Know Your Lore: Archbishop Benedictus of the Holy Light

The Church of Light. Central to the hearts and minds of most of the humans of Azeroth, it has stood as a bedrock of philosophy and faith for humankind throughout the madness of the orcish invasion, the war to restore Stormwind, and to the present day. The heroes who have borne the standard of the Light are many: General Turalyon, Uther the Lightbringer, Tirion Fordring, Alonsus Faol. It has endured betrayals from some of its best and brightest, such as Prince Arthas Menethil. It has sunk its roots into the very souls of humanity and been their beacon and their deliverance from evil.
In Stormwind today, the heart of the Church of Light is the grand Cathedral that dominates the eponymous district. The head of the Church of Light is Archbishop Benedictus, successor to Alonsus Faol, and it is Benedictus who has served as the rock of the faith. During the years that King Varian Wrynn was missing, when dragons and orcs menace Stormwind, Benedictus stood as a shining example, sending young heroes across the sea to root out the Scourge in Razorfen Downs. Even after the King's return and the assault of the very elements on Stormwind, Benedictus used his faith in the Light to defend his city and his people.
The following post contains spoilers for Patch 4.3, especially the Hour of Twilight dungeon and the novel Thrall, Twilight of the Aspects.
Before the Light
Benedictus wasn't born an archbishop, of course. We know that he was a student of Alonsus Faol, the great figure who saw the need to train warriors to help defend humanity from the invasion of the orcish Horde during the First and Second War. Faol's Holy Order of Northshire Clerics would become both the foundation for the Silver Hand and the modern Church of Light.
Some claim that Benedictus was born a merchant's son named Jarl. A native of Lordaeron, he embraced the Holy Light after a chance meeting with an old traveler. A pack of mercenaries nearly slew them both, and he petitioned to join the Church in order to repay the Light for his survival. Upon so doing, he met and became the student of Faol, after the great Archbishop's triumph in creating the Order of the Silver Hand and reforming the Church of the Holy Light.
Faol was either a native of Stratholme or first rose to prominence there. He was Bishop Faol at the time he met Uther. The others who would become the first paladins (Turalyon, Gavinrad the Dire, Saiden Dathrohan, Uther himself and Tirion Fordring) were all recruited from members of the Holy Order who had survived the evacuation of Northshire following the destruction of Stormwind.
Following the Second War, Faol returned to Stormwind and began work on a new home for the growing Church of the Holy Light, with Benedictus in tow as his loyal student, ally and friend. While the dream for the structure was Faol's, Benedictus did much of the work of rallying its construction. Together, the two men helped raise money not only to build the Cathedral but also to help rebuild Stormwind. When Faol died (seemingly of old age), Benedictus took on the mantle of Archbishop and consecrated the newly constructed home to the Holy Light to Faol himself, who had been teacher and mentor not only to himself personally but to many of the greatest heroes of the wars.

During the Third War, Stormwind found itself isolated, as the rest of humanity's kingdoms sealed themselves away, were lost to the Scourge and the Burning Legion, or were simply lost as if they had never been. Benedictus kept up Faol's example during this trying time, although like the rest of the city, he could do little but watch the flood of refugees from once-great Lordaeron and minister to his people. After the war's end, Benedictus served as a stable element in a city reeling from crisis to crisis, with a King missing, a child on the throne and treachery behind the scenes. He wasn't too busy to help those in need or so passive that he would allow threats to Stormwind to pass.
Even in a city where the House of Nobles had caused tension with the trade unions and the common man often distrusted those who ruled them, very few would say anything against Archbishop Benedictus. When King Varian Wrynn returned, he found in Benedictus a spiritual advisor and ready ear.

Sadly, not all was as it seemed. For the former student of Faol, the kindly and stalwart Archbishiop, the great leader and pastor for all of the Church of the Holy Light and bastion of Stormwind was no longer the real Benedictus.
We don't know when Benedictus turned. Was he the mysterious Black Bishop who tried to destroy Stormwind Cathedral? We know that the irony of subverting a man to destroy his own life's work would appeal to the Old Gods. It's clear that Benedictus, who lost most of his family to the Scourge during the Third War, was potentially primed to lose his faith and fall prey to the Twilight's Hammer message of destroying and remaking the world in a more perfect manner. For a man such as Benedictus, who had done so much for so many yet failed those closest to him, what good was the Light if he couldn't use it to save his closest loved ones? Benedictus himself says, "I looked into the eyes of the Dragon, and I despaired." Did it happen during the Elemental Invasion, when Deathwing came to Stormwind and destroyed the park, or before? We don't know. What we do know is that a once-good man fell to doubt, then anguish, and finally turned his back on the ethos he'd spent his life defending.
Some argue that it was all a sham from the start, that Jarl petitioned to join the Church always intending to betray it, that Archbishop Faol's death was suspicious and engineered to get Benedictus in a position of power. The truth hasn't been revealed yet, but I doubt it, based on Benedictus' words when he confronts Thrall: "If only you'd seen what I've seen, then you'd understand."

