Arcane Brilliance: The best trinkets for mages, patch 4.3 edition

Trinkets do three things:
- They keep your keys from being lonely.
- They hurt like hell when you forget to take them out of your pocket before playing pick-up basketball.
- They have the potential to increase your DPS more drastically than any other single gear slot in the game.
With that in mind, let's go over the best trinkets available for mages in the game right now and where to go get them.
I will list each trinket in the order in which I believe they belong, from least powerful to most powerful. You will undoubtedly have differing opinions about the order I go with, and I want to hear about them in the comments. In addition to being the most important gear choices in the game, trinkets are also perhaps the most subjective in terms of raw stats. When you're deciding between most gear, your comparison mainly involves seeing which item has a higher amount of intellect and then equipping that item. But when you're choosing between a stacking intellect proc on a hidden internal cooldown and an on-use ability listed as "Embrace the fel energies contained within," that choice can be a little less black and white.
Foul Gift of the Demon Lord
A great place to start, this trinket is comparably easy to obtain before you ever set foot in a raid. It has a fat chunk of intellect on it and a nice proc. Note that the on-use "fel energies" are mostly a vanity thing; it's a pretty inconsequential heal over time effect that also deals a pretty inconsequential amount of damage over time to nearby enemies. It's fun but doesn't really factor into the trinket's value (unless you like looking awesome, in which case your should move this trinket about six spots higher on the list, by my calculations).
Proc details
- Internal cooldown is 45 seconds.
- Grants mastery on both healing and damage spells, so you'll see healers in your party rolling on this as well.
Necromantic Focus (378)
If you have a guild that still runs Firelands, the normal version of this item can be another good starter trinket, though if you don't already have it, there are other trinkets out there that are probably a lot easier to snag than this one nowadays. It's a straightforward intellect increase and a stacking mastery buff from periodic damage.
Where to get it Normal Baleroc in the Firelands raid
Darkmoon Card: Volcano
This has been around since the start of the expansion, and for a long time it was very much the best-in-slot trinket for mages. It's not that anymore, but it is still on the list. As a starter trinket before hitting the raiding circuit, it simply can't be beat.
The proc details
- The internal cooldown is 45 seconds.
- The proc damage can crit.
- It scales with your stats and is affected by your buffs and talents.
- It triggers a cool explosion effect on your mage when it goes off.
Where to get it The only item on this list that you can simply throw gold at to obtain, this trinket is easiest to obtain by simply hiring a scribe to make it for you or just shopping the Auction House. You'll need to plunk down some funds, but if you're rolling in cash, this is one of the best trinkets available, and you can own it without ever setting foot in any kind of raid.
Variable Pulse Lightning Capacitor (384)
Again, this is a Firelands trinket and thus may be more trouble than it is worth to seek out and obtain, but that doesn't make it any less awesome. If you already have it or can get it without too much trouble, the sizable intellect bonus and fun lightning damage proc will serve you well.
Proc details
- Is an actual damage spell when triggered, and thus requires line of sight to your intended target.
- Capable of critting.
- Triggered by DoTs or direct damage spells.
Cunning of the Cruel (384)
Our first Raid Finder trinket! Lots of intellect and a really fun AoE damage proc.
Proc details
- Internal cooldown is 25 seconds.
- Can crit, and procs off DoTs as well as direct damage.
- Scales with your spellpower.
- Doesn't seem to hit CC targets in PvE but does in PVP. Use with care.
- Insanely high proc rate -- will proc almost immediately every time the internal cooldown is up.
Insignia of the Corrupted Mind (384)
With its massive haste proc, this Raid Finder trinket is well worth seeking out and slightly outperforms Cunning of the Cruel.
Where to get it Yor'sahj the Unsleeping in Raid Finder Dragon Soul.
Necromantic Focus (391)
This is the heroic version of the trinket listed above.
Where to get it Heroic Baleroc in Firelands
Cunning of the Cruel (397)
Normal, non-Raid Finder version of above trinket.
