Sunsmoon on WoW_ladies
makes an uncomfortably accurate observation concerning legendaries
-- people tend to get a little nuts around them. Anyone doing Tier 6 back in the day doubtless remembers the fistfights over who was going to get a Warglaive
players worldwide were in shock at a rogue getting Thor'idal over two hunters
, and the annals of classic WoW
are rife with nightmare stories of /gquits over Bindings of the Windseeker
and arguments over Sulfuras going to a druid
. Nowadays (as someone on my realm remarked in a moment's pique), of the six Val'anyrs
that have been assembled on our server, only one remains in its original guild. A reasonable person might be forgiven for thinking that the little orange text accompanying what's usually a decent weapon with a great proc is a lot more trouble than it's worth.
A good point is brought up by Amiyuy in the thread -- the process of creating a legendary, or having to keep farming for an extremely uncommon drop, tends to wear people out. A healer on track to build a Val'anyr can't reasonably expect to take any time off for fear of missing one of the inconsistent shards, and my guildmates and I continued to farm Black Temple well past the point that anyone was getting even offspec gear upgrades because we just couldn't
get a main-hand Glaive. With another legendary coming out in Icecrown Citadel
, guild leaders are facing the headache of figuring out who'll get it, and we've already fielded questions on our tip line on which class gets the most from Shadowmourne
and whether Blizzard could have nixed the stamina on it to discourage death knight tanks from picking it up (!).
So readers, I ask you -- are legendaries good for the game? If your guild was on a position to get one, did they ultimately help or hurt you more? And is the painful process of getting a Legendary the real source of the trouble, and not the item itself?
Filed under: Items, Analysis / Opinion, Breakfast Topics, Raiding