Know Your Lore: Scholomance revisited

The World of Warcraft is an expansive universe. You're playing the game, you're fighting the bosses, you know the how -- but do you know the why? Each week, Matthew Rossi and Anne Stickney make sure you Know Your Lore by covering the history of the story behind World of Warcraft.
On a lone island located in the middle of Darrowmere Lake it sits, the remnants of the keep of Caer Darrow. The history of this isle dates all the way back to the high elves of Quel'Danas, who used the site as the location of one of many runestones the quel'dorei used. But the history of this isle has been lost in the face of far more recent history -- the history of the noble Barov family and their downfall, the history of a school dedicated to horrors the rest of Azeroth would rather forget.
During the Second War, the ancient site was invaded by the Horde, who took the runestone and broke it into pieces that were taken to create Altars of Storms. And some time after that, the Barov line came to own the property, as well as several others across Lordaeron. The Barovs, however, were not content with their mass amounts of land -- they wanted to make sure they held that land and their fortune for as long as possible. And so they struck a deal with a powerful mage, one who could easily give them all they asked and more ... for a price.
The mage's name was Kel'Thuzad.
On a lone island located in the middle of Darrowmere Lake it sits, the remnants of the keep of Caer Darrow. The history of this isle dates all the way back to the high elves of Quel'Danas, who used the site as the location of one of many runestones the quel'dorei used. But the history of this isle has been lost in the face of far more recent history -- the history of the noble Barov family and their downfall, the history of a school dedicated to horrors the rest of Azeroth would rather forget.
During the Second War, the ancient site was invaded by the Horde, who took the runestone and broke it into pieces that were taken to create Altars of Storms. And some time after that, the Barov line came to own the property, as well as several others across Lordaeron. The Barovs, however, were not content with their mass amounts of land -- they wanted to make sure they held that land and their fortune for as long as possible. And so they struck a deal with a powerful mage, one who could easily give them all they asked and more ... for a price.
The mage's name was Kel'Thuzad.

Kel'Thuzad was more than a mage. He was the leader of the Cult of the Damned, a group of humans who swore fealty to the Lich King. In exchange for this fealty, Kel'Thuzad promised immortality, something that the Barovs were keen to have.
But Kel'Thuzad didn't just want the Barovs; he wanted Caer Darrow. Once he had it, the former house of the Barovs was turned into a school for the Cult of the Damned, one that researched the forbidden art of necromancy and the Plague of Undeath that would hopefully wipe the living from Lordaeron for good.
As for the Barovs, in exchange for their land and their devotion to the Scourge, Kel'Thuzad guaranteed that they would live forever, in a way. Lord Alexei became a death knight, and his wife Illucia and his daughter Jandice are now ghosts that haunt the halls of their former home, now known as Scholomance. The Barov family boasted two sons -- Alexi, now a Forsaken, and Weldon, the last living human heir to the Barov fortune. In classic WoW, Alexi and Weldon fought mercilessly for their rightful inheritance, both sending players to retrieve the deeds of Barov lands and ultimately sending players on assassination runs.

Well, most haven't.
In the new quests for the Western Plaguelands, Darkmaster Gandling and other members of the Cult are hard at work creating plague cauldrons, trying to continue the spread of the plague. Gandling himself can be seen at Andorhal, but he manages to flee after being confronted by Koltira Deathweaver and Thassarian. However, aside from these few small changes, there really haven't been any major changes to Scholomance in Cataclysm other than the relocation of quest givers. With a revamp to Scholomance in the works for Mists of Pandaria, what exactly could Blizzard do with this instance?

