Know Your Lore: The undead, part 2

Undeath in Azeroth and beyond it (such as the hordes of angry dead in Auchindoun on the former world of Draenor, now Outland) is a terrible condition. Undead are not supposed to be undead; undeath is an imposed condition that creates a moving entity that does not live. (Even in those few who achieved undeath themselves, like Meryl Felstorm, undeath is still imposed on their flesh or spirit -- it's simply self-imposed.) Undead spirits do not hold perfectly to this mortal coil, and as a result, they often suffer greatly.
Undead who manage to maintain any fraction of their former will and sapience are beings who simply cannot truly feel the world any longer. Their spirits dwell forever trapped in between the rest they are unable to achieve and the sensations that life brings, sensations they can no longer fully experience. This separation from life is due to the fact that their souls are, in essence, forcibly conjoined in some fashion. Necromantic magics fix the spirit to whatever form it maintains, be it a ghostly one or a prison of rotting flesh. Heat, pain, flavor, all the subtle and gross aspects of life are denied them.
The true horror of undeath
The undead can feel pain, yes. The touch of the Holy Light causes them dire agony as it sears away decomposing tissue, shakes the chains of dark magics that trap their essence to this world, and reminds them terribly for brief moments what it was like to truly be alive. This sensation is perhaps the cruelest one of them all. Not only is there true physical pain to be endured as the Light sears them body and soul, but worse, it's often the strongest sensation they can feel and mocks their usual muffled, empty experience as well as reminding them of what they've lost. Those of the Forsaken who can still touch and use the Holy Light to heal must endure this sensation every single time they call upon its power.
In a way, those undead without minds can be seen as the fortunate ones. They evade the true horror of their condition. They are not forced to exist devoid of the pleasures of life, cut away from feeling, sensing the world around them, their souls chained imperfectly to an existence they can only pantomime.
Undeath and the many forms of death
As we discussed last week, the undead are divided into factions based on how they were created and what happened to them after their unlives started. Some of these factions overlap.
There are Forsaken who are also death knights, in essence having died, been raised, regained their free will, then died again, only to be raised and enslaved again. The process of making a death knight is different from the Plague of Undeath that raised the majority of the Scourge and the Forsaken, for a variety of reasons.
First, because there are two different paths to becoming a death knight. The original process was devised by Gul'dan, using his knowledge of corrupt magics gained from Kil'jaeden's instruction. Gul'dan actually killed his own acolytes, trapped their souls with necromantic power inside jeweled staves, then placed these orc souls in truncheons into the bodies of deceased human knights. Teron Gorefiend was the first orc warlock to be so raised as a death knight in this fashion.
The death knights we know today are inspired by these, because Ner'zhul (the orc shaman who would become the first Lich King) met and worked with Teron Gorefiend after Gul'dan's death and the Horde's defeat during the Second War. After Kil'jaeden rent Ner'zhul asunder and imprisoned his essence within the ice that would become his prison (essentially imposing undeath upon him), the spirit of the former orc shaman remembered his former student's trick.
The modern death knights created by Arthas were thus inspired by the memories of Ner'zhul within the Lich King. These death knights are directly raised from the dead by the Lich King rather than created by the plague of undeath, in a manner similar to how the Nerubians who died in the War of the Spider became crypt fiends. Nerubians were targeted by the Lich King entirely because they were immune to the plague of undeath, but even those immune to the disease are able to be raised directly by powerful necromancy after they die.
In addition to death knights and crypt fiends, there are many kinds of undead. First, there are the incorporeal undead such as ghosts, lichlings, banshees and wraiths. The val'kyr who served Arthas directly and who now serve Sylvanas Windrunner are incorporeal undead as well. Many of these undead were created by moments of great tragedy and unleashed magical power, such as the destruction of the original Well of Eternity. One specific ghost, Varo'then's Ghost, was actually created by the land of Kalimdor's refusing to allow him to rest within it. While the Lich King and other necromancers seem capable of directly creating such undead as well, the plague of undeath does not seem to create them.
Bodies and souls chained forever
It should be noted that despite the fact that they have physical forms, a lich could be considered an incorporeal undead. They exist in phylacteries, and if slain, the phylactery will simply form a new body for them. In order to slay a lich, the phylactery itself must be destroyed. Lichs are usually powerful spellcasters, and at least one made himself a lich, beholden to no one else.
If left to fate or the occasional necromancer, there would perhaps be more ghostly undead, but thanks to the Lich King's rampage across Northrend and the former Lordaeron with his plague, a great many corporeal undead exist. Cult of the Damned necromancers working under Kel'thuzad before and then after his death expanded upon the standard rotting, shambling corpses with the creation of ghasts, ghouls, and abominations, to mention just a few.
