Know Your Lore: The hour of the king

The King of Stormwind wears the crown on a troubled brow. He inherited the mantle as a child, not through a peaceful succession but through bloody violence and the destruction of his home. He wore it in exile and only came home with the death of the man who saved him and carried him away from the sight of his entire world burned to the ground. His entire life has been shaped by violent loss, by tragedy and death -- his mother dead before he even knew her, his father murdered and butchered in front of him, his replacement fathers cut down, his wife taken from him in a moment's passing by an errant rock thrown from a mob.
His early rule was most notable by his lack of desire to actually do much rulership, busying himself by riding the land in search of his father's killer or drifting though a haze of loss after his wife's death, a haze seized upon and manipulated by someone who was supposed to be a close advisor. The circumstances of his disappearance from the throne and his return have been discussed in detail. For now, all we need to do is accept that they did little to encourage him to view the throne as anything but a responsibility to be maintained in the face of constant peril.
Following the Northrend campaign and its heavy cost both to King Varian and the kingdom as a whole (Bolvar's death, as well as the many deaths at the Wrathgate; the invasion of Undercity and the destruction of Putress; Horde troops ambushing Alliance forces engaged with the Scourge; the astonishing cost in lives and resources), it would have been difficult for either the King or the kingdom to quickly recover. The eruption of Deathwing and the Cataclysm he caused did not allow the luxury of time. Reeling from one blow, they suffered another and another.
How it ends for Wrynn kings
Let's list off the things Varian has experienced or even directly acted upon during the time following the fall of the Lich King:
- He led a dream army of the greatest warriors in the Horde and the Alliance to battle the Emerald Nightmare as it manifested on Azeroth.
- He defended Stormwind from the elemental invasion that presaged the Cataclysm and led a small force of Alliance veterans to kill Kai'ju Gahz'rilla and Prince Sarsarun, respectively.
- He invaded an occupied Ironforge to rescue his son from Moira Thaurissan (not being aware that Anduin had already escaped) and, with a small band of SI:7 agents, effectively toppled Moira and forced the creation of the Council of Three Hammers.
- He reconciled with Genn Greymane and the people of Gilneas (the Worgen) and defended Ashenvale from a Horde offensive under Garrosh Hellscream, disarming the Horde leader in single combat.
- He dealt with an assassination attempt by the Twilight Prophet and his Twilight's Hammer forces. This attempt nearly killed Varian and would have, had his son Anduin not called upon the Holy Light to rescue him from his grievous wounds.

His relationship with his son Anduin (named for Anduin Lothar) has revealed that in many ways, Varian is consumed with fear that he will lose his son the way he has lost everyone else he's ever loved. His experiences in the novel Wolfheart show just how driven by the fear of that kind of loss Varian is and how much he had to do to find it in himself to face that fear and the rage that created it.
No matter how dark, it can get darker
Contrasting Varian to his current chief rival, Garrosh Hellscream, we see immediately that Varian's entire life has been defined by violence that in many ways was directed against him and his people by orcs just like Garrosh. Blackhand the Destroyer and Orgrim Doomhammer led the orcish Horde that burned his city and did so not for any slight the humans of Stormwind had ever offered them. No, the orcs of the Horde attacked humanity and burned their city entirely because they'd already destroyed their own world in service to pure evil.
Doomhammer killed Anduin Lothar after the hero had driven the Horde back from the very walls of Lordaeron, where a very young orphan named Varian Wrynn was sheltered following his father's assassination. The repeated losses of his life -- of family, loved ones, even replacement figures -- have made Varian someone who would do anything to avoid losing anyone else. Every death (like Bolvar's) that touches his life is an agony to be endured.
This is how it ends for Wrynn kings.
Varian's anger has all too often left his own people afraid of him. Strangely enough, despite his noted antipathy for the Horde, it's often led individual members of the Horde to respect him (as in his working with Baine Bloodhoof and other Horde warriors during the Emerald Nightmare's invasion), because it's so similar to how they view leadership and a leader's proper behavior. But during and after the events of his near assassination, we saw a Varian who had finally come to terms with who he had been, who he now was, and who he needed to become. Despite his real and genuine rage and fear over what has been taken from him, we see a Varian growing to terms with his lot in life.