It's been mentioned that Scholomance will be changing from a whopping 13-boss instance all the way down to just five bosses -- which makes the instance a heck of a lot smaller. In addition, there is even an example of the new Scholomance map with all bosses listed -- Kirtonos the Herald, Jandice Barov, Ras Frostwhisper, Rattlegore, and finally Darkmaster Gandling. However, whether or not that boss list is accurate hasn't really been confirmed, to my knowledge -- and as with everything in development, nothing is really finalized until it's final and released. That said, those bosses may change, or they may stay the same as what has already been revealed.
But let's take a look at what's going on with Scholomance right now and what that could possibly say for the future of the instance.
- Cult of the Damned The Cult of the Damned was originally created for the Scourge and for the Lich King. But the Lich King is no longer a power worth worrying about. Whether or not the Cult of the Damned knows this, however, is up in the air -- it could be that they are simply unaware of Arthas and Kel'Thuzad's defeat, and they are awaiting their return. Or it could be that the Cult of the Damned has realized the Lich King and Kel'Thuzad are no longer a force to be reckoned with, so they have decided to begin work for their own motives ... which is a bit more dangerous than simply being brainwashed by the Lich King. People with motives aren't mad. They aren't corrupt. They're simply working for their own cause, whatever that cause may be. And people working for their own cause? Well ... they'll likely use whoever or whatever means necessary to get what they want.
- Sylvanas and the Forsaken Now here's an interesting thought: Sylvanas and the Forsaken are currently using the Plague of Undeath, despite Garrosh's orders not to do so. For what purpose, exactly? To retake Lordaeron in the name of the Forsaken. Speaking of retaking things, it was revealed in Tirisfal Glades that Sylvanas has made a deal with the val'kyr so that the Forsaken will not continue to die out. The val'kyr are continuing to bring the Forsaken to life, to serve Sylvanas or not, as they choose. But those val'kyr are apparently limited in number -- so what happens when they die out? Wouldn't it be interesting if Sylvanas approached the Cult of the Damned, a group bent on necromancy research, and perhaps offered something in exchange for the secrets of necromancy? Like say, I don't know -- how about the Plague of Undeath? Now there's a twisty reason for an instance.

- Lilian Voss Or we can go back to Lilian, who we mentioned last week as a possible resident of the heroic Scarlet Monastery. Lilian's not exactly sane. Lilian's not likely to want to ally with the Scarlet Crusade, because of their betrayal. Lilian's also not likely to ally with the Forsaken, because they brought her back from the sweet release of death as the very abomination she spent her life fighting against. So what if Lilian decided to take a different outlook entirely? She won't ally with the Scarlet Crusade, she won't ally with the Forsaken -- maybe she'd simply rather wipe everyone from existence and then cease to be as well. And the Cult of the Damned ally with neither the Forsaken nor the Scarlet Crusade, making them a neutral organization of evil-doers, to a degree.
- The Argent Crusade Or for a very simple premise, how about we take a look at the Argent Crusade? They're trying to heal the Plaguelands, and the Cult of the Damned is trying to spread the plague. Obviously the two sides aren't playing nice with each other, and we haven't seen the Argent Crusade or Tirion Fordring do much since Wrath. Maybe Tirion will once again ask for our help, seeing as how we're the heroes who helped him dispatch the Lich King and all. ... Or we could go with some really, really out-of-the-box options.

