Two Bosses Enter: Aethas Sunreaver vs. Roanauk Icemist

In last week's thrilling episode of Two Bosses Enter, Scryer head honcho Voren'thal the Seer went head-to-head against Yorg Stormheart, king of the Frostborn dwarves. Vorenthal's magister abilities were not match for the dwarven mountain king and his crazy hammer of jormungar bashing. Yorg Stormheart, also known as Muradin Bronzebeard, easily trounced this round, giving the dwarf a bona fide win.
This week's matchup signals the end of the first round of exhibition season one with an all-Horde fight between Archmage Aethas Sunreaver of the Sunreaver faction versus Roanauk Icemist, proud taunka chieftain of the Dragonblight. Aethas' leadership, vigilence, and savvy goes up against the brute strength and cunning of an elder taunka warrior. Only you readers have the power to decide who goes on to the next round.
Vote now -- the fate of the universe depends on your action.
| Archmage Aethas Sunreaver (The Sunreavers) | |
|---|---|
| Roanauk Icemist (The Taunka) |
The rules of the ring
- The WoW Insider Ring is considered neutral territory, where both combatants are able to access their usual encounter mechanics and abilities. If you can't visualize it inside the squared circle, visualize it someplace else -- but you must take into consideration all of each bosses' abilities and mechanics.
- Assume that each opponent is intelligent and capable of strategic thinking.
- All of the competitors' abilities, including crowd control and other effects to which bosses are usually immune, work on their opponents (with apologies to considerations of lore on this point).
- Assume that the opponents share similar levels, health pools, and comparative overall damage output.
- Don't get caught up in gameplay mechanics and what actual players might do in each encounter.
- Don't neglect style, story, and scale. Everything is a factor; seeking balance is your goal as a spectator and judge.

Archmage Aethas Sunreaver is an incredibly powerful mage and leader in the Kirin Tor, sitting on the Council of Six leadership of Dalaran. After the events of Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne and Kael'thas Sunstrider's departure from the Council of Six, the tensions between the Horde-aligned blood elves and the humans and high elves of the Kirin Tor were at a high point. Through Aethas' work and membership as a mage of the Council of Six, he got the blood elves back in the good graces of Dalaran. These followers eventually called themselves the Sunreavers after their leader and worked to get the Horde itself welcome in the floating city.
Aethas Sunreaver has had a feud with Grand Magister Rommath of Silvermoon, both differing on their attitudes toward the Kirin Tor mages. These two heavy personalities come to an agreement during the Quel'dalar quest line in Wrath of the Lich King, with both Rommath and Sunreaver expressing great joy if a blood elf brings them the broken blade. Both very much wish for the blood elves to put Quel'dalar back in the hands of one of their own.
Here are some cool things about Aethas Sunreaver:
- He's a powerful mage. The Kirin Tor Council of Six is the best of the best, once called home by such mage luminaries as Kel'Thuzad, Kael'thas Sunstrider, Arugal, Krasus, and their current leader, Rhonin.
- He wielded cross-faction power. Sunreaver was so persuasive in his arguments that he went to the Kirin Tor and got the Horde their own quarter in Dalaran, much to the dismay of Vereesa Windrunner.
- He wears awesome armor. Aethas Sunreaver appears in mage tier 8, one of the best sets ever.
- Many people think he is redeemed Kael'thas. Could be? Probably not. Keep the mask on, buddy.

There is no bigger, badder, or more stalwart hero of the taunka people of Northrend than Roanauk Icemist. After his home, Icemist Village, was completely overrun and destroyed by the Scourge, Roanauk was captured and held prisoner. Eventually, players free him, and he proceeds to enact swift vengeance on his captors. Roanauk ends the Scourge occupation of his precious village and leads his people into the arms of the Horde for honor, protection, and value.
As we found out in Wrath of the Lich King, the taunka people are a different breed, both figuratively and literally, than the tauren native to Kalimdor. The taunka bend the elements' will around them, choosing an active life to one where the weather and climate would take them if they didn't act against it. Roanauk is no exception. He is a man of honor and power, leading his people as best he can amidst a never ending invasion of the undead.
Here are some cool things about Roanauk Icemist:
- He's a taunka hero. Tauren players were very happy during Wrath to get some cool tauren lore as well as get to be best friends with the new taunka heroes.
- He kicks scourge butt. Roanauk stands with the player side by side, fighting off wave after wave of Scourge invaders.
- He's an ally of the Horde. Roanauk and his people, after players' help, become full-fledged members of the Horde in an awesome induction ceremony at Agmar's Hammer.
- The Icemist clan has a town named after it, Icemist Village.

