How to profit off Winter Veil

Winter Veil is probably one of the most profitable game holidays. There are lots of achievements and quests people do, and some of these involve acquiring things that can be sold on the Auction House. The most interesting thing is that none of the things people will be needing require a maximum-level character to get and are, in fact, farmable by just about anyone over level 6 or so.
Small Eggs
Let's start with Small Eggs. Five of these are used to make the five Gingerbread Cookies required for the holiday quest Treats for Greatfather Winter. Small eggs are easily farmed, but the demand for them between Dec. 15 and Jan. 2 is more than can reasonably be farmed by any one person. People in the know have been preparing since last year and have stockpiled these eggs.
That said, the bulk needed to meet the demand generated by just about every single active player doing this quest on all their characters is pretty high, and these eggs don't come up on the Auction House that often for cheap. For the next few days until demand drops off a bit, people will buy these for between 2g and 5g, and if you have a character capable of killing level 6 monsters, you can farm hundreds an hour in Eversong Woods outside Silvermoon.
It's best to put stacks of five and one on the AH. People will buy singles if they have some already, and the stacks of five will sell briskly to people who don't have any in their inventory. Remember that you don't always have to be the cheapest auction to make a sale. You can sell a high quantity by being cheaper than the largest volume posted; for example, if the lowest price is 2g but there are only about 30 eggs at that price, you could post yours for 4g and they'd still sell. Demand for these is very elastic because if the price gets too high, people will just go and farm it themselves. Decide whether you'd rather move a smaller volume for a higher price or a large volume for a smaller price.
Monopolists, beware: Buying out everyone below your chosen fixed price is a very bad plan here unless you choose a low enough price that people are still willing to buy. If you force the price up to, for example, 10g an egg, you'll stop most people from buying them and find more and more eggs posted for 5g, as people realize that you're buying everything below 10g. The higher you try to fix a price, the more risk you have of ending up with a ton of stock that cost you a lot more to acquire than your competition paid.
Ice Cold Milk
Bear with me on this one. Ice Cold Milk is purchasable at the inn for a couple of copper, but some people are too lazy to look up where it comes from and will simply buy it at the AH -- enough of them that the average price per milk on the AH is up to 90s each at the time this was written.
This market is a little strange. Like vendor recipes and sometimes Dust of Disappearance, when people are sometimes willing to pay more at the AH than they would at a vendor, the market dynamic is very different than what we're used to in the world of crafted or farmed goods. There's no limit to supply, so in theory, anyone with the time and bag space to do this could post thousands of milk on the AH for a couple of percent above cost and it would never be worth selling.
That said, this takes time and bag space and doesn't generate a reward other than knowing that people unwilling to walk 30 seconds to get to an inn can now get the same price as people willing to walk 30 seconds to get to an inn. Long story short, the supply is generally limited by the reward inherent from selling the milk, so when it's higher priced, there's more of an incentive to buy and list, but when it's low, it's not worth the trouble.
Crafting
Everyone working on achievements is going to try to get some Winter Clothes crafted. These are made with a ton of Runecloth and some Woolen Cloth. The boots are crafted from Wool and Rugged Leather. If you have any of these mats in your bank, you'll find that they sell for many times more now than they normally do. If you're a low-level character looking for some easy money, farming Wool and Runecloth can be done in lower-level instances, often soloable, depending on your level. Wool, in particular, comes from The Stockade, a low-level instance with its entrance in Stormwind. Horde players who can fly should be able to fly straight in without much trouble if they can avoid the flying guards.
Speaking of holiday-spirit city infiltration, there's a small but affluent market of people who like wearing things you can't get without some pain. The vendors who sell these recipes sell green clothes in Horde cities and red clothes in Alliance cities. They're not picky about who they sell to, though. If you can fly in fast enough and get to them, you can pick up the recipe from your opposite factions' vendors. If it helps, here's a macro that you can bind to a button or that will buy the recipe without forcing you to find it on the vendor: "/run BuyMerchantItem(10,1)"
Changes since last year
Last year, we were able to turn Deeprock Salt into Preserved Holly, which, unlike the fresh stuff, would allow people to get the Fa-la-la-la-Ogri'la achievement. The salt went for as much as 35g while the daily was up, so a lot of people had been stockpiling it for this year's event. Unfortunately, Blizzard seems to have deprecated this particular quest, and I can't seem to find any other way to get Preserved Holly.






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Nathanyel Dec 19th 2011 2:20PM
That may mean the stacks of Preserved Holly I have lying around might rise in value after Winter Veil!
Narayana Dec 19th 2011 2:36PM
Interesting that there's no mention here about the Miniature Winter Veil Tree that can be rewarded from doing the Greench daily.
It's not nearly as profitable as people seem to want it to be - some are staunchly standing by their 15K gold buy-outs- but if you're lucky enough you can get a few thousand gold from the quest.
lavergne.joseph Dec 19th 2011 2:42PM
I don't think you can get the preserved holly anymore cause they only wanted reindeer to be around during the holiday, esp since the pets and all are not with the restriction.
mheatleyadams Dec 19th 2011 5:24PM
Yeah, the Fresh Holly says 'Requires Winter Veil' on it now, so like most of the other Holiday items, looks like they don't want them to stick around after the event is over.