Despite everything, however, in the end Benedictus died a victim of the madness that had driven him so far from the Light he'd once served, cut down by the heroes of Azeroth escorting the World-Shaman to his destined confrontation with the Aspect of Death. So ended the life of Jarl, a merchant's son from Lordaeron, who embraced the Holy Light only to die in darkness through his own actions. He lived a beacon, an example to many of faith and righteousness, someone they trusted in. If only he hadn't seen what he'd seen.
While you don't need to have played the previous Warcraft games to enjoy World of Warcraft, a little history goes a long way toward making the game a lot more fun. Dig into even more of the lore and history behind the World of Warcraft in WoW Insider's Guide to Warcraft Lore.
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Lore, Know your Lore, Cataclysm






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
Zyxt Dec 7th 2011 9:25AM
Excellent article Mr. Rossi (and I believe a "happy birthday" is in order too, no?).
I have a question about the Archbishop: in the dungeon, he starts off using the Light to assault Thrall. Do you think that is because he still believes in the Light, or only so far as to use it as a weapon against those that would stand against his mission?
Catsmeow Dec 7th 2011 9:54AM
I am not sure, but I think that he only uses the Light as a means to an ends. He has gone so far beyond his own dogma, that he truly believes what he tells us before that battle, that there is no Light, there is no Dark, there is only Power.
earthexile Dec 7th 2011 9:46AM
We've seen the Light used by corrupt people before - the Blood Knights before their redemption, one of the Four Horsemen in Naxxramas, Paladins of the Scarlet Crusade, etc.
It could be that practitioners of the Light retain the knowledge and ability to utilize it, even when they've turned their back on their old idealogies. Or, and this seems more likely to me, maybe the Light operates on a higher understanding of morality and motive than mortal sectarian conflict.
Maybe, as we saw in the Sunwell, the Light allows itself to be used by bad people, or for the wrong reasons, in the hope of redeeming fallen mortals.
Or maybe it's an illusion, created by Benedictus to maintain his cover. Who knows?
shomechely Dec 7th 2011 9:57AM
I think Benedictus believes in the Light and so he can still wield it, but is egotistical enough to think he knows how to use it best and so chooses to use it against Thrall. Lots of "bad guys" use the Light to damage our heroes and others (I'm looking at you Whitemane).
LynMars Dec 7th 2011 10:27AM
Unlike traditional fantasy faiths where a deity has to give the practitioner the power, the Light as taught by the Human/Dwarven/High Elven Cathedral is a philosophy based on tapping into the holy power that flows through the life of the universe, affected by the practitioner's own willpower.
That's why Scarlets and other corrputed people could still use it; while they fell far from the Church's philosophy of benevolence and twisted the idea of making the world better through their own actions, they still had the knowledge and the will to work with the energy.
Even if his faith was shattered, Benedictus' will seemed to be mostly intact, though he reverts to Shadow in the second half of the fight (which always strikes me as a more psychic power in the hands of a priest, given the mental themes of the spells, so again likely linked to willpower in a way).
Hal Dec 7th 2011 10:44AM
Although, isn't the lore behind gnomish priests that they figured out how to "manipulate" (for lack of a better term) the light the way they could with the arcane?
Xantenise Dec 7th 2011 10:49AM
All evidence I've seen in WoW shows that Holy Light is just another kind of magic, one that humans worship. And why wouldn't they worship it? It can heal, bring people back from the dead. You don't need to believe in it to use it. It's just magic. It's just magic that inspired a religion.
In the end, Na'aru (sp?) are pretty much Light elementals the same way you get Arcane elementals.
Pazazu Dec 7th 2011 11:45AM
It's canon that ability to use the Light depends only on the user's belief in his or her ability to use it, which is why the less-than-holy groups mentioned by @earthexile can do so.
Matthew Rossi Dec 7th 2011 2:18PM
Yes, it is my birthday. Thank you. Back to my Skyrim cave now.
Jawn Dec 7th 2011 3:16PM
@ Pazazu
If there's one thing i've understood in the game, it's that - other than historical events - cannon does not necessarily mean absolute game fact. The only thing that is cannon about having faith to manipulate the Light, is that this is what is currently believed by the Church of the Holy Light. It doesn't, however, mean that they are right.