Meanwhile, the ancient troll empires understood how to use dark voodoo to likewise create zombified undead minions in a similar fashion -- a different means to the same end. This tradition is exemplified in the poisonous brews of Zanzil. It should be noted that unlike most necromancy, the troll voodoo tradition seems capable of actually returning the dead to life and not merely unlife.
The plague of undeath may not be able to raise ghostly undead, nor can it raise the dead to true life, but it is exceedingly good at infecting and killing the living who become undead in whole groups. What is troubling about every method of raising the dead isn't merely that it seems to often break the will of those who undergo it. No, the true horror is that, in many cases, the long-deceased can be raised. Do these also have spirits trapped in rotting flesh? Or are some mindless undead mindless because they are purely dead flesh and/or bones animated by raw necromantic power, the soul having long since departed?
While there are many different kinds of undead and many varied forms of necromancy, their creations all seem to have that same imperfect bonding of the spirit to the flesh (if they even possess flesh at all) or to the world. All the shared characteristics of the varied kinds of undead can be drawn from this incomplete anchoring of the spirit into the world of the living.
Next week, we tackle the ultimate questions of undeath and the undead.
While you don't need to have played the previous Warcraft games to enjoy World of Warcraft, a little history goes a long way toward making the game a lot more fun. Dig into even more of the lore and history behind the World of Warcraft in WoW Insider's Guide to Warcraft Lore.
Filed under: Lore, Know your Lore






Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
dleehollandjr Mar 14th 2012 1:43PM
Ive always wondered why -- if they indeed cannot taste -- zombies crave living flesh. Im pretty sure vampires use blood as sustenance, but what about zombies? Ive never heard of a case where a zombie used food to regenerate.
Maybe that constant hunger is a tool of the zombie's creator to drive it against whomever he wants dead? Or if undeath could be defined as "hell on earth" (or Azeroth) perhaps that insatiable hunger is part and parcel to the entire Hell experience.
Thank you, Miss Stickney. Youve given me much to contemplate on a long flight to Salt Lake...
hwacha Mar 14th 2012 1:44PM
tee hee, miss stickney xD
Matthew Rossi Mar 14th 2012 1:52PM
Well, I wrote this particular one, but thank you.
palooka Mar 14th 2012 2:48PM
I think I might know why they crave for food. Mindless zombies only have basic instincts, like eating food. They don't eat because they're hungry or think its tasty but its because that is the only thing it knows how to do. Sorry if it doesn't make sense, its kind of hard for me to explain.
leeholland Mar 14th 2012 3:45PM
Omg, so sorry about that, Rossi! Im so used Anne writing these that i didnt even check.
Posting comments via iPhone not recommended...
Jamie Mar 14th 2012 4:45PM
That's MISTER Rossi, to you!
Marcosius Mar 14th 2012 5:17PM
"Why do you eat people?"
"Not people, brains.."
"Brains only?"
"Yes"
"Why?"
"The pain"
"What about the pain?"
"THE PAIN OF BEING DEAD! I can feel myself rotting..."
"Eating brains, how does that make you feel?"
"It makes... The pain go away."
Snuzzle Mar 14th 2012 10:59PM
I always figured there was some kind of "life essence" believed to be in brains. Indeed, modern science knows that the brain is basically the epicenter of our body. What's really interesting is that zombies crave brains, and to kill a zombie one must sever the brain-body connection (shoot them in the head, smash their head, chop their head off). That can't be a coincidence.
It could also be that zombies are reduced to base instinct. Eat, reproduce, survive. It's a horrible thought to be reduced to such a crude bunde of instincts, made extra disturbing by that they feed on us. This gives them a hat trick of satisfying all three needs (food from our flesh, biting/killing us transforms a human into a zombie, and finally they are surviving by killing their most dangerous opponent: us).
Goshawk Mar 14th 2012 3:21PM
I was also wondering, now that we are on the topic of death knights, how you would describe unholy power. Frost is the use of magic to cast icy spells, and blood is the use of necromancy to regenerate health. But is unholy the opposite of the Light, the demonic and necromatic powers granted to an undead? Or is it the spread of infectious diseases that kill the enemy? I suppose the nature of undeath varies between those 2 extremes, evil necromancy from the Nether and the rotting decay of diseases. It just seems that the understanding of the state of undeath seems to depend heavily on the situation we are looking at.
VSUReaper Mar 14th 2012 6:58PM
I think you might be reading into the different presences/specs to much. One of those things where lore is suspended for the sake of game mechanics.
I think frost is exactly what you said: icy attacks.
Blood is a form of necrotic magic that steals the life of your opponent in order to continue fighting.
Unholy is also necrotic, but looks more into how it can overpower the opponent via shadow magic and diseases.