Death stalks the throne of Stormwind
Varian has never really had a great mentor -- or, more accurately, he's lost them. His father's death would have been traumatic enough if he had not witnessed it, witnessed Garona Halforcen cutting Llane's heart out, because becoming king at such a young age basically meant that he stopped being the child he still was. Even Arthas Menethil noticed that when Varian came to stay in Lordaeron, Varian did not at all act like a child. How could he? But that loss was compounded, and compounded again.

It had been Terenas Menethil who had convinced Varian to stand against Genn Greymane and Thoras Trollbane, who wanted to wipe out the orcs entirely after the Second War. The orcs rewarded Terenas for his mercy by helping defile everything he ever had. Storming into Lordaeron, Varian saw the horrors the Forsaken casually inflict upon anyone who comes into their clutches, huddled victims in cages poisoned and murdered by Putress and the Royal Apothecary Society to develop new plagues, including the one that killed Bolvar and the other Alliance soliders at the Wrathgate. He saw the confirmation of his entire life's experiences, the evidence that even dignity or the sovereignty of your own flesh can be stolen from you.
Dying to live free
Ironically, through his attempt to kill Varian and his son, Archbishop Benedictus accidentally allowed Varian to take the lessons learned in the Howling Oak to heart. Genn's introduction of the worgen ritual allowed Varian to channel his rage on his own terms, but it was Benedictus' bringing Anduin and Varian together (although he did so hoping to kill them both) that allowed Varian to finally let go of the fear of loss that crippled and hindered him as a king and a leader.
Perhaps it was because he managed to prevent his son's death at the near cost of his own life, and in so doing, managed for once to cheat the fate that seemed to dog him his whole life. He did not lose Anduin that day. Varian accepted his fate -- this is how it ends for Wrynn kings -- that he would die in front of his son as his own father had died in front of him, but at least his death would buy his son life, as his father's death had managed to buy Varian escape from the burning city of Stormwind.

But the king must rise above trading blow for blow, loss for loss. Lothar did not lash out in fury or vengeance; he acted to protect his people. Terenas knew when to put down the sword, that wanton butchery inflicted upon the people of the Alliance did not mean the Alliance could or should embrace it in return. Now Varian has learned, slowly and fitfully, that resolve does not have to be rooted in rage, that determination can exist without vengeance, that protecting those in your charge can be done without losing control. In battle, yes, the wolf, but never rabid.
When Varian marches on Orgrimmar, he will not come as Lo'Gosh or even Goldrinn. He will not come as Doomhammer, who burns everything and murders innocents. He will not even come as Garona, a knife in the heart. Varian will come to Orgimmar as Varian Wrynn, King of Stormwind, who once watched his own city burn, and he will not force another child to watch the same.
But come to Orgrimmar he shall, because soon is the hour of the king.
While you don't need to have played the previous Warcraft games to enjoy World of Warcraft, a little history goes a long way toward making the game a lot more fun. Dig into even more of the lore and history behind the World of Warcraft in WoW Insider's Guide to Warcraft Lore.
Filed under: Analysis / Opinion, Lore, Know your Lore, Wrath of the Lich King, Cataclysm, Worgen, Mists of Pandaria






Reader Comments (Page 3 of 6)
Matthew Rossi Mar 28th 2012 3:10PM
@Nagaina
Arthas is dead. Varian knows exactly what Arthas did, but Arthas isn't the one currently inventing plagues and unleashing them on anyone who gets in his way. Varian knows about what Arthas did, but he also knows that Sylvanas is the one currently acting just like Arthas used to, and with Horde support, as far as he can tell.
There's a reason Seventh Legion shows up in the Silverpine quests. Varian knows Sylvanas used the exact same plague (at least as far as he can tell) that the Scourge used, the same plague Putress used at the Wrathgate, on the people of Gilneas.
Daedalus Mar 28th 2012 3:12PM
@Transit:
You're conflating the Scourge and the Forsaken.
