WoW Moviewatch: Brand New Patch
Brand New Patch is by the same chaps who created Rolling With Mad Deeps. Clearly, we're looking at a different singer here, but Xander is still the creative force behind it. This review is a little tough, so let's frame this discussion a little differently from the usual.
The good parts of this video are the lyrics and animation. The lyrics do a good job of emulating Brand New Day's signature rhythm, even if the wording sometimes feels a little stretched to make it work. But when you consider the song is about some rebellious angst ("No! You move!"), then it generally comes together all right. The video and animation works just fine, and I actually really enjoyed the subtitles.
The not-so-great part is that the singing didn't work very well. The singer doesn't have a bad voice, but it's hard to match Neil Patrick Harris's chops, pound for pound. Unfortunately, that comparison is inevitable, considering how powerfully evocative of Dr. Horrible this song actually is. Again, I don't feel the singer is bad, just that this song isn't the best cup of tea for that voice. Luckily, it seems Xander knows that.
Ultimately, I enjoyed Brand New Patch, and I'm interested in seeing what he does next.
Filed under: WoW Moviewatch






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
exogenesis. Mar 6th 2012 6:14PM
Unfortunately, I really didn't enjoy that singing. I don't know much - anything, actually - about singing itself, but the voice made me cringe in parts, which is such a shame, because everything else is awesome.
Lachdanan Mar 6th 2012 6:19PM
I'm not usually a big fan of musical machinimas (I'm a little picky about the quality of the singing), except for Cranius and whoever did Welcome To The Deadmines, but the lyrics were really fun. :)
blacksword.ca Mar 6th 2012 8:22PM
Welcome to the Deadmines was Jesse Cox of OMFGCata if i recall right
Kuro Mar 6th 2012 6:45PM
Go Proudmoore, even if he is Alliance :P
As they say in France... "Des goƻts et des couleurs, on ne dispute pas"... but I find this more palatable than yesterday's video that got a mostly positive review.
blacksword.ca Mar 6th 2012 8:34PM
All in all, not a bad song. The guy was in tune, but seemed to lack confidence. Plus his mic wasn't the best either. With some practice I think he'll be a good vocalist.
Firiun Mar 6th 2012 8:39PM
Is there such a thing as an anti-whedon?
Durandal Mar 6th 2012 11:23PM
Is that Pansy Division?
ScrubRogue Mar 7th 2012 12:07AM
I'm sorry but I thought it was great, not everyone is, or needs to be incredible. If I had the ability to do half this quality I'd be proud lol
And Whedon ROXXORS
Jere Hunter Mar 7th 2012 10:08AM
My favorite song in Dr. Horribles Sing along so I am willing to be generous. I love the idea he has behind this and I wish I could have gone a little longer. I think it could have used a little more polish, but I for one really liked it :)