Poor, poor Voren'thal. You just had to have your first round against a Bronzebeard, didn't you? It's a shame, really. Leader of an army, friend of a naaru, and keeper of a ton of those tomes I turned in for reputation with his faction, all for nothing. Reader Jaq thought that this fight was a pretty simple one to call, on account of Yorg Stormheart's beating a jormungar in the face with a giant hammer after using his avatar ability:
"Yorg used the Avatar ability to grow real big and smash a jormungar in the face. Kaboom."I can't say I disagree. Yorg is a resilient little bugger who smashes pretty good with that hammer. And, let's be honest, avatar is one of the coolest abilities in Warcraft history. I can't say I'm surprised.
Even if he wasn't really Muradin, this one thing would be reason enough for him to win.
GrandOldDuke makes a good point -- Yorg has technically sort of maybe already died once and then didn't:
Given his proven ability to get up after being killed, even if Voren'thal had an advantage initially, Yorg has to win.You know, I didn't think of that. Now that's resilience! Not only has Yorg survived the blast from the reawakening of Frostmourne but also the harsh weather of Northrend and the aforementioned jormungar. To put a point in Voren'thal's favor, though, sitting out in the cold never gave you protection against fire and the arcane. You can only cover yourself in so much snow before the mage decides to use a different school of spells.
Eventually.
kyneska0 brought up Voren'thal's potential fragility and illness as a concern that might push the favor in Yorg's direction:
I do love Voren'thal--he's one of my favourite lore characters--and he has the added bonus of being a bookish male blood elf. Two thumbs way up.Have you been to Terokkar? There are a million moths all over the place, huge ones, and all they do every hour of every day is pump moth dust and spores into the air. Terokkar is killer on the allergies, and you can bet that Voren'thal has some sort of asthma. It's his hardship. If you spent one day in Terokkar forest, you would die from inhaling too much moth byproduct. Poor guy is just congested.
But realistically, he's going down. I mean, Sypmaster Thalodien says:
"Make sure Voren'thal doesn't topple over with excitement from the news - the old man's getting a bit fragile..."
And he himself admits:
"My frail health prevents me from aiding you in person with this endeavor."
So unless Voren'thal is going to put us through grinding rep--again--by killing his enemies--again--I'll hand this one to Yorg.
I'm sure he'll at least be gracious in defeat.
Sigh.
So there you have it -- an easy, solid win for Yorg Stormheart. For now, though, you should all be voting on who wins this week's matchup and decide which of these contenders goes on to the next round.
| Voren'thal (The Scryers) | |
|---|---|
| Yorg Stormheart (The Frostborn) |
Filed under: Two Bosses Enter