Where to get it Multiple bosses in the normal version of the Dragon Soul raid
Will of Unbinding (390)
The best of the Raid Finder trinkets, this one is pretty impressive. It has no passive bonus, but the proc is a stacking intellect buff (up to 790 intellect) that procs on any damage you cause, be it direct or DoT. For most mages, on most encounters, this will be stacked to full almost constantly just through normal rotation.
Where to get it Deathwing in Raid Finder Dragon Soul
Variable Pulse Lightning Capacitor (397)
Heroic version of above trinket.
Where to get it Heroic Ragnaros in Firelands
Insignia of the Corrupted Mind (397)
Normal version of Raid Finder trinket listed above.
Where to get it Yor'sahj the Unsleeping in normal Dragon Soul
Cunning of the Cruel (410)
Heroic version of above trinket.
Where to get it Multiple bosses in the heroic version of the Dragon Soul raid
Insignia of the Corrupted Mind (410)
Heroic version of above trinket.
Where to get it Yor'sahj the Unsleeping in heroic Dragon Soul
Will of Unbinding (403)
Normal version of above Raid Finder trinket.
Where to get it Deathwing in normal Dragon Soul
Will of Unbinding (416)
Heroic version of above trinket. As you can see by its placements on this list, this one is going to be the best in slot for every mage at every tier of gear. If you can get it, no matter what version of Dragon Soul you're able to run, it's going to be better than any other trinket you've got access to.
Where to get it Deathwing in heroic Dragon Soul
The Outlier: Shard of Woe (379)
This one is only on the list if you're an arcane mage, and its placement on the list is probably at #3, right behind the normal and heroic versions of Will of Unbinding. Because it reduces the base mana cost of all of your spells, its value in the whole Mana Adept scheme of things is vastly inflated. If you're an arcane mage and you can grab this trinket, chances are good that it's going to be taking up residency in one of your trinket slots pretty much permanently until the next expansion hits. Even if your guild has no intention of ever running heroic Bastion of Twilight again, this one is worth seeking out.
Where to get it Heroic Sinestra in Bastion of Twilight
That's all the room I have for today, my fellow mages. Thoughts? Are there any trinkets I forgot that belong on the list? How would you change the order? And in what manner should we end the miserable existence of any warlock who outrolls us on one of these beauties? I say messily.
Filed under: Mage, Analysis / Opinion, (Mage) Arcane Brilliance






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Fletcher Jan 21st 2012 8:19PM
What about the VP trinket? Bottled Wishes, I think? Is that worth anything?
Prelimar Jan 21st 2012 9:15PM
that's my question, too -- especially since i just bought it the other day. : [
Skyrei Jan 21st 2012 11:56PM
Id say unfortunately the VP trinket is "meh" at best. With a few exceptions, passive Int trinkets are where its at for most Mages. That's not to say that purchasing it is the wrong move; an upgrade is an upgrade.
Drew.wrong Jan 21st 2012 8:54PM
What about using Cunning for trash ( for AoE) and Insignia for bosses? I have been swapping them out, but would love to hear if that's a good idea...
Imnick Jan 22nd 2012 12:01AM
I think it's also better on some bosses anyway (Yor'Shaj, and Spine if you're doing it on Normal and feel like cheesing DPS meters by spreading combustion onto all the oozes) but I couldn't say for sure.
Crispn Jan 22nd 2012 1:32PM
The AoE trink will be better on bosses with adds, most specifically Yor'sahj, but it might be better on others too. On trash, it probably doesn't even matter what trinket you have on
AngrySlob Jan 21st 2012 9:04PM
Bottled Wishes is a pretty poor trinket, I wouldn't waste my VP's on it.