Daco Dec 19th 2011 2:52PM
First day of Winter Veil last week, I found myself in Ironforge. I'd saved a few small eggs, but realized I only had four. Quick ride to the buzzards in Loch Modan and I got my egg. After a moment's thought, I took a couple of minutes to farm up five more. Back to IF, where the cheapest stack on the AH was more than 50g for five. I posted mine for a buyout of 50g, and it sold within 10 minutes. Most profitable five minutes I've spent in-game.
I'm sure the prices have dropped, but never underestimate the amount of disposable income players have sitting around.
mem0ryburn Dec 19th 2011 3:07PM
5 small eggs went for I think 57g on my server as well. And wouldn't you know it was easier for me to part with the 57g than it was for me to bother flying down to Westfall to farm the buggers too.
Which reminds me, this brings out one of the traits in people that irritates me beyond anything I can describe. People who would they'd rather fly down and farm the eggs than spend the gold that LOSE THEIR MINDS IN TRADE over how utterly stupid people must be to spend SO MUCH GOLD on five eggs. If I have the gold and it's but a fleeting thought for me to think it's worth it to me to pay somebody to get them for me then why is that anybody's business? Also, I'd pay a mage 50g to port me somewhere so isn't that a rather similar tip for a rather similar service? Are these people broke and jealous? Do they think that just because I'd part with the gold that must mean I didn't know that I could find them easily on my own?
One thing that bothered me even more than that is when I noticed one of the people bitching in trade about the "idiots" who bought the eggs was one of the same people who was selling them. Luckily it was not them that I had bought my eggs from. I would hope enough people could notice that name and never buy another damned thing from them again. How terribly ignorant and non-appreciative of them.
RS Dec 19th 2011 2:57PM
For kicks I put up some left over milk on the AH, I got like 3 gold for it. All they had to do was walk 30 yards to the inn... lazy.... oh well convenience fee...
I was able to farm up some eggs up in the Hinterlands, killing Owlbeasts while doing Archeology. They seem to drop off them pretty decently, plus you get more money out of the MOB. For an 85, one shot one kill.
RS
babywhiz Dec 19th 2011 3:35PM
One of our guildies was shocked at the milk prices, so he would go over in disgust and put up milk for 50c each.
Someone would always buy them out. He'd go put up more.
I was dying laughing.
Tbah Dec 19th 2011 3:59PM
I bought some milk for the quest and thought I'd go and AH the rest... with 19g buyout per each.
I spent the afternoon laughing as my chat was filled with "A buyer has been found for your auction of Ice Cold Milk."
Best profit so far in the game. As in percents, not as in net gold gain. And the best laughs I've had in ages.
Anatolios Dec 19th 2011 3:27PM
I've found the best profits can be from buying (or farming) the eggs and turning them into the finished product. I've been selling the cookies in groups of five for just short of 19G/ea since the start. For the 90g sale price, 80g profit or so.
-Executus server
Thiron Dec 19th 2011 4:10PM
I bought eggs(they were pretty cheap here) and sold cookies from them. Fast and easy.
GabeCo Dec 19th 2011 4:21PM
for less than 2g, and ~20 minutes, I filled 2 build bank with snowballs (9c for a stack of 5), which have been flying off the shelves already, and will also make a huge profit down the road, especially now that some items can be used year round, but require snowballs to operate.
GabeCo Dec 19th 2011 4:27PM
*Guild bank tabs
GabeCo Dec 19th 2011 4:27PM
What should I do about idiots who undercut for ridiculous amounts? ex: There were only 2 purified Demonseyes left on the AH, so I went ahead and bought them , and posted my stash at 200g each. I sold 10 before the price went down, so I made some nice profit, but then some idiots came and ruined the market.
Someone first posted ~30 for 100g each, then 20 minutes later, a bunch more for 50g each, then another guy comes and posts them for 15g each. In no less than an hour, three people managed to destroy an absolute goldmine. And no, I wasnt the only one posting them expensive.
Someone also did this with a bunch of my enchants, undercutting for as much as 50g at a time.
Matthew Dec 19th 2011 5:31PM
if you find out what to do PLEASE POST IT! I don't understand it either. unless they're hacked accounts in which case any money is money.
Berna Dec 19th 2011 5:34PM
Buy a lot of them for 15g, wait until the price goes up again.
Cambro Dec 19th 2011 7:28PM
Buy up the really cheap ones, then get out of that market for a bit. Your competitors will probably have their own private little war and one or both will give up. I suspect they're either people that leveled jewelcrafting and have an excess of cut gems, or they cut way more than the market is actually able to support on your server, and they're trying to dump their inventory.
The rare gems are still going to be very popular til the end of the expansion, so if you have the patience, you can wait it out and sell for better prices once these guys either give up or run out of their cheap gems. I'd hesitate to buy ALL their gems, as you might get stuck with a few hundred and not be able to move them. But like those 15g each ones, as long as you know you can resell them for at least 25g, you've made a clear profit. You might even want to try barking in Trade especially on raid nights, discounting your prices by however much it costs you to list the gems.
Stickler Dec 19th 2011 5:03PM
It's 'deprecated', not 'depreciated'. Not to be a jerk.
Basil Berntsen Dec 19th 2011 6:27PM
Fixed.
goldeneye Dec 20th 2011 5:46AM
I think Blizz deprecated the quest because they depreciated it though (as in, not appreciate).
Or isn't that a word at all?
Too lazy to look it up really :p