The Alliance is well aware that the scourge came from a plague created by a human warlock and was lead to conquest by a human prince.
However, now that the scourge is defeated, the Horde is backing a faction of undead that is free of the scourge's influence but continues many of it's most evil traits; engineering and spreading a new plague, conquering Gilneas and driving out it's people, etc. If the Horde isn't willing to step back, denounce those actions, and either force the Forsaken to give up the plague, give back Southshore and Gilneas (and likely at least part of Lordaeron, which was a human kingdom...) or sever ties with them and let the Alliance drive them out.
Long story short: any atrocity committed by Sylvanas or her people (which includes Putress; she never objected to his work until he turned on her...) is on the Horde's head as long as they support her.
Nagaina Mar 28th 2012 3:22PM
@ Rossi ~
*Arthas* destroyed Lordaeron. Not the orcs. Not the Forsaken. The Forsaken -- the actual citizens of Lordaeron -- are defending the homeland that *Varian Wrynn* swore to take from them with sword and fire during the battle to retake Undercity from Varimathras and his puppets.
If Varian Wrynn didn't want the consequences of war with the Forsaken to fall on his people, he shouldn't have declared it.
Matthew Rossi Mar 28th 2012 3:28PM
@Nagaina
That's one perspective, yes. But it's not the only one. Varian grew up in Lordaeron, as did many people who currently live in Stormwind, who fled the demons of the Burning Legion who made the Lich King and who were once served by the orcs. To many humans (and there are as many survivors of Lordaeron living outside of it now as there are Forsaken in it) the Forsaken are monsters mocking their loved ones and squatting in the ruins of their homeland, and worse, spreading out from Lordaeron to attack Gilneas, Alterac, and Arathi, which were never part of Lordaeron. The Forsaken, to those people, are a threat to all life who must be stopped.
You see it from the Forsaken side, because you're a player and you have that ability. Varian does not. Alliance figures, including the many survivors of Arthas' rampage across Lordaeron, do not. Imagine it this way: if your home city was turned into a ravening ruin infested by zombies, and you escaped, would you care that among the zombies were your parents? Especially when the zombies want to kill everyone with a disease and make more zombies out of them? That's the Forsaken as seen by outsiders.
You have to try and remember, people inside a fiction don't see everything you, as someone experiencing the fiction, sees. Their viewpoints can be consistent even if they don't match your own. Varian and the others of the Alliance haven't played Warcraft III or WoW.
Transit Mar 28th 2012 3:30PM
@Daedalus
I know. :-) Actually I was confused that the article couples the allliance perspective of the orcs and scourge. I know the scourge were not part of the Horde. When Lorderon fell, Sylvanas was still a High Elf and Thrall had escaped to Kali. It just seems odd that Varian thinks the Orcs were responsable for this, since at the time the scourge started the orcs were still in internment camps.
I have to wonder now if the Alliance will do anything about the Dark Iron Dwarves. They are part of the Dwarf empire now and they torture, kidnap, enslave, etc. as well. Should be interesting.
Matheus314 Mar 28th 2012 3:32PM
Just to make clear that DEAD PEOPLE should not be allowed to live on the living world. If LORDAERON was their former living place, then UNDERCITY should be their current resting place. A big (and locked) crypt to keep safe the living from the dead (orcs, tauren, blood elves, trolls and goblins included).
That said, Lordaeron was human territory. And Undercity is not human at all (and never was).
arrowrest Mar 28th 2012 3:32PM
@ Nagaina
As already mentioned above, Varian knows that Arthas destroyed Lordaeron.
However, at the Wrathgate it was the Forsaken, members of the Horde under Thrall at the time, that launched a plague upon the combined forces in front of the Wrathgate. Varian may have officially declared war on the Horde in the Undercity, but open warfare had already been going on for years between the Horde and the Alliance. He didn't need to declare since it was already a fact.
No doubt it was a rogue portion of the Forsaken that launched the plague at that time but it was an open secret if you've done the Forsaken quests that Sylvanas had ordered the development of the plague. Experiments were conducted in the open on Alliance soldiers and civilians (and still are if you visit the Apothecary today). Varian saw this firsthand in the Undercity. Even after this "rogue" element of the Forsaken was eliminated, the combined Horde forces continue to use the plague in Gilneas and the destruction of Southshore. Varian and the Alliance hold the Horde accountable for these actions.