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
clundgren Dec 5th 2011 7:35PM
"Aethas" wins this one hands down. But you're not fooling anyone with that mask, buddy.
Kylenne Dec 6th 2011 6:19AM
I love how this crack ass theory is honest to god fanon now.
I'm not being sarcastic either, I genuinely think it's hilarious. (and secretly hope it's true, just for the lulz)
Al Dec 5th 2011 7:55PM
Going with Roanauk.
If we assume the fan theory to be correct, "Aethas" will do what he always does: Realise he might have to fight, give a Setback Speech, and run away to cosy up to someone with more power to do the fighting for him. He's almost of options there, too.
Assuming he's just some Blood Elf Mage who's keeping his mask on to hide his embarassing haircut: He still takes a beating.
jonahb Dec 6th 2011 12:35AM
Ok lets just do it like this.
Fury warrior versus Mage
If he's fire or frost Roanuk is toast in seconds. If hes arcane then its an even fight but hes pvp flagged so hes obviously frost.
I mean can't you see it in your mind.
Warrior spots mage and foolishly attempts to move to charge range.
frost bolt, deep freeze, ice lance ice lance ice lance ice lance.....and hes dead.
NekoDaimyo Dec 6th 2011 1:58AM
He is far moar than a simple fury warrior. Prolly a plate wearing shaman, when properly kitted out.
Wait, why's that sound familiar?
magic.swordsman Dec 5th 2011 8:06PM
Anyone else still a bit annoyed Horde got essentially a new sub faction to join them with the Taunka, whereas Alliance dealt with walrus men...who were neutral to both sides.
Al Dec 5th 2011 8:43PM
A little, but the Taunka got promptly "Draenei'd", so it didn't matter in the long run.
clundgren Dec 5th 2011 9:35PM
Must we look for Horde favoritism everywhere these days?
In Cataclysm, the Alliance got TWO new sub-factions, the Highborne and Dark Irons. Anyone annoyed by it?
If we try to keep score on every little thing it becomes ridiculous. We're not three.
Ilmyrn Dec 5th 2011 11:22PM
We also got the Frostborn in Wrath, who were (or should have been) much cooler than the Taunka.
Both got pretty well forgotten come Cat though.
calork Dec 6th 2011 1:59AM
Horde had to deal with the walrus men too you know...
Omegan01 Dec 6th 2011 3:50AM
I agree with clundgren in that it's not necessary to drag faction balance into every single discussion. Buuuuuuuuuuuuut-
That said, I think the fact that someone can equate the taunka to the tuskarr without even sparing a thought to the frost dwarves speaks volumes about how the two races were implemented.
Consider-
The taunka appeared in 5 of Wrath's 7 zones: BT, HF, DB, GH, and SP with quest chains in each, and several of their npc's showed up at the Argent Trounament. Both had breadcrumb questgivers in or near the initial quest hubs, meaning it was pretty easy to find your way to the taunka story. Roanauk's rescue was a fairly major quest/event, and the battle with the north wind and the story of Xarantaur was pretty epic as well.
The Frostborn, on the other hand, appeared in one zone (SP) with one quest hub. There was no breadcrumb unless you worked your way through K3, which not everyone did. It was worth finding, though, with an epic eagle-riding hammer-throwing quest chain where you proved your worth, and of course the story of Muradin Bronzebeard.
Since Wrath, the taunka have had little impact- there's one of them in the earthen ring and that's about all. Personally, I find the lack of Frostborn more obnoxious. It's irritating to see the dwarves going through a massive reunification story and not have a single frost dwarf anywhere in IF, especially with Muradin being there now.
Anyway, to wrap this up, I'm not going to harp on faction bias, but I really do feel that the Frostborn got pretty shafted compared to the taunka.
Jabadabadana Dec 5th 2011 8:16PM
I had to be reminded who Aethas was.
Whereas Roanauk is a Big Damn Hero, and legally on par with other faction leaders. He can mass rez half a village, and take the beating of a major scourge, and come up swinging. They never explain how he gets shackled into that prison, but I'm going to bet it was done by someone bigger than the nerubians.
A bit of magic, and a silver tongue does not save Aethas in this one. Besides, even if he is kaelthas, we've beaten that skinny elf's head in twice, and I'm not to impressed by his chances against surviving another drubbing by Roanauk.
GhostWhoWalks Dec 5th 2011 8:39PM
This one was a difficult call. Both are awesome characters; Aethas wields impressive political influence and is apparently skilled enough with magic that he can hand out quests in Angmar's Hammer while still sitting in on Council meetings, while Roanauk's appearance is short-lived but leaves a lasting impression.
In the end, I have to give the vote to Aethas, since Roanauk isn't around long enough to give more credibility to his badassery.
Matthew Dec 5th 2011 8:58PM
Jaina vs Aegwynn - can we see this next time?
icepyro Dec 5th 2011 9:19PM
I'm not entirely sure of this mage. Sure, his powers are obviously impressive, but can he withstand being chained and watch as half his village is killed in front of him? Can he break free (with player help), fend off wave after wave of Scourge while still weakened from his torment, mass res half the village, still have the strength to fight the leader of that Scourge invasion after all that and win? Does he have the humility to recognize the players brave efforts to give him the chance to do that and then take your advice to kneel before an Overlord that he could probably beat in combat? Does he have the honor to lead an entire (sub)race of warriors as they descend on the very gates of the citadel?
Diplomacy is one thing. Arcane power is one thing. But infamy? Now there's a power that can overcome any setback.
Needless to say, as I said when this tournament was mentioned. I will always vote for Roanauk and I still believe he is the right choice even in this battle.
Awesome Dec 5th 2011 11:19PM
Roanauk, just cuz he is a Taunka, which is a badass, already badass Tauren
Ilmyrn Dec 5th 2011 11:24PM
Wait, people think Aethas is Kael'thas? Really?
Really?
I don't know about the rest of you, but I lopped of good ol' Kael's head way back when. How'd he get better from THAT? And how do people suppose he became so popular with the Kirin Tor that he got the Horde invited inside?
Al Dec 6th 2011 1:27AM
Same way he got better from 25 people killing him in Tempest Keep.
Kylenne Dec 6th 2011 6:17AM
Decapitation was merely a setback. It didn't stop Zalazane, either.
Omegan01 Dec 6th 2011 4:09AM
I gave serious thought to this one. It's not really an easy choice.
First, Roanauk Icemist.
His strengths are pretty obvious- he's a pretty tough shaman, able to resurrect a dozen fallen warriors and call on the winds to leap high into the air, bringing down a foe from his perch.
On the other hand, Roanauk was clearly unable to prevent the overrunning of Icemist Village in the first place, and was captured by the Nerubians needing us to spring his fuzzy butt. Short of pledging himself and his people to the Horde he seemed at a loss to aid his people himself, and since the taunka story pretty much ends there we don't really know if he turned that around or not.
Now, Aethas Sunreaver.
Aethas, of course, is hard to judge since we've never seen him in combat. On the other hand, we can infer a bit about him from his position - a member of the Kirin Tor in Dalaran. Dalaran is the city of mages, and the six members at the top of the Kirin Tor are considered to be the best, most powerful archmages amongst the people of the city, highly respected for their expertise and knowledge. He's clearly a driven individual, as he was able to reintegrate the blood elves to Dalaran and establish good ties with the Argent Crusade despite the opposition of the Silver Covenant.
---
After much consideration, I've decided to toss my vote in to Aethas. Roanauk, for all his impressive feats of strength, strikes me as a bit of a big fish in a small pond. The taunka were isolated from the world at large for a long time, and as a result their strength, population, and prestige is comparatively small. Aethas, however, not only thrived but rose to the very top of the biggest heap of mages in the world, even despite the wars that erupted and the racial hatred he had to face.
...in retrospect, this almost strikes me as the scenario of Luke Skywalker vs Darth Vader in Cloud City - a farmboy from the hedges, talented but ultimately new to the world at large versus a practiced master of the art, a powerful figure known throughout the world.
Somebody start working on a new hoof for Roanauk.