- Koltira Deathweaver Say, where exactly did Sylvanas haul Koltira off to, anyway? More importantly, what has she been doing to him since he was dragged there? The only hint we received was that Koltira would get some form of deprogramming, something that would make him bend to Sylvanas' will. Well what if that whole incident blew right up in her face, and Koltira went a little cuckoo? What if he reverted to the creature that was devoted to serving the Lich King? What if he escaped, managed to find the Cult of the Damned, and decided that this was a group of easily manipulated people that would be best suited to carrying out the eradication of Sylvanas? The Banshee Queen certainly wouldn't stand for that, and she'd send anyone she could get her hands on to take care of the problem and get rid of him.
- The Risen This faction of undead has a really interesting story. See, they used to be the Scarlet Crusade. However, since the Scarlet Crusade failed so pathetically in its mission, they were killed and resurrected by Balnazzar, and they are now mindless servants of the Burning Legion. It's a sad story, in a way, but it also illustrates that the Burning Legion, no matter how hard we kick them to the curb, are still around and just as active as ever. What would happen if the Burning Legion sank their claws into the Cult of the Damned as well? After all, there's no Lich King to stop them, this time ...
Revamps, lore, and Lordaeron
The biggest and perhaps most interesting part about both of these scheduled revamps is that they take place in Lordaeron, a place that has been inundated with all kinds of new, tasty lore in Cataclysm but hasn't seen any resolution to any of those storylines so far. A lot of people have been sort of upset at the lack of resolution, but these revamps illustrate what I've been saying all along -- the purpose of Cataclysm wasn't just to revamp the world but to inject new pieces of lore and new situations that could propel the game further along.
There doesn't have to be a resolution to Sylvanas' apparent madness right now. There is more than enough going on in Cataclysm that the focus should be on the main storyline of the Dragon Aspects and Deathwing, and these tantalizing tidbits will have to wait until a later date to be addressed.
That said, it would be fantastic to see some of these storylines that have been started up in Lordaeron further addressed in Cataclysm. Let's see what happens with Sylvanas, with the Cult of the Damned, with the Scarlet Crusade, with Koltira Deathweaver. Let's see if Varian Wrynn ever makes good on his promise to try and reclaim the ruined capital from the Forsaken and put it back in Alliance hands. Let's see if The Risen, the fascinating new faction of undead former Scarlet Crusaders now led by the Burning Legion, attempt to make another move.
One thing's for certain -- the Cataclysm revamps to Lordaeron have not turned the former kingdom from Plaguelands to paradise overnight. It's a land still riddled with sorrow and conflict, although the conflicts have changed over the years. Though there are many nostalgic memories tucked away in quests long gone, perhaps it's time to move on. Let's see what comes next.
For more information on related subjects, please look at these other Know Your Lore entries:
- Scarlet Monastery revisted
- The unfortunate tale of Lilian Voss
- The Wrynn Dynasty
- Sylvanas Windrunner, part 1 and part 2
While you don't need to have played the previous Warcraft games to enjoy World of Warcraft, a little history goes a long way toward making the game a lot more fun. Dig into even more of the lore and history behind the World of Warcraft in WoW Insider's Guide to Warcraft Lore.
Filed under: Lore, Know your Lore