Transit Mar 28th 2012 3:47PM
@Matheus314
But werewolves are A-OK!
Undead bad! Werewolves good! Mummys.... Well it will depends on what faction they join.
mason.jdouglas Mar 28th 2012 4:24PM
"From Varian's perspective, yes, the orcs are to blame for allowing it to occur. Sylvanas is part of the Horde, is she not? If the United States had found American citizens being tortured and experimented on in a lab in any part of the former USSR, they would have blamed the Russians. "
Just to modify that a bit. It's more like the States finding out that Japan had American citizen's being tortured in a lab, and blamed Russia for allowing Japan (their allies) to do it.
Remember that Undercity is FAR from Orgrimmar, and if you argue that Varian can't know the difference between forsaken and scourge, you logistically ought to concede that Orgrimmar can't fully know or control what the forsaken are up to. Thus, the orcs can't be responsible for what happens in Lordaeron.
I would say though, that Varian knows what we know as players, and then some. My character has no idea what happened in "Wolfheart" or "The Shattering". I don't think it matters though.. Varian has plenty of reason to hate the orcs, and plenty of reason to hate the forsaken. (They ARE unabashedly evil, after all...and their existance is self-admittedly a torture and a corruption of their souls.) And they are most certainly a threat to all life on Azeroth. (Sylvanas is destroying souls in creating more forsaken... there is no justifying that; the forsaken aren't a race, their existance is more akin to a disease. Compassionate people don't kill the host, but they do quarantine the area and stop the spread... wait for the hosts to die off if there is no cure to be found.
Despite my endles criticism of Varian, I do give him credit where credit is due, and I think he would be informed about what the orcs are and aren't respinsible for, and aware of what Garrosh does and doesn't control.
If he chooses to resent the orcs for being ignorant/complacent in Sylvanas's atrocities, and assign some blame to them as a result....well THAT is totally understandable. I mean you gotta turn a critical eye to Germany's allies, who in WW2 knew about the concentration camps and REMAINED their allies, don't you?
Matthew Rossi Mar 28th 2012 4:35PM
@mason.jdouglas
"Just to modify that a bit. It's more like the States finding out that Japan had American citizen's being tortured in a lab, and blamed Russia for allowing Japan (their allies) to do it. "
The next time Russia can order Japan to attack another nation in order to provide the Russian/Japanese alliance with a port for further invasion, I'll accept your argument. The second Russian soldiers are seen throughout Japan, serving as police and army, this argument makes sense.
The Horde is not ALLIED to the Forsaken. The Forsaken are IN THE HORDE. No matter what we think about Sylvanas' actions, from Varian's perspective, any action taken by the Forsaken is supported by the Horde, including the orcs who are clearly the dominant faction in said Horde.
"Remember that Undercity is FAR from Orgrimmar, and if you argue that Varian can't know the difference between forsaken and scourge, you logistically ought to concede that Orgrimmar can't fully know or control what the forsaken are up to. Thus, the orcs can't be responsible for what happens in Lordaeron."
That's a specious argument. Varian doesn't have any reason to distinguish between the Forsaken and the Scourge, but the Forsaken are in the Horde, and Horde troops (including orcs) were present for the action in Gilneas. Varian knows this, because his Seventh Legion fought them and would have sent reports back. Varian knows the orcs DO know what happens in Lordaeron. If the orcs send Warlords to take part in the invasion of Gilneas how can they then be claimed to be innocent of knowing what's transpiring in Lordaeron? IVarian SAW Thrall and orcish troops in Lordaeron. How can the orcs claim not to have an awareness of what's taking place there?
You're trying hard to use your knowledge of the game world to justify your argument, not what Varian would know or infer. Furthermore, you're assuming the orcs aren't in any way responsible for what's happening in Lordaeron, but they are. There are orc soldiers in Undercity right now. Are they stopping the Royal Apothecary Society from torturing prisoners of war or experimenting on them? Are they preventing the use of the Plague in Gilneas? Are they taking any action at all?
