.
... which, when you think about it, allows Blizzard to skirt a knotty problem: How do you advance a PVP-centric story in a PVE-centric game, where most players would probably hate being forced to fight each other in order to advance their characters? The answer is to put it in another game and let players decide if they want to experience that. There are certain elements of the Warcraft story that are probably better told in an RTS than an MMORPG, and WoW's next expansion could simply pick up where Warcraft 4 ended.
But this is just a bunch of arm waving. Whether it's plausible or not is anyone's guess.
Andre asks:
How will you guys be hiring a new monk columnist? Will it take you a while to set up because you need to find somebody who's willing to learn EVERYTHING about a new class? How long did it take after Wrath for the DK column to start?
Before an expansion hits, the editors send around an email asking us if we plan to stay with our current characters, switch to an alt, or reroll entirely, and if this will affect any class columns or content we're writing. The death knight class just clicked for Daniel Whitcomb on the Wrath beta, so he left his druid and started playing his DK full time.
So Lichborne actually started in August 2008 during the Wrath of the Lich King beta, and it wouldn't surprise me if something similar happens during the Mists of Pandaria beta. Actually, it will probably happen even earlier, now that so many staffers have the annual pass and thus guaranteed access to the MoP beta. Alex Ziebart was reportedly getting texts from people eager to write for the monk column less than 10 minutes after Blizzard had revealed it.
Terrrant actually replied to Andre's comment above with something that's pertinent:
... An enterprising blogger could get into the MoP beta, start his or her own blog about the monk class, and hope WoW Insider does an open call for columnist submissions. Then you'd have your quality blog as evidence you could do the job.
Yep. While an involved article on WoW Insider's hiring practices is way beyond the scope of the Queue and my limited experience, I can tell you folks a few things:
- When an existing staffer can't write a column, we'll open applications. You'll see an article on the site describing what we need and the application/column requirements.
- Things that will help your chances Running a blog on the class or spec in question, posting a lot of thoughtful comments on the official forums or a site like Elitist Jerks, and/or writing a really kick-ass application will all give you an advantage. (I should stress that we don't expect you to have blogged previously, although it does give us a preview of your "voice" as a writer and, just as importantly, how you react to commenters.) Raid experience is a major plus, though obviously we won't expect you to have raided on a monk.
- Things that will not help your chances Being a jerk to others on your blog or Twitter, trolling us or other sites, accusing the developers of being unable to pour piss out of a boot with instructions written on the heel, and/or just being someone who's likely to cause problems if employed here. Remember, folks: We've all got Google, and we're 5% less stupid than we look.
- Even if you run a successful blog, keep in mind that making the transition from being an independent blogger to a professional one is a lot harder than you'd think. Writing whatever you want whenever you want bears only a faint resemblance to writing to deadlines and editorial requests.
Does ANYONE truly feel like they will be "too attached to their model if they are changed" because I for one don't care how they fix it, but they just NEED to be updated.
Robin kind of answered this one for me. The problem for Blizzard isn't so much redesigning the older races -- it's redesigning them without losing the stuff that made players want to roll them in the first place. I think Dea ex Machina also has an unfortunate point concerning player psychology in that "the way the character 'looks' is at least partly in your head," and that artists may "update" your character into something that no longer feels the same. Players aren't attached to low-poly models as such, but they're generally pretty attached to characters they've often played for years.
Hell, they're even attached to characters they don't play. As an example, you might want to compare the comment threads on the update to Sylvanas Windrunner's model with that of Jaina Proudmoore's. Response was overwhelmingly positive to the new Sylvanas, but a lot more equivocal on the new Jaina ... and these are just NPCs. Unsurprisingly, Blizzard is picking its way very, very carefully through the minefield of player characters.
I rolled my gray-furred, green-eyed female Tauren druid on the first day I ever played the game and have changed her very little since then. To me, she looks intelligent and observant, and I really hope that Blizzard's artists can update her without losing these essential traits.
Filed under: The Queue






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 17)
Jamie Oct 24th 2011 11:02AM
Welcome back to the general insanity that is The Queue, Allison!
Stay away from the punch. The cookies are delicious though.
MattKrotzer Oct 24th 2011 11:19AM
Also, we have pie. But stay away from the brownies, unless you don't need to get anything done for a few hours.
Jamie Oct 24th 2011 11:26AM
I had the brownies once. Found myself in a tree screaming at people saying "I AM THE CAT MAN".
