Dec 22nd 2008 4:23PM The elemental shaman in our group is pretty lucky, she's been getting a lot of gear and we end up DEing all the mail caster stuff now anyways.
I like lootlists, it forces people to research and prioritize their own gear, better for 25 mans though.
In our 10 mans we need/greed items. The simplest rule is this:
The item should be go to the raider that will use it the longest all other things remaining equal.
Sure, those boots with hit might be a huge wonderful upgrade for your priesty and not as much for the mage, however the priest will (or at least should) replace those boots with mp5 or spirit boots where as a mage would be less likely to replace them. It is the same general rule that applies to armor drops.