Even from a metagame perspective, much less one of a leader at a time of war, the orcs DO bear responsibility. Varian saw Undercity and was horrified. Thrall saw it, and did nothing. Garrosh, his successor, supports the Forsaken invasion of Gilneas with troops. What is Varian supposed to believe here, that the orcs are innocent of all this while they take part in it?
mason.jdouglas Mar 28th 2012 4:33PM
Another concern,
Can people please stop using the downvote feature? I find alot of the comments that get greyed out on this site are actually well written counterpoints that make quite alot of sense. I already read and liked Rossi's article, and I enjoy his comments and those who agree with him.
But simply because people introduce a good counterpoint is no reason to make it damn near impossible for me to read and consider it. Just upvote the ones you like and leave the rest alone.
K, thanks, bye!
mason.jdouglas Mar 28th 2012 4:36PM
Another concern,
Can people please stop using the downvote feature? I find alot of the comments that get greyed out on this site are actually well written counterpoints that make quite alot of sense. I already read and liked Rossi's article, and I enjoy his comments and those who agree with him.
But simply because people introduce a good counterpoint is no reason to make it damn near impossible for me to read and consider it. Just upvote the ones you like and leave the rest alone.
K, thanks, bye!
mason.jdouglas Mar 28th 2012 5:14PM
@ Rossi
Good post, I accept your your distinction between Alliances and Hordes. Though, Varian tends to order his "Allies" around in game. Not relevant to the current argument... but a reminder that literal terms don't often have their defined meanings in WoW.
So yeah, I concede that the Horde is responsible for what's going on in Lordaeron. As to what Varian actually knows, alot of it is speculation on my part and yours. My worgen warrior however, recalls overhearing Sylvanas plotting to use the plague despite Garrosh's strict orders. And Varian knows firsthand that the Wrathgate pissed Thrall off. So, I think he has reason to doubt the Horde's unity.
Sure Garrosh is in "Charge" but he has Sylvanas out of control in the eastern kingdoms, doing whatever she wants, despite his orders. Sure he's got a token force of troops there, but you're right...what DO they do except allow it to happen. He's got the Tauren having a Grimtotem revolution, that had to be put down in part by the Alliance. He's got Vol'Jin coming to the Alliance for help, because he knows that their leadership is more stable.
Garrosh IS a terrible warchief in Varian's eyes because he fails to command the Horde well. And he's gotta know Sylvanas is outta control, but does he do anything to stop her? I don't think Varian holds the Horde responsible for what it does, but for what it fails to do. I mean, do you blame Dr. Frankenstein, or do you blame his Monster? Garrosh fails in his responsibility, but he's not solely responsible for his monster's actions.
That said, I don't question that Varian blames the orcs for Lordaeron, but I'd think he still has to blame the forsaken more. As for knowing the difference between forsaken and scourge.... factions talk? There are forsaken in the Argent Crusade, and other external factions, and forsaken would take offense to being called scourge, I would think. So, really Varian has to have at least heard rumors that the Forsaken consider themselves different from the Lich King's minions...
But he doesn't really have to believe it. Hell, I don't think most of my Alliance or Horde characters would believe it. Have you seen all the crazy shit the forsaken are up to around the world? Even my forsaken character has a hard time believeing they're different!
But again, there's no telling what faction leaders do and don't know, it IS mostly speculaton between us. If you have people teleporting all over the world, and third party factions accepting all applicants, information should be pretty accessible, right?
clundgren Mar 28th 2012 5:22PM
The Alliance is *supporting* the Grimtotem by supplying them weapons. For that matter, the Alliance attempted to occupy Mulgore itself, and are still besieging it.
Killik Mar 28th 2012 5:36PM
@clundgren The Alliance make friends with the Grimtotems in Stonetalon, then drive them out of Freewind Post in Thousand Needles. No, it doesn't make much sense other than "Grimtotems are evil and automatically betray everybody, even when it's not in their own interest."
Tabasa Mar 28th 2012 5:38PM
@Transit - "But werewolves are A-OK!