AngrySlob Jan 21st 2012 9:05PM
Argh that was meant to be a reply to Fletch :/
Imnick Jan 21st 2012 10:30PM
Fortunately there's few enough replies yet that he'll probably see it anyway :)
Wolfrunner Jan 21st 2012 11:40PM
I'm wondering if the Moonwell Chalice is any good. I know it's not as powerful as the Foul Gift, but for a fire mage, the ability to hit that mastery booster right before throwing out your combust might be worth it. I find that often I'm tossing out combusts without the Gift active because I really can't afford to ignore that fireball crit.
I also have to wonder if there's a better add-on that Combustion Helper. As far as I can tell, it really doesn't help you find a good ignite too much. Or am I reading it wrong?
puffcake Jan 22nd 2012 2:29AM
I was going to mention this as well. A flat 340 intellect boost and an on use 1700 mastery boost every 2 minutes isn't so bad for a starter trinket. I've got this and foul gift, which I'm not upgrading until I get the two raid finder trinket drops. Any upgrade that's not on this list *ahem* bottledwishes *cough* would mean losing at least 340 intellect, which isn't worth it just to boost iLvl. Non raiders could certainly do worse than the Moonwell Chalice.
Skyrei Jan 22nd 2012 3:40AM
Moonwell chalice is a solid trinket. I just don't know if its worth the trouble to get. Foul Gift being comparably easier to get. Moonwell taking a couple of weeks to get or Foul Gift taking 3-4 (or more if you're unlucky, but still) runs.
At best, these trinkets are equals. I'd say because they fill the same trinket type (Passive Int + Mastery) and Foul Gift being easier to obtain, that's why it wasn't on this list.
Azzmodius Jan 22nd 2012 4:38AM
You may be missing some of the method of using CombustionHelper. Let me see if I can help you by explaining my thought process and what I'm looking at during raid casting:
-Using a combination of CombustionHelper and combat text I watch for that opportunity via watching for crits. I know about how large a single Fireball or Pyroblast will crit for, so if I get two crits in a row I'm probably in business. CH acts more as a reaffirmation that whatever I suspect just happened actually happened. It also acts as a learning tool to hone your instinct of when to use Combustion.
CAVEATS:
-I want to use Combustion on at least a 15k ignite AND Living Bomb up. Hopefully there will also be a Pyroblast DoT.
-2 Crits happen BUT they were simultaneous Fireball and Pyroblast - that means one of the ignites is almost certainly munched, and the DoT is only for one of the spells.
themightysven Jan 21st 2012 11:59PM
you forgot the rainbow generator
( I assume it's the real #1)
Randomize Jan 22nd 2012 2:18AM
Well, he probably didn't want to spark controversy, as there is still heavy debate between whether the rainbow generator is #1, or if a classic trinket like Piccolo of the Flaming Fire still tops charts.
ued_zoar Jan 22nd 2012 12:52AM
Will of Unbinding creates a stack on spell hit not on spell damage DoTs do not stack it every time they tick only when they are cast. I found this out to my disappointment on my warlock so just a warning to fellow casters.
trefpoid Jan 22nd 2012 1:46AM
I'm struggling to get any of the damn trinkets in LFR or any tier piece for that matter. I want Will of Unbinding badly.
Malon Jan 22nd 2012 5:56AM
Can I just say that while I love the AB column, it's nice to see a bit more of an advanced, raider-oriented subject than last week's (very) basic guide to increasing DPS. Some advanced Mage-specific tips and tricks to upping damage or avoiding death would be welcomed, too.
SpazzKultzCylAl Jan 22nd 2012 6:33AM
@ Malon. I agree. Much better topic this week.
@AB - great list. however I would personally switch the two bottom ones (not that it makes that big of a difference) In order for Necromatic Focus to beat Foul Gift of the Demon Lord, Foul Gift of the Demon Lord would have to not proc more than once every 58 seconds or so. But like I said....it's such a small difference....we'd be better off spending our time thinking up new ways to kill warlocks.
Scooba Jan 22nd 2012 10:34AM
Does the mithril pocketwatch fit in anywhere here? For a fire mage?