They had to get a fireman to rescue me from the tree. To this day, I have no idea how I got in that tree. Although I was convinced I had rocket boots, that would explain a lot.
Daco Oct 24th 2011 11:56AM
Better than Fox's ritual "I am a Golden God!" moments though.
Jamie Oct 24th 2011 12:01PM
And that's why you stay away from the punch.
devilsei Oct 24th 2011 1:29PM
So... what happens if you have the punch and brownie afterwords...? Or dipped the brownie in the punch...?! Or took a few brownies, mushed them together to make a cup, then poured yourself some of the punch into the brownie cup and drank/ate it?!
Peebers Oct 24th 2011 11:03AM
how come much of the same people that cry about blizz just tryin to get all the money they can, also bash occupyers for fighting big business? I mean, i see nothin wrong with cozying up to china a lil bit.
Peebers Oct 24th 2011 11:11AM
omg i apologize! completely blatant troll bait. trade chat got ripe real early this morning and i got a bit frustrated. mornin all!
Jamie Oct 24th 2011 12:02PM
And that's why you stay away from the punch.
MattKrotzer Oct 24th 2011 12:04PM
Jamie, I think that comment could be applied to SO many things here. I think you should make that your thing... like Shinae's /duck.
Shinae Oct 24th 2011 12:21PM
Amaxe has the /duck. I agree that Jamie's onto something there.
/pat Peebers
MattKrotzer Oct 24th 2011 12:50PM
Yeah. I don't know why I always get Shinae and Amaxe confused... But it happens every time I reference one of them....
Either way, I'd take it as a compliment... you're both great posters.
Joyous_Oblivion Oct 24th 2011 1:13PM
I really respect the fact he called himself out and apologized, the Internet would be so much nicer if more could do the same :)
SChristie Oct 24th 2011 11:06AM
With the introduction of the Monk class, do you think Blizz will extend the 10 Character per server limit to accomodate the extra class? Seeing as many people may already have a character of each class at some stage or another.
Thanks
Peebers Oct 24th 2011 11:13AM
enjoy that $3.99 extra slot. sounds fair enough to me actually. idk maybe even 3 slots. cuz c'mon you need 1 for the gnome monk and another for the panda spriest.
Leroy Oct 24th 2011 11:23AM
I saw the response to this in one of the WoWInsider liveblogs. Blizz say that this is something they are always considering and trying to figure out what to do. They said one of the things being talked about is keeping the total cap across all servers (50, I think) but removing the cap on individual servers. Nothing definite right now, though, but they are looking at the issue.
djsuursoo Oct 24th 2011 11:38AM
i've actually got one class doubled up(i could NEVER get into the priests, at all, ever, so i wound up with two paladins and one will get dumped in favor of possibly a monk), so i could drop one, and while my warrior is in the 60s and pretty capable... warriors feel RIDICULOUSLY stale and static. so far there's nothing to really sell me on the class anymore, and from talking with friends with high end warriors, there's nothing coming up that would redeem it for me. they're fun from 1-60, but best taken in small, short doses. once i re-rolled my DK and started tanking, my warrior started collecting dust.
so thusly i myself have two spots ready to roll.
so maybe a monk(no idea what race as gnome monks are going to be EVERYWHERE), and very probably a pandarian enhancement shaman. the thought of a massive chubby panda swigging beer and smashing everything in sight with dual hammers tickles my fancy.
though i could forgo the monk for a panda mage...
also: best name ever for an all-monk guild: Clan of the Waist Down Fist. obviously gnome monks only.
Peebers Oct 24th 2011 12:11PM
thanks leroy for clearing that up. i didnt really get what they meant when i read about taking the cap off individual servers. pretty sollid option. i hope they pull it off.
Dementron Oct 26th 2011 7:42PM
@Peebers- $4 for an extra slot I could see. I really hope they wouldn't do that, but it could be worse.
Before I played WoW, I played FFXI. On that you got ONE character slot. Additional slots were $1 a month. Each. -_-
All in all, keeping the overall cap and loosening the per world cap would probably be the best way to go. C'mon Blizz, don't make me delete another one of mah babies just so I can have a panda.
Sidvicious Oct 24th 2011 11:05AM
In order to be able to download the full Diablo III game for free when it comes out, as a World of Warcraft subscriber do I need to sign up for 12 consecutive months of just continue to be a subscriber until the release date? Seems to me that there trying to keep people subscribed to WoW for the time it takes to play Star Wars the old republic get bored of it and come back to Warcraft.