Undead bad! Werewolves good! Mummys.... Well it will depends on what faction they join."
Well, for one, Werewolves aren't undead, so that actually doesn't contradict Matheus' statement in the slightest.
For another, I'm getting awfully tired of the whole "Alliance doesn't like zombies but werewolves are okay zomg hypocrites" argument, as it's unbelievably shallow and ignores all the details of the story except for the fact that two of the races in the game can be compared to movie monsters.
The only real similarity between the two is that both are former humans suffering under curses, but the actions and circumstances surrounding both races in relation to the Alliance are totally different (for one, Gilneas actually appealed to the Alliance as a whole to join, which the Forsaken never did, and Sylvanas certainly had no intent to ever do at any point).
"I have to wonder now if the Alliance will do anything about the Dark Iron Dwarves. They are part of the Dwarf empire now and they torture, kidnap, enslave, etc. as well. Should be interesting."
I actually went into Cata hoping that the Dark Iron angle would give the Alliance their own morally-unsound group to be uncomfortable with, but unfortunately next to nothing came of that story development. If Moira is to be believed and actually has as much control over the Dark Irons as she claims she does (of which both points can be debated, but we've yet to see anything develop), the portion of the Dark Iron clan that she rules over that has joined with Ironforge is completely separate from the Dark Irons that are still tied to the Twilight's Hammer cult, who she considers traitors. We haven't actually seen the Moira-Dark Irons do much of anything yet to judge them one way or another (unless, as mentioned, she's lying or clueless) aside from being a massive political problem for Ironforge, but even that angle hasn't gotten much play. The Alliance has barely been given any reason to care about them, and I doubt the Horde is even aware that anything is different, given how little impact that development had outside of dwarven lands.
I actually hope that isn't the case, as it's far too hand-wavy of a turn for what could be a very interesting faction within the Dwarven community, not to mention the Alliance as a whole. But as things stand there's not a whole lot of reason for the Dark Irons to be anything close to comparable to the Forsaken, as they've yet to do much of anything since joining the Alliance.
mason.jdouglas Mar 28th 2012 5:38PM
@ clundgren
Actually, the Alliance helped baine retake Thunder Bluff. I do believe Anduin Wrynn himself gave Baine a sweet mace, and Jaina played a pivotal role in helping him retake Thunder Bluff.
clundgren Mar 28th 2012 5:52PM
@Mason,
Anduin and Jaina are very much acting on their own, as is made clear in the novel. They are not acting as agents of the Alliance. The Alliance is very much at war with the Tauren, as witness the giant wall that now separates Mulgore from an Alliance army, and the destruction of Camp Taurajo. So while Baine may respect Varian on a personal level, I don't think there are very good feelings between the Tauren and the Alliance just at the moment.
Jaina's actions are very confusing. In the novels, she is very supportive of Baine, but many of the troops in the Barrens are from Theramore. That can't be happening without her authorization.
Jem Mar 28th 2012 8:41PM
@Transit - "But werewolves are A-OK!
Undead bad! Werewolves good! Mummys.... Well it will depends on what faction they join."
Actually, the alliance allows deathknights to rejoin the ranks, so it isn't a case of simplistic "undead bad!".
The presence of DKs and the 'return to the fold' scene in SW after you complete the starter area indicates that Wrynn understands not all undead are evil, not all former scourge are untrustworthy. However, the actions of the Forsaken, both prior to Wrath with their ongoing experimentation on people for plague development, the ambush of the Wrathgate and the actions in Gilneas during Cata (plus the plague bombing on hillsbrad by the look) - all of this gives weight to the notion that the Forsaken aren't trustworthy. Quite frankly I think the Horde are insane to retain them as a member, they're out to destroy everyone including their own allies at this point. That the orcs have provided manpower to assist the Forsaken in their actions would imply a level of support from the rest of the Horde for the Forsaken's aims.
Griffdom Mar 29th 2012 9:39AM
@mason.jdouglas AND Matthew Rossi
Perhaps you guys should read up on some RL history. Japan and Russia are not, nor have they ever been allies.