Orrine Mar 14th 2012 3:24PM
I think that it's unfair that undead spirits can't rest after their resurrected bodies were destroyed. If Light doesn't abandon anyone, why is it happening? For example undead Death Knight should know what happens after second death (like Sylvanas) and so the knowledge of realm of torment should be somewhat common by the time of Cataclysm. And if this knowledge is common I think priests and paladins would like to help the souls of people who were resurrected.
Sinnerl Mar 14th 2012 3:35PM
I think that's one of the biggest open questions about the Undead: what happens when they die? From all the lore sources (Arthas, Sylvanas) it seems that Undead go to eternal torment when they die. But this seems weirdly arbitrary since they're not necessarily evil and most haven't chosen this state for themselves. However since Sylvanas became pretty evil after she died and we don't really have any accounts of what happens to 'good' undead maybe it isn't the case for all of them.
Sqtsquish Mar 14th 2012 6:02PM
Mograinne, the dad, was undeathed, slain, and then left to watch over his son, and not tormented seemingly. One might assume, that it has alot to do with what they do with their remaining conscience after undeath. For instance I figure Zeliek is probably being cuddled by a Naaru or something, for fighting against the LK with all his will, and still not having a choice.
rothide Mar 14th 2012 7:05PM
Mograinne the older, I thought, had his soul trapped in the Ashbringer. He was making it so that the younger couldn't wield it effectively against the Argent Dawn. Then when Arthas came, he took Mograinne's soul.
As for undead without a weapon to contain their soul, I think we can look forward to being screwed out of any paradise because the "light" decided we are of no use to them now.
ryan.ferris Mar 14th 2012 3:39PM
There is a difference between wanting to help - and having a means to do so.
Just because say a Naruu can do it, doesn't mean even the most power paladin or priests can release the souls from their torment.
Sintraedrien Mar 14th 2012 3:48PM
Yes, this does emphasize a fascinating conundrum- if the Light/good doesn't abandon its champions, how could it tolerate undeath. For example, how could the "real" Sylvanas be raised into undeath, and forcibly damned to darkness without hope of redemption?
The whole point of her suicide at ICC shows that she cannot be redeemed- likewise Arthas himself- "I see only Darkness . . . .", but surely the living Sylvanas didn't deserve damnation- she was slaughtered opposing the same evil Bridenbrad fought.
Does that mean there are two Sylvanas 's? One safely dead and enjoying heaven and the other is evil, unread, and eventually doomed?
Ylspeth Mar 14th 2012 7:29PM
That is a fascinating question. It seems ridiculous that good people raised against their will to be undead are damned. The idea being bantered around that the undead are being animated by a copy/reflection of the individual's true soul is an interesting one.
If you look at some of the quests where we have to kill zombies in order to release the souls of the heroes, I suppose an argument can be made that the individual's true soul is encapsulated inside the undead while the reflection is the consciousness running the body.
I suppose the same can be said of death knights and their bodies. They are technically dead but apparently can eat, drink, and even get intoxicated. So, something is going on that is a semblance or reflection of life.
Now, in the comic, I have Trigonometry able to enjoy blueberry lemon muffins. My reasoning is that undead can see and hear. Why would they lack touch, taste, or smell? My running idea is that undead can do so but with greatly reduced sensitivity. Hence, Trig can enjoy strongly flavored things like a lemon but cannot distinguish an apple from a potato. Whether or not that fits in the lore is yet to be determined. :)
awpowers_2000 Mar 15th 2012 12:04PM
If the body was raised with no soul attached to it, I could see there being two Sylvanases. The spirit that is off wherever they go, and the body that has her memories.
However, her undeath was very clearly laid out in the Arthas novel. After she died, Arthas forced her spirit to stay around, as the banshee (I'm not sure the difference between a banshee and a regular ghost in the context of WoW). He still had her body. Then her soul was forced into her body, and that is how she became the Sylvanas we know (and love?). There's nothing else of hers that is out there.
But from the point of the story, I think it was a reminder that Sylvanas isn't a good person now. Maybe she was before, but her soul still has to take credit for her actions since. It wasn't like she sacrificed herself to save others, it was just suicide. That in itself could be the reason for going on to the place of torment, or maybe just her actions of late.
cspenn Mar 14th 2012 4:39PM
That is a question I had after Wrath. Frostmourne was shattered and the souls within released. Did Arthas' soul return to his body before he died? What about Sylvanas' soul, since her body is still corporeal and animated? Did her soul pass on and what's in the world now a soulless shell?
VSUReaper Mar 14th 2012 7:04PM
Sylvanas was never absorbed by frostmorne? It was only used to rend her soul from her body.
As for Arthas, his soul was returned to the body just in time to die and be released.
I think not all the souls if the undead are destined for an eternity of pain and suffering. It could be assumed that it all depends on what they did during life and unlife?
Sylvanas was good in life, but her unlife is filled to the brim with evil.
Terenas Minithil never did anything wrong, so when his soul was released from Frostmourne, he was able to relax.