If people would understand this, there would be a lot less people going "lol retcon!" about changes in understanding of how the game world is.
budjb Dec 7th 2011 9:33AM
Or, perhaps, in his example and service to his people, he should have seen what THEY saw. Faith is not true if that faith is so easily broken.
xvkarbear Dec 7th 2011 9:39AM
I'm tired of killing people who are victims of maddness, mild controlled, or otherwise was once a Good Person and some outside force made them Bad.
I wanna kill people who are all out evil because they are. Because someone killed their loved one and they want revenge. Someone who doesn't want to destroy the world but someone who wants to rule it and take it by force if needed.
Don't get me wrong, I love the old gods and the concept of them. I just want more then the same shtick.
I know we're kind of getting this with the Sha in Pandaria.. but I remain skeptical. =/
Hierakles Dec 7th 2011 10:11AM
Sounds like the Defias, more specifically Vanessa VanCleff are right up your alley.
Matt P Dec 7th 2011 10:48AM
@Hierakles
I think you need to read the Defias and Vanessa's backstories more closely. I wouldn't say they are evil just for evil's sake by any means.
xvkarbear Dec 7th 2011 11:03AM
Vanessa fits the revenge for killed loved one..
but I was thinking on a much grander scale then westfall. :)
Boobah Dec 7th 2011 11:13AM
Real people (and realistic characters) aren't 'evil for evil's sake.' I know it's trite, but it's no less true: everyone is the hero of their own story. They fight the good fight, for good reasons. They may be wrong, or deluded, or just have wildly divergent values from you and/or your society. None of that means they don't believe they have good reason to do what they do.
xvkarbear Dec 7th 2011 11:24AM
@Boobah
I agree that evil for evil sake is a matter of perception.
But there's a difference between Azshara and her Highborne.. and say Deathwing.
Azshara wants to wipe out all the races on Azeroth because she thinks they're lesser then she is. Outside looking in, that's evil for purely selfish gain.
Deathwing wants to destroy the world because he's *insane*. The Old Gods drove him mad.
Arthas was an interesting villain in that he was crafty and sane. But he still fits the good guy turned bad from outside influence. He thought he was doing a good thing until way past the point of which he could turn back. You could also argue that the Lich King is evil to be evil, since it's a force of evil energy bent on ruling the world. But we didn't get much Lich King as we did the humans Arthas aspect of him.
Illidan is more a victim then a villain. He's ambitious and headstrong. He's just got SERIOUSLY bad judgement.
The Burning Legion and Sargeras is very much evil to be evil/their evil is perception based. But we're not going to attack the heart of the Burning Legion for a few expansions.
Matt P Dec 7th 2011 11:49AM
@Xvkarbear
Arthas didn't need much of a push. Even when I was playing through Warcraft III, I thought he didn't do what he did out of a sense of duty, but because of the glory he could potentially gain. Once he became a death knight, we saw his true nature with out any of the artifice and rationalization. Pretty good villain, agreed.
Pyromelter Dec 7th 2011 2:47PM
XV, I think you are barking up the wrong tree. Blizzard stories always have that sort of eastern storytelling mechanic of "no one is ever truly evil or truly good" kind of thing*. The Starcraft campaigns illustrate that idea beautifully, it seems to be the way Chris Metzen likes telling stories, and he's damn good at it.
You'll probably have to look outside the blizzard universe of games to get that kind of story
*I never played through diablo, so I can't speak for that series, but that's how it is in Starcraft and Warcraft
Kierbuu Dec 7th 2011 9:22PM
You know when the "Black Bishop" first started to make the rounds during Beta I was kind of pulling for Brother Crowley, a little known NPC in the Cathedral of Light's catacombs. He is listed as the Scarlet Crusade's emissary. I was thinking it would be kind of fun if after watching the Crusade get slaughtered in Northrend, those in the Plaguelands fall to undeath, and then seeing the Crowley family home of Gilneas fall to the Forsaken, Crowley would just give up on it all. He would decide that if this world was going to kill everything he loved, he would kill this world. Sign up with the Twilight Hammer and help them destroy everything from inside Stormwind's most sacred place.