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
Throm Jan 29th 2012 6:42PM
Now I'm hoping its Koltira having gone insane from Sylvanas' torture, and Thassarian for the Alliance or Nathanos Blightcaller for the Horde have to head in there and kick his ass.
Xantenise Jan 29th 2012 7:05PM
The Windrunners like their human men -- Alleria had Turalyon, Vereesa had Rhonin, and Sylvanas might have had Nathanos ( http://www.wowpedia.org/Nathanos#Speculation ).
If Sylvanas turns into a new Lich Queen, it'd be an eerie echo of Jaina and Arthas to have Nathanos watch Sylvanas become what she fought against most.
Vaniya, Durid X-trordinare Jan 29th 2012 9:54PM
I just want to say I'm in the "Sylvanas is only taking her motherlyness too far" instead of crazy camp. She seems to actually care about her people, and just has some bad ideas on how to take care of them. Including putting down what she sees as a traitor in her own special, banshee queen way. Please blizz, she is one of the only strong female leaders, don't make her batsh*t crazy!
Soeroah_the_second Jan 29th 2012 10:38PM
@Vaniya I don't know. Sylvanas' leader story suggested she only ever considered the Forsaken a weapon she could use against Arthas. "The arrows in my quiver". Then she made a pact with the Val'Kyr and decided to continue on living. I'm not sure what her motivations are now.
Kyrt Jan 30th 2012 2:44PM
@Vaniya
Sorry - but I think Sylvanas' short story put paid to any notion that she actually cares about her people as anything other than unliving shields.
paul.morales91 Jan 29th 2012 7:01PM
" ...it could be that they are simply unaware of Arthas and Kel'Thuzad's defeat, and they are awaiting their return. Or it could be that the Cult of the Damned has realized the Lich King and Kel'Thuzad are no longer a force to be reckoned with, so they have decided to begin work for their own motives..."
"There doesn't have to be a resolution to Sylvanas' apparent madness right now."
Wait a minute...
What if the Cult of the Damned has realized both Arthas and Kel'thuzad have fallen...but they don't care? What if Ner'zhul and Darkmaster Gandling had a backup plan? What if Sylvanas has been possesed by Ner'zhul and is now slowly being turned into the Lich Queen under everyone's noses. Think about it, why else would the val'kyr have sacrificed themselves to bring her back from the dead unless they felt some crazy devotion to their new master...or former master...
Do I think Sylvanas will be turned into a raid boss? Unlikely, but possible. What's more likely is that she'll become the final boss of a dungeon, and half of the fight will be spent giving her an exorcism of sorts and releasing the spirit of Ner'zhul from her body, who will then posses Darkmaster Gandling or someone else. She will then help us in a raid to defeat Ner'zhul and his new host once and for all.
DrPestilence Jan 30th 2012 10:25AM
That would be damn fun.
Xantenise Jan 29th 2012 7:01PM
Koltira going insane from the torture?
We already have enough bosses that "went insane" for SOME reason or another. Please, not another one, Blizz.
Like the idea of the Burning Legion or Sylvanas getting mixed up with the Cult though.
followthategg Jan 29th 2012 7:34PM
Hmm, the risen. This is my preferred story line for scarlet monastery heroic, keep the original version for the normal level 30-ish dungeon. I think that would be a great way for them to keep the story line behind SM intact and allow players to see the progression. But i don't think that will happen as i seem to recall them messing around with the map of the instances?
As for Scholomance, i don't think the story line will be as compelling, i hope i'm wrong though. It would be rather great if the Burning Legion got involved somehow, it would definitively give it story a twist.
Al Jan 29th 2012 9:12PM
The Scarlet instances have been merged, so it's two instead of four, but it looked pretty much the same.
Blayze Jan 29th 2012 8:00PM
Or it could just be that our past victories were retconned out of existence. Again.
Ata Jan 29th 2012 10:37PM
Such as? We've only had two real revamps to dungeons, really, and there wasn't any retcon as to what happened, adventures won, and things progressed to their next logical state.
VanCleef was most decidedly killed by adventurers, setting up his daughter.
We all saw that Arugal was dead dead dead, he was just logically brought back by those who can bring people back from the dead to go wreak havoc in Northrend, leaving the keep empty and perfect for the jerks to move in.
You could maybe suggest that with the new quests in Scarlet Monastery, previous player victories were retconned, but Im sure Joseph will be addressed when that's changed in Mists, making player victories there not 'retconned' or moot.
I figure the Alliance got control over Stockades, then put Hogger in there, and with the Cataclasym opening up a hole to let elementals through, that was pretty logical progression as well. All of the original bosses in there being gone, I think that's a pretty clear sign that what the adventurers who went in there before did stuck.
Al Jan 29th 2012 11:49PM
I think Blayze is referring to Onyxia.
Imnick Jan 30th 2012 6:43AM
Onyxia was never retconned, Blizzard has said time and again that killing her in Wrath was completely non-canon and just a bonus instance for the WoW anniversary
Al Jan 30th 2012 7:27AM
The retcon being "oh, you guys never killed her, Varian did. He killed her so dead we're taking her quest chain out of the game."
Killik Jan 30th 2012 7:29AM
Onyxia was retconned so that King Chin Wrynn was the one to slay her.
Ata Jan 30th 2012 12:02PM
Okay, so a single raid kill from a Vanilla raid was retconned to give a character that badly needed development some development...the original post sounded like this was a chronic issue that happened every time something was changed. Even the Zul's have followed logical progression after the 'group of heroes' went in and foiled their plans. Trolls and voodoo and raising people from the dead sure works well for the lore in there.
Ata Jan 29th 2012 10:31PM
I like the idea of the Argent Crusade, myself. They've basically 'retaken' Stratholme, Scholomance is a perfectly good next step for them to clean out the house, so to speak. I thought it was interesting which Barovs they chose to not have as bosses, at least so far, though.
donz Jan 29th 2012 11:08PM
Note that the new layout keeps all of Gandling's side rooms, meaning the mini-bosses preceding him may return in some form - be it staying the same as they are now (killing all of them to summon Gandling), or being somehow involved in the new, presumably revamped Gandling fight.
skatersrule99 Jan 30th 2012 12:55AM
Something a lot of people forgot about in Wrath.......Mal'ganis is still around as well.......we found out that he was leading the Scarlet Onslaught in Icecrown, we revealed him for what he was but he got away again. he was pulling Arthas' to get him to Northrend for the Lich King may be he'll decide to go check out what the Cult of the damned is doing.....or team up with Balnazzar and his Risen.....I'd personally like to put an end to Mal'ganis once on for all